Homoeopaths say the darndest things

Mojo

Mostly harmless
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
47,082
Location
Nor Flanden
I just found this classic comment on Blogging the Organon:
goodscience said:
I do not know what the situation is, but if she saw a competent homeopath then the only reason homeopathy did not work is because the remedy chosen was not the correct remedy for her.


Just in case anyone was having trouble telling competent homoeopaths from incompetent ones...
 
This comment is even more astounding when read in context.
 
I'm not even bothering to check it this morning because I know I will end up throwing my laptop out the window. It is related to a crisis in my rather close knit extended family.

I am even trying to not violate several JREF policies right now, my fingers just want to type so many naughty things.

Let me just say that those folks, including the "mystic" GaleG, could use a better funded and more competent public mental health system.
 
Here’s another one for you, Mojo:
http://www.homeopathyzone.com/blog/...omeopathy-cannot-we-just-ignore-the-skeptics/

Skepticism About Homeopathy: Can’t We Just Ignore The Skeptics?

The people who inform the media range from clueless journalists to professional skeptics who are rarely clueless but often disingenuous in their skepticism. The list of such skeptics includes academics such as Michael Shermer, Richard Wiseman and Richard Dawkins, magicians such as James Randi, and physicians such as Stephen Barrett and Ben Goldacre.

Some of these skeptics are high-level or world-class scientists in their domain (Richard Dawkins is a leading evolutionary biologist). Others are media figures who achieved fame prior to becoming professional skeptics (James Randi won fame during his early career as a professional magician appearing on television), and others yet have garnered attention thanks to their journalistic rather than their primary professional pursuit (Ben Goldacre is a physician who writes a weekly skeptical column for England’s Guardian newspaper).

While in some cases skeptics are professionally suited to their task (e.g., James Randi regularly applies his magician skills to the debunking of fraudulent claims by reproducing the phenomenon under investigation) all skeptics are limited in their ability to evaluate phenomena in which they are not themselves expert.

To bypass this limitation, for example in the case of a non-homeopath skeptic investigating homeopathy, skeptics apply standard criteria of evidence to questionable phenomena, whereby they determine whether a phenomenon is real by whether or not it passes a test that they devise based on their understanding of what constitutes evidence for or against the phenomenon in question. Consequently they engage in “armchair skepticism” rather than sincerely encountering the field or belief they are criticizing.

-snip-

What are the main issues in the homeopathy debate?

In upcoming articles on this topic I will be answering the following questions which represent the main issues in the ongoing ‘homeopathy debate’:

  1. What are the main skeptical arguments against homeopathy?
  2. What are the proper responses to these arguments?
  3. What scientific research is there in support of homeopathy?
  4. What other data are admissible as evidence for homeopathy?
  5. What conclusions should be drawn (by homeopaths, patients, scientists, and regulatory bodies) from these research findings?
  6. Can homeopathy be explained within the context of the current scientific paradigm?
  7. If not, what world-view could incorporate modern science and medicine, homeopathy, and other unexplained phenomena without mutual conflict?

I believe that this debate has been ongoing for the entire duration of the existence of homeopathy because it brings up fundamental questions about the nature of reality that have remained unanswered by modern science.
 
I prefer the linked article "This is Why Homeopaths Emphasize Clinical Results over Theory". Note that while it "emphasizes clinical results over theory" and claims that "conventional medical thinking is based on the view that what cannot be explained cannot be addressed", it completely ignores controlled trials and the question of whether the effects of homoeopathic medicines are real (beyond placebo, of course).
 
6. Can homeopathy be explained within the context of the current scientific paradigm?


Yes, if we consider the possibility that the effects observed are the results of the placebo effect.

I'm currently reading Roberta Bivens's history of Alternative Medicine and it's becoming clear that it fits neatly into the same 18th century scientific paradigm as mesmerism.
 
We have another winner:
"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Paolo Bellavite, M.D. and Andrea Signorini, M.D., The Emerging Science of Homeopathy: Complexity, Biodynamics, and Nanopharmacology, 2002, pp.68-69


Cited by Dana Ullman on Wikipedia, and spotted by shpalman.
 
Water remembers it was kept in a freezer? Sounds traumatic. Does it get PTSD?
 
Perhaps we should explore the moral implications of water having a memory, all I'm saying...
 
We have another winner:
[The Emerging Science of Homeopathy]
Cited by Dana Ullman on Wikipedia, and spotted by shpalman.
"Emerging science"?? After more than 200 years!!?? Chemistry was recognized as a discipline around the same time, one could hardly call it "emerging" today.
 
There aren't enough jawdropping smilies for this one.

I thought that Malcolm Kirkman's idea that gravity is a function of atmospheric pressure (hence there being no gravity inside a CRT, obviously that's how the electrons get to the other side) was the daftest science this century. (Well, that was in a CT thread and so it got not only the August Stundie, but the overall 2007 award too, we need a science equivalent don't you think?)

This trumps it.

Rolfe.
 
Perhaps this is an alternate explanation for global warming? The world isn't getting warmer, it's just the ice is forgetting it's not supposed to melt.
 
"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Paolo Bellavite, M.D. and Andrea Signorini, M.D., The Emerging Science of Homeopathy: Complexity, Biodynamics, and Nanopharmacology, 2002, pp.68-69 .

Wow.

...


Wow.
 
Here's another, posted by "Dr.Ramanand Jhingaadey" on Wikipedia:
Note: Homeopathy does not produce any side effects what so ever!

Homeopathic treatment is best taken from a Qualified Homeopathic Doctor because people who medicate themselves on their own or take treatment from a person who isn't Qualified, can go into a state of 'Drug Proving', i.e. they start showing the symptoms that drug produces when taken in milligram doses (remember Homeopathic remedies are not herbal, but sub-atomic, electromagnetic remedies), worse they may become immune to treatment by other Qualified Doctors (including Allopaths/Conventional Doctors).
 
Oh, another homoeopath who doesn't know that provings are done on 30C potencies, not "milligramme doses".

Apart from the old records of Hahnemann's early work, before he decided he'd better stay away from material quantities of poisons, I've yet to see any sign of a proving done using "miligramme doses".

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom