Upchurch
Papa Funkosophy
You missed the point entirely.You have a funny definition of what constitutes evidence for your position. They were fighting against 20th century communist imperialism, not 19th century colonialism.
That was not meant as evidence that they were fighting colonialism. That was meant as evidence that they are politically motivated. That they are willing to work with us when politically convenient suggests that their antagonism towards us now is based on political reasons rather than religious ones. After all, neither groups have changed their religious beliefs between then and now. It is only the political situation that has changed.
The bit about the colonialism and subsequent world wars, etc. was describing the roots of the middle-east conflict which was also inherently political and not religious in nature.
Again, you are blurring the lines and painting with a very broad brush.You say that as if the political dimension to the conflict means that the religion is merely pretext. But it is not. For the Islamists, religion and politics are not separate.
Not all Islamists (i.e. those who view Islam as both a religion and a political system, by definition) hold identical ideological goals or approve of the same methodologies. No more than two Democrats or two Republicans might.
And yet, what is the difference between these violent, radical Islamists and their more moderate brethren? Do they hold different religions or different politics?For them, everything political is religious, and everything religious is political. And you will fail to understand them if you cannot wrap your head around that, and you clearly do not yet.
And if he or his followers did start killing people, what would you suggest? Do we declare war on Fred Phelps and his followers or on Christianity in general?How serious a threat do you think Fred Phelps is to anyone? How many people has he or is followers killed?