I thought you were smart enough to figure out what I meant without me having to write an essay. Apparently you either are not that smart, or you're just not interested in what I meant but only whether or not you can gain an upper hand in an argument. I do not know or care which it is.
I was trying to baby-step you through the ramifications of your position. Either you still don't understand or you just don't care.
Herein lies a neat little summary of your oversimplification of a grossly complicated situation. I won't even pretend to understand the complete history and nuance of the middle-east conflict, but it does
not boil down to:
But our enemies ... have values which are inherently antagonistic to ours. It is not by our choice, but by theirs, that conflict arises. They will continue to attack us for as long as they hold on to their values and cannot accept ours. The war will be over when they stop attacking us, and that will happen when they can at least tolerate our values. But they are the aggressors, not us.
If you think it amounts to: "Golly, they're just a bunch of meanies!" Then you are less informed about it than even I am.
Then they will continue to spawn radicals who will attack us, and the war will go on.
How do you justify the position that holding certain non-western principles will necessarily lead to "spawning radicals who will attack us"? There are other societies (and even ideologies) that hold principles other than our own who are not spawning radicals, are there not?
It's a war against an ideology. That ideology is tied to certain societies, but it is not synonymous with those societies.
You're close. It is a war against a
political ideology. The conflict has far more to do with the results of 19th century colonialism and a few subsequent world and cold wars than it has to do with any inherent discrepancies between specific social or religious ideologies outside of those politics.
Need evidence? In a different political situation, these very same radical Islamic fighters who are fundamentally and ideologically opposed to us in every way were
our allies against the Soviets little more than 20 years ago.
You can object that it isn't mainstream Islam, but it is still a form of Islam, and it was not used as an excuse, it was the entire justification.
You make it sound as if an excuse and a justification are two different things.
Religion is the methodology used to control and use the lower-end foot soldiers, but religion is not the reason for the conflict. As I said, the reason for the conflict is politics and, like most politics, it is about territory in one form or another.
I'll not only object that it isn't mainstream Islam, I'll object that it isn't even the vast majority of Islam.
That very much has something to do with freedom of speech, because radical Islam and free speech are not compatible. You cannot hold on to both. If they accept free speech, we will know that they have abandoned radical Islam. Just as if a country can only embrace free speech if it drops communism, or fascism, or any other form of totalitarian despotism.
You cannot hold radical
anything and free speech, but the converse is not also true. Having free speech in a society does not mean that there are not radical elements within it. Take our own society and folks like Fred Phelps. Not only does free speech permit radical ideologies, it protects them.
Bin Laden and Co. did not attack us on 9/11 because we allow free speech. They attacked us because of their disagreement with our foreign policy positions, past and present, concerning the middle-east. Otherwise, why would they have bothered?
Go through
his released statements
. How many of them have to do with condemning freedom of speech or the religious ideological differences the middle-east and the west?
Yes. Because your misunderstanding and misrepresentation of my position continues like clockwork.
Back to the baby-steps then.