How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

Mark6 also defined "Them" as those who subscribe to a specific kind of ideology and "who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT" (#134). He also calls for continued warfare not until just the soldiers give up, but the society does, as well (#130 again).


If that is your opinion, that is fine. I happen to agree with that. However, that is clearly not the position Mark6 is taking. Just because I am attacking his position does not mean I am attacking yours, Zig.
My posts had not been very articulate, mainly because I type in snatches at work. Bu Ziggurat has been more articulate than me, and his position is essentially identical tio mine.
I've explained why several times now. A threat is only really a threat if there is a reasonable expectation that it would be acted upon. Until then, and Mark6 even agreed with this, "their mutterings are unimportant" (#143). And yet, it is on the basis of their mutterings, not the expectation that it would be acted upon that Mark6 defines his criteria for the war to be over.
Another result of hasty typing. It should have been:

"There are plenty of hate groups of all stripes throughout the world, who are essentially nothing but mutual adoration societies, telling each other how many blacks/whites/Chinese/Jews/capitalists/gays/whatever they will kill "come the revolution". As long as they do not actually do anything, their mutterings are unimportant. If/when Islamic Fundamentalists are reduced to such impotent mutterings, I will be happy. As of now, that is not the case."
 
I know. That was in response to Mark6's proposal.


There are some pragmatic questions about how that might be guaged, but from a more philosophical perspective, would it be accurate to restate your position as:

The War On Terror is won when the nations that harbor terrorist organizations are more terrified of us than they are of the terrorist organizations.​

Wouldn't it be ironic if the only way to win the War On Terror is to be the biggest source of terror?
Only if you consider it terror to attack countries that are supporting organisations at war with the west. I guess we terrorised Japan and Germany? I am not one that considers most Middle Eastern leaders as irrational maniacs. They are completely rational regarding their own self interests. If it is more advantageous for them to, as a matter of national policy, support terrorist organisations to maintain their personal power that is what they will do but it is also true if that support puts their very existence, as in lives, at risk from the US/West then the self-interest calculus changes.
 
Last edited:
Only if you consider it terror to attack countries that are supporting organisations at war with the west. I guess we terrorised Japan and Germany?
We weren't branding WWII as a war against an emotion or tactic only to use that same emotion or tactic to combat it. And if we had used Japan and Germany (and Italy) to fight Japan and Germany (and Italy), I would still call that ironic, because it would have been.


If it is more advantageous for them to, as a matter of national policy, support terrorist organisations to maintain their personal power that is what they will do but it is also true if that support puts their very existence, as in lives, at risk from the US/West then the self-interest calculus changes.
So, we threaten them with violence and death unless they capitulate to our demands on their foreign policy. Brilliant! I wonder if there is a term for that?


Seriously, though, I'm not saying you are incorrect in some cases, but it is just a tad hypocritical to put ourselves on a higher moral pedestal if we will stoop just as low.
The Flash said:
Grammy Flash always used to say the problem with 'an eye for an eye' is that everybody ends up blind.
(source)
 
The Flash said:
Grammy Flash always used to say the problem with 'an eye for an eye' is that everybody ends up blind.
(source)

Both Granny Flash and Ghandi (the original source) were wrong. As Adam Smith said, ""Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent." Refusal to retaliate encourages aggression on the part of others: it is not only not moral, it is immoral. Let us not forget, either, that Ghandi thought the Jews should accept genocide at the hands of the Nazis rather than fight back.
 
Both Granny Flash and Ghandi (the original source)
Yes, I know. Quoting Grammy Flash was more fun.

As Adam Smith said, ""Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent." Refusal to retaliate encourages aggression on the part of others: it is not only not moral, it is immoral.
There is a difference between vengeance and justice, retaliation and punishment. To quote another TV show (although I can't remember where I heard it), "How do you fight fire?"
"...with a hose?"

What do you call someone who threatens violence and death against someone unless they capitulates to demands on their foreign policy?

Let us not forget, either, that Ghandi thought the Jews should accept genocide at the hands of the Nazis rather than fight back.
(spoiler tags for to prevent needless scrolling for the uninterested in off-topic discussion.)
You're talking about the pacifist who made this statement, are you?

The crime of an obviously mad but intrepid youth is being visited upon his whole race with unbelievable ferocity. If there ever could be a justifiable war in the name of and for humanity, a war against Germany, to prevent the wanton persecution of a whole race, would be completely justified. But I do not believe in any war. A discussion of the pros and cons of such a war is therefore outside my horizon or province.

You are mis-characterizing what Ghandi was saying (later in that same essay). He is not saying that they should merely accept genocide.
Can the Jews resist this organized and shameless persecution? Is there a way to preserve their self-respect, and not to feel helpless, neglected and forlorn? I submit there is. No person who has faith in a living God need feel helpless or forlorn. Jehovah of the Jews is a God more personal than the God of the Christians, the Musalmans or the Hindus, though, as a matter of fact in essence, He is common to all the one without a second and beyond description. But as the Jews attribute personality to God and believe that He rules every action of theirs, they ought not to feel helpless. If I were a Jew and were born in Germany and earned my livelihood there, I would claim Germany as my home even as the tallest gentile German may, and challenge him to shoot me or cast me in the dungeon; I would refuse to be expelled or to submit to discriminating treatment . And for doing this, I should not wait for the fellow Jews to join me in civil resistance but would have confidence that in the end the rest are bound to follow my example. If one Jew or all the Jews were to accept the prescription here offered, he or they cannot be worse off than now. And suffering voluntarily undergone will bring them an inner strength and joy which no number of resolutions of sympathy passed in the world outside Germany can. Indeed, even if Britain, France and America were to declare hostilities against Germany, they can bring no inner joy, no inner strength. The calculated violence of Hitler may even result in a general massacre of the Jews by way of his first answer to the declaration of such hostilities. But if the Jewish mind could be prepared for voluntary suffering, even the massacre I have imagined could be turned into a day of thanksgiving and joy that Jehovah had wrought deliverance of the race even at the hands of the tyrant. For to the god fearing, death has no terror. It is a joyful sleep to be followed by a waking that would be all the more refreshing for the long sleep.
Is Ghandi telling them to fight back? No, he is a pacifist. But he does think they can resist nonetheless. (Of course, this kind of resistance has little comfort to an atheist like me, but he wasn't talking to an atheist like me.)
 
Is Ghandi telling them to fight back? No, he is a pacifist. But he does think they can resist nonetheless.

By what possible logic can you call a course of action that does nothing to impede the slaughter resistance? It is not. To call it that is positively Orwellian. And the sentence "But if the Jewish mind could be prepared for voluntary suffering, even the massacre I have imagined could be turned into a day of thanksgiving and joy" sounds an awful lot like accepting genocide to me.
 
You don't understand non-violent resistance, fine.

I understand it plenty well. I also understand that there are only limited circumstances in which it can work - namely, there must be an authority with power over your adversary which is interested in maintaining peace. It works when it persuades someone else to fight (or be ready to fight) for you. Without that (and there are no candidates for such an authority in regards to Islamic terrorism), pacifism is an exercise in futility and surrender preening as moral superiority. Thanks, but no thanks.
 
I do not believe Ghandi understood it either. He faced a unique situation in history -- an imperial power too squeamish to do what was necessary to maintain its grip on the empire. In this particular situation, non-violent resistance was effective. Had Ghandi tried his methods against Hitler, or Stalin, or even British Empire of 1840 instead of 1940, none of us would have known his name because he'd be nothing but another anonymous victim -- shot by some minor local imperial functionary without even bothering his higher-ups. Because that's how empires dealt with "peons getting above their station" since the days of Cyrus the Great.

But British Empire circa 1940 was too civilized to act like an empire. Ghandi's non-violent resistance sent British public into a fit of guilt and self-recrimination, which led to abandoning India and ultimately the rest of the Empire. As a result, Ghandi -- and many who quote him today, -- became conviced that non-violence is an appropriate way to deal with evil. What he (and those who quote him) do not understand is that Britain circa 1940 was not evil at all. You can only use non-violence against a fundamentally decent opponent.
 
Whoa, Upchurch, I knew you were making odd replies at times, but the one about the Ghandi stuff. My goodness!
 
Okay, first and most importantly,this is off-topic and irrelevant. If you want to discuss it, take it to R&P.

Second, I didn't say I agreed with Ghandi and I didn't say his position on the Jews in Germany was in any way applicable to the War on Terror. All I said was that Zig is mis-characterizing Ghandi's position which wasn't to "accept genocide". Ghandi's position was a more spiritual one than that. Zig is looking at it from a materialist's perspective which is not how it was intended.
 
All I said was that Zig is mis-characterizing Ghandi's position which wasn't to "accept genocide". Ghandi's position was a more spiritual one than that.

Ghandi's position was exactly that. The fact that it was motivated and justified by spiritualism does not change the fact that he advocated accepting your own death and the hands of your killer - if you believe what Ghandi did, that may change the significance of the act for you, but it will not change the act itself.
 
Both Granny Flash and Ghandi (the original source) were wrong. As Adam Smith said, ""Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent." Refusal to retaliate encourages aggression on the part of others: it is not only not moral, it is immoral. Let us not forget, either, that Ghandi thought the Jews should accept genocide at the hands of the Nazis rather than fight back.


Did you just affirm that the "War on Terror" is partly based on Israeli interests? :confused:
 
So, what's your point, Zig?

You don't agree with Ghandi's position of passivism, so his position on "an eye for an eye" must also be wrong? Therefore, the only appropriate reponse to terrorism is more terrorism?

What are you trying to say?
 
I do not believe Ghandi understood it either. He faced a unique situation in history -- an imperial power too squeamish to do what was necessary to maintain its grip on the empire. In this particular situation, non-violent resistance was effective. Had Ghandi tried his methods against Hitler, or Stalin, or even British Empire of 1840 instead of 1940, none of us would have known his name because he'd be nothing but another anonymous victim -- shot by some minor local imperial functionary without even bothering his higher-ups. Because that's how empires dealt with "peons getting above their station" since the days of Cyrus the Great.

But British Empire circa 1940 was too civilized to act like an empire. Ghandi's non-violent resistance sent British public into a fit of guilt and self-recrimination, which led to abandoning India and ultimately the rest of the Empire. As a result, Ghandi -- and many who quote him today, -- became conviced that non-violence is an appropriate way to deal with evil. What he (and those who quote him) do not understand is that Britain circa 1940 was not evil at all. You can only use non-violence against a fundamentally decent opponent.
That was a very good post. A pacifist lives only as long as a non-pacifist allows him to live.
 
So, what's your point, Zig?

You don't agree with Ghandi's position of passivism, so his position on "an eye for an eye" must also be wrong? Therefore, the only appropriate reponse to terrorism is more terrorism?

What are you trying to say?
Aren't most criminal laws in civilized countries "eye for an eye"?

Therefore, the only appropriate response to terrorism is more terrorism?

No the appropriate response to terrorism is justice and self-defense. Pacifism allows for neither.
 
As for the topic, we'll be making progress once we don't have articles like this one anymore.

Abu Mustafa has a degree from the University of Saarbrücken in Germany's far west. For seven years, until 2000, he studied chemical engineering and led a largely normal student existence. He had periodic jobs with a moving company or in construction, and he occasionally cooked up Palestinian specialties for other students living in the dormitory. "I miss Germany," he says. He's even looked on Google Earth for the street where he used to live and the cafeteria where he used to eat.

He explains that he was largely accepted in Germany and found people there to be quite friendly. The only problems came about when he encountered scantily clad women or fellow students who spent much of their time in clubs and bars. He says such experiences rooted him even deeper in his beliefs. "It would be better for such people were they to follow the pure Islam," he says. "We are going to try and bring the faith to them."

Even if he has to kill them to save them, he'll bring Islam to them. Gee, what a swell fella.

DR
 
Aren't most criminal laws in civilized countries "eye for an eye"?
Define "civilized countries". The US mostly holds a corrective form of criminal punishment system. The exception is capital punishment.

According to Wikipedia, these are the countries that known to have carried out capital punishment in 2007:
Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Belarus, Botswana, China, Egypt, Equatorial Guinea, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Japan, Kuwait, Libya, North Korea, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, USA, Vietnam, Yemen.
Were these the civilized countries you were thinking of?

No the appropriate response to terrorism is justice and self-defense.
...which would not be "an eye for an eye".

Ever hear of the "tit-for-tat" strategy of the prisoner's dilemma?
Not being big into game theory, I hadn't. Here are some things your source says about the subject:
Still, this "group" victory illustrates an important limitation of the Prisoner's Dilemma in representing social reality, namely, that it does not include any natural equivalent for friendship or alliances. The advantage of "tit for tat" thus pertains only to a Hobbesian world of rational solutions, not to a world in which humans are inherently social.

...

While Axelrod has empirically shown that the strategy is optimal in some cases, two agents playing tit for tat remain vulnerable. A one-time, single-bit error in either player's interpretation of events can lead to an unending "death spiral". In this symmetric situation, each side perceives itself as preferring to cooperate, if only the other side would. But each is forced by the strategy into repeatedly punishing an opponent who continues to attack despite being punished in every game cycle. Both sides come to think of themselves as innocent and acting in self-defense, and their opponent as either evil or too stupid to learn to cooperate.

That countries must retaliation against aggression.
According to the summary, part of the tit-for-tat strategy is to be quick to forgive. When/Where/How you envision that part of the strategy coming into effect in the War On Terror?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom