How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

I don't believe Congress declared "War" on terror, either.....

Sure, they did.

They declared a War on Poverty and a War on Drugs, too.

That little thing in Vietnam was declared a "conflict".

Feeling better?
 
Hardly. Going to war is surely the most significant act a nation can undertake. Terminology, conditions of war, etc. are at their most importance at such a time.

Consider the last time we went to war. Here is the full declaration:


Please provide me with a citation where the US Congress (not the President - by the Constitution he does not have the power to declare war) declared that the USA is in a "state of war" with Iraq....

Well, Congress has been very cowardly with regard to war. They don't seem to "declare" war anymore, however, they do "authorize" it:

The 1st Gulf War was "authorized".

I'd like to see Congress step up to the plate that was intended, but it appears that they prefer to relegate that to the President. I suppose that's how "kings" are made.

Go ahead. Blame the president. Further the problem.

The problem is that we have a bunch of cowards in Congress.
 
The War on Terror will be won when we no longer notice it's being fought....

Yeah, right. Like has been posted:

War on Drugs
War on Poverty
War on Crime
War on Illegal Immigration
War on Indecency

Don't hold your breath.

...Although that sounds bad, fighting a War on Terror for decades isn't anything like fighting a conventional war for decades.

Yup, you're right. It doesn't sound bad.

But it will be like the wars illustrated above. Noble, right, and lasting forever.

If you don't intend to fight, you'd better sit down, be quiet, and accept the consequences.

If you intend to fight, you'd better get it on, and fight like there's no tomorrow.

Anything else is foolish.
 
Rates are time independent. If you're saying that even though the rates of death and destruction are lower in a WoT the total amount might be as much as a conventional war because the WoT will last longer, then, well, perhaps, depending on how long the hypothetical conventional war would last. It depends on a lot of things.

Look at it this way, if people keep dying at the rate they have been so far in the WoT (if we definte the WoT as beginning on 9/11/2001), then how long would the WoT have to last until the number of deaths equalled the number of deaths in WW II? I don't know the answer to that but I think it would be a very long time. Then again, the nature of the WoT is such that that could change quickly. I mean, maybe a million people will be killed by a dirty bomb in NYC tomorrow and then the rates of deaths change a lot.

Are you stating that all wars should be hot?

I tend to think that, but after thousands of years of hot wars, and the advent of chemical and nuclear weapons, I may be a dinosaur.

This "nitpicking" war stuff is tiring, though. Frankly, I think every location that Osama is thought to be should be thoroughly carpet bombed by B-52 conventional bombs. If it's in a habited town, it should be considered like German or Japanese cities during WWII.

War is Hell. Deliver more Hell than your enemy.
 
Last edited:
Are you stating that all wars should be hot?

I tend to think that, but after thousands of years of hot wars, and the advent of chemical and nuclear weapons, I may be a dinosaur.

This "nitpicking" war stuff is tiring, though. Frankly, I think every location that Osama is thought to be should be thoroughly carpet bombed by B-52conventional bombs. If it's in a habited town, it should be considered like German or Japanese cities during WWII.

War is Hell. Deliver more Hell than your enemy.
Wow, just wow. Do not insult dinosaurs. You are a bloodthirsty hypocrite with a very sad twisted mind.
 
Wow, just wow. Do not insult dinosaurs....

Why not? Dinosaurs are dead, and they were more bloodthirsty than you claim I am.

...You are a bloodthirsty hypocrite with a very sad twisted mind....

Nope.

I'm a warrior. When somebody wants a fight, I want to give them more fight than they wanted.

That's how you win, which is what you go into a fight for (whether you picked the fight or not).
 
A warrior? That's a laugh. So your idea of a warrior is someone who carpet bombs thousands of innocents on the off chance they get their target? Also by carpet bombing the area there is a good chance you will never know if you DID get your target.
Dinosaurs were certainly not more bloodthirsty than you. They killed what they needed to survive, not what they needed plus everything else living in a few square mile radius.
I guess the whole "Thou shalt not kill" bit was wasted on you in church, huh?
 
A warrior? That's a laugh....

Actually, it's not so much a laugh. It's some serious stuff. Depressing, actually.

...So your idea of a warrior is someone who carpet bombs thousands of innocents on the off chance they get their target?...

No, "my idea" of a warrior is one who engages in total war. I don't expect you to understand what that means.

...Also by carpet bombing the area there is a good chance you will never know if you DID get your target....

Not really.

If he survives, he'll either go into submission, go into complete hiding, or engage in the type of war that Osama has chosen from the outset (very wise on his part, BTW).

If he doesn't survive, he goes away, along with his minions.

...Dinosaurs were certainly not more bloodthirsty than you. They killed what they needed to survive, not what they needed plus everything else living in a few square mile radius....

I'm not a dinosaur. I'm a warrior.

If you're a "peacenik", get to "peace-nikking".

If you fail, get the hell out of the way.

...I guess the whole "Thou shalt not kill" bit was wasted on you in church, huh?

Nope. Killing is wrong.

That goes for Osama as well as GW and me.

But when the killing happens, I want to be on the killing and righteous side, not the dying and stupid side.

You?

Do you deny the fact of life and death? Do you deny the facts of righteous and wrong? Do you deny the facts of democracy and dictatorship?

Where do you stand?
 
Actually, it's not so much a laugh. It's some serious stuff. Depressing, actually.

That's right, you've wrestled bigfoots and sasquatches in your backyard.

No, "my idea" of a warrior is one who engages in total war. I don't expect you to understand what that means.

Your one-man war against the evil armies of sasquatch and bigoot doesn't really count. Your LARPing on the JREF forum isn't really going to impress everyone. You are simply a twit on a forum that pretends to be more intelligent, brave and tough than you'll ever be. You are a woo-woo fool armed with nothing but a keyboard and still unable to use it effectively.
 
Where do I stand? I have no problem killing the ones who need killing. I am in no way a "peace-nik".

But killing perhaps thousands of innocents to possibly kill the one who deserves it? That isn't righteous. That's ineffective. That's bloodthirsty That's just about totally murderously insane.

As for your comment that you don't expect me to understand what that means, you have no idea of me or my background. There are plenty of people both on this forum and this planet that have military experience that can draw a rational distinction between killing the enemy and your 'kill em all and let god sort em out' machismo garbage.

Thankfully it seems most countries have people that can draw that distinction making the tactical decisions and not bloodthirsty freaks like you. We do have a term for people who blow up an entire area to get there intended target or message across. Fundy terrorist.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
Actually, it's not so much a laugh. It's some serious stuff. Depressing, actually.
That's right, you've wrestled bigfoots and sasquatches in your backyard....

Nope. Never even seen a sasquatch.

But I've seen "thai boxers".

Wasn't impressed.

No, "my idea" of a warrior is one who engages in total war. I don't expect you to understand what that means.

Your one-man war against the evil armies of sasquatch and bigoot doesn't really count.

I'm not waging war against "evil armies of sasquatch and biggot". I'm waging war against idiots......

Like you.

...Your LARPing on the JREF forum isn't really going to impress everyone....

Damned shame. I'd hoped my LARPing would have an effect.

I never expected the learned to be effected by LARPing, but I figured idiots might learn something.

Of course, I have no idea what LARPing is, but I'm willing to learn.

...You are simply a twit on a forum that pretends to be more intelligent, brave and tough than you'll ever be. You are a woo-woo fool armed with nothing but a keyboard and still unable to use it effectively....

Pray you never know the truth.

Bye, ken. I *clicked* you earlier, but unclicked you in some sort of foolish regret.

Now, you're *clicked* forever.

Wisely so, I might add.
 
Where do I stand? I have no problem killing the ones who need killing. I am in no way a "peace-nik".

But killing perhaps thousands of innocents to possibly kill the one who deserves it? That isn't righteous. That's ineffective. That's bloodthirsty That's just about totally murderously insane....

Welcome to today's warmaking policy.

Notice Osama is still out and about, making videos, and under the protection and loving care of the locals.

One man. Against the whole U.S. of A. After killing thousands of innocent American (and other) civilians.

He's still out there.

Your answer?

...As for your comment that you don't expect me to understand what that means, you have no idea of me or my background. There are plenty of people both on this forum and this planet that have military experience that can draw a rational distinction between killing the enemy and your 'kill em all and let god sort em out' machismo garbage....

You're right. I have no idea of your background.

Nor do you have an idea of mine. Nor do you know of my "foreground".

...Thankfully it seems most countries have people that can draw that distinction making the tactical decisions and not bloodthirsty freaks like you. We do have a term for people who blow up an entire area to get there intended target or message across. Fundy terrorist.

That's your word for me. I disagree.

I'm not much for "fundy", and I'm damned sure not much for "terrorism".

But when war is declared (especially when somebody else did the "declaring"), it's open season.

And "domestics" that whine and cry, IMO, are part of the problem.

A BIG part of the problem.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
Sure, they did.
They declared a War on Poverty and a War on Drugs, too.

Please give a cite to a bill passed by both houses and signed by the President that uses the words "War" and "Poverty" or "Drugs" that invokes the real meaning of the word "war"....

You don't get it, do you?

They declared war on poverty, drugs, etc.

They refused to declare war on North Vietnam. That was a "conflict".

There was plenty of "talk" of war on poverty and drugs.

Have you seen the casulties?

With regard to the "real meaning of war", do you know that "real meaning"?

Been there? Done that?

Originally Posted by Huntster :
Feeling better?

I am, thanks for asking..

I'm glad you feel good!

I feel good, too!
 
You're right. I have no idea of your background.

Nor do you have an idea of mine. Nor do you know of my "foreground".

Gee lets see, at a guess...
Roman Catholic.
Served and saw action in the military.
Married to a school teacher whom he seems terrified of.
Thinks he once saw bigfoot tracks.
Lives in Alaska and spends his spare time hunting bear, caribou, moose & occaisionaly wolf.

How did I do on your background and foreground? Quite a bit better than you would do on mine I think.

I'm not much for "fundy", and I'm damned sure not much for "terrorism".

But when war is declared (especially when somebody else did the "declaring"), it's open season.

Open season on innocent bystanders? Again I repeat carpet bombing is not an exact science, it's hit & hope. You are certain to kill a whole bunch of people but not certain to kill the ones you want dad. Your 'solution' is to maybe kill Osama and maybe create a thousand more like him out of the survivors of your carpet bombing.
And "domestics" that whine and cry, IMO, are part of the problem.

A BIG part of the problem.

Sorry I must have missed the bit where telling you you were a bloodthirsty maniac was whining or crying. I guess that first amendment you swore to uphold along with the rest of the constitution must really irritate you since voices of dissent are such a BIG part of the problem.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
You're right. I have no idea of your background.

Nor do you have an idea of mine. Nor do you know of my "foreground".

Gee lets see, at a guess...
Roman Catholic.
Served and saw action in the military.
Married to a school teacher whom he seems terrified of.
Thinks he once saw bigfoot tracks.
Lives in Alaska and spends his spare time hunting bear, caribou, moose & occaisionaly wolf.

How did I do on your background and foreground? Quite a bit better than you would do on mine I think....

Not bad at the background, although I gave it to you.

And the foreground?


Originally Posted by Huntster :
I'm not much for "fundy", and I'm damned sure not much for "terrorism".

But when war is declared (especially when somebody else did the "declaring"), it's open season.


Open season on innocent bystanders? Again I repeat carpet bombing is not an exact science, it's hit & hope.

Apparently you don't have much background on "open season", do you?

Yeah, carpet bombing isn't an "exact science", but it's science nonetheless.

It's total destruction. Total destruction destroys totally. It has an effect.

You might call it "total war". Complete. No BS. A long time ago military leaders realized that warfare isn't a game. Apparently, you haven't figured that out. I can understand why.

Osama is hiding. He's getting help. He's supported. He's causing big problems here, and his ilk is causing problems there.

Those who are squeemish about warfare are causing problems here. Been there, done that.

You have your right to talk and write. I have my right to ignore your drivel.

We don't have near enough troops or effort in SW Asia to put this thing to bed. Were it me, I'd do more than "carpet bomb".

...You are certain to kill a whole bunch of people but not certain to kill the ones you want dad. Your 'solution' is to maybe kill Osama and maybe create a thousand more like him out of the survivors of your carpet bombing...

We carpet bombed North Vietnam. Big time. In my lifetime.

No problems there now, are there? In fact, diplomatic relations have been restored.

Originally Posted by Huntster :
And "domestics" that whine and cry, IMO, are part of the problem.

A BIG part of the problem.


Sorry I must have missed the bit where telling you you were a bloodthirsty maniac was whining or crying. I guess that first amendment you swore to uphold along with the rest of the constitution must really irritate you since voices of dissent are such a BIG part of the problem.

Yup. You musta missed it.

You seem to miss a lot.

I swore to uphold all the Constitution, not just the 1st Amendment. People like you make that oath challenging.

I'm glad you aren't one of us. You don't qualify.
 
Last edited:
So, when not engaged in wrestling sasquatch, do you dabble in wizardy and alchemy? Oh, I see you're suspended, rendering your only weapon here (the keyboard) useless for a time being.
 
We carpet bombed North Vietnam. Big time. In my lifetime.

No problems there now, are there? In fact, diplomatic relations have been restored.
Yeah but you may have forgotton in your dotage the North Vietnamese won. Victory tends to remove the sting and make such things easier to overlook. And carpet bombing mostly jungles is different than carpet bombing any area we think Osama may

I'm glad you aren't one of us. You don't qualify. be hiding in.

Whatever you regard as "one of us" saty glad that I am not and I will stay proud that I am not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom