How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

Upchurch

Papa Funkosophy
Joined
May 10, 2002
Messages
34,265
Location
St. Louis, MO
I've asked it before, but I've never gotten a really satisfying answer.

What event or sequence of events must occur in order for us to say that we are no longer at war on terror, or with terrorists?

I don't accept "when all the terrorists are dead" because that just leads to the question of how do we know when that has happened. I guess I'm looking for a measurable condition.

Anyone know?
 
When a muslim comic can mock Mohammed in Saudi Arabia, we'll know we've won.
 
I guess it would be when the terrorists get on a battleship and sign a letter of surrender. After we promise not to kill Hirohito Osama.

In other words, never.
Allowing for the fact that this is a shemp post (;)), who are "the terrorists" that we'd need to do that signing?
 
I've asked it before, but I've never gotten a really satisfying answer.

What event or sequence of events must occur in order for us to say that we are no longer at war on terror, or with terrorists?

I don't accept "when all the terrorists are dead" because that just leads to the question of how do we know when that has happened. I guess I'm looking for a measurable condition.

Anyone know?
Isn't more or less like the war on drugs. Isn't it?
 
That's kinda hard to quantify, because there's no way to know that all the terrorists are dead. Practically nobody knew Timothy McVeigh existed until he blew up the Murrah building.

But you don't have to hunt them all down. I don't think many people would claim we haven't won the war against the KKK. I'd say we've won it when any terrorist knows that he can't find refuge anywhere, that if he blows up a building in New York, he'll be hunted night and day in Pakistan; if he blows up a train in Singapore, he'll find no haven in Afghanistan; if he blows up a ship in Haiti, he won't be safe even in Timbuktu.
 
I've asked it before, but I've never gotten a really satisfying answer.

What event or sequence of events must occur in order for us to say that we are no longer at war on terror, or with terrorists?

I don't accept "when all the terrorists are dead" because that just leads to the question of how do we know when that has happened. I guess I'm looking for a measurable condition.

Anyone know?

When our 52nd president - Muhamed Ala-Karbari - gets elected.
 
What event or sequence of events must occur in order for us to say that we are no longer at war on terror, or with terrorists?

Hopefully, the United States will remain at war with terrorism and terrorists as long as they exist.
 
That's kinda hard to quantify, because there's no way to know that all the terrorists are dead. Practically nobody knew Timothy McVeigh existed until he blew up the Murrah building.

But you don't have to hunt them all down. I don't think many people would claim we haven't won the war against the KKK. I'd say we've won it when any terrorist knows that he can't find refuge anywhere, that if he blows up a building in New York, he'll be hunted night and day in Pakistan; if he blows up a train in Singapore, he'll find no haven in Afghanistan; if he blows up a ship in Haiti, he won't be safe even in Timbuktu.
'kay. How do we know when this has occurred?
 
Hopefully, the United States will remain at war with terrorism and terrorists as long as they exist.
Certain things, like some civil liberties, can and should be set aside during times of war. It is a very special situation and not meant to be a perpetual one.

We should always be opposed to terrorism and terrorists. We should not and can not always be at war with terrorism and terrorists.
 
Certain things, like some civil liberties, can and should be set aside during times of war. It is a very special situation and not meant to be a perpetual one.

We should always be opposed to terrorism and terrorists. We should not and can not always be at war with terrorism and terrorists.

Have you considered reading the AUMF - the actual instrument of war in this particular instance - before posing this question. There's some information in there you may find useful.

"War on Terror" is a foreign policy objective set by the executive branch. It is not a statutory claim. We should and can, in fact, always be at war from a policy standpoint with terrorism and terrorists. Being at war from a statutory standpoint requires another procedural step.
 
I remember when the war on terror first started. Someone reminded Bush about the Vietnam War, asking him if the war on terror had a clear objective, and how would we know when the objective had been met. He answered with something like, "When the nations of the world are bathed in the wonderful glow of freedom".

When I heard this, my reaction was, "oh, crap..." :(
 
When the credits roll. Then you get to play the bonus levels:

War on Drugs
War on Poverty
War on Crime
War on Illegal Immigration
War on Indecency (AKA convert to a fundamentalist theocracy)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom