You backed the invasion of Afghanistan, but you challenged me regarding the adequacy of treating terrorism as a law enforcement problem. That is... inconsistent, to put it charitably.
Not at all. The military can be used for many other things besides just war.
We have used the term "police action" for using the military before. I consider this a potential legitimate use of the term, possibly the first. As far as law enforcement goes, the Taliban amounted to an accessory to the 9/11 attacks, certainly after the fact if not before. As such, they were acting like an aggressor nation. That pushed the invasion of Afghanistan into being a legitimate act of national defense, even "retaliation" if it makes you feel any better.
Throwing Iraq and North Korea in that mix was just nonsensical. They had nothing to do with Al-Qaeda and Al-Qaeda would have had little to do with them. Iran was at least plausible. I would have given Bush a little more benefit of the doubt on Iran than I did on Iraq. North Korea is just out of left field.
Once we invaded Iraq, it stopped being about 9/11. It became, instead, about some sort of PNAC-like BS political agenda.
Indeed we have. Funny thing, though: you'll be hard pressed to find the Korean Police Action Veteran's Memorial, for example. Calling a war a police action doesn't stop it from being a war. And our invasion of Afghanistan was a war, no ifs, ands or buts about it.
Throwing Iraq and North Korea in that mix was just nonsensical.
That is an issue of how best to fight the war in question, it does NOT address whether or not you can treat or are treating the problem as a law enforcement issue. If you backed an invasion of another country (which you have), then you're not advocating a law enforcement approach. Weak, Upchurch, really weak. Even by your standards.
That is an issue of how best to fight the war in question, it does NOT address whether or not you can treat or are treating the problem as a law enforcement issue. If you backed an invasion of another country (which you have), then you're not advocating a law enforcement approach.
That is such a selective reading of what I said that I'm not even sure how to respond other than to repeat this portion:
As far as law enforcement goes, the Taliban amounted to an accessory to the 9/11 attacks, certainly after the fact if not before. As such, they were acting like an aggressor nation. That pushed the invasion of Afghanistan into being a legitimate act of national defense, even "retaliation" if it makes you feel any better.
The end result would be to capture (or kill, if that is how it plays out), convict, and sentence Bin Laden and Co. I'm not sure how that isn't advocating a law enforcement approach.
The end result would be to capture (or kill, if that is how it plays out), convict, and sentence Bin Laden and Co. I'm not sure how that isn't advocating a law enforcement approach.
Because you invaded another country and waged war with your military to do so. Labelling war as law enforcement doesn't stop it from being war.
Edit to add:
It's really quite simple, but since you seem to be having trouble understanding the distinction, let me give you something a little more concrete to help you understand the difference. Let's say one of our predator drones sees bin Laden treking across some remote mountain pass far from any of our forces. The drone has a hellfire missile. What's the law enforcement approach? Try to track him if you can, hopefully get some forces to catch him before he escapes. What's the wartime approach? Shoot the hellfire missile and kill the bastard.
Nope, but I thought a one time Cruise Missile attack was not a effective way of getting Al Qaeda.
I am not a Clinton Hater, but thought when it came to Al Qaeda he should have taken a much stronger stand. He seems to have unwilling to take politcal risks in order to pursue a stronger line against Al Qaeda..and that was a bad mistake which I think Clinton has admitted.
Nope, but I thought a one time Cruise Missile attack was not a effective way of getting Al Qaeda.
I am not a Clinton Hater, but thought when it came to Al Qaeda he should have taken a much stronger stand. He seems to have unwilling to take politcal risks in order to pursue a stronger line against Al Qaeda..and that was a bad mistake which I think Clinton has admitted.
Remember that Afghanistan is a land locked country. We didn't have the option of landing Marines on the beach. We only knew about the meeting of Al Qaeda leaders a couple days before it happened.
Weren't even hardly trying to do that anymore until recently.
Now how is what we have done (or attempted to do only to get distracted by shiny objects in Iraq only to remember at the last moment what the whole point of this was and to try to squeeze it in before Bush leaves office so that he doesn't look like a total douche in the history books) supposed to show using the military in an attempt to capture an exceptionally bad criminal during an exceptional time in history could not still have been handled as a law enforcement problem?
First you would have to define what victory is in the War On Terror. People should concentrate on eliminating the reasons that create terrorism like poverty, fundamentalist religion....
Well, no. We've been whacking Al Qaeda with drone-fired missiles for a long time now, starting at least in early 2002. Very un-law enforcement-like of us, too, what with no trial or appeals process or even a right to talk to a lawyer before detonation.
Now how is what we have done (or attempted to do only to get distracted by shiny objects in Iraq only to remember at the last moment what the whole point of this was and to try to squeeze it in before Bush leaves office so that he doesn't look like a total douche in the history books) supposed to show using the military in an attempt to capture an exceptionally bad criminal during an exceptional time in history could not still have been handled as a law enforcement problem?
Have you not been paying any attention at all? Evidently not. I've already said it, but apparently telling you something once isn't enough. Toppling the Taliban and removing Al Qaeda's bases from Afghanistan was not something a law enforcement approach could handle. That took a war, and wars are not simply law enforcement, even if you call it a police action (which we didn't even do). And in the long run, the removal of Al Qaeda bases was a lot more important than capturing bin Laden, because he can't do much if he's on the run, but if those safe havens and training grounds were still in operation, not having bin Laden wouldn't do much to slow Al Qaeda down.
First you would have to define what victory is in the War On Terror. People should concentrate on eliminating the reasons that create terrorism like poverty, fundamentalist religion....
Poverty doesn't cause terrorism. Bin Laden was rich, much of the Al Qaeda leadership is solidly middle class or above, and even the foot soldiers tend to have at least enough money to travel. It's not because of poverty that Saudi Arabia is a bigger source for terrorists than, say, Botswana. And if you've got any ideas for how to eliminate fundamentalist religion, I'm sure plenty of people would be interested - otherwise, it's a little like saying we should cure cancer.
We stopped being at war with Iraq when Saddam left, and have been trying to win the peace ever since, which has been confounded by an outbreak of a civil war in which we became involved due to being there, and helping set the conditions conducive to civil war by how we handled the end game of the original war. (And other things . . . long list.)
Put another way, Uppie, that wiseacre question wasn't your finest moment. No probs.
And going back to the OP, when do you think the "game" is over?
Since this thread is dying anyway, I'm going to risk a little hypocrisy and take it off topic. I didn't know how else to tie it back into the off-topic conversation in this thread anyway.
The title refers to a rather large Gallup poll of Muslims world-wide and included things like their understanding of jihad, attitudes toward Americans and the west in general, and whether or not they feel that terrorism and the 9/11 attacks were justified and why they feel that way.
Even though I had several misconceptions of my own, it turns out, according to this study, I was mostly correct when it came to the meaning of jihad and the motivations of radical Muslims being primarily political in nature rather than religious.
Since this thread is dying anyway, I'm going to risk a little hypocrisy and take it off topic. I didn't know how else to tie it back into the off-topic conversation in this thread anyway.
The title refers to a rather large Gallup poll of Muslims world-wide and included things like their understanding of jihad, attitudes toward Americans and the west in general, and whether or not they feel that terrorism and the 9/11 attacks were justified and why they feel that way.
Even though I had several misconceptions of my own, it turns out, according to this study, I was mostly correct when it came to the meaning of jihad and the motivations of radical Muslims being primarily political in nature rather than religious.
As to the meaning of Jihad, I'd like your explanation, if you have one, of the original wave of war and conquest, by a variety of means, that resulted in the invasion and occupation of Spain for seven hundred years and whose crest was the defeat of the forces of The Prophet by Charles Martel. A second crest of this tide came about during the seige of Vienna, the culminating point a Jihad under the Turk led Caliphate.
The Siege of Vienna in 1529, as distinct from the Battle of Vienna in 1683, was the first attempt of the Muslim Ottoman Empire, led by Sultan Suleiman I (the magnificent), to capture the city of Vienna, Austria. The siege signaled the Ottoman Empire's highwater mark and the end of Ottoman expansion in central Europe, though 150 years of tension and incursions followed, culminating in the Battle of Vienna in 1683.[5]
Note 5 => Stavrianos, p 77; "Sitting outside the Hapsburg capital, with his army beset by seemingly insurmountable logistical problems, Suleiman was brought to conclude that the Ottoman Empire could expand no further into Europe, that Muslim expansionism in Eurasia had reached, indeed had probably extended beyond its destined territorial limits." Sicker, p 1-2.
Some historians believe that Suleiman's main objective in 1529 was to re-establish Ottoman control over Hungary, and that the decision to attack Vienna so late in the season was opportunistic.[6]
Random note: I find it interesting, if only coincidentally, that the Crusader kingdoms in the Holy Land lasted about 150 years. If historical cycles come and go similarly, Israel is due to go down in flames in about 90 years, if one accepts the Crusader/Zionist model of what Israel is.
As to the meaning of Jihad, I'd like your explanation, if you have one, of the original wave of war and conquest, by a variety of means, that resulted in the invasion and occupation of Spain for seven hundred years and whose crest was the defeat of the forces of The Prophet by Charles Martel. A second crest of this tide came about during the seige of Vienna, the culminating point a Jihad under the Turk led Caliphate.
This was a survey of modern Muslims and their understanding of meaning of the term. They are, after all, the only ones who count today. I would hate to be held to my ancestors' views on certain topics.
eta: "Your great-great-great grandfather believed that slavery was good for black people, therefore you must feel that way too."
Moderate vs. Extremist Views in the Muslim World said:
Radicals vs. the Moderate Masses
In order to investigate characteristics that distinguish Muslim world residents who are potentially prone to extremist views, we divided respondents from the region into two groups. Classified as political radicals were those who met the following criteria: 1) they felt the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, were “completely justified”, and 2) they indicate that they have an “unfavorable” or “very unfavorable” opinion of the United States. Those who did not say the attacks were completely justified were termed moderates.
Why great, I guess I can sleep better now knowing the great majority of 'moderates' doesn't think the attacks were completely justified! Go 'moderates'!
I can't tell you how relieved I am! Really, I am!
Islam and Democracy said:
Often assumed in the West to be an oppressive corpus of law associated with stoning of adulterers,
chopping off limbs for theft, and imprisonment or death
in apostasy cases, the incorporation of Sharia as at
least a source of legislation enjoys the support of an
average of 79% in the 10 countries surveyed.
Often assumed? What does this mean, that it's a wrong assumption?
Islam and Democracy said:
For Muslims, the presence of the Sharia as a
source of legislation does not conflict with drafting
a constitution that would allow freedom of speech.
Substantial majorities in all nations surveyed — the
highest being 99% in Lebanon, 94% in Egypt, 92%
in Iran, and 91% in Morocco — said that if they were
drafting a constitution for a new country, they would
guarantee freedom of speech, defined as “allowing all
citizens to express their opinions on political, social,
and economic issues of the day.” Support is also
strong in most nations for freedom of religion and
freedom of assembly.
What about freedom of saying 'Islam sucks donkey balls for breakfast' without being punished for it? Huh Gallup? What about that? Probably not the only 'Question not asked in Saudi Arabia' but a question not asked at all.
Muslims and Americans: The Way Forward said:
Ways to Bridge the Gap
While Muslims and Americans have similar views
on some issues, they voiced diverse remedies
for bridging the gap. [...] some Americans
offered other remedies. They [...] characterized the rift
as one of mutual cultural misunderstanding.
Muslims voiced a consistent theme that has appeared
frequently in recent Gallup surveys -- their desire for
the West to “respect Islam” and stop interfering in the
internal affairs of predominantly Muslim states.
Ah yes, the ominous 'misunderstanding' and the 'respect Islam' crap. I don't know why I should even think about respecting something that wants to kill me among billions of others based not only on their (non)belief.
The title refers to a rather large Gallup poll of Muslims world-wide and included things like their understanding of jihad [...]
Even though I had several misconceptions of my own, it turns out, according to this study, I was mostly correct when it came to the meaning of jihad and the motivations of radical Muslims being primarily political in nature rather than religious.
Jihad means "struggle", in part against others but also against one's own faults and vices. For some, it is the stereotypical physical fight against non-believers. My understanding is that more commonly, it is considered a kind of self-improvement: a struggle against sin.
Care to point out the misconceptions you came across?
I'll listen to the podcast soon. As for the motivational part of radicals, would you call 'make jihad in the way of Allah for Allah's law / Islam to reign supreme on earth' political? Sounds like foreign politics to me. This is religious and political. To strip Islam from politics is in my view not possible. But I think I know what you mean and maybe you can adjust your viewpoint a bit once you understood mine.
Has anyone read 'The Al Qaeda Reader' by Raymond Ibrahim by the way? He's a new guy over at jihadwatch.org and it might be very interesting. I thought of Oliver when I saw this interview on FOX News' Hannity when they're talking about the propaganda part. It might also cover your, Upchurch's, notion of the radicals' primary motivation. I'd say there are two levels to the whole thing.
Ah yes, the ominous 'misunderstanding' and the 'respect Islam' crap. I don't know why I should even think about respecting something that wants to kill me among billions of others based not only on their (non)belief.
You misunderstand. I had a few misconceptions about various generally held Muslim opinions. About democracy, for example, or what constitutes respect towards women. I wasn't referring to having misconceptions about jihad.
eta: I gave you Gallup. You give me Hannity? Seriously?
Please, enlighten us. What does jihad mean to a Muslim? And is it even relevant what this Muslim thinks it means?
I had a similar discussion with 'Firegarden' before. I'm curious.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.