How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

You have a funny definition of what constitutes evidence for your position. They were fighting against 20th century communist imperialism, not 19th century colonialism.
You missed the point entirely.

That was not meant as evidence that they were fighting colonialism. That was meant as evidence that they are politically motivated. That they are willing to work with us when politically convenient suggests that their antagonism towards us now is based on political reasons rather than religious ones. After all, neither groups have changed their religious beliefs between then and now. It is only the political situation that has changed.

The bit about the colonialism and subsequent world wars, etc. was describing the roots of the middle-east conflict which was also inherently political and not religious in nature.


You say that as if the political dimension to the conflict means that the religion is merely pretext. But it is not. For the Islamists, religion and politics are not separate.
Again, you are blurring the lines and painting with a very broad brush.

Not all Islamists (i.e. those who view Islam as both a religion and a political system, by definition) hold identical ideological goals or approve of the same methodologies. No more than two Democrats or two Republicans might.


For them, everything political is religious, and everything religious is political. And you will fail to understand them if you cannot wrap your head around that, and you clearly do not yet.
And yet, what is the difference between these violent, radical Islamists and their more moderate brethren? Do they hold different religions or different politics?


How serious a threat do you think Fred Phelps is to anyone? How many people has he or is followers killed?
And if he or his followers did start killing people, what would you suggest? Do we declare war on Fred Phelps and his followers or on Christianity in general?
 
That was not meant as evidence that they were fighting colonialism. That was meant as evidence that they are politically motivated.

Did I deny that? No. But politics and religion are not separate for them. That's why the Islamists want their religious leaders and their political leaders to be the same people. So why do you continue to say that they're politically motivated when I explicitly acknowleged that?

That they are willing to work with us when politically convenient suggests that their antagonism towards us now is based on political reasons rather than religious ones.

No, actually, it doesn't. Bin Laden and many other Islamists considered the Soviets to be the greater threat, and with good reason. The Soviets were hostile to religion and, unlike us, explicitly expansionist. They had to be defeated first. Why would Bin Laden have any problem with accepting help from one kufir to help defeat another? That's just common sense, divide-and-conquor. It says nothing about the absence of any fundamental religious tension between him and us. They have plenty of support from religious doctrine for making expedient compromises to further long-term religious goals (look up the phrase "hudna" for an example).

The bit about the colonialism and subsequent world wars, etc. was describing the roots of the middle-east conflict which was also inherently political and not religious in nature.

Except those roots stretch back much farther than Europe's colonial period, and they very much DO include religion throughout them, even if the religious dimensions were often ignored by those Europeans.

Not all Islamists (i.e. those who view Islam as both a religion and a political system, by definition) hold identical ideological goals or approve of the same methodologies. No more than two Democrats or two Republicans might.

And yet, in the big picture, democrats and republicans have more in common than not. Yes, the Islamists are not all identical, but what, exactly, is your point? I did not claim that they were all identical, but they are similar enough.

And yet, what is the difference between these violent, radical Islamists and their more moderate brethren? Do they hold different religions or different politics?

In effect, both. You keep harping on the fact that it's political. Yes, it is. But it is also religious. And nothing you have said demonstrates it is not. Instead, you choose to bury your head in the sand and pretend that religion is irrelevant. Well, it isn't. They tell us so, time and time again.

And if he or his followers did start killing people, what would you suggest? Do we declare war on Fred Phelps and his followers or on Christianity in general?

I would suggest starting by treating it like a law enforcement problem. But if that approach proved fundamentally inadequate (as it already has with Islamic terrorism), then it might indeed be worthwhile to declare war on his brand of Christianity. But that hasn't happened, and it's bloody unlikely to happen. So what, exactly, is your point?
 
um... how's that now?

This is exactly the sort of response that shows why I do not take you seriously on this issue. It's not simply that you don't agree with my position, you evidently don't even have a passing familiarity with one of the main motivating arguments for why we have a war on terror in the first place. No wonder you can't figure out when it might end, you're clueless about why it even started.
 
Yeah, why is treating it like a law enforcement problem fundamentally inadequate?

I mean, it worked the last time the World Trade Center was attacked. Those responsible were found, tried and convicted within three years. That's more than what has been accomplished in the last seven this time around.

Yeah. That was a fantastic success. Thanks for proving my point yet again for why I don't take you seriously.
 

Attachments

  • wtcdestroyed.jpg
    wtcdestroyed.jpg
    34.7 KB · Views: 87
Yeah. That was a fantastic success. Thanks for proving my point yet again for why I don't take you seriously.

Let me see if I understand your argument correctly. If law enforcement does not stop a type of crime from happening again, law enforcement is an inadequate method of handling the crime. So, because theft still happens even after law enforcement has been used against it multiple times, law enforcement is a failure?

Is this what you are trying to say?

...or are you trying to appeal to emotion rather than dealing with a rational argument?
 
Let me see if I understand your argument correctly. If law enforcement does not stop a type of crime from happening again, law enforcement is an inadequate method of handling the crime. So, because theft still happens even after law enforcement has been used against it multiple times, law enforcement is a failure?

Is this what you are trying to say?

No, you do not correctly understand my argument. You never have. Your counterarguments have always consisted primarily of misunderstanding or misrepresentations of my argument.

I do not expect law enforcement to stop all crime. I do expect it to reduce crime rates. I do not expect counter-terrorism efforts will be able to completely stop terrorism. But counterterrorism efforts in the 1990's not only didn't eliminate terrorism, they didn't even manage it successfully. To point to the 1993 WTC bombing convictions as evidence that such approaches work is simply laughable. Conviction rates are NOT the metric I care about, and the relevant metrics (the number and severity of attacks) do not show that it was any kind of success. Which is why your reference to it was simply laughable.
 
No, you do not correctly understand my argument. You never have. Your counterarguments have always consisted primarily of misunderstanding or misrepresentations of my argument.
Well, at least I understand the difference between a counterargument and asking for clarification. A picture, picked for its emotional value, is not a clear argument. Even after having clarified somewhat, that picture didn't even come close to adequately describing your argument.

All I have to go on is what you actually say. Please don't assume I can read your mind.

Conviction rates are NOT the metric I care about, and the relevant metrics (the number and severity of attacks) do not show that it was any kind of success.
What are you counting as "attacks" in your metric? How are you measuring "severity"?
 
Yeah, why is treating it like a law enforcement problem fundamentally inadequate?

Because you can't send out the FBI or the Police to Afghanistan or Pakistan to arrest Bin Laden and Company.
If you think the US should have done nothing other then some symbolic but ineffective measure after 9/11,have the honest guts to say so.
 
Well, at least I understand the difference between a counterargument and asking for clarification.

Your previous post in response to the photo I posted was not simply asking for clarification. It was a strawman which you erected and which you yourself didn't even believe, and its sole purpose was to set up the subsequent accusation that I didn't even have an argument and was merely appealing to emotions. Don't try to play clever, Upchurch, you're no good at it.
 
Because you can't send out the FBI or the Police to Afghanistan or Pakistan to arrest Bin Laden and Company.
If you think the US should have done nothing other then some symbolic but ineffective measure after 9/11,have the honest guts to say so.

Sending the military to Afghanistan didn't result in the capture of Bin Laden. And sending the military to Iraq seems to have generated far more terrorist attacks than it prevented.
 
Sending the military to Afghanistan didn't result in the capture of Bin Laden.

No, it did not. But it removed Al Qaeda's safe havens and training camps, and much of Al Qaeda's leadership was killed or captured. The FBI and even cruise missiles could not do either.
 
Because you can't send out the FBI or the Police to Afghanistan or Pakistan to arrest Bin Laden and Company.
If you think the US should have done nothing other then some symbolic but ineffective measure after 9/11,have the honest guts to say so.
Pages ago, I said that I thought sending in the military into Afghanistan to get Bin Laden and Company was the right thing to do. If they prefer to be taken dead rather than alive, that's okay by me too.

I happen to think that everything done after the invasion of Afghanistan was pretty much unrelated to 9/11 and a huge distraction from the mission at hand.
 
Pages ago, I said that I thought sending in the military into Afghanistan to get Bin Laden and Company was the right thing to do.

You backed the invasion of Afghanistan, but you challenged me regarding the adequacy of treating terrorism as a law enforcement problem. That is... inconsistent, to put it charitably.
 
No, it did not. But it removed Al Qaeda's safe havens and training camps, and much of Al Qaeda's leadership was killed or captured. The FBI and even cruise missiles could not do either.

Were you one of the guys yelling "wag the dog" when Clinton attacked an Al Qaeda camp with cruise missiles?
 
Why did you bring up Israel when I didn't mention Israel?

Here are some posts of Oliver's dealing with jews and Israel, for anyone who's interested. I think the pattern is fairly consistent.

Regarding whether or not I'm Jewish:


So? How does this explain the fact that the "War on Terror" surely -surprise, surprise- includes Israels interests? - Or the fact that I live in complete harmony with the majority of liberal Jewish people in the US, which you seem to hate for some reasons, "liberal Jew-Hater".

Explain...
 
Were you one of the guys yelling "wag the dog" when Clinton attacked an Al Qaeda camp with cruise missiles?

No. I'm not claiming Clinton's cruise missile strikes were an attempt to distract the nation: quite the reverse, far more should have been done. And accusations of "wag the dog" made it less likely that more would be done. I did not at the time appreciate how costly a mistake such accuations were, but I recognized them for the cheap politics they were.
 
So? How does this explain the fact that the "War on Terror" surely -surprise, surprise- includes Israels interests?

What exactly do you think Israel's interests are? Something nefarious, no doubt. You really are quite predictable.
"The modern anti-Semite does not believe in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. But instead he fantasizes about an “Israel lobby” that is supposed to control American foreign policy like a tail that wags the dog. For the modern anti-Semite, it goes without saying that every year on January 27 he will commemorate the liberation of Auschwitz. But at the same time he militates for the right of Iran to have atomic weapons."
 
What exactly do you think Israel's interests are? Something nefarious, no doubt. You really are quite predictable.
"The modern anti-Semite does not believe in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. But instead he fantasizes about an “Israel lobby” that is supposed to control American foreign policy like a tail that wags the dog. For the modern anti-Semite, it goes without saying that every year on January 27 he will commemorate the liberation of Auschwitz. But at the same time he militates for the right of Iran to have atomic weapons."


I will repeat myself so that even you are capable to understand me:

I live in complete harmony with the majority of US Jewish citizens who just want to see peace - and in this context - also disagree with your loved AIPAC-Friends being actively and successfully interested in shaping the "War on Terror".

So what's your conservative argument in here anyway?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom