How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

What exactly is the misconception, my belief and the data conflicting my belief on this point (what point?)?
That Muslims want to kill you or that the small radical minority (7% of polled population at most) who do want to kill you want to do so because of their religion.
 
That Muslims want to kill you or that the small radical minority (7% of polled population at most) who do want to kill you want to do so because of their religion.

I'm sorry to tell you this (most likely again) but that's the reality. That is not what I said though. In case you didn't catch it:

I don't know why I should even think about respecting something that wants to kill me among billions of others based not only on their (non)belief.

Exchange 'something' with Islam and 'wants to' with 'commands Muslims to' for a better understanding. Do you even understand what radical means, especially in this context? It doesn't mean 'misunderstander of Islam'.

They indeed want to kill me, and most likely you as well and all based on their religion. And that's about 7 million Muslims if you accept Gallup's claim to represent the Muslims of those areas (going with a billion Muslims) after extrapolating the result. Tell me if I'm wrong, but I think this is what Gallup does with this poll, isn't it?

Or do you say the 7% aren't Muslims? Since you seem to regard what Muslims (individually) think as what Islam commands or is as pretty much authoritative, instead of the mainstream and primary sources as well as the earliest interpretations or just plain old history, it would be strange to go along with that now.

But remember, those 7% are apparently only those who see the 9/11 attacks as completely justified. How many of the remaining 93% 'moderates' who accept the attacks as partly justified would condone the killing of 'legitimate targets'?

I don't recall the exact data, but there's a recent poll that pretty much said 1/3 of British Muslim students are in favour of violence in the name of Islam.

There's two things that come to mind, maybe three from an Islamic viewpoint as to why the 9/11 attacks were not completely justified: The killing of Muslims, the killing of women and the killing children as well as the killing of those who have not been 'called to Islam' as laid out in sura 9, verse 29 for example and thus couldn't get in the Islamic fold by either converting or paying the jizya and well, live under Islamic rule.

Of course there are other factors of objection, like being human. Being of a pacifist nature. Or being ignorant of your own religion.

Quran 9 said:
PICKTHAL: Fight against such of those who have been given the Scripture as believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, and forbid not that which Allah hath forbidden by His messenger, and follow not the Religion of Truth, until they pay the tribute readily, being brought low.

I don't know why I should even think about respecting something that wants to kill me among billions of others based not only on their (non)belief.

Why do you, Upchurch?

I've spent almost 3 years on this subject now and I really wish I would have come to a different conclusion. I can disagree with many things these 7% do based on my understanding of Islam. Unfortuneately I can also agree on a lot of undesirable things as well. And that being that Islam commands Muslims to kill you and me as well as billions of other people. Whether they do it or not is an entirely different thing. It's like with Catholics using contraceptions.
 
I'm sorry to tell you this (most likely again) but that's the reality.
I'm not sure what you are basing your view of reality on, but it certainly doesn't include empirical evidence, like what I provided.


Do you even understand what radical means, especially in this context? It doesn't mean 'misunderstander of Islam'.
"Radical" certainly doesn't mean "common", "usual", or "generally accepted".


And that's about 7 million Muslims if you accept Gallup's claim to represent the Muslims of those areas (going with a billion Muslims) after extrapolating the result. Tell me if I'm wrong, but I think this is what Gallup does with this poll, isn't it?
Actually, it would be 70 million, if you want to take it out of context like that. That 7% were the ones that sympathetic with the 9/11 attacks, not the ones that would be necessarily willing to duplicate them. After all, only 30 or so out of 1 billion actually did "try to kill you" so to speak. That's 0.000003%


Or do you say the 7% aren't Muslims?
Not at all. What I am saying is that their pro-9/11 motivation is not primarily religious in nature. It is the "radical" part that is dangerous, not the "Muslim" part. As it is with most of us human beings.


But remember, those 7% are apparently only those who see the 9/11 attacks as completely justified.
I'll have to actually read the findings, but that is not the impression I got off the podcast. Perhaps you could show me where you found that?


How many of the remaining 93% 'moderates' who accept the attacks as partly justified would condone the killing of 'legitimate targets'?
Again, my impression is that you extrapolating beyond what the data actually says. On what do you base this?


Why do you, Upchurch?
As was pointed out in the interview, few of those who fell in the "radical" designation pointed to the Quran to justify the violence. Many who opposed the violence pointed to the Quran as a reason why.

All religious texts seem to have their bloody sides. What matters is how the adherents choose to interpret those texts. As has been pointed out to you, at least 93% of Muslims, when polled, do not use the Quran or their religion as justification to do violence or justification for others to do violence. Apparently, most of the remaining 7% do not do so either.

I respect Islam because I understand that, even though it is not the lens through which I interpret the world, it is the lens that a large number of people use. And the vast majority of those people do well by it and are kind to others. It seems to work for them, so more power to them. Every section of humanity has bad people in it, some of whom do bad things. It is not my impression that the Muslim section has a disproportionate percentage of those people.


I've spent almost 3 years on this subject now and I really wish I would have come to a different conclusion.
And how did you spend that time? Reading the Quran through the perspective of a westerner who has little to no context or by talking to Muslims about their perspective of their religion. In the end, your understanding of the Quran doesn't matter. It is the practitioners of Islam whose understanding of their religion that defines what the religion is.

It's like with Catholics using contraceptions.
Funny you should mention that. When you listen to that very same podcast I mentioned earlier, you will learn that a good 75% of Catholics ignore the Humanae Vitae.

Regardless, Islam, unlike Catholicism, does not have an orthodox authority structure. Islam is practiced on an individual level and is, thus, individually interpreted. Sure, there are structures in place to help teach the laity, but it is ultimately a individual thing. There is no Islamic Pope who hands down edicts.

In that, it is not like the Humanae Vitae at all.
 
Actually, it would be 70 million, if you want to take it out of context like that. That 7% were the ones that sympathetic with the 9/11 attacks, not the ones that would be necessarily willing to duplicate them. After all, only 30 or so out of 1 billion actually did "try to kill you" so to speak. That's 0.000003%

Yes, 70 million. Fine, let's say they would 'just like to see you killed' and see it justified. Bad enough. But I'm not just talking about grand scale attacks or attacks outside their countries or wherever they are right now. They're not just out to kill you, they're already killing others all over the world on pretty much a daily basis.

Not at all. What I am saying is that their pro-9/11 motivation is not primarily religious in nature. It is the "radical" part that is dangerous, not the "Muslim" part. As it is with most of us human beings.

At least you're not saying it's not connected to their religion.

I'll have to actually read the findings, but that is not the impression I got off the podcast. Perhaps you could show me where you found that?

Again, my impression is that you extrapolating beyond what the data actually says. On what do you base this?

Here, in the one called 'Radicals vs. the Moderate Masses':

In order to investigate characteristics that distinguish Muslim world residents who are potentially prone to extremist views, we divided respondents from the region into two groups. Classified as political radicals were those who met the following criteria: 1) they felt the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, were “completely justified”, and 2) they indicate that they have an “unfavorable” or “very unfavorable” opinion of the United States. Those who did not say the attacks were completely justified were termed moderates. The “radical” group represents about 7% of the total population across the 10 countries included in the study.

Surely this is not the whole survey, I am aware of that. But they're the ones extrapolating and talking about 'Muslim world residents', not me. And if I am not mistaken, they even claim to show what Muslims think world wide, not me. Hell, your podcast's called 'Probing the Minds of One Billion Muslims' and the book they put out is called 'Who Speaks for Islam? What a Billion Muslims Really Think', isn't it?

But you asked me where I got that from. Did you just spasm out when you saw the word Hannity, or did you actually read what I said and saw what I put an emphasis on? Because if you had done so, you should have seen it.

As was pointed out in the interview, few of those who fell in the "radical" designation pointed to the Quran to justify the violence. Many who opposed the violence pointed to the Quran as a reason why.

The violence being specifically the killing of innocents on 9/11 here. You have to understand what being innocent means in an Islamic context. Again, I pretty much already told you that not only once.

All religious texts seem to have their bloody sides.

I still have to see where the Bible commands Christians / Catholics to go out and fight and kill or subdue mankind in order to establish a world wide Christian theocracy. That's the biggest difference here and the most important one.

What matters is how the adherents choose to interpret those texts.

No doubt. But the earliest leaders, Muhammad and his four 'rightly guided caliphs' as well as the four schools of Sunni Islam (about 90% of Muslims are Sunni) seem to agree with what I am saying here about jihad and Islam.

As has been pointed out to you, at least 93% of Muslims, when polled, do not use the Quran or their religion as justification to do violence or justification for others to do violence. Apparently, most of the remaining 7% do not do so either.

No, at least 93% do not see the killing of Muslims, women and children justified, which it isn't (at least not deliberately). When you look to Palestine, Lebanon and other regions, what is terrorism to us can be their 'freedom fight'.

This is exactly what al-Qaradawi complained about when he talked about 9/11. See here. Read it carefully. It becomes more of an 'ease the westerners' minds' propaganda piece mixed with a good amount of truths (the best kind I once read) when you think about how basically everyone in Israel is regarded as a combatant by such authorities like al-Qaradawi.

I respect Islam because I understand that, even though it is not the lens through which I interpret the world, it is the lens that a large number of people use. And the vast majority of those people do well by it and are kind to others. It seems to work for them, so more power to them. Every section of humanity has bad people in it, some of whom do bad things. It is not my impression that the Muslim section has a disproportionate percentage of those people.

While I agree with most parts, you might have noticed that I am mainly talking about Islam and not Muslims. You respect Muslims, not Islam as it was lived out by early guys - those who al-Qaeda among others cite.

And how did you spend that time? Reading the Quran through the perspective of a westerner who has little to no context or by talking to Muslims about their perspective of their religion. In the end, your understanding of the Quran doesn't matter. It is the practitioners of Islam whose understanding of their religion that defines what the religion is.

I don't understand why you're saying I have little or no context?

I did both of course since I am a 'westerner'. But the main part would be to juxtapose the Quran and interpretations by Muslims, especially scholars and not just the run-of-the-mill imam to see what they think; be it the early interpretations or the current ones. People who have spent a large portion or their whole life on the subject. Fatwas, articles. News. I watched and read a lot of (translated unfortuneately, although I am thinking about learning Arabic) material of prominent scholars like al-Qaradawi of al-Azhar as well as others and then try to figure out what their sources are or better said what they base their stuff on. Last thing I did was spending a good amount of time on women and shari'a.

And well, I have two or three books written from a non-Muslim viewpoint, but I don't take what is said by face value. I compare it to the interpretations and texts, history, you name it. One book pretty much served as a compressed introduction and I acquired some of the cited sources, of which the 'Umdat al-Sail is one. Ahadith and tafsir are available online, which also helps a lot.

Funny you should mention that. When you listen to that very same podcast I mentioned earlier, you will learn that a good 75% of Catholics ignore the Humanae Vitae.

And so can Muslims. This does in no way change what Islam says though, just like 75% Catholics ignoring the 'Humanae Vitae' and thus their authoritative figure doesn't change Catholicism or what the pope said.

Regardless, Islam, unlike Catholicism, does not have an orthodox authority structure. Islam is practiced on an individual level and is, thus, individually interpreted. Sure, there are structures in place to help teach the laity, but it is ultimately a individual thing. There is no Islamic Pope who hands down edicts.

Yes, but this is both good and bad. Although you have prominent scholars who many look up to and many of those issue fatwas many adhere to. Then there's the caliphate so many want back.

I reckon what's being taught to for example imams if they get an education which many don't seem to get, isn't so individual anymore though. Rather not at all, but pretty much the consent of it all. There is a consent on many things, not least because they refer to what their founder did and (relatively) early Muslims' interpretations which pretty much make up the foundation of the four schools of thought.

This individual interpretation you speak of is all fine and dandy, but the Muslims I have seen who haven't indulged in Islamic texts etc. like I have (and that is not much when you keep in mind this is a vast topic) are quite frankly very bad at it for all its worth. It's very hard to get your head around the whole content of the Quran. An example is my sister. When I asked my sister about what it's like to be more or less regarded as a tilth by her religion, she didn't even know the Quran says that. (See here). Once I showed it to her she fled (sadly, I can't describe it as anything else) into her individual 'interpretation' and claimed it works both ways. Unfortuneately there is no indication of that, nor is it the mainstream consent but quite the opposite. Same with the notorious 'wife beating verse'. Although it is not meant to be a command to beat your women to a bloody pulp, it is there. Not in her mind though! Just like she heard Jacques-Yves Cousteau converted to Islam (some sort of appeal to authority early on in our discussions as in 'Look! That guy is clever and he converted!'), she heard that the word being used for 'to beat' here has 14 different meanings in Arabic. Just too bad the consent when it comes to (not only) a translation of the passage is to use 'to beat'. Another interesting observation was her exposure to Muslims born and raised outside of Europe, while she was staying with some in London. Some of their views, be it Egyptian Muslims or I think a Jordanian one as well, all women by the way, were alien and shocking to her and her 'individual interpretation'. It is this 'individual interpretation' that makes so many, especially women, demand shari'a - because they think what they see in their countries is 'wrong'. Just like my sister and her friends claim what's being done for example to the homosexuals in Iran, has 'nothing to do with Islam'. They don't base this on their knowledge of Islam, but what they regard as good.
 
Baracuda, did you read the Koran? How many times did you talk about Islam with moslems?
Does the koran demand to kill ppl of other or no religion? and where in the koran does it say that ? what page of the koran?
 
Baracuda, did you read the Koran? How many times did you talk about Islam with moslems?
Does the koran demand to kill ppl of other or no religion? and where in the koran does it say that ? what page of the koran?

Although I feel in no way obliged to answer any of your questions because you're a tard who doesn't think it's good form to answer the questions of people you have recently talked to, especially after they have answered yours, here goes in short:

Yes, I have read the Quran.
Innumerable times, my sister is a convert for starters.
Yes it does, unless they convert or get into the Islamic fold and feel themselves subdued.
I can not tell you on 'which page' it says that.
What I can do though is tell you in which sura and verse.
Examples: 2:216, 4:89, 9:5, 9:29, 9:36.
 
Although I feel in no way obliged to answer any of your questions because you're a tard who doesn't think it's good form to answer the questions of people you have recently talked to, especially after they have answered yours, here goes in short:

Yes, I have read the Quran.
Innumerable times, my sister is a convert for starters.
Yes it does, unless they convert or get into the Islamic fold and feel themselves subdued.
I can not tell you on 'which page' it says that.
What I can do though is tell you in which sura and verse.
Examples: 2:216, 4:89, 9:5, 9:29, 9:36.

do you think that the interpretation / translation is correct when it demands you to kill "infidels" while the same book / rules teach you, only allah may give or take life?
 
do you think that the interpretation / translation is correct when it demands you to kill "infidels" while the same book / rules teach you, only allah may give or take life?

Given that Muhammad himself and his subordinates took innumerable lives early on in Islam's history, that point is more than moot. The Quran is full of double standards. To make it simple: Love your fellow Muslim, hate all others. This is a problem not understood by many. They read all these things like 'Islam does not condone the killing of innocent people' or 'Islam is a tolerant religion' without knowing what innocence is defined as in Islam as well as what this tolerance is.
 
Given that Muhammad himself and his subordinates took innumerable lives early on in Islam's history, that point is more than moot. The Quran is full of double standards. To make it simple: Love your fellow Muslim, hate all others. This is a problem not understood by many. They read all these things like 'Islam does not condone the killing of innocent people' or 'Islam is a tolerant religion' without knowing what innocence is defined as in Islam as well as what this tolerance is.

im just happy most moslems dont understood the koran / islam like you do :)
even the hatepreachers in iran that normaly chant stuff like death to the USA etc. on 9/11 they told theyr ppl, massmurder is wrong, no mather if in Palestina, Dafour or in New York. Massmurder is wrong and not what Islam teaches us.
.
 
Well either that you think I misunderstand Islam or they do. Most likely the former, given it's you.
 
Well either that you think I misunderstand Islam or they do. Most likely the former, given it's you.

as im not a moslem i dont know if you misunderstood it, but i guess so :)
you seem to accept the interpretation of the extremists that try to excuse theyr killings with the koran, as the main interpretation as you said the Koran demands you to kill infidels.

and what you told me is in contradiction to what a iman told me about islam and the koran. but he is a very modern iman.
 
as im not a moslem i dont know if you misunderstood it, but i guess so :)
you seem to accept the interpretation of the extremists that try to excuse theyr killings with the koran, as the main interpretation as you said the Koran demands you to kill infidels.

Yawn.

and what you told me is in contradiction to what a iman told me about islam and the koran. but he is a very modern iman.

I suppose he wants to stay in the country.
 
aah i see, he lied just to hide his very evil belive in the koran........
jaja langsam wird klar aus welcher richtung der Wind weht.

Well, preaching hatred and animosity towards the populace isn't necessarily the best way to stay free or in the country. But if you see him that way, your opinion. Not mine.
 
Well, preaching hatred and animosity towards the populace isn't necessarily the best way to stay free or in the country. But if you see him that way, your opinion. Not mine.

are you one of those that belive that Islam conspired against the west?
and those moslems living in our countrys are just undercover mujahedeens?
they lie about theyr real belive to us, just to fool us?

how many are in on it?
 
are you one of those that belive that Islam conspired against the west?

I don't know any chap by the name of 'Islam' who conspired against the west.

and those moslems living in our countrys are just undercover mujahedeens?

And you're one of them.

they lie about theyr real belive to us, just to fool us?

Oh many seem to do, although I wouldn't call it lying. I'd call it deceiving.

how many are in on it?

In on what? You lost me at 'are'.
 
I don't know any chap by the name of 'Islam' who conspired against the west.



And you're one of them.



Oh many seem to do, although I wouldn't call it lying. I'd call it deceiving.



In on what? You lost me at 'are'.

darn i have been uncovered, yes i just claim to be an atheist, im a total extreem islamist.......
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom