How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

How many calling for global jihads, etc., are there and how many of them actually lead to violence?

Enough. There is precious little Islamic terrorism unaccompanied by such speech.

Does every call for jihad and killing the unbeliever end in violence?

Of course not, or we'd all be dead already. But it's not necessary for all of them to lead to such behavior in order to qualify as incitement.

He does not mention the practicality of doing enforcing it a private level.

Perhaps because he figured it was obvious that it's not only impractical, but impossible. It certainly should have been obvious.
 
.
And what will sacrificing the Muslims to people who think the way you do accomplish? Should that "ultimate solution" (interesting choice of words, btw) be applied to you as well, as you would have also compelled people to conform to your way of life (i.e. not Muslim)?
I do not want to compel anyone to conform to MY way of life. You are building a strawman. Jihadis, on the other hand, DO want the entire world to conform to THEIR way of life. That is intolerable.
eta: Just in case I'm being thick, are you being sarcastic? Referring to genocide as the "ultimate solution", a synonym for "final solution", and all?
I was not being sarcastic, but neither was it intended as a euphemism for genocide. Parallel with "final solution" did not occur to me.
 
Perhaps because he figured it was obvious that it's not only impractical, but impossible. It certainly should have been obvious.
Correct. There are plenty of hate groups of all stripes throughout the world, who are essentially nothing but mutual adoration societies, telling each other how many blacks/whites/Chinese/Jews/capitalists/gays/whatever they will kill "come the revolution". As long as they do not actually do anything, their mutterings are unimportant.
 
reasons he did not include private behavior. One of the most obvious is that as a practical matter, we cannot know what people are doing in private, and so the question (when will we know the war on terror is over) is simply not answerable if we adopt a metric we can't actually measure, and we cannot accurately measure private behavior, especially in cases where people might have reason to conceal it. There are other additional reasons for not adopting such a standard (I'll leave it as an exercise to you to figure some of them out - you need the practice), but regardless, none of that means that Mark6 in any way approves of such incitement in private, making your statement a complete logical disconnect.
Also correct.
 
Whatever it is, this thread is about specifying what criteria must be met in order for it to be over.


Well now that terrorists are death penalty protesters...

Protesters added to database of terrorist suspects


Undercover Maryland state troopers infiltrated three groups advocating peace and protesting the death penalty — attending meetings and sending reports on their activities to U.S. intelligence and military agencies, according to documents released Thursday.



The activist was identified as Max Obuszewski. His "primary crime" was entered into the database as "terrorism - anti govern(ment)." His "secondary crime" was listed as "terrorism - anti-war protestors."


Welcome to the Brave New World!!!

:gnome:
 
I don't consider the issue of whether or not to go into Iraq as relevant to the 9/11 attack. It is highly questionable if it was relevant to the War on Terror (for any reasonable definitions of "terror").

Well al-Qaeda thought it was if we are believe what they said to one another in various communications. And if using Iraq pre-invasion as a sanctuary from which to launch terrorist attacks makes it relevant, then it was clearly relevant. Before the invasion, al-Qaeda met in Baghdad to kick off a plan to kill tens of thousands of Jordanians and everyone in the US embassy in Amman. Fortunately, those terrorists were caught before they could do it.
 
Enough. There is precious little Islamic terrorism unaccompanied by such speech.
Perhaps, but how much of that speech is unaccompanied by Islamic terrorism?

I'm not saying that speech that actually incites violence or is reasonably expected to should not be prosecuted. What I am saying is that we should not be considering genocide because a certain religion bad mouths us. Hell, I'm saying we should not be consider genocide at all, let alone for those reasons.

I can't believe you're giving me grief because I'm taking the "I don't like what you say, but I'll defend your right to say it" position and not saying anything to guy taking the "I don't like what you say and we should keep killing you until you stop saying it" position.


I do not want to compel anyone to conform to MY way of life. You are building a strawman. Jihadis, on the other hand, DO want the entire world to conform to THEIR way of life. That is intolerable.
You weren't talking about "Jihadis", you were talking about Muslim fundamentalists including those who merely speak out against others.

It isn't a strawman. You listed aspects of their ways of life (dress and marriage practices of British Muslims, for example) that you found unacceptable, something that needed to be fought against with violence to prevent them from doing.

I was not being sarcastic, but neither was it intended as a euphemism for genocide. Parallel with "final solution" did not occur to me.
Do you understand the parallel now? Do you understand the significance of what you are suggesting with your "ultimate solution"? I mean, seriously, you are talking about continuing the War on Terror until there isn't a single "madrassa left in the world openly calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers".

Heck, you don't even understand Islam well enough to know the difference between a madrassa and a mosque or that the "Jihadis" are called the Mujahideen. From the context, I'm not even really sure you understand what "jihad" means to a Muslim.

As long as they do not actually do anything, their mutterings are unimportant.
Then why keep killing them until they stop muttering about "global jihad and killing of unbelievers"?
 
I can't believe you're giving me grief because I'm taking the "I don't like what you say, but I'll defend your right to say it" position and not saying anything to guy taking the "I don't like what you say and we should keep killing you until you stop saying it" position.


Aren't you concerned that if broad-minded universal brotherhood clocks in prematurely the net result will be only Big Mac wrappers all over the floor at The Hague?
 
When we can take our families and safely vacation in Syria, Iran, Pakistan, North Korea, etc? :p

Can you do that in all parts of Miami, Florida? Oh, dearie me, no.

Los Angeles? Oh dear.

BAC, begin at home! BAC to basics for you, BAC! :p
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying that speech that actually incites violence or is reasonably expected to should not be prosecuted.

I think it should be obvious that calling for killing infidels qualifies under that heading. But then, maybe I'm funny that way, being an infidel and all myself.

What I am saying is that we should not be considering genocide because a certain religion bad mouths us. Hell, I'm saying we should not be consider genocide at all, let alone for those reasons.

Nobody has advocated genocide, making this a strawman. In fact, Mark6 already made clear that this is not what he meant, but you seem to have chosen to ignore him.

I can't believe you're giving me grief because I'm taking the "I don't like what you say, but I'll defend your right to say it" position

You are defending what I consider to be incitement to violence. Sorry if I don't consider that as you protecting free speech.

and not saying anything to guy taking the "I don't like what you say and we should keep killing you until you stop saying it" position.

Except nobody took that position. So why do you expect me to attack your strawman alongside you?
 
Oh, there is a War on Terror, all right. It has a Wikipedia article and everything. It seems to encompass far more than just terrorism. Or perhaps, it has little to do with terrorism. It's hard to say.

Whatever it is, this thread is about specifying what criteria must be met in order for it to be over.
You have been given many answers to that question but appear to have rejected them so, it is only fair that you answer a couple of question yourself. Do you feel that we should even be fighting a "WOT"? If so, how do you think it should be fought?
 
I think, when it comes to how the War On Terror, even if misnamed, is fought there are at least (as in not limited to) two schools of thought: those that feel that appearing to win it, by any means necessary, is more important than maintaining the integrity of free societies fighting in it and those that feel that regulating how you fight, even against the most heinous criminals, speaks more about your character than just the appearance of winning the fight. I would like to think I'm with the latter though I'd speculate that certain pragmatic arguments could be made for the former.
 
You have been given many answers to that question but appear to have rejected them so, it is only fair that you answer a couple of question yourself. Do you feel that we should even be fighting a "WOT"? If so, how do you think it should be fought?


Impeaching Bush, Cheney and Gang for a start? :confused:
 
Impeaching Bush, Cheney and Gang for a start? :confused:

That's how you would have fought the War On Terror? Your first action after 9/11 would have been the impeachment of American Politicians?

I'd love to hear your rationale for this.
 
According to MY government, I have terrorists in my home State!!!


:jaw-dropp


Many of us here live in countries who have domestic terrorism issues (and have had so since long before 9/11); the UK, the Spaniards, and so on. If you believe that terrorism is a remote beast, that it is restricted to 9/11, then you are either niaive or a fool. There will always be those who reach for the gun, or the bomb, before they will go to the ballot box.

What you are purportedly concerned about - and given your previous inability to adequately research the topics you seek to talk on, I have no great faith in your proposition - is that your government is worngly or vexatiously classifying action groups as bein terrorist. Well, when we see proper evidence, links, and a balanced analysis then we might think about it. Now go away and do your homework, son.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom