How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

Never thought I'd say this, but I'm glad George is in charge over there, and not Hunster.

Hunster scares me. (Funny, but I bet that pleases him)
 
*bump*
When you no longer find the need to ask that question.
FWIW, I still feel the need to ask the question.

Any new insights on this at least two year old question? Or to broaden the scope a little, I'll also include the question: How do you know when the war in Iraq is won?
 
I have a question: What should the US have done in response to 9/11? Nothing but a UN resolution condemning it?
I am not comfortable with the idea that someone can kill 3000 people on US soil and it should be written off as "A unfortunate incident" or "The cost of doing business".
Bush has screwed up the battle against Terrorism incredibly with his stupid invasion of Iraq. but saying we should not battle terrorism by all means..including the military....is,IMHO, unrealistic.
BTW, I don't hear Obama talk about giving up the fight against Terrorism.
 
It will be like in those fantasy movies where the old wise man tells the protaganist, "you will know when the time comes!" Then everyone can go back to the Shire.
 
I have a question: What should the US have done in response to 9/11? Nothing but a UN resolution condemning it?
I am not comfortable with the idea that someone can kill 3000 people on US soil and it should be written off as "A unfortunate incident" or "The cost of doing business".
I wasn't aware that anyone had suggested this course of action. I thought at the time, and still think, that going into Afghanistan after Bin Laden (or where ever he happened to have gone) was an appropriate response to 9/11.

My question was about the concept of a War On Terror and what the measurable goals are.


Bush has screwed up the battle against Terrorism incredibly with his stupid invasion of Iraq. but saying we should not battle terrorism by all means..including the military....is,IMHO, unrealistic.
I don't know about all means, but I'm certainly not against using the military to that end.

...but what does that have to do with anything?

BTW, I don't hear Obama talk about giving up the fight against Terrorism.
...I hadn't either. Was there a reason you would expect him to?
 
You find that calling me stupid is funny.

Of course not. Calling you stupid isn't funny at all. The humor is in the delivery, which is why I only implied it. But explaining humor ruins it, so it's not really funny anymore.
 
As soon as Koran Fried Chicken spreads its greasy bearded goodness all over the Middle East. I'll have a Mohammad 5 piece special with a side of Infidel tortured potatoes and Sharia mutilated biscuits.
 
I wasn't aware that anyone had suggested this course of action. I thought at the time, and still think, that going into Afghanistan after Bin Laden (or where ever he happened to have gone) was an appropriate response to 9/11.

Well that's refreshing. Most people who question the validity of the WOT think the terrorists are noble freedom fighters, that capitalism is evil and believe in peace at all costs.

My question was about the concept of a War On Terror and what the measurable goals are.

While using the term "war" seems to imply that this should be some sort of tidy and easily definable activity such as declaring a war with a nation state which is usually over when one of the states surrenders or negotiates a cessation of hostilities (though even that is not always so discernible as sometimes rogue elements of a nation will continue the war long after the government actually surrendered) this is not "war" in that sense and is more a "war" in sense of it being a "conflict." Would calling it the Conflict With Terrorism be any better? We, as a stable free society, are certainly in conflict with Terrorism in the sense that we, hopefully, wish to prevent it and that, ultimately, is the measurable goal; the absence of terrorism is the hallmark of a "victory." I suppose we could put some sort of statistical goal out there, in the way they do for the War On Poverty, such that less then X number of terrorist attacks over Y period of time are the benchmark of victory. If so, what should those numbers be?
 
Whenever I see "war on terror" I read it as "war of terror" (thank you Borat).

Speaking seriously though, I agree with pipelineaudio's initial post, way back when. The War on Terror (which is actually a War on Radical Islam, it's just everyone is too PC to admit it) will end when we lose and they win. I give it a couple of hundreds years or so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom