How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

You know the War on Terror is won when the words "Player One Wins" flashes across the screen.
 
Well that's refreshing. Most people who question the validity of the WOT think the terrorists are noble freedom fighters, that capitalism is evil and believe in peace at all costs.
"Most people" think that? Seriously? I am curious to know what has lead you to paint with such a very broad brush.

While you're at it, which terrorists are you referring to? The only ones I'm specifically interested in are the ones who were involved in the 9/11 attacks.


Would calling it the Conflict With Terrorism be any better?
No, not really. It isn't the "War" that is ill defined, in this context. It's the "Terrorism". The ambiguity of the former is a direct result of ambiguity of the latter.


We, as a stable free society, are certainly in conflict with Terrorism in the sense that we, hopefully, wish to prevent it and that, ultimately, is the measurable goal; the absence of terrorism is the hallmark of a "victory."
You sound as if we, a stable free society, are incapable of using fear and terror to further our own ends.
 
"Most people" think that? Seriously? I am curious to know what has lead you to paint with such a very broad brush.

While you're at it, which terrorists are you referring to? The only ones I'm specifically interested in are the ones who were involved in the 9/11 attacks.

I should have added the caveat "that I've encountered" which would explain that it is a small, likely not representative, sample that I'm talking about.

No, not really. It isn't the "War" that is ill defined, in this context. It's the "Terrorism". The ambiguity of the former is a direct result of ambiguity of the latter.

A criminal act directed against civilians with the implication that such acts will continue unless the perpetrators demands are satisfied. Doesn't seem so ambiguous to me.



You sound as if we, a stable free society, are incapable of using fear and terror to further our own ends.

We are certainly capable but one characteristic of a stable free society is that it generally wants to remain stable and free and persecuting acts of terrorism is a good way to bring that all to an end. That isn't to say it doesn't occasionally happen of course.
 
I should have added the caveat "that I've encountered" which would explain that it is a small, likely not representative, sample that I'm talking about.
Gotcha.


A criminal act directed against civilians with the implication that such acts will continue unless the perpetrators demands are satisfied. Doesn't seem so ambiguous to me.
Traditionally, yes, that is how terrorism is usually defined: A criminal act.

That isn't how the word is being used now. A crime is something that is prosecuted and tried. The War on Terror is being used to suspend the prosecution process, not further it.

Terrorism, in this sense, now being used to mean something along the lines of a coordinated military attack against a sovereign nation, thus justifying a declaration of war. Except no military was involved, because that would mean they are protected by the Geneva Convention. So, they are non-military combatants, meaning that terrorism is a coordinated non-military attack against a sovereign nation, thus justifying a declaration of war. Except for Iran. Iran has an actual military, but it is still a terrorist state, just not the same kind of terrorist as the other kind of terrorists. Then, there is North Korea which appears to be designated a state sponsor of terror solely because they have been developing nuclear weapons. At least, we supposedly going to remove that designation if they denuclearize.

Yeah, I call that ambiguous. :)

"Terrorist" has become a catch-all term for anything someone doesn't like and they want others not to like by making them afraid of it. It's like "communist" last century or "witch" from centuries before.

[short sketch]
"The terrorist/communist/witch needs to be dealt with!"
"Why?"
"Because they are a terrorist!/communist!/witch! Weren't you paying attention?"
[/short sketch]


We are certainly capable but one characteristic of a stable free society is that it generally wants to remain stable and free and persecuting acts of terrorism is a good way to bring that all to an end. That isn't to say it doesn't occasionally happen of course.
Do you mean "persecuting" or "prosecuting"? I'll assume the latter until you say otherwise.

Until very recently, I would have disagreed with you that, by your definition, we fit that one characteristic of a stable, free society. As I said above, our government has gone out of its way to not prosecute acts of terrorism. Only the very recent Supreme Court decision has begun to push back against the swing away from that stable and free society characteristic. Still, the Bush administration is pushing against it. Only time, and hopefully some hard work by the right people, will tell what kind of society we really are and if we live up to our expectations.
 
Traditionally, yes, that is how terrorism is usually defined: A criminal act.

That isn't how the word is being used now. A crime is something that is prosecuted and tried. The War on Terror is being used to suspend the prosecution process, not further it.

Terrorism, in this sense, now being used to mean something along the lines of a coordinated military attack against a sovereign nation, thus justifying a declaration of war. Except no military was involved, because that would mean they are protected by the Geneva Convention. So, they are non-military combatants, meaning that terrorism is a coordinated non-military attack against a sovereign nation, thus justifying a declaration of war. Except for Iran. Iran has an actual military, but it is still a terrorist state, just not the same kind of terrorist as the other kind of terrorists. Then, there is North Korea which appears to be designated a state sponsor of terror solely because they have been developing nuclear weapons. At least, we supposedly going to remove that designation if they denuclearize.

Yeah, I call that ambiguous. :)

"Terrorist" has become a catch-all term for anything someone doesn't like and they want others not to like by making them afraid of it. It's like "communist" last century or "witch" from centuries before.

I agree that the term "terrorism" has been misused a lot lately to mean basically anyone attacking someone who isn't a part of state military. I feel that this is an introduced ambiguity that I think needs to be resolved, hopefully by the next administration.

I do not, however, think that merely using military forces means that we need to treat the matter in a purely military matter, ie treating captured Al Qaeda as POW's, but can instead use the military to augment what might otherwise be a criminal matter.

To be clearer I feel those that fight with, or for, Al Qaeda are criminals while those that fought for the Taliban are soldiers and both, if captured, should be treated in the appropriate, and legal, manner.


Do you mean "persecuting" or "prosecuting"? I'll assume the latter until you say otherwise.

You were wise to assume the latter. "Persecuting" would imply a very different meaning.

Until very recently, I would have disagreed with you that, by your definition, we fit that one characteristic of a stable, free society. As I said above, our government has gone out of its way to not prosecute acts of terrorism. Only the very recent Supreme Court decision has begun to push back against the swing away from that stable and free society characteristic. Still, the Bush administration is pushing against it. Only time, and hopefully some hard work by the right people, will tell what kind of society we really are and if we live up to our expectations.

The way I look at is is that one need not act like a savage brute even if one is fighting a savage brute. I feel that the manner in which we deal with terrorism will have to evolve if we hope to stay "stable and free."
 
I agree that the term "terrorism" has been misused a lot lately to mean basically anyone attacking someone who isn't a part of state military. I feel that this is an introduced ambiguity that I think needs to be resolved, hopefully by the next administration.
If so, it will be done by Obama. McCain, from what I can tell, is using the same non-definition of terrorism that the current administration is.

I do not, however, think that merely using military forces means that we need to treat the matter in a purely military matter, ie treating captured Al Qaeda as POW's, but can instead use the military to augment what might otherwise be a criminal matter.

To be clearer I feel those that fight with, or for, Al Qaeda are criminals while those that fought for the Taliban are soldiers and both, if captured, should be treated in the appropriate, and legal, manner.
Could not agree more. Were that the case, the answer to my OP question would be: "when the people involved in the 9/11 attacks are found, tried, and sentenced." The appropriate branding would not be "War on Terror" but rather "War on the 9/11 Terrorists", decoupling it from the invasion of Iraq and whatever it is we're doing* with North Korea and Iran.


The way I look at is is that one need not act like a savage brute even if one is fighting a savage brute. I feel that the manner in which we deal with terrorism will have to evolve if we hope to stay "stable and free."
The problem is that some of us are perfectly willing, maybe even enthusiastic, to act like a savage brute when fighting a savage brute.



* it might be called "diplomacy", but that is something of a dirty word these days in some circles.
 
I agree completely that "War on Terror" is an idiotic term, far too undefined, and should never have been coined. "War on Islamic Fundamentalism" would have been much more honest, for that's what WoT really is (or should be). Unfortunately that would offend our "friends" the Saudis. And we can't have that, right?

Having said that, I think a lot of legal terms do not apply well to the current world situation -- and by "current" I mean since 1990 or so. Laws dealing with criminals are separate from laws dealing with international relations -- and both do not take into account that a group without allegiance to ANY government can inflict damage on the scale of a sizeable war. That sort of thing simlpy could not occur during Industrial Age, so our laws do not cover it.

Shortly after 9/11 and Bush declaring "War on Terror", many of his critics said that wars occur only between nation-states, and Al-Qaeda is not a nation-state, so any action against Al-Qaeda can not be a war. Whatever I think about "War on Terror", this particular argument is ridiculous. Modern concept of a nation-state dates only to 1648; wars most assuredly happened before that.

So, what do we call a violent movement, not controlled by any government (although allied to some), and bound more by common ideology than by any definable organization? It is a lot more than a criminal gang, but less than a military force. Fighting it requires combination of police actions, military actions, and good old fashioned diplomatic arm-twisting -- convincing governments who may decide otherwise, that it is in their interests to act against Al-Qaeda rather than look the other way, let alone cooperate with it. It's not exactly a "war", but is something Queen Elizabeth I would have recognized. What did they call that sort of thing back then?

As for how do we know War on Terror (or whatever we call it) has been won? I would say when there is not a single madrassa left in the world openly calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers (i.e. either destroyed or driven into hiding), I would say it has been won. How will we know it happened? Well, the word "openly" is key here. If they are open about it, we know it has not been won yet.
 
Heck, we aren't even winning.


... or fighting.

Oh wait, I heard rumors on the internets that there are indeed two ore three US Soldiers in Afghanistan based on the war on terror premise.
 
I agree completely that "War on Terror" is an idiotic term, far too undefined, and should never have been coined. "War on Islamic Fundamentalism" would have been much more honest, for that's what WoT really is (or should be).
Stop right there. I have to disagree with this in the strongest terms.

Not all Islamic fundamentalists are terrorists. (I suppose it goes without saying that not all terrorists are Islamic fundamentalists.) If we were to declare war on Islamic fundamentalists, we would be declaring war on a people not for what they've done, but for who they are. It would be an ideological war fought, not for our safety, but because they hold different beliefs and values.

That absolutely must not be what this is about.

What this should be about is finding the people who coordinated the 9/11 attacks and holding them responsible.


Having said that, I think a lot of legal terms do not apply well to the current world situation -- and by "current" I mean since 1990 or so. Laws dealing with criminals are separate from laws dealing with international relations -- and both do not take into account that a group without allegiance to ANY government can inflict damage on the scale of a sizeable war. That sort of thing simlpy could not occur during Industrial Age, so our laws do not cover it.
Which of the following, exactly, do our laws not cover:
  • Hijacking
  • Murder
  • Reckless endangerment
  • Destruction of property
  • Terrorism
  • Conspiracy
  • Extradition from a foreign country
Am I missing anything?

So, what do we call a violent movement, not controlled by any government (although allied to some), and bound more by common ideology than by any definable organization? It is a lot more than a criminal gang, but less than a military force.
The Mob. International organized crime.

As for how do we know War on Terror (or whatever we call it) has been won? I would say when there is not a single madrassa left in the world openly calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers (i.e. either destroyed or driven into hiding), I would say it has been won.
How far are you willing to curtail free speech like that? Will you only watch the madrassas or will you also watch the mosques? Will you watch the city halls and the market places? How about in individual homes?

Do you only count the fundamentalists or all Muslims? Do you count just the Muslims or anyone from any religion?

What if they only speak of wounding unbelievers? What if they only speak poorly about unbelievers? Do we not allow anyone to think negatively about anyone else?

What you are talking about is not a War on Terror, it's a war on thought. That is why this must not be a war on based someone else's beliefs or values, but rather on their actions.
 
Which of the following, exactly, do our laws not cover:

It isn't enough that a law covers something. We had laws that covered extraditing bin Laden from foreign countries, for example. But it didn't happen, and passing laws couldn't make it happen.

How far are you willing to curtail free speech like that?

Incitement to violence? That's already unprotected speech in the US, and pretty much always has been. And it isn't more generous speech protection which makes such speech permissible elsewhere.
 
One of the reasons that our nation, and indeed the world, is so divided on the so-called War on Terror, is that we have major divisions over what motivates the people who make war on us.

If you're a traditional leftist, you see everything through the lens of capitalist, colonialist oppression, and suicide bombers look like stalwart and admirable fighters against The Man. To people like Michael Moore, they are simply freedom fighters, just like the Minute Men of our own revolution.

If you're a multi-culturalist, you see them as misunderstood, their culture under daily siege from an unrelenting barrage of western music, and sexual images, and women with flesh exposed to the world. It's only understandable that they would want to strike out, and even end their lives when they hear about their holy book being defiled (whether it actually happened or not).

To others, of a transnational international-law bent (Upchurch seems to be in this group), their behavior is not so easily excused, but they're still just a criminal gang, a problem to be solved by international cooperation among police agencies. Whenever they commit one of these crimes, they are to be infiltrated, arrested, indicted, tried, and imprisoned (though never executed -- that's so uncivilized and... American). It might even be acceptable to infiltrate them before the crime is committed, if there's some chance that it might actually prevent one of these crimes from occurring, as long as we don't go too far, and violate their civil rights in any way.

Whereas I see them as the latest totalitarian ideology, like the Stalinists, the Maoists, and their spinoffs the Khmer Rouge and Shining Path, who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT (yes, Upchurch, that's exactly what it is!), and are not only willing to murder innocents to accomplish their vile goals, but revel in doing so.

Similarly, many seemingly seek to look into the mind of a terrorist and his actions, and see what they want to see: anger at Israel, anger at the apparent impotence of the Arab world against the west, frustration at the inability to raise your children as properly Islamic in a secular West, even the desire for the reestablishment of the Caliphate.

Sadly, I agree that all of the above are motivating the bombers, and many of the people who agree with them. But if these are the grievances, they cannot be assuaged, they cannot be appeased. They are what we call in American divorce courts, "irreconcilable differences."

Yes, we could withdraw from Iraq, but they were doing this before we were in Iraq, and Egypt, last time I checked, had no troops in Iraq. Withdrawing from Iraq won't change the desire of many British Muslims to swaddle their women from head to toe, to force adolescent girls to marry old men they've never met, to call down Fatwas on homosexuals. Yielding to demands to allow Arabs to flood into Israel won't bring about peace in the Middle East. Once we've sacrificed the Iraqi people, struggling for democracy, once we've sacrificed the Jews to them, they'll only hunger for further expansion of their Caliphate. There cannot be peaceful coexistence with a people whose ultimate goal is to compel everyone to live under a single religion, one that is not just a religion but a way of life. And if that's the case, the only ultimate solution is to defeat them militarily, however long it takes, which sadly cannot be done without killing large numbers of them, because it may well prove impossible to change their minds.
 
It isn't enough that a law covers something. We had laws that covered extraditing bin Laden from foreign countries, for example. But it didn't happen, and passing laws couldn't make it happen.
Therein the invasion of Afghanistan was more than justified.


Incitement to violence?
If it could reasonably be considered to incite violence, yes, but you have to make that distinction.

If I were to say, "Oh, I could just kill the neighbor if he lets his dog howl all night again!" then I would not reasonably be guilty of conspiracy to commit murder. What Mark6 was saying (in the context of a war on an specific belief system) is that any kind of public talk on a certain topic, meant literally or not, was justification for war.

Somehow, he thinks that if it is said in private that it is okay. Not sure what that is about.
 
Whereas I see them as the latest totalitarian ideology, like the Stalinists, the Maoists, and their spinoffs the Khmer Rouge and Shining Path, who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT (yes, Upchurch, that's exactly what it is!), and are not only willing to murder innocents to accomplish their vile goals, but revel in doing so.
So, as Travis put it, you would be willing to fight the savage brute by becoming a savage brute?

It is not the thought that is dangerous. It is the ability and action taken to "make the world conform to their THOUGHT" that is dangerous. I have no problem restricting harmful actions against others (of, failing that, punishing those harmful acts), but if you attempt to restrict the thoughts and values of others, how are you any different than those who would make the world conform to their thoughts and values?


Withdrawing from Iraq won't change the desire of many British Muslims to swaddle their women from head to toe, to force adolescent girls to marry old men they've never met, to call down Fatwas on homosexuals.
Nor will it prevent anyone from criticizing them for it. Or passing laws that prevent forced marriages from taking place in countries where those laws can be passed.


Yielding to demands to allow Arabs to flood into Israel won't bring about peace in the Middle East.
I did not suggest that it would, nor did I suggest that they should be allowed to do so.


Once we've sacrificed the Iraqi people, struggling for democracy, once we've sacrificed the Jews to them, they'll only hunger for further expansion of their Caliphate. There cannot be peaceful coexistence with a people whose ultimate goal is to compel everyone to live under a single religion, one that is not just a religion but a way of life. And if that's the case, the only ultimate solution is to defeat them militarily, however long it takes, which sadly cannot be done without killing large numbers of them, because it may well prove impossible to change their minds.
And what will sacrificing the Muslims to people who think the way you do accomplish? Should that "ultimate solution" (interesting choice of words, btw) be applied to you as well, as you would have also compelled people to conform to your way of life (i.e. not Muslim)?


eta: Just in case I'm being thick, are you being sarcastic? Referring to genocide as the "ultimate solution", a synonym for "final solution", and all?
 
Last edited:
Therein the invasion of Afghanistan was more than justified.

The issue of whether or not to go into Iraq was not the same as the issue of whether or not terrorism can be treated like a law enforcement problem.

If it could reasonably be considered to incite violence, yes, but you have to make that distinction.

Mark6's statement was about preachers "calling for global jihad and killing of unbeliever". You quoted that part in your response. And it rather explicitly and obviously refers to incitement to violence. So I'm at a loss as to why you objected on free speech grounds when you acknowlege that incitements to violence are not protected.

Somehow, he thinks that if it is said in private that it is okay. Not sure what that is about.

There are several rather obvious reasons he did not include private behavior. One of the most obvious is that as a practical matter, we cannot know what people are doing in private, and so the question (when will we know the war on terror is over) is simply not answerable if we adopt a metric we can't actually measure, and we cannot accurately measure private behavior, especially in cases where people might have reason to conceal it. There are other additional reasons for not adopting such a standard (I'll leave it as an exercise to you to figure some of them out - you need the practice), but regardless, none of that means that Mark6 in any way approves of such incitement in private, making your statement a complete logical disconnect.
 
Last edited:
... or fighting.

Oh wait, I heard rumors on the internets that there are indeed two ore three US Soldiers in Afghanistan based on the war on terror premise.


Well, Upchurch, I was addressing you with this rather sarcastic remark. There is no "War on Terror" since the main focus never was on Terrorism. So what is this thread about anyway? :confused:
 
The issue of whether or not to go into Iraq was not the same as the issue of whether or not terrorism can be treated like a law enforcement problem.
I don't consider the issue of whether or not to go into Iraq as relevant to the 9/11 attack. It is highly questionable if it was relevant to the War on Terror (for any reasonable definitions of "terror"). That decision is a separate issue altogether and I was not referring to it.


Mark6's statement was about preachers "calling for global jihad and killing of unbeliever". You quoted that part in your response. And it rather explicitly and obviously refers to incitement to violence. So I'm at a loss as to why you objected on free speech grounds when you acknowlege that incitements to violence are not protected.
How many calling for global jihads, etc., are there and how many of them actually lead to violence? Simply making threatening speeches does not necessarily equate to violence taking place.

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but in order to incite violence, it must be reasonable that your words will actually result in violence. Does every call for jihad and killing the unbeliever end in violence?


There are other additional reasons for not adopting such a standard (I'll leave it as an exercise to you to figure some of them out - you need the practice), but regardless, none of that means that Mark6 in any way approves of such incitement in private, making your statement a complete logical disconnect.
I suggest you re-read what he said:
Mark6 said:
As for how do we know War on Terror (or whatever we call it) has been won? I would say when there is not a single madrassa left in the world openly calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers (i.e. either destroyed or driven into hiding), I would say it has been won. How will we know it happened? Well, the word "openly" is key here. If they are open about it, we know it has not been won yet.
At best, he is ambiguous about it.

He does not mention the practicality of doing enforcing it a private level. It is a matter of comfort. If they are comfortable talking about it openly, the war is not won. If they are not comfortable talking about it openly (leaving room for talking about it privately), the war is won.
 
Well, Upchurch, I was addressing you with this rather sarcastic remark. There is no "War on Terror" since the main focus never was on Terrorism. So what is this thread about anyway? :confused:
Oh, there is a War on Terror, all right. It has a Wikipedia article and everything. It seems to encompass far more than just terrorism. Or perhaps, it has little to do with terrorism. It's hard to say.

Whatever it is, this thread is about specifying what criteria must be met in order for it to be over.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom