Homoeopaths say the darndest things

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Your argument is t[/font][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']he so-called well-designed studies (the studies you have, and confirm to your scientific standards) must be satisfied by homoeopathy if it want scientific recognition. [/font][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Homoeopathy lacks a metaphysical model of understanding pathogenesis and as such have failed to come up with a model that could be used for research. In order for research to establish the viability of homoeopathy a model must be proposed, researched, refined and established, and validated over time. With the model it can also be used for diagnosis, evaluation and cure. But what to do now till the time we came up with the model? [/font][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']How does the scientific method begin to address that? That is, basically quite simple: Apply the modality, and see if there is an effect. In other words, do the patients get better, or don't they? [/font]

Is there a homeopathic remedy for the inability to use tags?
 
Here we go! Dr. MAS at his finest!

For those who know homeopathy dilution nomenclature, please sit before reading:

1st succession 1:100 = 1C
2nd succession 1:100 = 2C
3rd succession 1:100 = 3C
4th succession 1:100 = 4C
5th succession 1:100 = 5C
6th succession 1:100 = 6C

7th succession in water and dilution = 30C
8th succession in dilution = 200C

9th succession in dilution = 1M
10th succession in dilution = 10M
11th succession in dilution = 50M
12th succession in dilution = CM
 
[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Your argument is t[/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']he so-called well-designed studies (the studies you have, and confirm to your scientific standards) must be satisfied by homoeopathy if it want scientific recognition. [/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']Homoeopathy lacks a metaphysical model of understanding pathogenesis and as such have failed to come up with a model that could be used for research. In order for research to establish the viability of homoeopathy a model must be proposed, researched, refined and established, and validated over time. With the model it can also be used for diagnosis, evaluation and cure. But what to do now till the time we came up with the model? [/FONT][FONT='Arial','sans-serif']How does the scientific method begin to address that? That is, basically quite simple: Apply the modality, and see if there is an effect. In other words, do the patients get better, or don't they? [/FONT]


Quite a good submission to the thread.

Homoeopathy, being based on vitalism, has nothing but a metaphysical model.

How does the scientific method begin to address that? That is, basically quite simple: Apply the modality, and see if there is an effect. In other words, do the patients get better, or don't they?


Precisely. The model doesn't matter. All that is being looked at is whether patients treated with homoeopathy do better than patients not treated with homoeopathy. And the results appear to indicate that they don't.
 
I disagree that Homoeopathy is emerging Science.
It's been around for 200 years. So far, there is no evidence that it does anything at all. Nor do its practitioners follow, on the whole, anything resembling the scientific method.

So, no. No it's not.

It is emerging Science in the sense that its rudiments are being unfolded now. Scientist have started to show that it works in a scientific manner and the whole world is acknowledging its effectiveness.
This is completely untrue.

If Allopathy is modern medicine, I would say Homoeopathy is post-modern medicine.
Ooh, burn! Take that, homeopaths!
 
Last edited:
1st succession 1:100 = 1C
...
6th succession 1:100 = 6C

7th succession in water and dilution = 30C
8th succession in dilution = 200C

9th succession in dilution = 1M
10th succession in dilution = 10M
11th succession in dilution = 50M
12th succession in dilution = CM
So, basically, they're lying? (About this as well as everything else.)
 
Actually, the quote is to show MAS's explanation(!) for why molecules of MT still exist in ultra-molar dilutions. His method is simple - ignore 200 years of homeopathic practice and naming convention, and simply change the names for the levels of dilution. Doing so then forces reality to comply with his own naming convention. :D

Even his fellow-travellers are laughing at him now...
 
Found via Ben Goldacre's Bad Science blog:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZEi8l7p56I
I was entertained hugely by her pseudoscientific reinterpretation of Einstein and string theory, but the analogy of homeopathy being a bomb you threw at your neighbour when his dog pooped in your yard took the biscuit.
Also I like the idea that each of us vibrates, either with a plant, a mineral or an animal.
I believe rebecca vibrates with a bunny.
 
Last edited:
I was entertained hugely by her pseudoscientific reinterpretation of Einstein and string theory...

Speaking of Einstein, is there any field of quackery or woo which has not yet abused his name and fame?
 
Here's another (my emphasis):
Many people don't understand that there are problems with using a placebo if one is evaluating treatment by a homeopath - rather than a specific remedy for a particular condition, which is how conventional medicine works. The homeopath uses the patient's responses to guide further remedy choices which over a course of treatment may potentially benefit the patient. The practitioner can't make proper clinical decisions if they don't know if the patient was using an actual remedy or a placebo because they can't guage what the person was responding to. A pragmatic trial would be a better design in such instances. There is little point in evaluating sub-optimal interventions that bear little semblance to clinical practice.


This is in the context of a suggested trial of individualised homoeopathy against placebo. He appears to be suggesting either that the homoeopath's inability to correctly prescribe for the placebo group would somehow prevent the remedies given to the treatment group working, or that incorrectly prescribed placebos somehow work as well as homoeopathic remedies.

The real brilliance, though, lies in his claim that placebo controlled trials of homoeopathy don't work because, since there is no observable difference between homoeopathy and placebo, the homoeopath can't prescribe correctly.
 
Last edited:
Not actually a homoeopath, but someone expressing a desire to be "considered to be on the same footing" with them:

I have been looking around through other threads and I am finding here that there is a concession that there are modalities that would be considered to be on the same footing as NSIR. These are called 'complimentary', or 'alternative'. So now you just need to get used to the idea that yes there is yet again another 'alternative' method to the mainstream systems of healthcare. If you did that then you wouldn't be so hostile toward me. After all, why is it that reiki or massage would be allowed to exist for what they are and yet NSIR is refused the same?

Tammy Kennedy
Certified NSI Specialist
 
Is there an active homeopathic forum out there worth visiting? I've been banned at Hpathy, Otherhealth is all crickets (one such is named Gina Tyler :roll: ), and the Pakistani NCH forum is mainly gibberish.

Hans
 
I do like Harriet Hall's style.

He is like a child butting into an adult discussion to say “There really is a Tooth Fairy and I can prove it because here’s the money she left me.”


I am so going to steal that.

Rolfe.
 
Here's another:

Back in the 1930s the German government commissioned some rigorous research into the effectiveness of homoeopathy, carried out by homoeopath Fritz Donner, under the supervision of a pharmacologist and an internist. The report itself seems to have disappeared, but the results seem from Donner's later accounts to have been entirely negative, to the extent that homoeopaths appear to get rather upset if the research is mentioned (see, for example, this off-topic rant, provoked by the last paragraph of this article).

Now a homoeopath has come up with an explanation for the results:
It is no wonder that the Nazis were desperate to uncover these amazing homeopathic secrets, and the only way to protect homeopathy and to protect innocent people was for Fritz Donner to find against his own profession.

How else could he keep homeopathy out of Nazi hands?


Naturally, Dana (MPH) has turned up in the comments:
Wow…it makes so much sense that Donner’s report would suggest that there was NOTHING of value in homeopathy as a way to dissuade his Nazi superiors to avoid doing anything with it. I believe that you have correctly interpreted history, especially by noting Donner’s previous history of research on homeopathy and his family’s association with the field.

The fact that Donner never sought to publish his negative research on homeopathy further helps to substantiate your interpretation of history.


Dana's assertion that Donner "never sought to publish his negative research" is not exactly borne out by the sources Young links to, which include a book stating that "A translation of the report written by Donner in 1966 finally appeared in a French journal in 1969" and that Donner wrote a letter to the editor of the journal Allgemeine homoopathische Zeitung describing the results. This information is even included in Young's post that Dana was replying to.
 
Dana continues to be an idiot, especially when cornered by the fact he has yet to answer BSM's question after over a year:
http://scienceblogs.com/terrasig/2009/01/lesson_1_homeopathy_is_not_her_1.php#comment-1361881

I finally realized why you have now changed your question from ANY clinical evidence to now just FOUR different diseases: these are diseases from which you suffer! You are rabid. You are syphilitic (read about the effects of syphilis on the brain, and it is a perfect description of your personality...or is it just a coincidence?).
You can continue to change the goal posts, but your syphilitic blindness won't allow you to see the results. What a pity...
And heck, I previously referred to you evidence of malignant cancer...but THAT wasn't good enough when you change the goal posts (again).
 
We have another winner:

"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Paolo Bellavite, M.D. and Andrea Signorini, M.D., The Emerging Science of Homeopathy: Complexity, Biodynamics, and Nanopharmacology, 2002, pp.68-69

Cited by Dana Ullman on Wikipedia, and spotted by shpalman.

:eye-poppi

Can't wait to read the rest of the thread.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom