Mark6
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 17, 2008
- Messages
- 6,261
My posts had not been very articulate, mainly because I type in snatches at work. Bu Ziggurat has been more articulate than me, and his position is essentially identical tio mine.Mark6 also defined "Them" as those who subscribe to a specific kind of ideology and "who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT" (#134). He also calls for continued warfare not until just the soldiers give up, but the society does, as well (#130 again).
If that is your opinion, that is fine. I happen to agree with that. However, that is clearly not the position Mark6 is taking. Just because I am attacking his position does not mean I am attacking yours, Zig.
Another result of hasty typing. It should have been:I've explained why several times now. A threat is only really a threat if there is a reasonable expectation that it would be acted upon. Until then, and Mark6 even agreed with this, "their mutterings are unimportant" (#143). And yet, it is on the basis of their mutterings, not the expectation that it would be acted upon that Mark6 defines his criteria for the war to be over.
"There are plenty of hate groups of all stripes throughout the world, who are essentially nothing but mutual adoration societies, telling each other how many blacks/whites/Chinese/Jews/capitalists/gays/whatever they will kill "come the revolution". As long as they do not actually do anything, their mutterings are unimportant. If/when Islamic Fundamentalists are reduced to such impotent mutterings, I will be happy. As of now, that is not the case."