How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

According to the summary, part of the tit-for-tat strategy is to be quick to forgive.

Yes: after you've retaliated.

When/Where/How you envision that part of the strategy coming into effect in the War On Terror?

I think our rebuilding efforts in both Afghanistan and Iraq fall under that category pretty well.
 
I think our rebuilding efforts in both Afghanistan and Iraq fall under that category pretty well.
Wait, are we at war with the people of Iraq and Afghanistan or the ambiguously defined terrorists?

And going back to the OP, when do you think the "game" is over?
 
Wait, are we at war with the people of Iraq and Afghanistan or the ambiguously defined terrorists?

Not as a whole. But those whom we are fighting would indeed benefit from our reconstruction efforts if they ever stop fighting and try to live normal lives. Really, Upchurch, this was a weak counterargument. Especially since forgiveness under tit-for-tat doesn't happen until agression stops. And it has for certain groups (such as some Sunni tribes in Al Anbar).

And going back to the OP, when do you think the "game" is over?

The game is never over. But the war is only part of the game, and it can end.
 
Hey Upchurch, I got a reverse question for you!
When is the war on terror lost? Maybe that helps us with finding out what makes us win it. ;)
 
No. And I take your dodging reply as a "yes". :)

Why did you bring up Israel when I didn't mention Israel?

Here are some posts of Oliver's dealing with jews and Israel, for anyone who's interested. I think the pattern is fairly consistent.
So of course Obama is more popular with his diplomatic tone on Iran and his wisdom about the Iraq war before it started. But it also comes down to the fact that the rest of the world simply doesn't play Israels the world's police.
What's the fuss about? "Jews" rule middle-eastern
US-policies. So what?
Since Jews have an own State, yes - I think they have a nationality
You just discovered a pretty basic Caucasian Way of thinking about others "evildoers by default". Quite shocking that there are so many people who actually support this selfish "And who the **** are you ******* Arab/Jew/Native/N-Word...?" World View.

Basically the whole Jewish-Republican Wing in here more or less thinks this way - sometimes without even recognizing it. Lovely folks, eh? :boggled:
Everyone with a little bit if
knowledge knows that Israel gives a **** about human
rights of third parties.

Regarding whether or not I'm Jewish:
It wouldn't matter to me if he's a Jew or not. I would like to know it to understand his position - because making a secret out of it makes him look non-credible.
 
You, you.. you secret Jou!
I wonder: Am I part of 'the whole Jewish-Republican Wing in here'? I can only hope.

And if not: We can change. YES WE CAN!
 
When a muslim comic can mock Mohammed in Saudi Arabia, we'll know we've won.

So Saudi Arabia is our benchmark and bellweather --- and that's why we've got troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, and are eyeing up Iran?

Doesn't that strike you as counterproductive? Or at least misguided? I mean, if my goal is to get milk in my refrigerator, I go to the dairy, not to the shoe store. If I need a screwdriver, I don't go to the video rental store.

But when Bush wants to improve civil liberties in Saudi Arabia, he goes into Iraq?
 
So Saudi Arabia is our benchmark and bellweather --- and that's why we've got troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, and are eyeing up Iran?

It's funny: this is a common argument in certain circles, and yet no one who makes it seriously advocate military intervention in Saudi Arabia, because they know it would sink the global economy. You're using a fundamentally dishonest argument in the hopes that no one will notice. We didn't fight the cold war by attacking Moscow, but it was events in Moscow which made clear our final victory.

But when Bush wants to improve civil liberties in Saudi Arabia, he goes into Iraq?

Frankly, I don't know how interested Bush is in civil liberties in Saudi Arabia. But there's not much he can do about them directly, and it was obvious to those actually paying attention to the issues that the fight against Islamic terrorism is going to take a long time, certainly longer than Bush will be in office. The only pressure we can afford to exert against Saudi Arabia is indirect, and yes, the Iraq invasion may be our best shot at that. Democracies are inherently threatening to authoritarian regimes by virtue of their existence, and a democratic Iraq would put enormous pressure on both Saudi Arabia and Iran.
 
Implicit in my answer was doing it without threat of violence or legal punishment. And no, I don't think that can happen now.
Oooh. You want something out of Saudi Arabia that we haven't been quite able to manage here in the US, huh? (for example)

I'll guess that you meant "without threat of violence" to a certain degree? But that goes back to "what is a creditable threat" and how seriously do you take it, doesn't it? Does it matter if it is Christan leaders or Islamic leaders who call certain groups "the enemy" and use threatening language toward them?
 
Does it matter if it is Christan leaders or Islamic leaders who call certain groups "the enemy" and use threatening language toward them?

Were any Christian leaders calling for the death of people who make jokes about Jesus? Because in the absence of such threats (which quite definitely do exist from Muslim leaders regarding jokes about Mohammed), the parallel simply doesn't exist. Really, Upchurch, it's hard to take you seriously when your interest in the topic now centers around trying to gain a rhetorical advantage over me rather than to examine the subject with any clarity.
 
Were any Christian leaders calling for the death of people who make jokes about Jesus? Because in the absence of such threats (which quite definitely do exist from Muslim leaders regarding jokes about Mohammed), the parallel simply doesn't exist. Really, Upchurch, it's hard to take you seriously when your interest in the topic now centers around trying to gain a rhetorical advantage over me rather than to examine the subject with any clarity.
Let's just cut straight to the meat of it, then.

"When a muslim comic can mock Mohammed in Saudi Arabia, we'll know we've won. ....Implicit in my answer was doing it without threat of violence or legal punishment."

Inherent in your response is the belief that our principles are the very best principles there are (which may very well be true) and that this, therefore, gives us the right to force others to accept our principles over their own. Ironically, this last part is a betrayal of those very principles, which values freedom of choice and freedom from oppression. What if we give them that choice and they choose to keep mockery of Mohamed illegal and deathly insulting?

What you are suggesting is that this war is about changing Islamic social norms and values as well as governmental principles to match our own norms, values, and principles. After all, you are arguing that they shouldn't be deeply outraged at the mockery of their spiritual leader nor should an Islamic monarchy be able to create and enforce religious based laws, right? Would that be a fair characterization?

Is this a war against Terrorism or a war against another society, the vast majority of whom have done nothing to us? You've lost focus on what actually happened on 9/11. We were attacked by a bunch of criminals that used Islam as an excuse. It has nothing to do with whether or not they embrace our ideas of freedom of speech, a criteria you see as sufficient for ending the war.

So, let's say a Muslim newspaper prints a comic in Saudi Arabia that mocks Mohamed and, while maybe there is some grumbling, the editors are not brought up on charges and the building is not bombed. Is the war, then, over? Never mind that we still have not caught Osama Bin Laden?

And you find it hard to take me seriously?
 
Let's just cut straight to the meat of it, then.

I thought you were smart enough to figure out what I meant without me having to write an essay. Apparently you either are not that smart, or you're just not interested in what I meant but only whether or not you can gain an upper hand in an argument. I do not know or care which it is.

Inherent in your response is the belief that our principles are the very best principles there are (which may very well be true) and that this, therefore, gives us the right to force others to accept our principles over their own. Ironically, this last part is a betrayal of those very principles, which values freedom of choice and freedom from oppression.

I do happen to believe western values such as freedom of speech are superior to the alternatives. As for forcing others to accept that principle, well, no. I actually said nothing of the sort. But our enemies (and since you're likely to deliberately misinterpret this if I don't point out that this category doesn't include all muslims) have values which are inherently antagonistic to ours. It is not by our choice, but by theirs, that conflict arises. They will continue to attack us for as long as they hold on to their values and cannot accept ours. The war will be over when they stop attacking us, and that will happen when they can at least tolerate our values. But they are the aggressors, not us. If you haven't noticed, we're not trying to force Saudi Arabia to do anything.

What if we give them that choice and they choose to keep mockery of Mohamed illegal and deathly insulting?

Then they will continue to spawn radicals who will attack us, and the war will go on. You asked how we would know the war was over. You did not ask what we should do to win it. Your inability to distinguish those two things is at the heart of your repeated misinterpretation of my position.

What you are suggesting is that this war is about changing Islamic social norms and values as well as governmental principles to match our own norms, values, and principles. After all, you are arguing that they shouldn't be deeply outraged at the mockery of their spiritual leader

I said nothing of the sort. They should not use violence to express that outrage, but I have no problem with outrage in and of itself.

Is this a war against Terrorism or a war against another society,

It's a war against an ideology. That ideology is tied to certain societies, but it is not synonymous with those societies.

You've lost focus on what actually happened on 9/11. We were attacked by a bunch of criminals that used Islam as an excuse. It has nothing to do with whether or not they embrace our ideas of freedom of speech,

Oh, but it does. You can object that it isn't mainstream Islam, but it is still a form of Islam, and it was not used as an excuse, it was the entire justification. That very much has something to do with freedom of speech, because radical Islam and free speech are not compatible. You cannot hold on to both. If they accept free speech, we will know that they have abandoned radical Islam. Just as if a country can only embrace free speech if it drops communism, or fascism, or any other form of totalitarian despotism.

So, let's say a Muslim newspaper prints a comic in Saudi Arabia that mocks Mohamed and, while maybe there is some grumbling, the editors are not brought up on charges and the building is not bombed. Is the war, then, over? Never mind that we still have not caught Osama Bin Laden?

Well, yes. At that point, it's no longer a war. Bin Laden would remain a criminal at large who should be hunted down (as Nazi war criminals were decades after WWII), but one man does not make a war.

And you find it hard to take me seriously?

Yes. Because your misunderstanding and misrepresentation of my position continues like clockwork.
 
I thought you were smart enough to figure out what I meant without me having to write an essay. Apparently you either are not that smart, or you're just not interested in what I meant but only whether or not you can gain an upper hand in an argument. I do not know or care which it is.
I was trying to baby-step you through the ramifications of your position. Either you still don't understand or you just don't care.


Herein lies a neat little summary of your oversimplification of a grossly complicated situation. I won't even pretend to understand the complete history and nuance of the middle-east conflict, but it does not boil down to:
But our enemies ... have values which are inherently antagonistic to ours. It is not by our choice, but by theirs, that conflict arises. They will continue to attack us for as long as they hold on to their values and cannot accept ours. The war will be over when they stop attacking us, and that will happen when they can at least tolerate our values. But they are the aggressors, not us.
If you think it amounts to: "Golly, they're just a bunch of meanies!" Then you are less informed about it than even I am.


Then they will continue to spawn radicals who will attack us, and the war will go on.
How do you justify the position that holding certain non-western principles will necessarily lead to "spawning radicals who will attack us"? There are other societies (and even ideologies) that hold principles other than our own who are not spawning radicals, are there not?


It's a war against an ideology. That ideology is tied to certain societies, but it is not synonymous with those societies.
You're close. It is a war against a political ideology. The conflict has far more to do with the results of 19th century colonialism and a few subsequent world and cold wars than it has to do with any inherent discrepancies between specific social or religious ideologies outside of those politics.

Need evidence? In a different political situation, these very same radical Islamic fighters who are fundamentally and ideologically opposed to us in every way were our allies against the Soviets little more than 20 years ago.


You can object that it isn't mainstream Islam, but it is still a form of Islam, and it was not used as an excuse, it was the entire justification.
You make it sound as if an excuse and a justification are two different things.

Religion is the methodology used to control and use the lower-end foot soldiers, but religion is not the reason for the conflict. As I said, the reason for the conflict is politics and, like most politics, it is about territory in one form or another.

I'll not only object that it isn't mainstream Islam, I'll object that it isn't even the vast majority of Islam.


That very much has something to do with freedom of speech, because radical Islam and free speech are not compatible. You cannot hold on to both. If they accept free speech, we will know that they have abandoned radical Islam. Just as if a country can only embrace free speech if it drops communism, or fascism, or any other form of totalitarian despotism.
You cannot hold radical anything and free speech, but the converse is not also true. Having free speech in a society does not mean that there are not radical elements within it. Take our own society and folks like Fred Phelps. Not only does free speech permit radical ideologies, it protects them.

Bin Laden and Co. did not attack us on 9/11 because we allow free speech. They attacked us because of their disagreement with our foreign policy positions, past and present, concerning the middle-east. Otherwise, why would they have bothered?

Go through his released statements
. How many of them have to do with condemning freedom of speech or the religious ideological differences the middle-east and the west?


Yes. Because your misunderstanding and misrepresentation of my position continues like clockwork.
Back to the baby-steps then.
 
If you think it amounts to: "Golly, they're just a bunch of meanies!" Then you are less informed about it than even I am.

But I do not think that, so what's your point?

How do you justify the position that holding certain non-western principles will necessarily lead to "spawning radicals who will attack us"? There are other societies (and even ideologies) that hold principles other than our own who are not spawning radicals, are there not?

Precisely because it is certain other beliefs which they hold, and not simply any other beliefs.

You're close. It is a war against a political ideology.

It is not simply a political ideology. It is also a religious ideology as well. And it is precisely that combination which makes it both dangerous and inherently antagonistic to us.

The conflict has far more to do with the results of 19th century colonialism and a few subsequent world and cold wars than it has to do with any inherent discrepancies between specific social or religious ideologies outside of those politics.

Keep telling yourself that. But it does not explain why bin Laden calls for the reconquest of Al Andalus. It does not explain why Islam has bloody borders on all sides, even where it meets other colonized groups. It does not explain why Saudi Arabia, which has long had everything it needs for complete independence from "colonial" influences, is an exporter of this violence. Which colonial grievance, pray tell, are the Wahabists struggling to fix?

Need evidence? In a different political situation, these very same radical Islamic fighters who are fundamentally and ideologically opposed to us in every way were our allies against the Soviets little more than 20 years ago.

You have a funny definition of what constitutes evidence for your position. They were fighting against 20th century communist imperialism, not 19th century colonialism. And many of those (including bin Laden) were fighting against it because they believed in Islamic imperialism, not because they were opposed to imperialism or colonialism on principle.

Religion is the methodology used to control and use the lower-end foot soldiers, but religion is not the reason for the conflict. As I said, the reason for the conflict is politics and, like most politics, it is about territory in one form or another.

You say that as if the political dimension to the conflict means that the religion is merely pretext. But it is not. For the Islamists, religion and politics are not separate. For them, everything political is religious, and everything religious is political. And you will fail to understand them if you cannot wrap your head around that, and you clearly do not yet.

I'll not only object that it isn't mainstream Islam, I'll object that it isn't even the vast majority of Islam.

That's nice. But it's who we're fighting.

You cannot hold radical anything and free speech, but the converse is not also true. Having free speech in a society does not mean that there are not radical elements within it. Take our own society and folks like Fred Phelps. Not only does free speech permit radical ideologies, it protects them.

And it also isolates them and minimizes their influence. How serious a threat do you think Fred Phelps is to anyone? How many people has he or is followers killed?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom