Homoeopaths say the darndest things

Well, there’s the cartoon of a medium saying, “come on, there must be somebody here who knew someone whose name begins with a J!”

J and M are favourites for them, because it's almost a guaranteed hit. Now why the spirits would only communicate a single letter to the medium is beyond me, but maybe they're just deliberately trying to make them look stupid.
 
J and M are favourites for them, because it's almost a guaranteed hit. Now why the spirits would only communicate a single letter to the medium is beyond me, but maybe they're just deliberately trying to make them look stupid.

Presumably it's for the same reason that the spirits don't just begin with "There is someone here whose father lost his left hand in a bizarre gardening accident. The father says the lost will is behind the elephant-patterned cushion we bought in Chang Mai". Why not get straight to the point? They know what they want to say.
I guess there is also some kind of explanation for the strange fact that the spirits of the dead relatives don't know who to ask for. "Can I speak to Dave Johnson? It's his aunt" never seems to happen. For some reason, they have to wait until the audience member says their name before the spirits recognise them and remember their names.
As you say, it's beyond me too.
 
One of the very best cold reader "mentalists' and debunker is Derren_BrownWP

He's half-debunker, really. He shares his fair share of mumbo-jumbo in order to make himself seem preternaturally gifted. I know that this has been a point of contention between him and Penn & Teller, even though they are friends.
 
Last edited:
He's half-debunker, really. He shares his fair share of mumbo-jumbo in order to make himself seem preternaturally gifted. I know that this has been a point of contention between him and Penn & Teller, even though they are friends.

It depends whether he’s performing or not. On stage, yes, he uses misdirection regarding what he’s doing; off stage, he states he just uses conjuring and hypnosis techniques.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom