How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

Does it really take that much of a cognitive leap to infer "hate" from words like "dangerous" and "just want to kill me"?

Yes, especially when you claim that he feels this way about muslims in general.

Look, we obviously have two different perspectives going on here. I believe in holding people accountable for what they actually do. You two believe that the entire group is responsible.

Strawman again. I've said nothing about accountability. I haven't even imlpied anything about accountability. You just can't stop, can you?

I knew I wasn't going to convince you of anything and you haven't shown me anything that convinces me, anyway.

You've shown no indication that you understood what was presented to you, so that really means very little. Have you figured out what it means yet that the gates of ijtihad are closed, for example?
 
Sin-Lam-Min is a triconsonantal root from which a wide range of Semitic words are produced. There is no related meaning between these words, and translating one as another is total nonsense.

well ill ask my sister when i see her next time, she studied Semitic languages.
 
As I said, we're talking past one another.

That's because all you can do is misrepresent my position. You cannot actually respond to the substance of it. Once again, have you even tried to find out what I meant when I said that the gates of ijtihad are closed? If you're feeling frustrated, blame yourself. You're the one with the problem here, not me.
 
That's because all you can do is misrepresent my position. You cannot actually respond to the substance of it. Once again, have you even tried to find out what I meant when I said that the gates of ijtihad are closed? If you're feeling frustrated, blame yourself. You're the one with the problem here, not me.

and who decided that no new intepretations of the islamic laws are allowed?
 
That's because all you can do is misrepresent my position.
And just how accurately do you think you understand my position?


eta:
Once again, have you even tried to find out what I meant when I said that the gates of ijtihad are closed?
oh, and yes, I did find out what you meant by that. It is completely irrelevant to the point I was making.
 
Last edited:
And just how accurately do you think you understand my position?

Is there any point at which I attributed to you something that you don't believe? Or is it just that I'm saying things you think are wrong? There's a difference, you know. And you're not simply saying things I disagree with, you're attributing to me positions I don't agree with.

oh, and yes, I did find out what you meant by that. It is completely irrelevant to the point I was making.

That's nice. But it's not irrelevant to the point that I was making. Of course, by now I'm well past expecting you to be able to figure out why it's relevant to my point.
 
oh, and yes, I did find out what you meant by that. It is completely irrelevant to the point I was making.
Actually, that's not exactly correct. It isn't that it is completely irrelevant so much as it demonstrates that you really don't understand my point either. Indeed, the wikipedia discussion on the topic following the 10th century only goes to support my general premise.
 
Actually, that's not exactly correct. It isn't that it is completely irrelevant so much as it demonstrates that you really don't understand my point either. Indeed, the wikipedia discussion on the topic following the 10th century only goes to support my general premise.

Hey great, a Wikipedia discussion! Surely the guys over at al-Azhar are impatiently following that one!

If it's apparently so hard for us to see your point, what is it?
 
If it's apparently so hard for us to see your point, what is it?
Don't you know?

eta:
...and actually, I'm not sure I said it was hard for you to see my point. I just said that we were talking past one another, to which you assured me that only I was.
[/over-parsing :p]
 
Last edited:
Don't you know?

Nope. That's why I am asking. Unless of course you don't actually have one, which it looks like. With your poor understanding it should be hard to have one anyway. I assume you are arguing for arguing's sake, just like you called baloney for the sake of calling baloney.
 
After all this, you have no idea what I'm saying or even if I even have a point, but I'm the one talking past you. Wow.

Okay, then.
 
After all this, you have no idea what I'm saying or even if I even have a point, but I'm the one talking past you. Wow.

Okay, then.

I was the one who said it was only you talking past me, not mrbaracuda.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom