How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

How's that minarette-ban in Switzerland going by the way?

im not up to date in that. my oppinion is.
they can build moscues if they want, we also have synagoges, and chruches, why not, but dont let them sing pls, i need my sleep :D
i hope they also ban those anoying church bells.
 
Yes, 70 million. Fine, let's say they would 'just like to see you killed' and see it justified. Bad enough.
That is, until you consider that there are 930 million who would not 'just like to see you killed'.


At least you're not saying it's not connected to their religion.
I'm saying the religion part is an insignificant factor.



But you asked me where I got that from. Did you just spasm out when you saw the word Hannity, or did you actually read what I said and saw what I put an emphasis on? Because if you had done so, you should have seen it.
Hannity's bias and dishonesty is fairly well known. He quite often brings people on his show specifically because they reinforce his biases or, if they do actually disagree with him, because he can easily dominate them and make them look weak.

Regardless, the source of Ibrahim's book is a review of Al Qaeda propaganda, not Islamic propaganda. That amounts to condemning an entire religion based on the propaganda of what I would guess is far less than 1% of the total population.


I still have to see where the Bible commands Christians / Catholics to go out and fight and kill or subdue mankind in order to establish a world wide Christian theocracy.
You seem to be under the impression that a religion's holy book(s) determine the nature of the religion. That could not be further from the truth. Religion is determined by the people who practice it. They then pick and choose from their holy books to justify their dogma.

There may not have been biblical support for it, but Catholics did a large amount of going out and fighting and killing or subduing of mankind (specifically Muslims) in order to establish a world wide Christian theocracy in the previous millennium in the form of the Crusades. Indeed, the Catholics largely ignored their holy book in the name of their religion.

It appears to be a truism that in practicing any particular religion, its holy books are interpreted through the lens of the religion rather than the religion being an application of the holy books. It doesn't matter if the holy book tells you to or not to kill someone, the practitioners of that religion will find a way to rationalize their beliefs. Consider St. Augustine's concept of a just war, for example, despite the fact that it directly contradicts the Christian Bible in a number of instances.


No doubt. But the earliest leaders, Muhammad and his four 'rightly guided caliphs' as well as the four schools of Sunni Islam (about 90% of Muslims are Sunni) seem to agree with what I am saying here about jihad and Islam.
And Jesus preached non-violence and the good inherent in all mankind, but we still had the KKK. Like I said, it doesn't matter what practitioners in the past felt. What matters is how the practitioners now understand the religion.


No, at least 93% do not see the killing of Muslims, women and children justified, which it isn't (at least not deliberately).
By this, I assume you are implying that those same 93% would be just fine with the killing of non-Muslims? Do you have evidence for this? That certainly wasn't reflected in the Gallup poll.



This is exactly what al-Qaradawi complained about when he talked about 9/11. See here. Read it carefully. It becomes more of an 'ease the westerners' minds' propaganda piece mixed with a good amount of truths (the best kind I once read) when you think about how basically everyone in Israel is regarded as a combatant by such authorities like al-Qaradawi.
So, even though al-Qaradawi condemns the attacks and calls defines very specifically that innocents shouldn't be killed, you see this as back-handed indictment of everyone in Isreal? What about this?
"What we warn against, even if becomes a reality, is to hold a whole nation accountable for a crime carried out by a limited number of people or to characterize a certain religion as a faith giving support to violence and terrorism," Qaradawi said.


While I agree with most parts, you might have noticed that I am mainly talking about Islam and not Muslims. You respect Muslims, not Islam as it was lived out by early guys - those who al-Qaeda among others cite.
So Islam is defined by the tiniest of minorities who practice it? Do you define America or Christianity solely by the KKK? Do you define Germany solely by the Nazis?


I don't understand why you're saying I have little or no context?
I say that for a number of reasons. First, you continually cite the Quran as an authoritative source on modern Islam. That is no more true than the Bible is an authoritative source on modern Christianity. Poll 100 Christians who aren't biblical scholars or clergy, I would be greatly surprised if 10 of them actually knows what the Bible says on various subjects like shell fish or menstruation.

Second, you cherry-pick legitimate authoritative sources on modern Islam. I have never seen a wide scale survey as the one Gallup performed and yet, you reject 930,000,000 sources in favor of only 70,000,000 sources.
 
That is, until you consider that there are 930 million who would not 'just like to see you killed'.

How do you know that? For all I know they might be ok with it as long as your wife and daughter are spared.

Regardless, the source of Ibrahim's book is a review of Al Qaeda propaganda, not Islamic propaganda. That amounts to condemning an entire religion based on the propaganda of what I would guess is far less than 1% of the total population.

No. I watched an hour long speech by that guy on his book and the book is split up into two parts. The smaller part is the propaganda for westerners and the political BS propaganda like the complaints about how Americans mass murdered native Americans or the Israel - Palestine conflict. The far larger part, about two thirds I think, is about purely Islamic propaganda with endless citations of Quran, ahadith and so on. This is exactly what makes it so interesting. If anything, it amounts to better understanding what drives al-Qaeda.

You seem to be under the impression that a religion's holy book(s) determine the nature of the religion. That could not be further from the truth. Religion is determined by the people who practice it. They then pick and choose from their holy books to justify their dogma.

What are you smoking? I'm really having a hard time here understanding you. Either you're smoking too much of the good stuff, or you really are **** at expressing yourself properly in a way to be understood the way you want to be understood.

Of course they, the holy books and other essential scriptures, determine the nature of a religion. If religion a)'s book said 'Go out and kill anyone who doesn't belong to this religion!' and religion b)'s book said 'Do no resist anyone, be peaceful, even if hardship comes over you.' it's perfectly reasonable to assume adherents of religion a) are more prone to violence than those of b) and the nature of the religions are violent and peaceful, respectively. What the people do with it can be quite different from what the founder(s) of the religion did.

There may not have been biblical support for it, but Catholics did a large amount of going out and fighting and killing or subduing of mankind (specifically Muslims) in order to establish a world wide Christian theocracy in the previous millennium in the form of the Crusades.

No, they didn't set out to establish a world wide theocracy, they set out to repel Muslim aggression after the Byzantine Empire requested help to recapture territories lost to Muslim aggressors waging their jihad. A very important point you're making is that there was indeed no biblical support for it. The Muslims had and were following such support and the commandments as well as Muhammad's example.

Indeed, the Catholics largely ignored their holy book in the name of their religion.

And jihadists follow their book. That's a big difference.

It appears to be a truism that in practicing any particular religion, its holy books are interpreted through the lens of the religion rather than the religion being an application of the holy books. It doesn't matter if the holy book tells you to or not to kill someone, the practitioners of that religion will find a way to rationalize their beliefs. Consider St. Augustine's concept of a just war, for example, despite the fact that it directly contradicts the Christian Bible in a number of instances.

A discussion about 'turning the other cheek' here comes to mind. The guidelines laid out by St. Augustine are for your behaviour after or during an ongoing aggression.

And Jesus preached non-violence and the good inherent in all mankind, but we still had the KKK. Like I said, it doesn't matter what practitioners in the past felt. What matters is how the practitioners now understand the religion.

The KKK is obviously ****ed up and consisted of white supremacists and war veterans. You're trying to compare apples with oranges here. Groups like al-Qaeda follow the example of Muhammad for the most part, but go to extremes like the 9/11 attacks. This does not render my point null that the Quran commands Muslims to wage warfare against all 'unbelievers'.

By this, I assume you are implying that those same 93% would be just fine with the killing of non-Muslims? Do you have evidence for this? That certainly wasn't reflected in the Gallup poll.

No, I am not implying this. What I am saying is, you don't know how many of the 93% would be okay with 'selective killing' according to what their scripture and sunnah has to say about this.

So, even though al-Qaradawi condemns the attacks and calls defines very specifically that innocents shouldn't be killed, you see this as back-handed indictment of everyone in Isreal? What about this?

No, I am referring to other texts written by him and debates in which he appears where this topic is discussed. There is this one for example:

al-Qaradhawi said:
At times, a woman or child may be hurt. First of all, in Israeli society, even women are recruited to the army. Israeli society is militaristic to the core. Men and women are recruited, either to the regular army or as reservists. If children are hurt, they are hurt unintentionally. These are necessities of war.

Last time I checked your society as well as mine permits women to enter armed service, so I don't know if he'd stop if he'd be going against us. This seems to be exactly what Ibrahim is talking about in one of his books part. War is deceit and Muslim leaders understand this very well when they most likely fool you with the belief Muslims would stop if Israel were to give 'their land' back.

Upchurch said:
So Islam is defined by the tiniest of minorities who practice it? Do you define America or Christianity solely by the KKK? Do you define Germany solely by the Nazis?

No, Islam isn't defined like that and I am not saying this. Like I said earlier, unfortuneately I, as well as prominent scholars and the four schools of Sunni Islam, agree (or as for me, I can follow where it stems from) on major parts of al-Qaeda ideology (although I can not be sure, because this is what I will tackle next and that aforementioned book will be a good start I reckon).

I am very well able to differentiate between your '08/15' (do you know that expression?) Muslim and one who is out of the bounds laid out by consent and by the example of Muhammad and his four immediate successors.

I say that for a number of reasons. First, you continually cite the Quran as an authoritative source on modern Islam. That is no more true than the Bible is an authoritative source on modern Christianity. Poll 100 Christians who aren't biblical scholars or clergy, I would be greatly surprised if 10 of them actually knows what the Bible says on various subjects like shell fish or menstruation.

I'm not going into detail on this one, but it is not relevant. I'd like you to tell me though what this 'modern Islam' is and why it doesn't need the Quran as an authoritative source. I really am having a difficult time assessing on what drugs and which amount of said you are.

Second, you cherry-pick legitimate authoritative sources on modern Islam. I have never seen a wide scale survey as the one Gallup performed and yet, you reject 930,000,000 sources in favor of only 70,000,000 sources.

Again, what the hell is 'modern Islam'? And no, I don't reject 930 million viewpoints. They can live with their fluffy Islam if they want to, this does in no way change what Islam teaches, what the consent is on what it commands you, nor what Muhammad did.
 
Last edited:
How do you know that? For all I know they might be ok with it as long as your wife and daughter are spared.
How do you know that 70 million Muslims would 'just like to see you killed'?


Of course they, the holy books and other essential scriptures, determine the nature of a religion. If religion a)'s book said 'Go out and kill anyone who doesn't belong to this religion!' and religion b)'s book said 'Do no resist anyone, be peaceful, even if hardship comes over you.' it's perfectly reasonable to assume adherents of religion a) are more prone to violence than those of b) and the nature of the religions are violent and peaceful, respectively. What the people do with it can be quite different from what the founder(s) of the religion did.
I'm sorry. You must be new to the human race. We don't conform our actions to fit what we read. As a rule, we rather conform what we read to fit our actions.

The founder of a religion, as admired as they often are, rarely has as much impact on religion as the current leadership, especially the older the religion. Why, a mere 300 or so years after Jesus and his pacifist teachings, there came about a series of Christian empires.


No, they didn't set out to establish a world wide theocracy, they set out to repel Muslim aggression after the Byzantine Empire requested help to recapture territories lost to Muslim aggressors waging their jihad.
Oh, it goes back further than that. You can take any one slice of history to make one side look good and another side look bad. Regardless, while the Crusades did set out to free Christians from Islamic rule, they also rebuilding the lost Christian empire (or empires depending on how you look at it).


A very important point you're making is that there was indeed no biblical support for it. The Muslims had and were following such support and the commandments as well as Muhammad's example.
And are there not very specific instructions in the Quran about not killing innocents? Like I said, we humans fit what we read to what we do, not the other way around.


And jihadists follow their book. That's a big difference.
They follow some parts of it while ignoring other parts. No difference.

What you are also ignoring from the Gallup poll was that, of the 7% radical respondents, when asked why they felt the 9/11 attacks were justified, they did not respond with religious reasons or even quotes from the Quran. They responded with political and secular reasons.


A discussion about 'turning the other cheek' here comes to mind. The guidelines laid out by St. Augustine are for your behaviour after or during an ongoing aggression.
And yet, Jesus never put a time limit on 'turning the other cheek'. Indeed, he turned it all the way to his grave (and back again, if you believe in that sort of thing).


The KKK is obviously ****ed up and consisted of white supremacists and war veterans. You're trying to compare apples with oranges here. Groups like al-Qaeda follow the example of Muhammad for the most part, but go to extremes like the 9/11 attacks. This does not render my point null that the Quran commands Muslims to wage warfare against all 'unbelievers'.
The KKK saw themselves in much the same light. Note the wide use of Christian symbolism through out the KKK.

But if that is too much of a stretch for you, let's look at the Spanish Inquisition. They used violence and torture to, in part, forcibly convert adherents of other faiths to their own particular form of orthodoxy.


No, I am not implying this. What I am saying is, you don't know how many of the 93% would be okay with 'selective killing' according to what their scripture and sunnah has to say about this.
You're right. I don't know this because the survey didn't cover it. Neither did it cover 'indiscriminate killing', so we cannot assume that either.


Last time I checked your society as well as mine permits women to enter armed service, so I don't know if he'd stop if he'd be going against us.
But he is still only talking about military personnel, not civilians.


Again, what the hell is 'modern Islam'? And no, I don't reject 930 million viewpoints. They can live with their fluffy Islam if they want to, this does in no way change what Islam teaches, what the consent is on what it commands you, nor what Muhammad did.
Answer me this: How does 'Islam' (or any religion) teach if not through the perception of living, breathing people? Does a literal reading of the Quran or the Bible sync up exactly with the way people practice Islam or Christianity? If so, why have there been so many variations of Islam and Christianity through out their existences? If 93% of Muslims here and now practice "their fluffy Islam", does that not make it the norm here and now?

When I talk about modern Islam, I'm talking about how the religion is currently practiced by most of its adherents. If 93% (an overwhelming margin) practice the "fluffy" version, then modern Islam is, in fact, the "fluffy" version. The hard-line radical version, almost by definition of "radical", is not the regular version.
 
Answer me this: How does 'Islam' (or any religion) teach if not through the perception of living, breathing people?

And where do those breathing people get their understanding of Islam from?

Does a literal reading of the Quran or the Bible sync up exactly with the way people practice Islam or Christianity?

No, and I've never claimed otherwise.

If so, why have there been so many variations of Islam [...] through out their existences?

The many variations you might be talking about are pretty much fringe groups outside of Sunni Islam. You can even say Shia Islam is pretty much a fringe group, since it only makes up about 10% of all Muslims.

If 93% of Muslims here and now practice "their fluffy Islam", does that not make it the norm here and now?

You don't even know what they believe. The question is how much their ideas can stand up to mainstream interpretations if they don't already follow those.

It's really hopeless with you though. Keep clinging to those 93% as evidence of something you don't understand.
I'll talk to you about Islam more once you've got a better understanding, which you don't seem to have.

One thing though, what do you make of the following:

Perspectives of Women said:
Gender inequality was not mentioned at all in response to this question among Jordanian women, and was cited by no more than 2% of women in Egypt and Morocco. It was mentioned somewhat more frequently by Saudi women (5%), but “lack of unity” and “high unemployment” outranked it. The two exceptions were Lebanon and Turkey, by far the
most Westernized of the eight countries surveyed, where this sentiment was expressed by 9% to 11% of women, among the top five spontaneous responses. (In these two countries, because the question asked about the “Arab/Muslim” world, respondents may have felt it applied to other societies in the region rather than their own; 40% of Lebanese respondents
are Christian
, while Turks are not Arab and many are secular Muslims.)

Am I correct when I understand this as 40% of the surveyed Lebanese in a poll about what Muslims think were.. Christian?
 
Last edited:
"Warfare has been ordained for you, though it is hateful unto you; but it may happen that you hate a thing which is good for you, and it may happen that you love a thing which is bad for you. GOD knows, but you do not know." 2:216

how do you interpret that Baracuda?

and you do you know about what Sura 9 is about? in when you read the 9:xxx suras then, how do you interpret them in that context?
 
"Warfare has been ordained for you, though it is hateful unto you; but it may happen that you hate a thing which is good for you, and it may happen that you love a thing which is bad for you. GOD knows, but you do not know." 2:216

how do you interpret that Baracuda?

The way it's written.

and you do you know about what Sura 9 is about? in when you read the 9:xxx suras then, how do you interpret them in that context?

Without foam around your mouth and in English?!
Sura 9 is about many things.
 
And where do those breathing people get their understanding of Islam from?
From older breathing people.


No, and I've never claimed otherwise.
So, if the Quran does not sync up with the way people practice Islam, it can not be a very authoritative source about Islam, can it?


The many variations you might be talking about are pretty much fringe groups outside of Sunni Islam.
And Sunni Islam has been pretty much constant over the last 1700ish years, has it?


You don't even know what they believe. The question is how much their ideas can stand up to mainstream interpretations if they don't already follow those.

It's really hopeless with you though. Keep clinging to those 93% as evidence of something you don't understand.
I'll talk to you about Islam more once you've got a better understanding, which you don't seem to have.
I don't have intimate knowledge of Islam? No. I have studied a lot of different religions over the years and I do have intimate knowledge of humanity. There are two things that almost all religions practitioners have in common. First, they all tweak the religion to their own needs. Second, nearly all of them believe they have the one true version of their religion.

(There is a slim minority out there that recognize that there are multiple valid versions of their religion or even the validity of other religions. Crazy, I know.)

Even though (I assume) you are not Muslim yourself, you share these characteristics about Islam. You tweak it to fit your needs, in this case: Islam is the evil villain, and you believe that you understand the one true version of Islam. Of course, that would necessitate that there could be one true version of Islam.

I know I can't persuade you otherwise, but I would just remind you that the world owes earlier Islamic societies a great deal. Like the rest of us humans, they have their good days (or centuries, as the case may be) and their bad days.


One thing though, what do you make of the following:

Am I correct when I understand this as 40% of the surveyed Lebanese in a poll about what Muslims think were.. Christian?
Certainly reads that way, doesn't it?

I don't know what they are trying to say there. I have heard that some Muslims consider themselves to be a more developed form of the Christian faith and thus, I suppose, "completed Christians" in the same way that some Christians consider themselves to be "completed Jews". Perhaps that is what these respondents classified themselves as, both Muslim and Christian?

"Arab/Muslim": I don't know if this means that the respondents were both Arab and Muslim or either Arab or Muslim, inclusive.
 
From older breathing people.

A-ha! And where did they get their stuff from? ;)
You see where this is going.

So, if the Quran does not sync up with the way people practice Islam, it can not be a very authoritative source about Islam, can it?

It entirely depends on what those 'sync errors' are. From what I have seen it's pretty much minor things like certain parts of how shari'a is implemented. I think you really give the fringe groups inside Islam, inside Sunni Islam, too much value/importance.

And Sunni Islam has been pretty much constant over the last 1700ish years, has it?

More or less, yes, one might come to that conclusion apart from fringe groups or movements, although those also adhere in most cases to one school of thought. The different schools of thought have been developed over centuries but differ not that much from each other, even though they span a couple of centuries. The 'Umdat al-Salik is based on the Shafi'i school and it points out differences compared to the other schools. It says it (Shafi'i)'s in agreement in about 70% with the other three. If I am not really mistaken now, there hasn't been a new, maybe 'modern' or 'moderate' school of thought because it's not deemed to be necessary, since they got the analogy procedure where they rule by analogy, and ijtihad, the interpretation process or part of it is deemed to be only performed by highly learnt scholars - who seem to see no need in doing a new interpretation.

I don't have intimate knowledge of Islam? No. I have studied a lot of different religions over the years and I do have intimate knowledge of humanity. There are two things that almost all religions practitioners have in common. First, they all tweak the religion to their own needs. Second, nearly all of them believe they have the one true version of their religion.

Sure, I am not contesting this and I like your input in that regard. I'm not assuming the position of 'my understanding of Islam is the true one', far from it. But there is a consent among the vast majority of people adhering to the mainstream orthodox Sunni Islam and the majority of the people in Muslim majority / Islamic countries and they want - as the poll shows except for a highly secularized country like Turkey (or Lebanon, but that one is a bit confusing so far when it comes to the poll and the current developments in regards to Hezbollah) - shari'a. And shari'a is in Sunni Islam pretty much just based on one of the four schools of thought depending on the country and thus pretty much negates your championed 'individual interpretation'. So I don't see why I shouldn't go with the knowledge I can acquire about those schools in order to get a better grip on the whole structure.

Saudi Arabia uses predominantly the Hanbali school, Yemen too I think. Generally you can say large parts of north-east Africa as well as the Indonesian and Oceania areas adhere to the Shafi'i school, while western Africa is predominantly Maliki. If I remember correctly, Hanafi is spread east of Saudia Arabia and all are used more or less equally in Egypt. See this amateur-map. ;)

(There is a slim minority out there that recognize that there are multiple valid versions of their religion or even the validity of other religions. Crazy, I know.)

Shocking!

Even though (I assume) you are not Muslim yourself, you share these characteristics about Islam. You tweak it to fit your needs, in this case: Islam is the evil villain, and you believe that you understand the one true version of Islam. Of course, that would necessitate that there could be one true version of Islam.

You assume correctly. I have to disagree with the rest though. I don't tweak it to fit my needs, I make observations about what the four schools say because they are the source for Islamic law and whenever I quote out of the 'Umdat al-Salik for example, I offer what it says including possible differances among the four schools. Then, when you look at people like al-Qaradhawi and what he says, you have a better understanding of the whole thing.

When some Sufis meditate to get closer to Allah or a dervish guy swirls about in a happy fashion, these things do not affect me. What affects me and you is what Muslims adhere to and for Sunnis, unless they belong to one of the fringe groups, that is for the vast majority one of the four schools. And those four schools agree for example on what I am saying about jihad.

I'd be happy to see you point out where I am 'tweaking Islam to my needs' though. Also, your notion that I am regarding Islam as 'the evil villain' is nonsense and leads to things like your following statement underneath.

I know I can't persuade you otherwise, but I would just remind you that the world owes earlier Islamic societies a great deal. Like the rest of us humans, they have their good days (or centuries, as the case may be) and their bad days.

Yea, and many of those scientists seem to have been 'moderate' Muslims, and a lot was taken from Persia and India. Thing is though, where has this high culture gone to? Maybe you can answer that.

With for example the amount of outsourcing work in the Gulf States one has to wonder what they do other than let foreigners build artificial islands off the coast of Dubai. ;)
Even prominent Muslim figures like the Qaradhawi guy complain about how 'lazy' Muslims are. :D

Certainly reads that way, doesn't it?

I don't know what they are trying to say there. I have heard that some Muslims consider themselves to be a more developed form of the Christian faith and thus, I suppose, "completed Christians" in the same way that some Christians consider themselves to be "completed Jews". Perhaps that is what these respondents classified themselves as, both Muslim and Christian?

I doubt that, but it certainly is strange. There are, and I base this on the few samples they offer without having to buy the book, a couple of odd things in there. Some I have pointed out in my initial post after you had cited the poll.
 
Last edited:
Just one more thing for now which really makes this whole thing tedious. It's statements like this applied to Islam:

The founder of a religion, as admired as they often are, rarely has as much impact on religion as the current leadership, especially the older the religion. Why, a mere 300 or so years after Jesus and his pacifist teachings, there came about a series of Christian empires.

Anyway, here is one article about the survey of British Muslim students. In short:

article-1038953-0216F38E00000578-702_468x450.jpg
 
A-ha! And where did they get their stuff from? ;)
You see where this is going.
Not really. Are you going to suggest that the chain leads back to something other than a person, someone whose own perceptions color and change the information as it passes along over time?


It entirely depends on what those 'sync errors' are. From what I have seen it's pretty much minor things like certain parts of how shari'a is implemented. I think you really give the fringe groups inside Islam, inside Sunni Islam, too much value/importance.
Who do you consider the fringe groups? Those who actually kill in the name of Islam or those who don't (the 'fluffy' version mentioned before)? The 'fluffy' version appears to be the majority, but the hard line version seems to be more in sync with your description of "true" Islam.


More or less, yes, one might come to that conclusion apart from fringe groups or movements, although those also adhere in most cases to one school of thought.
More or less constant over 1700ish years? Here in the US, we can't agree what our founding fathers meant about certain topics a mere 200 years ago. You'll excuse me if I'm a tad skeptical that a school of religions thought has remained more or less unchanged over 8 times that period. We are all, essentially, playing "telephone" over the years and generations. The possibility of the message not distorting and changing seems extremely small to me.


Sure, I am not contesting this and I like your input in that regard. I'm not assuming the position of 'my understanding of Islam is the true one', far from it.
No? You certainly think with those practitioners who practice the "fluffy" version are wrong about it, do you not? They can only be "wrong" about it if there is a "right" version. The assumption is implicit in your claims about the definitiveness in what "Islam teaches".


I'd be happy to see you point out where I am 'tweaking Islam to my needs' though. Also, your notion that I am regarding Islam as 'the evil villain' is nonsense and leads to things like your following statement underneath.
Perhaps I indulged in a bit of hyperbole, but what exactly are your objections to Islam? It "teaches" that you should be killed, right? Do you not consider wanting to kill you "just because" to be villainous behavior?



As for the British Muslim students, if the graphic accurate reflects the questioning, you'll note that "killing for religion could be justified" and doesn't give any specific situations, like in self-defense of the religion vs. actively murdering civilian infidels. I'm sure you know that in Islamic society, women wearing the veil and not mixing freely is considered respectful for the women. US society felt much the same about dress codes and unsupervised co-mingling a century ago.

I'm honestly surprised that percentage of Muslim students felt that men and women were treated equally. I think things have gotten better here in the US, but equality certainly isn't the case here. Same with respecting homosexuals. Here in the US, it is probably more like 50% (our whole red/blue thing).
 
Last edited:
Upchurch, to be honest, it is too much hassle to explain everything here or to convey what I have learnt in the last few years. If you are really interested, I recommend looking up the following:

tafsir (Quran exegesis)
ahadith (recordings of Muhammad and others)
ijtihad (independent interpretation)
naskh (loosely: abrogation; especially in regards to 9:29 and the likes)

Wikipedia should be sufficient and this should be good for starters.

As for the 'fluffy', what do you think I mean when I say 'fluffy' and what do you mean when you say 'fluffy'? I think there is a stark difference. When I say it, I mean people like my sister; the somewhat uninformed Muslims who do not base their opinions on their religion (or only selective parts) but on their own wishes. The problem with some of the fringe groups which try to 'modernize' and maybe 'liberalize' Islam is that I have not yet seen one that could stand up against what I am referring to here most of the time. Thing about them is, they lack a solid foundation. Not to mention they're (mainly because of that) ridiculed and shunned by the established scholars in debates.
 
Last edited:
The problem with some of the fringe groups which try to 'modernize' and maybe 'liberalize' Islam is that I have not yet seen one that could stand up against what I am referring to here most of the time. Thing about them is, they lack a solid foundation. Not to mention they're (mainly because of that) ridiculed and shunned by the established scholars in debates.
I find it strange that you consider 90+% of Muslims a "fringe" group.

You are still working under the assumption that a religion is something that is defined by the thoughts and writings of just a few people hundreds and thousands of years ago, as if it were something that exists independently from its practitioners. People are not defined by the books they live by. They use the books they live by to justify things they most likely still would have done otherwise.

If the vast majority of practicing Muslims see jihad as a personal struggle against sin, why are they wrong? Is religion immutable, something that exists apart from those who express it?

You didn't explain how "Islam teaches" anything other than from the person who explains it from their own perspective. I think this is a key point to understand before condemning an entire group of people based on a perspective they apparently don't hold.
 
Excuse me? Why should I consider 90%+ a fringe group?
Well, 90%+ of Muslims consider jihad either a personal struggle against sin (or the equivalent) and/or an act of self defense, rather than an actively wanting to destroy non-believers. Did you not state that this is an uninformed, modernized, or "fluffy" position? Did you not call those groups who "try to 'modernize'" Islam "fringe groups"?

Let me know which part you don't understand.

As for "why" you should do this, that is a much more personal question. Only you know for certain. I can only guess. As I mentioned before, I suspect you are looking for black and white pigeon holes in which to stick the "good guys" and the "bad guys". It is much easier to paint an broad group as different and the villains than to come to grips with the fact that the group is pretty much just like us with a few bad apples, just like us.

I could be wrong.

You really still don't get it, do you? Shame.
Well, someone doesn't get something. Are you so sure it's me?

I understand what you are trying to get across. There are major religious schools of thought that you can use to find justification for your views of Islam. My point is that it does not matter because they do not define the religion. A religion is defined by the people who practice it.

The Gallup poll not only shows that the vast majority of Muslims are moderate in nature and not prone to war-like jihad, but also that the radical Muslims are more politically motivated in nature rather than religiously motivated. That's data. That's evidence.

So, the question is this: Do you ignore the new data and stick to your hypothesis or do you modify or discard your hypothesis in light of the data?

My hypothesis accounts for both the data and the historical understandings you've mentioned. Yours does not, unless you want to assert that 90%+ of Muslims do not follow "real" Islam. That, however, just opens a whole other set of issues to resolve, like how one determines what the "real Islam" is and if only a small minority follow it, does the "real Islam" even matter?
 
Well, 90%+ of Muslims consider jihad either a personal struggle against sin (or the equivalent) and/or an act of self defense, rather than an actively wanting to destroy non-believers.

If we were honest about this, we would admit that "jihad" has exactly the same set of meanings as "crusade".
 
If we were honest about this, we would admit that "jihad" has exactly the same set of meanings as "crusade".
Depends on what definition you use, I suppose. Do you mean "crusade" or "Crusade"?

The former means to approach a particular task with zeal. The latter means a Christian military expedition to conquer (or re-conquer) foreign lands many centuries ago.
 
Well, someone doesn't get something. Are you so sure it's me?

Yes, I'm pretty sure you are the one.

This was a survey of modern Muslims and their understanding of meaning of the term. They are, after all, the only ones who count today. I would hate to be held to my ancestors' views on certain topics.

"Your great-great-great grandfather believed that slavery was good for black people, therefore you must feel that way too."

Your mentality, your approach to Islam in this way is not only ridiculous, it's just wrong. The Quran is not a redundant thing for Muslims. Not for the vast majority. And especially not for the pious, who make up the overwhelming majority of those in the survey.


I tried addressing everything, but it only hurt my head. One major thing you still don't seem to get is what shari'a is. I pretty much told you already and thought you'd 'get it' at some point. Apparently not, but looking back and taking your apparent mentality in account, it's not surprising.


The four schools aren't just 'some schools', they're not just 'some redundant thing of the past'. They're pretty much every command and law taken from the Quran and ahadith. It's what defines countries' politics. They define a country's society. A Muslim's daily life. It's the extract of everything their religion commands them to do or not to, based on their book and scriptures. The very thing you seem to deem to be antiquated, outdated or obsolete when it comes to what defines Islam.

It doesn't work that way with Islam and what I told you about jihad is the consensus of those four schools. It's not just my opinion.

If you put together the first two answers to the question what role shari'a should play in the available material of the poll, namely 'Sharia must be the only source of legislation' and 'Sharia must be a source of legislation, but not the only source', you arrive at:

90% for Egypt
81% for Pakistan
93% for Jordan
91% for Bangladesh
98% for Morocco
68% for Indonesia
79% for Iran
32% for Turkey
65% for Lebanon

Are these your 'moderates', your 'modern' Muslims, your 'modern moderate majority'? What exactly is your definition of 'moderate' or 'modern'? What is a 'moderate' or 'modern' Muslim one who puts adulterers in jail instead of stoning them?

Or could it be that you find your 'modern' or 'moderate' majority of Muslims in places like Turkey, a country which was secularized by force?

The Gallup poll not only shows that the vast majority of Muslims are moderate in nature and not prone to war-like jihad, but also that the radical Muslims are more politically motivated in nature rather than religiously motivated.

What you don't get is that just because 93% wouldn't want to see you killed on the spot means they're modern or moderate. Do you see nothing wrong with their definition alone of who is moderate and who is a radical? I pointed it out at least once already.

That's data. That's evidence.

Your evidence is what, a couple of PDF pages? A podcast?
The data on a specific topic?

Your evidence for 'moderates' is 93% who do not see the 9/11 attacks completely justified, right? Among those 93% these:

the incorporation of Sharia as at
least a source of legislation enjoys the support of an
average of 79% in the 10 countries surveyed.
In five countries, only a minority wanted Sharia as
“the only source” of law. However, in Egypt, Pakistan,
Jordan, and Bangladesh, majorities wanted Sharia as
the “only source” of legislation.

Is that your kind of 'evidence' for 'moderates'?

You say:

If the vast majority of practicing Muslims see jihad as a personal struggle against sin, why are they wrong?

No, it's not wrong. I never said it is. I only said it's not the only thing it is. You got to ask yourself though: What is sin in Islam?
 
If we were honest about this, we would admit that "jihad" has exactly the same set of meanings as "crusade".

No. The definition Upchurch linked to says firstly it was a war to get back lands conquered by Muslims. And that was pretty much it. Jihad is not to get land back which was conquered by Christians or whoever, but to get the whole world under Islam's control and law.

Let me add to that that jihad is supported by Islamic scriptures, while the Crusades weren't.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom