Homoeopaths say the darndest things

There's something about that that is just............. wrong! :eek:
 
Yes, she really did say that holding a cup of coffee for two weeks prepares your body for homeopathic remedies. :cool:
questioning homeopath said:
what if the homeopath insists it is the right rememdy but on every dosage it causes aggravations like muscle pains coldness stomach paains. then wat could it mean? a block?

Dr Leela said:
Idiosyncratic reaction of the vital force, oversensitive to remedies, medicinal aggravation.

You could take hald a cup of warm black coffee for two weeks, give your body/vital force a rest from ANY interferences and after a month begin on (accurate, homeopathic) prescriptions again.
...not to mention more from the school of "Make Up Any Old Crap As You Go".

http://www.otherhealth.com/homeopathy-discussion/10406-possible-mental-aggravation.html
 
Last edited:
Interestingly, that's what I thought too, initially. But no. You are thinking far too logically to be a homeopath.

She actually means that you hold the cup - the coffee does its magic through the ceramic/glass/plastic the same way putting a bottle of blank homeopathic pillules next to a bottle of potentised pilules will (slowly) infuse them with whatever it is that makes them work. (Seriously, that's what they think happens.)

Drinking coffee would do something else - instantly antidoting all remedies and potions, apparently. But this is hotly debated! :rolleyes:
 
Interestingly, that's what I thought too, initially. But no. You are thinking far too logically to be a homeopath.

She actually means that you hold the cup - the coffee does its magic through the ceramic/glass/plastic the same way putting a bottle of blank homeopathic pillules next to a bottle of potentised pilules will (slowly) infuse them with whatever it is that makes them work. (Seriously, that's what they think happens.)

Drinking coffee would do something else - instantly antidoting all remedies and potions, apparently. But this is hotly debated! :rolleyes:


Hahnemann had a thing about coffee.
 
That link is quite funny. It starts out just like a sceptical exination of Hahnemann's delusional mind-set, until the author reveals himself as a true believer further down the page, with no sense of irony.

Rolfe.
 
That link is quite funny. It starts out just like a sceptical exination of Hahnemann's delusional mind-set, until the author reveals himself as a true believer further down the page, with no sense of irony.


Being convinced in his mind of the certainty of the theory apparently impelled him to then find 'evidence' for it, no matter how ridiculous. That was my main point. Further, one might say, he showed a peculiar and recurrent tendency to create 'grand theories' upon what is arguably scant evidence.


No kidding. :)
 
Interestingly, that's what I thought too, initially. But no. You are thinking far too logically to be a homeopath.

She actually means that you hold the cup
I don't want to be super picky (but, hey, it's what I do!) but the original text in the post reads "You could take hald a cup of warm black coffee for two weeks".

To me it looks more likely the poster was trying to say "you take half a cup..." (only one mistaken letter and "F" is right next to "D" on the keyboard) than "you take hold a cup..." - cos that means either the sentence doesn't make sense (I'm talking grammar, not medicine now) or she's either missed out the word "of" (as in "take hold of") or accidentally included the word "take" for no reason as well as (at the same time) accidentally substituting the letter "A" for "O" - two letters which are pretty much at the opposite ends of the keyboard.

'Pologies for the derail.

Yuri
 
OK, if you like.

It still exposes yet more bizarre notions that are the basis of homeopathic practice.
 
Okay- if drinking coffee will negate the effects of homeopathy, will a homeopathic dilution of coffee make you ultrasensitive to homeopathic remedies?
 
Okay- if drinking coffee will negate the effects of homeopathy, will a homeopathic dilution of coffee make you ultrasensitive to homeopathic remedies?

I am not sure, the article mentioned/focused on something about coffee internalising disease as opposed to something else with an alchemy name.

It appears that drinking coffee will cause disease, suppress symptoms thereby delay healing, and that the diluted version will do that too.

So the diluted version can be used to control the severity of symptoms which is equal to speed of healing?

"The sicker the better" or somesuch?

I recall Rolfe describing a hypothetical dog being eaten by skin-decease with a homoeopath cheering "it is comming to the surface".
 
It wasn't hypothetical, sadly. Mrs. Badly Shaved Monkey has all the details, including the name of the homoeopath in question.

Rolfe.
 
It wasn't hypothetical, sadly. Mrs. Badly Shaved Monkey has all the details, including the name of the homoeopath in question.

Rolfe.

And I was just feeling so happy.
Now the reality of what scam does kind of put me off.

(guess that is the difference between silly woo, and it's nasty effects in the real world)
 
Actually, I'm just thinking, you may be talking about a different case, one which I only saw as court evidence papers and photographs, but which was much worse. That dog had to be destroyed, while the one Mrs. Badly Shaved Monkey saw eventually got better on its own.

Two different dogs, both real. Two different homoeopaths, both MsRCVS. I'd better stop now, before this turns into more "disparaging remarks against your colleagues", which we're not supposed to make.

Rolfe.
 
I had to gooogle MsRCVS, and you have a point there.
Perhaps you should go forward with the idea of getting acceptance for voodoo vet. :D
 
Alas, more darndest nastiness...
I come from Italy. Nothing exists in my country as regards experience of curing Asperger syndrome with homeopathy. I know there is a lot about this subjects in the US (sites like "The Impossible Cure" etc...)

Anyway, I have a question. I have a 6-year-old-son with AS [Aspergers Syndrome]. Two years ago he was seen by an homeopathy for a problem of enlarges tonsild and sleep apnea. The dyagnosis of AS had not been made at the time, anyway the doctor recommended us to go deep into the matter, as the child showed evident behavioural problems. The child was given first Tub. bov. 200ch; after about two weeks hyperactivity and temper tantrums had lessened. Tub. was repeated after 40 days, but the tonsil problems was not solved, to the doctor gave him Calc. Phos. 30 ch three times a week. After some months, the tonsils become normal-sized. [so the child suffered throat pain all that time] He no longer has had problems with tonsils and his general health during winter has greatly improved. He stopped Calc. Phos. in May 2009. Calcarea has never influenced his behaviour.
Last year he started psychotherapy once a week. He slighlty benefited from this, but he still has several problems at school, refuses to do what he is told, temper tantrums, echolalia, etc... Last January, after reading a lot on the Internet, I gave him Natrium Muriaticum 200 ch for three weks (a dose per week). Then I gave him two weekly doses of Bufo. Finally, after another week, I gave him two weekly doses of Tub. 200ch. [This is knowledge-free self-diagnosis as well]
I hope I have not have a mess with these three remedies. I have given them without going to the doctor because I was not really satisfied by his way of dealng with the matter and I have not had time to find another reliable homeopath.
Anyway, my son has not improved; insetead, echolalia and oppositional-defian behaviour has got worse. [please note...] Maybe the remedies have nothing to do with this, [unfortunately this blinding flash of the obvious will not lead to an equally obvious conclusion] anyway is there anyone who can give me advice? Thank you very much.
http://www.otherhealth.com/children-parenthood/11107-aspergers-homeopathy.html
 
Re: Coffee. This one from a US poster:
I've heard from some sources that it's okay to drink coffee so long as you wait a couple of hours before taking your remedy. While I've had success when using low potency doses for minor problems despite the fact that I've had a cup of coffee, is it critical to stop drinking it when taking a higher potency for chronic conditions? What happens if you live in a household where the coffee pot is almost always on so that you are smelling it almost all the time?

Is there anything else that should be avoided during treatment? I don't want to bother taking a remedy if I'm only going to antidote it before it's had a chance to work.
http://www.otherhealth.com/homeopathy-discussion/11108-drinking-coffee-while-using-remedies.html

See also the current posts in the UK Parliament Homeopathy Inquiry thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom