How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

wow i think i agree about the case that baracuda brought up, in a few cases there seems indeed to be an acceptance of things (like hiting your wife) that we should not accpet in our countrys.
and indeed the more left orientated multyculti lovers (like i am one) often downplay it, while the more right leaning peoples overestimate it and think it is always that way.

and sure things like beating your wife cannot be accepted and normaly are not, cause also for other cultures it is not allowed. but we also may not forgot that just a few years ago it was pretty common in our culture to beat your wife. there are many things we have already improved or are trying to, like equal rights for woman etc. alot of this things are just a few decades old in our culture and we are still learning it.

you cant force a culture to change from the outside, that has to happen from inside, the woman of that culture have to rise up and no longer take it, they have to teach theyr kids (especially the boys) that woman are equal etc.

we can help those woman making progress, but we cannot force men to think diffrent, it didnt work here also, while we have laws that should take care that woman are equal to men, woman still earn alot less money. alot men dont think they are equal. there is the problem.
 
Last edited:
there is no hell :) but humans tend to creat hell here on earth from time to time.
 
and you dont agree that right leaning peoples overplay such cases?
but oc you agree that leftists do downplay it.
 
Could you be any more specific?
And it's people, not peoples. Peoples means Völker mein Freundchen.



Yes I do because they do downplay it.

everytime someone commits a "Ehrenmord" the right jumps up and declares the end to the multiculti culture, like it is something that happens daily around here.

how more specific do you need it?

strange you dont need it more specific about the left side downplaying it.
 
If that means to handle every crappy piece of a different culture as equal to your own and by no means see yours as superior, yes.
Ah, that was my mistake. I assumed you understood what cultural relativism means. No, what you said above isn't what it means.

Cultural relativism does not mean every culture is equal. "Cultural relativism is the principle that an individual human's beliefs and activities should be understood in terms of his or her own culture." Just like special relativity in physics, cultural relativity is the means to understand what is happening in one reference frame from another reference frame. You'll note that I said "understand" and not "approve of" or "agree with".

In all cases (moral, cultural, or even special), relativity exists in the lack of an absolute that is free from arbitrariness. Terms like "good" or "bad" are inherently arbitrary and grounded in a specific culture. Thus, morality is inherently relative between societies and relative within heterogeneous societies. The only way you can approach a moral absolute is within a homogeneous society and I have my doubts about such a society being able to maintain that homogeneity. Moral and cultural relativism isn't something you can agree or disagree with. It is simply a fact of life. Or, perhaps I should say, a fact of humanity.

This is why I questioned your arguing against moral relativism in a secular society. A secular society, almost through definition, lacks a common belief system that grounds its concepts of "good" and "bad". I thought you were denying the existence of moral relativism, which would the equivalent to saying "there are no such things as people." It appears that you are, instead, opposed to other moral/cultural systems or, at least, a specific other moral/cultural system.

You aren't opposed to this moral or cultural relativism?
As I pointed out, your example of wife beating is not moral or cultural relativism, but legal relativism and of course I am against it.

Here, in the political sphere, the bad things about Islam are usually just dismissed because of the fear of being labelled, I don't know, a racist, or fascist. Or the newcomer of labels, Islamophobe. To call someone a Nazi just to smear the person works particularly well, too. The brains of many of the recipients seem to just shut down any thought process when those words are dropped. If that doesn't work another way is to blame the bad stuff on 'the culture'. Nevermind Islam pretty much is the culture it stems from or the major influence.

Keep in mind this is mainly a German / European point of view.
I'm certainly no expert on the German/European point of view, so I will take your word on that.

However, there certainly are legitimate reasons to label people racist, fascist, or Islamophobe. Take the last one, for example. Fearing or hating someone simply because they are Muslim would, literally, make someone an Islamophobe. Fearing or hating a particular Muslim or group of Muslims because of what they have done or threaten to do, would not make someone an Islamophobe.

And yes, based on what you've said in this thread, I'm implying that you are an Islamophobe. If you are uncomfortable with that label, why are you uncomfortable with it?

Eventually the judge was replaced by the way.
As she should have been.
 
Ah, that was my mistake. I assumed you understood what cultural relativism means. No, what you said above isn't what it means.

If it's not the case, then it is at least part of the reason why many among the left and multiculturalists accept or downplay the negative sides, even though they're not talking about people in Islamic / Muslim majority countries anymore but immigrants and their offspring.

I am sorry, but this is the way it is seen and understood here in Germany or even Europe. Couple that with the fear of suddenly being yourself a bigot, racist or fascist - or just being called that - which is enough to drive people especially on the left crazy and to dismiss the negative sides and stifle discourse.

Then again, I could mean moral relativism. It's a difficult topic! My bad.

legal relativism

Whatever that is.

It appears that you are, instead, opposed to other moral/cultural systems or, at least, a specific other moral/cultural system.

Not the whole system I suppose.

And yes, based on what you've said in this thread, I'm implying that you are an Islamophobe.

Define 'Islamophobe'. Since you're such an avid fan of Wikipedia, let's use this one:

The Runnymede report identified eight perceptions related to Islamophobia:

  1. Islam is seen as a monolithic bloc, static and unresponsive to change.
  2. It is seen as separate and "other." It does not have values in common with other cultures, is not affected by them and does not influence them.
  3. It is seen as inferior to the West. It is seen as barbaric, irrational, primitive, and sexist.
  4. It is seen as violent, aggressive, threatening, supportive of terrorism, and engaged in a clash of civilizations.
  5. It is seen as a political ideology, used for political or military advantage.
  6. Criticisms made of "the West" by Muslims are rejected out of hand.
  7. Hostility towards Islam is used to justify discriminatory practices towards Muslims and exclusion of Muslims from mainstream society.
  8. Anti-Muslim hostility is seen as natural and normal.

  1. In general, no.
  2. In general, no.
  3. In general, yes.
  4. In general, yes.
  5. Which it also is, yes.
  6. No.
  7. No.
  8. In general, no.

If you got any questions regarding clarification, go ahead and ask. I'll try to answer them to the best of my abilities. The wording and lumping together of several subjects doesn't help here. But, in general, you have my answers.

Am I still an Islamophobe? How many of these listed perceptions do you have to hold to count as one?

If you are uncomfortable with that label, why are you uncomfortable with it?

Can't say I am one, so I can't tell you I am uncomfortable.
 
If it's not the case, then it is at least part of the reason why many among the left and multiculturalists accept or downplay the negative sides, even though they're not talking about people in Islamic / Muslim majority countries anymore but immigrants and their offspring.

I am sorry, but this is the way it is seen and understood here in Germany or even Europe. Couple that with the fear of suddenly being yourself a bigot, racist or fascist - or just being called that - which is enough to drive people especially on the left crazy and to dismiss the negative sides and stifle discourse.

Then again, I could mean moral relativism. It's a difficult topic! My bad.



Whatever that is.



Not the whole system I suppose.



Define 'Islamophobe'. Since you're such an avid fan of Wikipedia, let's use this one:



  1. In general, no.
  2. In general, no.
  3. In general, yes.
  4. In general, yes.
  5. Which it also is, yes.
  6. No.
  7. No.
  8. In general, no.

If you got any questions regarding clarification, go ahead and ask. I'll try to answer them to the best of my abilities. The wording and lumping together of several subjects doesn't help here. But, in general, you have my answers.

Am I still an Islamophobe? How many of these listed perceptions do you have to hold to count as one?



Can't say I am one, so I can't tell you I am uncomfortable.

while i can understand you answered nr. 3 with yes, i think number 4 falls again under your generalisation.
you seem to take the extremists as the representants of Islam.
the Islamic organisations in germany that organised preotests against terrorism and war, did they lie when they say that they understood Islam as a peacefull religion?
 
Which organizations and protests are you referring to?

ABAF- Avrupa Ehli Beyt Alevi Federasyonu
ATB – Verband der türkischen Kulturvereine e.V. in Europa
ATIB – Union der türkisch-islamischen Kulturvereine in Europa e.V.
Cem Stiftung
DML Deutsche Muslim Liga e.V.
DITIB Türkisch Islamische Union der Anstalt für Religion e.V.
Hür Türk Deutsch Türkischer Freundschaftsverband
IF Islamische Föderation in Berlin
IGD Islamische Gemeinschaft in Deutschland
IGMG Islamische Gemeinschaft Milli Görüs
IZH Islamisches Zentrum Hamburg
IRH Islamische Religionsgemeinschaft in Hessen
Islamrat für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland
MÜSIAD
MJD-Muslimische Jugend in Deutschland
RTS Rat türkeistämmiger Staatsbürger
Schura Bremen
Schura Hamburg
Schura Niederachsen
Schura Schleswig Holstein
TIDAF – Bundesverband der Vereine Unabhängiger Industrieller und Unternehmer e.V. UETD Union European Turkish Democrats
UIAZD Union der Islamisch Albanischen Zentren in Deutschland
VIKZ Verband der Islamischen Kulturzentren
VIGB Verband der Islamisch-Bosnischen Gemeinden
Zentralrat der Muslime in Baden Württemberg
ZMD Zentralrat der Muslime in Deutschland

organisations like that

websites like that
http://www.islamverfluchtterror.com/

or Protests like in Köln on 21. November 2004, when around 20 000 Muslims protested violence in the name of Islam.
 
Yay, a Harun Yahya page. In other words: Yay, a holocaust denier's page.
Not a demonstration. And yea, I've seen that.

that page said:
Das Wort "Islam" bedeutet auf Arabisch "Frieden".

And we got us a liar!

Allah hat der Menschlichkeit befohlen, das Übel zu meiden; Er hat Unmoral, Rebellion, Grausamkeit, Aggressivität, Mord und Blutvergießen verboten.

Right. Who are you kidding?

Sorry but you are just listing a bunch of organizations, not when they held a demonstration you are referring to and I didn't ask for the page of a Muslim apologist who happens to be a holocaust denier.
 
I am sorry, but this is the way it is seen and understood here in Germany or even Europe. Couple that with the fear of suddenly being yourself a bigot, racist or fascist - or just being called that - which is enough to drive people especially on the left crazy and to dismiss the negative sides and stifle discourse.
Whether or not that is true, I don't know. I understand that is your perception of the situation.

Then again, I could mean moral relativism. It's a difficult topic! My bad.
It is a different topic, but your previous argument falls through in the same way. Moral relativism is not that all moral systems are equal, either. It is an understanding that there is no absolute moral authority and, thus, there is nothing that always "moral" or "immoral". It is only so within a given moral context.


Whatever that is.
"legal relativism" is a hyperbole I used to distinguish the judge's actions from moral or cultural relativism. I doubt it is even a real term. The judge applied the law differently based on conditions irrelevant to the law. Unlike culture or morals, the legal system does have an absolute authority, namely the law and the judges who are supposed to interpret it.

This judge screwed up and was removed for it, as per the absolute legal authority in Germany.

Define 'Islamophobe'.
Etymologically put, "fear of Islam".


1. Islam is seen as a monolithic bloc, static and unresponsive to change.
In general, no.
I call baloney.

You spent several posts telling me how Islam is defined by the Qur'an and that Islam still specifically follows the example of Muhammad. In general, you do see them as a monolithic bloc that is unresponsive to change. You consider those who modernize from this bloc "fluffy" Muslims who don't know or deny what Islam "really teaches".

Am I still an Islamophobe?
Do you view Islam, itself, as a dangerous religion?


Dear Upchurch, which part of 'Jihad means to wage war against non-Muslims, and is etymologically derived from the word mujahada, signifying warfare to establish the religion.' did you not understand?

I don't recall any 'calls for jihad' in a different context; can you produce some?
'Jihad in the way of Allah' would be something that sounds like 'Jihad fi sabil Allah'.

You might want to argue it depends on the context, but I really haven't seen it being used outside of this context and the problem is that it's just too interlinked - even if 'a call for jihad' is not directly a call for violence against others, it will eventually end there.

Once the inner struggle is resolved, or at least thus far deemed to be under control, and 'a call for jihad' is spoken - what else is left than violence against non-Muslims? What other meaning?

You also have to ask yourself: What does the inner struggle mean and consist of to a Muslim? Part of it in the context of war would be to overcome one's own reluctance to fight the enemy and submission to Allah and his messenger - and both, from a Muslim view point - command to wage war against the 'unbelievers' until Islam reigns supreme over the earth.


Of course they, the holy books and other essential scriptures, determine the nature of a religion. If religion a)'s book said 'Go out and kill anyone who doesn't belong to this religion!' and religion b)'s book said 'Do no resist anyone, be peaceful, even if hardship comes over you.' it's perfectly reasonable to assume adherents of religion a) are more prone to violence than those of b) and the nature of the religions are violent and peaceful, respectively.

{snip}

No, they didn't set out to establish a world wide theocracy, they set out to repel Muslim aggression after the Byzantine Empire requested help to recapture territories lost to Muslim aggressors waging their jihad. A very important point you're making is that there was indeed no biblical support for it. The Muslims had and were following such support and the commandments as well as Muhammad's example.

{snip}

Groups like al-Qaeda follow the example of Muhammad for the most part, but go to extremes like the 9/11 attacks. This does not render my point null that the Quran commands Muslims to wage warfare against all 'unbelievers'.
 
You spent several posts telling me how Islam is defined by the Qur'an and that Islam still specifically follows the example of Muhammad. In general, you do see them as a monolithic bloc that is unresponsive to change.

I won't speak to mrbaracuda's position, but there are actually two issues here (monolithicness and unresponsiveness), and you seem to want to treat them as a single one. I do not think Islam is monolithic - the Shia/Sunni split, as well as the number of schools of Islamic jurisprudence, indicates it is not. But Sunni Islam IS unresponsive to change, and deliberately so. The gates of ijtihad are closed.
 
or Protests like in Köln on 21. November 2004, when around 20 000 Muslims protested violence in the name of Islam.

I had a little stroll on the DITIB-webpage (since DITIB was the organizer of the event, or protest) and came across this little press statement about apostasy. Maybe you can imagine why I was a bit confused. But hey, even DITIB can change (or can they?)! Some time ago when I was on their page they had instructions for women and a rather scary definition of honour and what constitues the 'breach' of it. Read about it here. Now, mind you, their webpage is probably the least consulted place for guidance seeking Muslims. It's rather the hundreds of mosques with their imams who are being sent over to Germany from Turkey. Yea.

Maybe you can see why I don't really trust such organizations. Especially not those who are being controlled by the Turkish ministry for religion. When they pull off their demonstrations, well, good for the Muslims who believe that. For DITIB it's probably just that - propaganda in the name of Islam.

Oh and call me paranoid, but if "To kill innocent people does not mean jihad", does killing the 'guilty'?

0_1020_409624_00.jpg
 
Last edited:
Etymologically put, "fear of Islam".

I think you are forgetting the part about a phobia being an irrational fear. I don't think I have displayed any form of irrational behaviour in describing my viewpoints. See, thing with that term is, it's complete and utter garbage.

I call baloney.

And I say you are calling baloney for the sake of calling baloney.

You spent several posts telling me how Islam is defined by the Qur'an and that Islam still specifically follows the example of Muhammad. In general, you do see them as a monolithic bloc that is unresponsive to change. You consider those who modernize from this bloc "fluffy" Muslims who don't know or deny what Islam "really teaches".

Nope. Well, see Ziggurat's post.

in Sunni Islam[...]

[...]Hanbali school
[...]Shafi'i school
[...]Maliki.
[...]Hanafi

[...]When some Sufis meditate to get closer to Allah or a dervish guy swirls about in a happy fashion, these things do not affect me. What affects me and you is what Muslims adhere to and for Sunnis, unless they belong to one of the fringe groups, that is for the vast majority one of the four schools. And those four schools agree for example on what I am saying about jihad.

Oh, what's that? Four movements alone in the orthodox Sunni branch and the mystical branch in one post? I'm sure I've mentioned the Shia branch of Islam as well as the Salafis. But yea, quite the monolithical view I constructed here.

Now, let me please: I call baloney.

Do you view Islam, itself, as a dangerous religion?

Is that what defines me as an Islamophobe now? Let's consult Merriam-Webster on danger real quick:

2 : able or likely to inflict injury or harm <a dangerous man>

Well then, yes, and let me be your personal Islamophobe.
You know what, you could request a change of my little avatar title to just that. Maybe I'll give you permission once you have given me a good reason to. I think you would be pleased.
 
Yay, a Harun Yahya page. In other words: Yay, a holocaust denier's page.
Not a demonstration. And yea, I've seen that.

oh i almost never read Harun Yahya
can you link me to their denial?

on the mainpage there is a link to antisemitism, and it start with

Der Antisemitismus ist untrennbar mit einer der großen Katastrophen des 20. Jahrhunderts verbunden. Kein Zweifel, die Grausamkeiten und Massaker, die die Nazis gegen die Juden begangen haben, gehören mit zu den schrecklichsten.

but i dont know, they also have stuff that denies the holocaust?

And we got us a liar!

afaik comes salam, silm, shalom and islam from the semitic s-l-m. thus i would say one can indeed translate it that way.

Right. Who are you kidding?

Sorry but you are just listing a bunch of organizations, not when they held a demonstration you are referring to and I didn't ask for the page of a Muslim apologist who happens to be a holocaust denier.

this bunch of organisations have several times public spoken against terrorism publlished letters against terrorism, orgsnised protests. what should they do in your oppinion?
 
I think you are forgetting the part about a phobia being an irrational fear.
Nope, I remembered.

I don't think I have displayed any form of irrational behaviour in describing my viewpoints.
Irrational behavior? Not as such, no.

Irrational fear? Well....

And I say you are calling baloney for the sake of calling baloney.
Maybe, but also for the reason I outlined.

Oh, what's that? Four movements alone in the orthodox Sunni branch and the mystical branch in one post? I'm sure I've mentioned the Shia branch of Islam as well as the Salafis. But yea, quite the monolithical view I constructed here.

Now, let me please: I call baloney.
Fine, quintolithic then. Do you see them as able to change an evolve over time or are they still the same dangerous people Mohammad and the Qur'an define them to be?

Is that what defines me as an Islamophobe now?
Oh, no. It defined you that way before, too, not just now.

When you generalize your hatred of certain members of a large group to the group as a whole, as you do when say the religion is dangerous rather than just the extremists, you are irrationally (see? I didn't forget) prejudiced against that group.

Well then, yes, and let me be your personal Islamophobe.
Just so long as you are now aware of what you are doing.
 
oh i almost never read Harun Yahya
can you link me to their denial?

on the mainpage there is a link to antisemitism, and it start with

but i dont know, they also have stuff that denies the holocaust?

If I am not mistaken he has published a book or books with positions of holocaust denial a few years back. This was mentioned in one of the reports of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, or Verfassungsschutz. I think it was the Baden-Württemberg one. My understanding is that he has not gone back to publically proclaim this view, because of understandable repercussions that would await him in Germany. This guy is a propagandist par excellence, who covers many things with his various movies or 'documentaries' to lure people into Islam.

afaik comes salam, silm, shalom and islam from the semitic s-l-m. thus i would say one can indeed translate it that way.

I don't know about shalom, but you are wrong about Islam. Islam means submission. Submission to 'Allah'.


this bunch of organisations have several times public spoken against terrorism publlished letters against terrorism, orgsnised protests. what should they do in your oppinion?

Yes, publically they might condemn things like 9/11 or other things. What they do in their mosques is a different thing. Not that I'd have any evidence to the contrary regarding 9/11; it's not my concern at the moment what they think of 9/11. Publically they won't and can't say different anyway. But this is hardly the only matter. Organisations like DITIB are actively working against any integration as we understand it. Their understanding of integration is pretty much just that - to integrate Muslims into a foreign society without interacting much with this foreign society. See this in case you haven't already. You might also know the farce that has been going on for years we call 'Integration Summit' where they let 'orthodox' and 'fundamentalists' voice their opinion and actively shape the 'integration process'. You can imagine much woo-ing is going on there. As a matter of fact so much that the 'moderates' or ex-Muslims have left the discussions for the most part already.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom