Homoeopaths say the darndest things

From Kaviraj on Hpathy:
Astro wrote:
yet at the same time things like polio have been nearly wiped out.

That is another propaganda story.
Any time a famine strikes in a third world country, they are being given chickpeas.
A diet consisting mainly of chickpeas will cause a polio epidemic.
Why?
Because Lathyrus sativa, the chickpea, is a homoeopathic remedy for polio.
Why?
Because it has been proven countless times that chickpeas cause polio in the healthy - ALSO WITH THE HOMOEOPATHIC REMEDY IN A PROVING.
It is even called "lathyrism".


There's more further down the thread, including:
As you well know, when a disease is full-blown you are also riddled with virus, right?
Therefore the virus is as much a result as the disease
Result and cause are two different things - right?
So how can they be the same?
That is utter nonsense.
But logic is not your strong point i can see, because you still fall for the fallacy they are the same.

ETA: AstroTheDog's post at the top of page 2 sums it up nicely.
 
Last edited:
If Allopathy is modern medicine, I would say Homoeopathy is post-modern medicine.
Well, "Allopathy" is not actually modern medicine. Allopathy was the mainstream medicine of the time when Hahnemann came up with homeopathy. But of course, that was before we discovered germs.

The Germ Theory of disease quite quickly demolished the theories of allopathy and homeopathy both, replacing them with modern medicine. There are no allopaths today; they accepted the new understanding, since allopathy was based on logic (though with a flawed model of sickness). Homeopathy being illogical and contrary to evidence from the very start, there are still homeopaths today, even though science comprehensively disproved their notions long ago.
 
It is no wonder that the Nazis were desperate to uncover these amazing homeopathic secrets, and the only way to protect homeopathy and to protect innocent people was for Fritz Donner to find against his own profession.

How else could he keep homeopathy out of Nazi hands?
I'm dying to know why someone would be desperate to keep homeopathy out of the hands and the Nazi's. How would keeping it from the Nazi's protect homeopathy and/or innocent people?

Anyone seeing an angle here I am not?
 
I'm dying to know why someone would be desperate to keep homeopathy out of the hands and the Nazi's. How would keeping it from the Nazi's protect homeopathy and/or innocent people?

Anyone seeing an angle here I am not?

Imagine the horror if the Luftwaffe had loaded their bombers with 30C explosive! It would be more powerul than an atom bomb.

Or if bullets for infantry were made with homeopathic concentrations of gunpowder - the bullets would have gone through tank armour.
 
"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Oh how did we manage to come this far as a specie.
 
I'm dying to know why someone would be desperate to keep homeopathy out of the hands and the Nazi's. How would keeping it from the Nazi's protect homeopathy and/or innocent people?

Anyone seeing an angle here I am not?

Because they would extract the sweat of vikings and dilute it into 1/1 googol (and shake it real good!), and make the jews drink it and it would "cure" their jew-ness and transform them into blond-haired-blue-eyed-vikings whom the nazis would use as soldiers and declare war on France.
No?
 
Bumpity-bump... Because I found this amusing:
http://gimpyblog.wordpress.com/2007...of-ethics-in-leaflet-part-three/#comment-5053 ...

Again, you are confusing the short termism ’science’ of the pharma drug trials, with actual science. Ok a drug produces the short term answer you are misguidedly looking for in trials, but you are forgetting already, the scientific goal of medicine is to cure, not, I repeat, to induce the dependence on drugs, that cause, you guessed it, and please don’t side-step the seriousness of, continuously serious damaging side-effects. Therefore, from the beginning, the whole set up of these drug trials, are philosophically very weak science, i.e. the person develops more illness as a result of all of this laborious chemical tinkering.
Actual scientific medicine, homeopathy, produces curative results consistently!, from rock solid principled philosophical foundations. So instead of trying to get your hold onto that something very particular, you require for ‘absolute’ proof, just try and give a fair hearing, without tripping into total bias, that the homeopathic cures did, no matter how your present logic protests, actually take place. Isn’t this something incredibly celebration worthy and worth true examination, rather than something to run away from?
 
I cannot really make sense of that.
Does it say homeopathy is science and works?
 
Interresting link.
And yes you should establich if there is an effect before looking for explanations.
As far as I recall handwashing was determined to have an effect before germ teori came along.
 
And here's HelenSan commenting on Science-Based Medicine:
Let me ask you this. What do you think you would find if RCTs had 2 control groups? One placebo control group and one do-nothing-at-all group? Would you expect a higher positive outcome in the placebo group than the do-nothing group? Of course you would. That is why the placebo effect is called a placebo *effect.*

Now if a CAM remedy can produce the same positive effect, however small, of a placebo, it is better than doing nothing at all. It would be as good as a placebo. Not as bad as doing nothing at all. See?
 
Because they would extract the sweat of vikings and dilute it into 1/1 googol (and shake it real good!), and make the jews drink it and it would "cure" their jew-ness and transform them into blond-haired-blue-eyed-vikings whom the nazis would use as soldiers and declare war on France.
No?

OK, you win the internet! You at least win the 'best proposed use of homeopathic medicine in a forum' award.

A
 
I think somebody might have devised a homoeopathic pomo generator: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentis...mmentKey:e3fbef02-c6ea-410e-b457-d4755fc73ab0

hmmm, this is a question of western materialism and our reductive ideas about cause and effect. i think about it this way:
1. nothing EXISTS in our world without some kind of description or narrative surrounding it. you could say that all objects and events we can perceive are inextricably embedded in narrative. the main one at issue here is the narrative of technology, a mechanical cause and effect story; very rational. modern medicine is fully immersed in this, except at the edges where it moves towards psychotherapy and various alternative therapies.
2. the body has extremely robust self-healing mechanisms which western medicine isn't equipped to activate. western medicine requires a passive subject, one who is acted upon by medicines, instruments, the expertise of doctors etc, each of these factors playing a part in the narrative of cure.
3. "psychosomatic" illnesses are those which are broadly understood to have imaginary causes, however, all illness has a psychosomatic aspect, even broken limbs exist within the subject's understanding of the situation and have a psychological corollary which can help or hinder their cure. ie, there is always a psychological "reaction" to illness and this can have a profound effect [see the litereature about the use of hypnosis to reduce tissue damage in burn victims].
4. homeopathy could be seen as a way of chaneling and focussing the body's reaction mechanisms through the use of story. there isn't a way that this can be understood using western allopathic paradigms which are generally blind to their own mechanistic narratives and tend to view other narratives as substandard, primitive or bogus. judging homepathic infusions by the same standards as drugs entirely misses the point.
 
I don't know what a "poMo" generator is, but I had to read the word two or three times.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom