How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

So Mrbaracuda, now that you have stumbled apon this source of great evil what would you like to see done about it?
 
i think upchurch was very correct about jihad.
most moslems see it as a personal strugle or the justification for a fight against forces that invaded the country or a friendly nation. something like self defence or helping others that are occupied or the like.
(sound better than a preemtive war doctrine)

a small minority uses it to justifiy theyr crimes.

But MrBaracuda is so well informed about Islam he is able to spot those blatant lies from those alleged "moderate" or modern moslems. they are al lieng to us so we dont trow them out of the country.....
 
So Mrbaracuda, now that you have stumbled apon this source of great evil what would you like to see done about it?

That's a very good question, but I am not sure which hemisphere you are talking about. If you are talking about 'their' countries, they can do whatever they want, it's none of my business.

As for the 'western' hemisphere, 'our' countries:

Stop the crap with 'this has nothing to do with Islam' and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the 'Islam is peace' crap and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the 'Islam is a religion of tolerance' crap and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the defamation of critics and criticism of Islam or Muslims as 'Islamophobe' or don't make it a 'right-wing-issue' to stifle discourse about the subject.
Stop supporting any imams or scholars in governmental programs for 'integration' who deny the ugly side of Islam that is mainstream.
Stop supporting those who preach peace and tolerance to the media and violence, segregation and intolerance when the camera is off and the 'unbeliever' gone.
Stop treating Muslims and Islam in any special or favourable way.
Stop the cultural relativism crap and stop undermining the secular society we have and enjoy.
Stop letting their crap creep into secular places unopposed.

That's what comes to mind right now, off the top of my head.

Something like this would be a good start as well.
 
Depends on what definition you use, I suppose. Do you mean "crusade" or "Crusade"?

The former means to approach a particular task with zeal. The latter means a Christian military expedition to conquer (or re-conquer) foreign lands many centuries ago.

The The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition has this definition:

crusade n.
often Crusade Any of the military expeditions undertaken by European Christians in the 11th, 12th, and 13th centuries to recover the Holy Land from the Muslims.
A holy war undertaken with papal sanction.
A vigorous concerted movement for a cause or against an abuse.

Note the second definition.
 
The The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition has this definition:

crusade n.
often Crusade Any of the military expeditions undertaken by European Christians in the 11th, 12th, and 13th centuries to recover the Holy Land from the Muslims.
A holy war undertaken with papal sanction.
A vigorous concerted movement for a cause or against an abuse.

Note the second definition.

The 2nd definition is 'Any of the military expeditions undertaken by European Christians in the 11th, 12th, and 13th centuries to recover the Holy Land from the Muslims.'
Or have I missed any Crusades recently? ;)
 
That's a very good question, but I am not sure which hemisphere you are talking about. If you are talking about 'their' countries, they can do whatever they want, it's none of my business.

As for the 'western' hemisphere, 'our' countries:

Stop the crap with 'this has nothing to do with Islam' and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the 'Islam is peace' crap and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the 'Islam is a religion of tolerance' crap and let apologists go unchallenged.
Stop the defamation of critics and criticism of Islam or Muslims as 'Islamophobe' or don't make it a 'right-wing-issue' to stifle discourse about the subject.
Stop supporting any imams or scholars in governmental programs for 'integration' who deny the ugly side of Islam that is mainstream.
Stop supporting those who preach peace and tolerance to the media and violence, segregation and intolerance when the camera is off and the 'unbeliever' gone.
Stop treating Muslims and Islam in any special or favourable way.
Stop the cultural relativism crap and stop undermining the secular society we have and enjoy.
Stop letting their crap creep into secular places unopposed.

That's what comes to mind right now, off the top of my head.

Something like this would be a good start as well.

and you called me brownshirt and fascist because i was on counterdemonstrations against NeoNazis in my countrys some 15 years ago.
they just express theyr oppinion?
 
Last edited:
and you called me brownshirt and fascist because i was on counterdemonstrations against NeoNazis in my countrys some 15 years ago.

Stop lying. I have not called you a brownshirt and fascist.
And I know exactly what your 'counterdemonstrations' look like.

That is one of the reasons or even the sole reason you left the antifa-fascists, isn't it?

the just express theyr oppinion?

I don't get it.
 
Last edited:
and you called me brownshirt and fascist because i was on counterdemonstrations against NeoNazis in my countrys some 15 years ago.
they just express theyr oppinion?

Its their not theyr. I have told you this more than once IIRC. Are you incapable of learning anything?
 
The 2nd definition is 'Any of the military expeditions undertaken by European Christians in the 11th, 12th, and 13th centuries to recover the Holy Land from the Muslims.'
Or have I missed any Crusades recently? ;)

How about the one we are currently engaged in according to George W. Bush?

This crusade, this war on terrorism is going to take a while.

If a Moslem leader said he was launching a jihad and then occupied a couple of Christian nations, would you feel it was just a moral struggle?
 
Last edited:
How about the one we are currently engaged in according to George W. Bush?

Very bad choice of words, but not a Crusade, but a crusade. Sane people also call it war.
Neither was it sanctioned by the pope I guess. Or can you show us where Bush Jr. requested papal sanction? ;)

Thus the third definition you quoted would be the one most applicable, wouldn't it?

If a Moslem leader said he was launching a jihad and then occupied a couple of Christian nations, would you feel it was just a moral struggle?

Eh, although you could argue our 'way of life' is immoral to them, no, I doubt I would! :D
 
Stop lying. I have not called you a brownshirt and fascist.
And I know exactly what your 'counterdemonstrations' look like.

That is one of the reasons or even the sole reason you left the antifa-fascists, isn't it?



I don't get it.

you are generalizing.
while i agree there are very violent peoples among the AntiFa, the majority is still not violent. but yes i left cause those violent peoples dragged the whole group into a very bad light.

when some are violent, it means to you that the whole group is violent.

you do the same with Islam.

are all germans still neonazis? alot germans are neonazis, alot peoples vote for NPD in germany, does that mean all germans like the NPD and are still deep in theyr heart nazis? they just lie about what they really think?
 
you are generalizing.

No. I don't care whether they throw stones and bottles or blockade and provoke. They do most of the time both anyway. Not to mention the retarded May 1st stuff that's going on every year at least in Germany, where your former of antifa **** up friends set fire to buildings and destroy property.

It's not only about their violence, it's about what they represent.

while i agree there are very violent peoples among the AntiFa, the majority is still not violent. but yes i left cause those violent peoples dragged the whole group into a very bad light.

Right. I don't care either way, because what they represent is bad enough. What they do is worse. And that is the majority of the antifa morons. If the 'peaceful majority' you talk about can't get rid of their 'violent minority' but instead support them and chant for them it speaks volumes about your 'peaceful majority'.

when some are violent, it means to you that the whole group is violent.

No, it doesn't. Stop assuming things you have no clue about.

you do the same with Islam.

No I don't. Do you mean Islam or Muslims?

are all germans still neonazis? alot germans are neonazis,

Yea, and? Hitler was an animal lover. That doesn't make national socialism in that form any better, now does it?

alot peoples vote for NPD in germany, does that mean all germans like the NPD and are still deep in theyr heart nazis? they just lie about what they really think?

DVU Brandenburg 6,1%
DVU Bremen 2,7%
NPD Mecklenburg-Vorpommern 7,3%
NPD Saarland 4,0%
NPD Sachsen 9,2%

The national socialist parties are present in five of sixteen state parliaments. Not present in the capital, not present in the Bundestag and overall of 1600% they amount to 29% votes. Yea, what a menace. We have a bigger problem with socialists and communists than with their equally crappy opposite.
 
No one seems to care much either.
Even the 'Did Jesus smoke cannabis (marijuana, weed)?' attracted many more people. Doesn't speak well for a 'Religion and Philosophy' forum heh.
 
No one seems to care much either.
Divorced from prejudices, it is a trivial issue. While there were only 11 comments, there were 252 views. Why comment on something that is plainly obvious when presented without the emotional knee-jerk reactions?

Feel free to make your case, however.

Even the 'Did Jesus smoke cannabis (marijuana, weed)?' attracted many more people. Doesn't speak well for a 'Religion and Philosophy' forum heh.
Yeah, what idiots, having a sense of humor and all. :rolleyes:

You are so quick to jump to conclusions...
 
Incidently:
Stop the cultural relativism crap and stop undermining the secular society we have and enjoy.
How do you propose a secular society devoid of cultural relativism? Zealously insist that your version of secular society is the only true one and persecute anyone who suggests that other societies have any merit?
 
Divorced from prejudices, it is a trivial issue. While there were only 11 comments, there were 252 views. Why comment on something that is plainly obvious when presented without the emotional knee-jerk reactions?

Feel free to make your case, however.


Yeah, what idiots, having a sense of humor and all. :rolleyes:

You are so quick to jump to conclusions...

Maybe so, but next time I'll make sure to throw in a handful of smilies, just for you Upchurch.

Incidently:

How do you propose a secular society devoid of cultural relativism? Zealously insist that your version of secular society is the only true one and persecute anyone who suggests that other societies have any merit?

To say I am the one jumping so quickly to conclusions is kind of funny, coming from you. It's hard to pin point what I mean; maybe I even mean moral relativism, but they often seem to go hand in hand.
What I am talking about is the acceptance of the unacceptable because of this relativism, which can lead to stuff like this.

"This is a sad example of how the conception of the law from another legal and cultural environment is taken as the basis for our own notion of law," he said on Wednesday.

This isn't the first time that German courts have used cultural background to inform their verdicts. Christa Stolle of the women's rights organization Terre des Femmes said that in cases of marital violence, there have been a number of cases where the perpetrator's culture of origin has been considered as a mitigating circumstance -- although such verdicts have become seldom in recent years.

But there remains quite a bit of work to do. "In my work educating sexist and short-sighted Muslim men," asked Michaela Sulaika Kaiser of the Network for Muslim Women, "do I now have to convince German courts that women are also people on the same level with men and that they, like any other human, have the right to be protected from physical and psychological violence?"
 
It's hard to pin point what I mean; maybe I even mean moral relativism, but they often seem to go hand in hand.
So you are arguing against moral relativism in a secular society? Does that mean you are arguing for moral absolutism and, if so, based on what absolute moral authority?


What I am talking about is the acceptance of the unacceptable because of this relativism, which can lead to stuff like this.
No, what you are arguing against here is uneven application of the law (legal relativism, if you will) and you would be correct to do so, in my opinion*. The difference is that there is a more or less absolute legal authority (i.e. the letter of the law and the judges whose job it is, in aggregate, to interpret it). There is no such absolute cultural or moral authority in an open secular society**.




* Assuming the information presented in the article is accurate, within context, and doesn't leave out a legal precedent in German law that is applicable because of some legal minutiae in this case.
** One could make the argument that a fascist non-religious society would be a secular society with an absolute cultural or moral authority, namely the government or political party in question. I added the "open" descriptor to "secular society" above to specifically avoid this kind of pedantic loop hole. I'm going to go out on a limb and assume that this is not the kind of secular society you "have and enjoy".
 
So you are arguing against moral relativism in a secular society?

If that means to handle every crappy piece of a different culture as equal to your own and by no means see yours as superior, yes. An example would be to accept wife beating because it's a common or even normal part of a different culture, as cited, instead of opposing it by all means.

You aren't opposed to this moral or cultural relativism?

Here, in the political sphere, the bad things about Islam are usually just dismissed because of the fear of being labelled, I don't know, a racist, or fascist. Or the newcomer of labels, Islamophobe. To call someone a Nazi just to smear the person works particularly well, too. The brains of many of the recipients seem to just shut down any thought process when those words are dropped. If that doesn't work another way is to blame the bad stuff on 'the culture'. Nevermind Islam pretty much is the culture it stems from or the major influence.

Keep in mind this is mainly a German / European point of view.

Does that mean you are arguing for moral absolutism and, if so, based on what absolute moral authority?

No. See above. Don't go straight to the extremes, Upchurch.

No, what you are arguing against here is uneven application of the law (legal relativism, if you will) and you would be correct to do so, in my opinion*.

Well, thing is, I see this as result of this sort of behaviour and outlook, and as mentioned in the article, it's not the only case.

You don't? Where else does it come from then?
Eventually the judge was replaced by the way.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom