Homoeopaths say the darndest things

Another random homeopath from India. What a surprise.

Well, random Indian homeopath, should you still be reading this, some homework: Compare the infant and child mortality rates for India and Sri Lanka. Re-examine India's healthcare practices in light of this information.

I think this is a little unfair to the Indian medical system. Comparing health outcomes in an island country of 20 million people and a continent of a billion people is rather difficult.

The Indian medical education system is somewhat schizophrenic. There is a fairly good state supported system that churns out competent (and vastly experienced given the volume of patients seen) doctors. There is also a parallel (and unfortunately also state supported) system that turns out "doctors" "trained" in CAM - Homoepathy, Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani.

The graduates of these courses are a very small fraction of the doctors trained in India. They are unfortunately quite vocal and make a splash disproportionate to their size.
 
Last edited:
One for the connoisseur of irony*:
"I have to say I find Lessell's opinions (they are not theories) to be an uncritical procession of mental meanderings randomly generated from a variety of popular physics and fringe science sources."

Lionel Milgrom, book review of Colin Lessell's A new Physics of Homeopathy, Homeopathy 92 No. 1 (2003): 61. Quoted in Jay Shelton, Homeopathy - how it really works, p. 62.




*Partly in view of this homeopath, who managed to repeatedly cite both Milgrom and Lessell, often in the same post.
 
One for the connoisseur of irony*:




*Partly in view of this homeopath, who managed to repeatedly cite both Milgrom and Lessell, often in the same post.
Oh, c'mon Mojo, we all know perferctly well that homeopathy is good for what ails you.











If what ails you is that you're a diabetic whos blood sugar has dropped to the point where a mouthfull of sugar pills will bring you back from the brink of insulin shock.
 
Hmmm. We need a chiros say the darndest things too. One is claiming that kids are healthier than adults because they laugh more? Huh? My kids don't get sick often, but when they were toddlers they were fighting off every bug out there with their novel immune systems (except they were spared the deadlier vaccine preventable diseases, thank you very much).

From a weekly email "health update" from a local chiropractor, here's an excerpt from a recent issue:

Mental Attitude : That's Funny! Laughing lowers levels of stress hormones and strengthens the immune system. Six-year-olds laugh an average of 300 times a day. Adults only laugh 15 to 100 times a day. People who laugh a lot are much healthier than those who don't.
Dr. Lee Berk, Loma Linda School of Public Health in California

Hm. 300 times a day... that's like 21 times an hour if they are awake 14 hours a day. That is close to 3 times every waking minute! Wow, what kids did this person figure into their "hypothesis"? And what exactly is "healthier"? Younger? That usually goes hand in hand like that! What stress hormones are lowered and by how much when you laugh?
 
Last edited:
Hmmm. We need a chiros say the darndest things too. One is claiming that kids are healthier than adults because they laugh more? Huh? My kids don't get sick often, but when they were toddlers they were fighting off every bug out there with their novel immune systems (except they were spared the deadlier vaccine preventable diseases, thank you very much).



Hm. 300 times a day... that's like 21 times an hour if they are awake 14 hours a day. That is close to 3 times every waking minute! Wow, what kids did this person figure into their "hypothesis"? And what exactly is "healthier"? Younger? That usually goes hand in hand like that! What stress hormones are lowered and by how much when you laugh?

Oh great. Now I have only 13 laughs to go to reach the low end of the adult "average". Thank the IPU for quacks. :(
 
Here's Marian Harkin, Irish MEP and organiser of an EU Homeopathy Day in the European Parliament on 23 March:

http://euobserver.com/9/29620

"There's always a question about the science," said Ms Harkin. "But with homeopathy, a lot of it is based on tradition and you need to be careful that the judgments that are not purely based on science. They need to be based on efficacy as well as that."
 
"The agenda is to say that science has the answer to everything. Well, they should have learnt by now that it hasn't."

Why, yes, the overpowering spread of technology and the regression of superstition speak volumes on the impotence of science.
 
"The agenda is to say that science has the answer to everything. Well, they should have learnt by now that it hasn't."


Standard homeopathic strawman. I think they assume, because they believe that homoeopathy is absolute truth, that science must claim the same thing. It doesn't, of course - in science, any "answers" are provisional and can potentially be overturned by new evidence.
 
Why, yes, the overpowering spread of technology and the regression of superstition speak volumes on the impotence of science.

Dara O'Briain said:
Jesus, homeopaths get on my nerves, with the old 'Well, science doesn't know everything'! Well, science *knows* it doesn't know everything, otherwise it would stop. . . . Just because science doesn't know everything doesn't mean that you can fill in the gaps with whatever fairy tale most appeals to you."

He says it better than I could.
 
That's hilarious!

The cartoon which MAS starts the thread with is one I've seen before. It's actually from a book on SCAM which is used as an actual medical textbook in actual medical schools. I saw it because David Colquhoun had it as a slide in his lecture in Edinburgh, when he was laying into the universities for condoning and teaching rubbish.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom