Homoeopaths say the darndest things

Institutional Training in Homoeopathy

Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Institutional Training in Homoeopathy

[FONT='Times New Roman','serif']Training for a minimum period of 5 1/2 years (BHMS) is absolutely necessary for becoming qualified to practice this system in India as it gives a complete understanding not only about the structure and functioning of the human body but also a thorough understanding of the homeopathic philosophy and its practical utilization while treating diseased persons. And to do M.D. further, you have to spend three more years after BHMS[/FONT]
 
http://www.webindia123.com/career/h...r+of+Homeopathic+Medicine+&+Surgery+(B.H.M.S)

Institution Name: A.M.Shaikh Homoeopathic Medical College, Belgaum
Place: Karnataka
Address: A.M.Shaikh Homoeopathic Medical College, Nehru Nagar, Belgaum
Contact Now: (E-Mail Address Not Available)
Website:
Institution Details: -
Course(s) Offered: Bachelor of Homeopathic Medicine & Surgery (B.H.M.S)
Eligibility - 10+2 Science, 50 % marks in Physics, Chemistry and Biology
Duration - 5 1/2 years Seats - 100

If they reduced the percentage marks required in Physics, Chemistry and Biology, it wouldn't take over 5 years to erase what students have learnt before entering the college.

Anyone have any ideas on what homoeopathic surgery is?
 
Last edited:
In order to determine which specific remedies could be used to treat which diseases, Hahnemann experimented on himself and others for several years, before using remedies on patients. His experiments did not initially consist of giving remedies to the sick, because he thought that the most similar remedy, by virtue of its ability to induce symptoms similar to the disease itself, would make it impossible to determine which symptoms came from the remedy and which from the disease itself. Therefore, sick people were excluded from the provings.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

No wonder I tend to avoid this topic. It's not just stupid, it's intentionally stupid.
 
"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"
Well, that dispells my theory. I thought the reason ice didn't melt is it had lost all its flogiston.
 
Oh puh-lease!!!

It's "aether". Flogiston has SO been abandoned.
 
Last edited:
Another random homeopath from India. What a surprise.

Well, random Indian homeopath, should you still be reading this, some homework: Compare the infant and child mortality rates for India and Sri Lanka. Re-examine India's healthcare practices in light of this information.
 
Just remember, these people teach these things to others and feel they have better knowledge than MDs. They feel they are better qualified because of all this wonderous knowledge that... they were taught by others.

Garbage in, garbage out.

Until India does something about its education system, then don't expect anything but garbage.

Also note that people are allowed to teach just as much craziness in "schools" here. My teachers did at my school. They figured homeopathy was worthy to note as a system to treat that is not fairly recognized in our 'western' system. Let's not forget flower remedies either. I'm quite certain this water remembering it was frozen would be a worthy, well, "theory". Afterall, they figure tape can suck toxins out of your body through your skin...

It's odd though, there are some hospitals of worthy repute in India, but of course they have real doctors that were educated somewhere.

So, what can I say. When I compare North America to India, I see some parallels. They just seem to have a higher population, with a proliference of quack education to match. They just seem to have more than we have... but we have much of the same, just diluted down a bit. Until we clean up our own acts more, then...
 
Last edited:
Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.


I must admit, I didn't expect homoeopaths to submit items to this thread themselves...
 
Last edited:
It irks me that these people can call themselves "doctors". We had this lady come to a business woman's "expo" recently. She calls herself a doctor and says she practices kinesiology. Well, she was not a doctor, not having a degree in anything, and she does applied kinesiology. She was taught her techniques by a chiropractor in the states. She proceded to go on to whine that she couldn't get "training" like that anywhere in Canada. Wah.

Her act consisted of pushing a person's arm until it gave her the answers to the questions she asked the person about their childhood. She explained that the body knows what the mind has stored. It didn't matter if her hapless victim disagreed with what the arm apparently told the "doctor". It was quite a show... Like watching a psychic doing cold reading and then attempt to be their 5 minute therapist to solve all of their life's problems. A lot of people were very impressed. I wasn't impressed, especially with the usual quack's doctor bashing that she did. She even said that she didn't care if there were any doctors present in the audience, they could get as angry as they wanted...she said she didn't care. She also said you don't need credentials to be a doctor/business woman because she was one, and she didn't have no stinkin credentials that were pushed on people. Nobody was gonna tell her what she need to be a doctor/business woman. She was good at what she did, and that was all that mattered to be a doctor/business woman. quack quack quack.

Homeopaths have the same self righteousness and are given credibility they don't deserve by being able to call themselves doctos.
Some people, like the quack applied kinesiologist, just take the title even more undersevably.

I'm starting to view EVERYONE skeptically who introduces themselves as a doctor.
 
Her act consisted of pushing a person's arm until it gave her the answers to the questions she asked the person about their childhood.

I have a mental image of this person with their victim in a half-nelson, screaming, "Tell me where you went to school!!"
 
I just found this classic comment on Blogging the Organon:

goodscience said:
I do not know what the situation is, but if she saw a competent homeopath then the only reason homeopathy did not work is because the remedy chosen was not the correct remedy for her.


Just in case anyone was having trouble telling competent homoeopaths from incompetent ones...

That there is golden irony. You win the intrawebz :D
 
Last edited:
{snip} Anyone have any ideas on what homoeopathic surgery is?
I take your point. This probably does not really apply to your question; however, there is a peculiar situation in some US states. They license homeopaths only if they are also licensed MDs (Arizona and Nevada are examples). Their homeo licenses, then, cover more than is traditional homeopathy.

A year ago a homeo in Arizona (AZ) killed a woman in the process of liposuction. AZ allows homeos to do minor surgery, and the licensing board had to decide if an 8-hour operation under general anesthesia was minor. To our surprise, the guy's license was revoked (such boards usually go out of their way to protect quacks).

In Nevada a homeo/MD injected a woman with inappropriate drugs. The MD board refused to act "because he was acting as a homeo" at the time!!?? I don't know what the homeo board has done; but they are not known for acting against their own.

In the USA, you may not even get homeopathy from a homeopath. How about that?

You can read about those cases at http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/ As I recall, Orac mistakenly attributes the Nevada case to naturopathy.
 
Last edited:
I disagree that Homoeopathy is emerging Science.

It is emerging Science in the sense that its rudiments are being unfolded now. Scientist have started to show that it works in a scientific manner and the whole world is acknowledging its effectiveness.

If Allopathy is modern medicine, I would say Homoeopathy is post-modern medicine.
 
[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Your argument is t[/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']he so-called well-designed studies (the studies you have, and confirm to your scientific standards) must be satisfied by homoeopathy if it want scientific recognition. [/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Homoeopathy lacks a metaphysical model of understanding pathogenesis and as such have failed to come up with a model that could be used for research. In order for research to establish the viability of homoeopathy a model must be proposed, researched, refined and established, and validated over time. With the model it can also be used for diagnosis, evaluation and cure. But what to do now till the time we came up with the model? [/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']How does the scientific method begin to address that? That is, basically quite simple: Apply the modality, and see if there is an effect. In other words, do the patients get better, or don't they? [/FONT]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom