How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

I believe the threat of terrorism will increase over time. Terrorism is far more effective against a liberal democracy than against any other form of government. The more liberal and the more democratic a state becomes, the more vulnerable it is to terrorism.
 
I believe the threat of terrorism will increase over time. Terrorism is far more effective against a liberal democracy than against any other form of government. The more liberal and the more democratic a state becomes, the more vulnerable it is to terrorism.

Good point. It saddens me to see how tolerant, liberal people treat intolerance with tolerance or indifference just for the sake of holding up their tolerance.
 
I believe the threat of terrorism will increase over time. Terrorism is far more effective against a liberal democracy than against any other form of government. The more liberal and the more democratic a state becomes, the more vulnerable it is to terrorism.


Wow, that's the most impressive Argument against Democracy I heard in a while.

Run, Netherlands! - Run, Poland! - Run, Luxembourg! - Run New Zealand! We democratic/liberal Nations will all gonna die teh Terrordeath. :rolleyes:

You acknowledge how ridiculous your worldview is? You should start to comprehend that 9/11 and the "War on Terror" would never have happened if the US would just stay at home when it comes to the ME.

Simple as that.
 
Please, enlighten us. What does jihad mean to a Muslim?
Jihad means "struggle", in part against others but also against one's own faults and vices. For some, it is the stereotypical physical fight against non-believers. My understanding is that more commonly, it is considered a kind of self-improvement: a struggle against sin.
 
You should start to comprehend that 9/11 and the "War on Terror" would never have happened if the US would just stay at home when it comes to the ME.

Simple as that.

The US went to Saudi Arabia because Saddam attacked Kuwait. They stayed and somehow the little nutjob OBL didn't like it.
 
Jihad means "struggle", in part against others but also against one's own faults and vices. For some, it is the stereotypical physical fight against non-believers. My understanding is that more commonly, it is considered a kind of self-improvement: a struggle against sin.

That is the impression some are striving to create. I am skeptical of such claims, however. The only time I ever hear jihad used that way is when people are trying to explain that it can be used that way, whereas the people who use it to mean violence don't need to explain the manner in which they mean it. That suggests rather strongly to me that whatever possible meanings the word might have, the most common meaning remains one of violence.
 
I can offer what the commentary in 'Umdat al-Salik (verified by al-Azhar, Egypt) has to say about this:

o9.0 JIHAD said:
(O: Jihad means to wage war against non-Muslims, and is etymologically derived from the word mujahada, signifying warfare to establish the religion. And it is the lesser jihad. As for the greater jihad, it is spiritual warfare against the lower self (nafs), which is why the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) said as he was returning from jihad,

"We have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad."

My conclusion is: It means both, but one should not mistake the word lesser for less important.
 
Neither should one consider all "calls for jihad" to be necessarily calls for violence against others, correct?

Dear Upchurch, which part of 'Jihad means to wage war against non-Muslims, and is etymologically derived from the word mujahada, signifying warfare to establish the religion.' did you not understand?

I don't recall any 'calls for jihad' in a different context; can you produce some?
'Jihad in the way of Allah' would be something that sounds like 'Jihad fi sabil Allah'.

You might want to argue it depends on the context, but I really haven't seen it being used outside of this context and the problem is that it's just too interlinked - even if 'a call for jihad' is not directly a call for violence against others, it will eventually end there.

Once the inner struggle is resolved, or at least thus far deemed to be under control, and 'a call for jihad' is spoken - what else is left than violence against non-Muslims? What other meaning?

You also have to ask yourself: What does the inner struggle mean and consist of to a Muslim? Part of it in the context of war would be to overcome one's own reluctance to fight the enemy and submission to Allah and his messenger - and both, from a Muslim view point - command to wage war against the 'unbelievers' until Islam reigns supreme over the earth.
 
I don't recall any 'calls for jihad' in a different context; can you produce some?
I won't even pretend to be an Islamic scholar. The best I can do without more research is what Wikipedia has to offer:
In Modern Standard Arabic, jihad is one of the correct terms for a struggle for any cause, violent or not, religious or secular (though كفاح kifāḥ is also used). For instance, Mahatma Gandhi's struggle for Indian independence is called a "jihad" in Modern Standard Arabic (as well as many other dialects of Arabic); the terminology is applied to the fight for women's liberation.

In modern times, Pakistani scholar and professor Fazlur Rahman has used the term to describe the struggle to establish "just moral-social order", while President Habib Bourguiba of Tunisia has used it to describe the struggle for economic development in Tunisia.
Should these also be silenced before we can consider the War on Terror won?

[sarcasm]
If women are liberated and Tunisia's economy develops, the terrorists win!
[/sarcasm]
 
Well I thought we were still in the context of madrassas and masjids etc; i.e. the meaning as laid out by the commentary I cited. If I were to speak of an Endlösung for a mathematical issue it would be something else than if I were a Nazi talking about it, wouldn't it?

That politicians in Muslim majority or Islamic countries utilize terms like jihad shouldn't be surprising, besides the meaning of a 'normal' struggle in the case of Ghandi.

In the case of Mr. Rahman though you have to think about what this "just moral-social order*" would look like and what it brings with it. Also, what the usage of this term applied to a Muslim audience can actually cause and who will carry this change.

Should these also be silenced before we can consider the War on Terror won?

It wasn't my idea to silence anyone.

*To pick up on that point without derailing; Just as a sidenote: If you keep the whole Islamic mindset in mind and what a "just moral-social order" is in Islam and read the 'Islam is against terror' statements you might get sick after a while when it's almost always phrased a la 'Islam condemns the indifferent killing of innocent people'. Sounds great when you don't think much about it and have a quick read without the emphasis, doesn't it? Maybe not after a closer look. I can honestly not understand anyone pandering to those people and unfortuneately, there are too many doing just that.
 
Last edited:
I won't even pretend to be an Islamic scholar. The best I can do without more research is what Wikipedia has to offer:

Should these also be silenced before we can consider the War on Terror won?

[sarcasm]
If women are liberated and Tunisia's economy develops, the terrorists win!
[/sarcasm]
I would agree to the extent that the "war on poverty" is unrelated to what the term WAR means. Tell me, what context does OBL, Hamas, Hezbollah, the Muslim Brotherhood, the Taliban etc. use when it comes to Jihad? I couldn't care less if an Islamic country declares a "Jihad on poverty", but that is not what Islamic nations or groups mean when they declare a Jihad against other nations or populations of non-believers. If a Mullah is preaching Jihad in his Mosque against non-believers or governments it is supremely logical to assume it means to make war and to act accordingly. OBL declared Jihad on the United States years before 911 and he was pretty much laughed at. That is a mistake I hope we never repeat.
 
If a Mullah is preaching Jihad in his Mosque against non-believers or governments it is supremely logical to assume it means to make war and to act accordingly. OBL declared Jihad on the United States years before 911 and he was pretty much laughed at. That is a mistake I hope we never repeat.

He did it cleverly as well! More or less. At least he was following tradition it seems, when he invited America to embrace Islam:

OBL (not sure if it's the 1st time he did this) said:
"There are two solutions to stopping it. One is from our side, and it is to escalate the fighting and killing against you. This is our duty, and our brothers are carrying it out," bin Laden said.

"The second solution is from your side," he said. "I invite you to embrace Islam."
From wcbstv article.
(Muslim,) Book 019, Number 4294:

It has been reported from Sulaiman b. Buraid through his father that when the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) appointed anyone as leader of an army or detachment he ... would say: Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war, ... (w)hen you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. If they respond to any one of these, you also accept it and withold yourself from doing them any harm. Invite them to (accept) Islam; [...] Then invite them to migrate from their lands to the land of Muhairs [...] If they refuse to migrate, tell them that they will have the status of Bedouin Muilims and will be subjected to the Commands of Allah like other Muslims [...] If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them. [...]

Koran 9 said:
SHAKIR: Fight those who do not believe in Allah, nor in the latter day, nor do they prohibit what Allah and His Messenger have prohibited, nor follow the religion of truth, out of those who have been given the Book, until they pay the tax in acknowledgment of superiority and they are in a state of subjection.

[quote='Umdat al-Salik o9.8 THE OBJECTIVES OF JIHAD] 09.8 The caliph (o25) makes war upon Jews, Christians and Zoroastrians (N: provided he has first invited them to enter Islam in faith and practice, and if they will not, then invited them to enter the social order of Islam by paying the non-Muslim poll tax (jizya, def: o11.4) ... while remaining in their ancestral religions) (O: and the war continues) until they become Muslim or else pay the non-Muslim poll tax (O: in accordance with the word of Allah Most High, "..." (Koran 9:29) [...]"[/quote]

Also note o9.6 and o9.9, which say:

[quote='Umdat al-Salik]o9.6 It is offensive to conduct military expedition against hostile non-Muslims without the caliph's permission (A: though if there is no caliph (de: o25), no permission is required).[/quote]
[quote='Umdat al-Salik]o9.9 The caliph fights all other peoples until they become Muslim [...][/quote]
 
Last edited:
Do I think we should find, capture, or kill those responsible for planning and executing the 9/11 attacks? You betcha! Do I believe that has been the primary goal of the current "War on Terror" since 2003? Nope.

Ok. Let's say we leave Iraq and concentrate on Afghanistan to find OBL. By some miracle we find him and kill or capture him. Then what? Is that the end of the WOT? You have focused exclusively on 911. 911 was just the most spectacular act out of thousands committed by hundreds of terrorist organisations around the world many of which are state sponsored. That is the reactive thinking we had been using all along. It is simply not enough to just react to each attack and then wait passivly for the next one.

In my view the WOT will be "won" when Nations that harbor these organisations and even provide active support are more afraid of the consequences of such support than they are of the terrorists themselves.
There will always be terrorists but they would be almost impotent without the type of support they get from nation states in the Middle East. In the case of Islamic terroism the Middle Eastern countries hold the keys to the end of the WOT if they have the will to do so.

As far as the United States the domestic WOT has been quite effective since 911 in regard to further attacks at home. That could just be dumb luck or it could be that OBL at least was not prepared for the ferocity of the military response and decided to go after softer targets. Spain and the UK haven't been quite as fortunate.
 
In my view the WOT will be "won" when Nations that harbor these organisations and even provide active support are more afraid of the consequences of such support than they are of the terrorists themselves.
There will always be terrorists but they would be almost impotent without the type of support they get from nation states in the Middle East.

I agree but I'd like to add failed states or near-failed states as well as financial support coming from outside the Middle East by those like the CAIR affiliated organisations; CAIR seems to be entangled with those who collect money which is then channeled to jihadists and many of the major Islamic organizations in 'the West' seem to have shady dealings going on, often under the disguise of 'relief help'. Although one might wonder if people just aren't interpreting things from an Islamic POV. Those crappy 'Islam is peace' campaigns don't help with that among other things.


In the case of Islamic terroism the Middle Eastern countries hold the keys to the end of the WOT if they have the will to do so.

And how would they do that? Many of the states' governments are either Muslim themselves or not exactly antipathetic to them. Not to mention the Muslim mobs we could experience over cartoons. Or all the cells and little organizations. Imagine the same thing over a government that is not deemed Islamic enough while having no means of security or weak defense forces to control them. Lebanon comes to mind.
 
Last edited:
I


And how would they do that? Many of the states' governments are either Muslim themselves or not exactly antipathetic to them. Not to mention the Muslim mobs we could experience over cartoons. Or all the cells and little organizations. Imagine the same thing over a government that is not deemed Islamic enough while having no means of security or weak defense forces to control them. Lebanon comes to mind.

They could stop stoning women and stone terrorists instead. That was sarcasm which I am lousy at. I agree that it may be too late for that. I know the vast majority don't want to admit it but maybe in the end the only way to win the WOT may be total war on a global scale. Should the next attack take the form of a nuclear or biological weapon and kills tens of thousands then there will be no more talk of moderation or trying to understand the reasons it will just be hell unleashed on to that part of the world.
 
It wasn't my idea to silence anyone.
I know. That was in response to Mark6's proposal.

In my view the WOT will be "won" when Nations that harbor these organisations and even provide active support are more afraid of the consequences of such support than they are of the terrorists themselves.
There are some pragmatic questions about how that might be guaged, but from a more philosophical perspective, would it be accurate to restate your position as:

The War On Terror is won when the nations that harbor terrorist organizations are more terrified of us than they are of the terrorist organizations.​

Wouldn't it be ironic if the only way to win the War On Terror is to be the biggest source of terror?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom