Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Originally posted by MRC_Hans
Ah, good, Kumar! I was almost tempted to register a sockpuppet there to answer that nonsense, but they'd just delete my post.

By somebody called val_drjkr:
Now I will state a simple naked eye experiment to prove homoeopathy as a science.

Come, we will go to sea with one kg of sugar with us. Now I will throw this sugar in front of all of you in the sea at particular place and I will collect the sample from that particular place containing the thrown sugar in it.

Now I will send this sample of water to laboratory for detecting sugar in it. After performing several tests, according the Avagadro’s law and molecule detecting tests, the laboratory authority gives the report that the sample sent for test does not contain sugar in it. How lies the science? So homoeopathy believes in truth observed by naked eyes only. An observing eye does not need any Laboratory to detect the truth. Many, many years after the time will come that these scientists will become successful in inventing that acute machine which will detect the sugar in the sample provided by me. Then they will have to admit the dynamic existence of homoeopathic drugs. Till then we will have to say that homoeopathy is more an art of healing than a science.

Ye olde sugar in the ocean nonsense. OK let's pick this one apart once and for all:

If you put a kg of sugar into the ocean, the ocean contains a (at least) kg of sugar, period. Science does not deny or refute this. What science DOES say is that once that sugar is distributed over the ocean, the probability that a molecule of it is present in "ONE SAMPLE" is low. But if you somehow analyzed the whole ocean, you would find all your sugar (unless some micro-organisms had eaten it in the mean-time, of course).

However, this has NOTHING WHATSOEVER to do with the way homeoathic drugs are prepared, because here, the major part of the solution is discarded at each step, so that at each step, most of the original substance is REMOVED from the sample.
There's an even simpler explanation than this. If you dump a bag of sugar in the ocean and scoop up a cup of water from the spot you dumped it, you won't find any sugar because it will sink ;)
 
Mr.Hans,

Many many thanks. Done much hard work. You could only handle such a big mess. I read this news paper several times but could not understand any logic behind it. This only made me irritated & furthur aggravation. No one had said a single apprecition word inspite of his big claims. I was thinking to mention much more, but it was his so many year's earning-as he indicated. But I think it is JUST a ???? i can't slect the word. However your reply is worth mentioning there.

It he would have said if we pass electricity in sea water, it would have made some example( as energy), but sugar??? it is just...He has just given chance to others to show -what the hom.remedy is? He even mentioned it as an experiment, not an example--whereas it is not even eligible for example. What more to say--he tells, he is very senier & from my ********.
 
I wonder if the Hpathethics would post a Rolfe post just to poke fun and discredit the post? But then they confused the identity with Hans. One of these days when I'm really bored (maybe in 15 years) I might try going on one of the nard boards.

Hmm, maybe I should sign on just to get banned, that shouldn't take long. Maybe I'll go in an earthy/fairy name of some sort. Anyway, have to get back to work-thanks you for the posts on this page Rolfe and Hans, and even Kumar. Interesting lunch time reading.

Eos
 
Kumar said:
I read this news paper several times but could not understand any logic behind it. This only made me irritated & furthur aggravation. No one had said a single apprecition word inspite of his big claims. I was thinking to mention much more, but it was his so many year's (l)earning-as he indicated. But I think it is JUST a ???? i can't slect the word.
Hmm, I can think of a few. Most of which are on the banned list.

Kumar, good for you for reading it so carefully, and good for Hans too. I read it quickly, for a laugh, but addressing it point by point takes work.

The reason you cannot understand any logic behind it is that there is none. You yourself made some excellent observations, and in case you didn't see them, you received some very favourable comments from people on this forum for your replies. I'm only sorry Naturalhealth ignored and (deliberately?) misunderstood your points so blatantly, and "Humble", a newbie, was inexcusably rude to you. Then you were banned. This was not nice, and they should be ashamed of themselves.

In case anyone hasn't read it, here is what Kumar himself observed, I think the post for which he was banned....
You didn't get the sample tested. If sample is collected just immediately after sugar thrown in sea water from the same place where sugar is thrown-there is probability of getting its effect in sample testing ( along with its reaction with sea water if any) as its quantitative existance . But if its molecules are dispersed in sea, then you may not get any molecule at a particular place. But it does not mean sugar molecule's quantitative existance are not present in sea as a whole inspite of the fact that these may not be present at one particular place. Eg. if a bunch of flower in thrown in sea water & if a bucket of sea water is taken- it may or may not contain any flower. It does not mean its quantitative existance is not there in sea water as a whole.
Kumar, this is sensible, it is well-written, and it is well-argued. It also gets straight to the heart of the matter. If you write like this on this forum you will gain much respect.

Yes. If you throw the sugar in the sea, then immediately take a sample from that spot, of course you will get sugar. But if you take the sample only a minute later, from the other side of the ocean, of course you will not get sugar in it - even though it is all part of the same body of water. Such a large amount of water isn't uniform, and substances take a while to mix and disperse. If you come back a year later and sample from the spot where the sugar was thrown, perhaps there will be none in the sample. Not because there's none in the sea, but because there is a finite number of molecules in 1 kg of sugar, and they may well all be elsewhere by the time you came back (including metabolised by sea creatures, but that's another story - you could do the same "thought experiment" with a stable, indigestible substance if you wanted to, so let's assume that the sea creatures aren't feeling hungry).

If I've got this right, sugar (sucrose) has a molecular weight of 364 daltons. That means a mole (Avogadro's number) of sugar weighs 364 grammes. Therefore there are about 2.75 moles of sugar molecules in a kilogramme. That is 16.54 x 10 <SUP>23</SUP> molecules, or
1,653,846,100,000,000,000,000,000 molecules. Approximately.

Now if someone will only tell me the volume of water in all the world's oceans, we can work out the probability of getting one molecule in a sample of say (to make it easy) a litre in volume, once complete mixing has occurred. Yes, you could say that the sugar is "present" in the sea as a whole, but once you have separated out your one-litre sample from the rest, there is no special "presence" of the sugar in that litre in its jug.

That's all there is to it, and Kumar seems to have been the only person on H'pathy bright enough to realise it. What this eminent homoeopath is trying to say is, since we put some of the remedy into the first dilution of the sequence, then of course there must still be some there at the end - you've seen it go in with your own eyes. So if science can't detect this, science must be wrong. He then chooses a false analogy, a system where none of the solution is discarded, to try to trick his readers into agreeing with him. All he succeeds in doing is demonstrating his own ignorance, and lack of understanding of basic molecular theory.

As we all know, and even most homoeopaths know, there is no mysterious "disappearing remedy" to produce mythical white holes or trace energies. The molecules are simply gradually discarded with each successive dilution until there are none left. You could do the same trick yourself very easily with a jug of water with (now I can't think of a suitable substance, but can we imagine marbles of the same specific gravity as water so that they disperse evenly in it?). Say you had 64 marbles. You pour out half the water, and half the marbles go with it. Now you have only 32. You fill the jug up again and mix it. Again you pour out half the water and half the marbles. 16 left. Next time, 8 left. Then 4. Then 2. Then one.

Now where do you go? At the next dilution step, there is a 50% chance the marble will stay, and a 50% chance it will go. Maybe it stays. But you dilute again, again with the same 50% chance. By the fourth or fifth dilution past the one-marble stage, you're pretty much certain to have discarded the marble. And then there were none. Nothing can bring the marbles back if all you do is keep topping up with water. And all you have is water.

This is so simple a concept, so childish almost, that I'm embarrassed to explain it. It was a real shock to me that there were some homoeopaths who just didn't understand this simple concept, and would invent strange theories and even stranger analogies to complicate what is a very straightforward process.

No mysterious energies, no white holes, and honestly, no bits of marbles. Stable molecules don't split easily, and stable atoms, fortunately, take an enormous amount of energy to get them to split. All there is in the final remedy is water, and there is no mystical connection of the water to the molecules it no longer contains.

Then you drop some of that on a sugar pill and let it evaporate.

Kumar, you say the person who posted this is very senior and has many years of learning. Or he says he does. This matters nothing if his learning is false, and his understanding is faulty. You were able to see how his reasoning was at fault, therefore you are the better thinker on that matter. You were right, and the people on H'pathy were too closed-minded to see it.

A lot of what is said on H'pathy is just as silly as this sea-water stuff. In fact more so. If it doesn't seem to make sense to you, then maybe it isn't sense. Congratulations.

Now, you came here saying that you were convinced that homoeopathic remedies had a biological effect, and the only mysterious part was how. You can see why there is a problem with that.

But we start earlier. We want to talk about whether there is any effect there in the first place. We've talked quite a lot about it on this thread already. Are you prepared to go back a step and open your mind a bit more, and examine whether the effect you think you see is real, or whether you could be mistaking coincidence and wishful thinking for effect?

Rolfe.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Here

Seems I get all the credit. But then they hardly know you over there ;).
More fun. After that single post (which said stuff I've said, but in very few words (for me) and with no specific detail), Bach attacked by answering a different question based on the assumption that the controlled trial is a poor tool for examining homoeopathy, val_drjkr said something completely woo-woo in line with the drivel we've just been discussing, Divina was rude (no change there then), someone called "Fopper", also a first post, asked them to address the question (of why there are no positive controlled trials for homoeopathy), and JanZy said Rolfe deserved no answer as he had given no details of the negative studies he referred to (completely ignoring the multiple threads also in that forum where the studies were cited and linked to in detail and the homoeopaths beseeched to come and have their say...), closed the thread to further discussion, and banned both "Rolfe" and Fopper before either could post a second time.

Totally mysterious. Would anyone here care to admit to being either Rolfe or Fopper, since it sure as hell wasn't me?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
If I've got this right, sugar (sucrose) has a molecular weight of 364 daltons. That means a mole (Avogadro's number) of sugar weighs 364 grammes. Therefore there are about 2.75 moles of sugar molecules in a kilogramme. That is 16.54 x 10 <SUP>23</SUP> molecules, or
1,653,846,100,000,000,000,000,000 molecules. Approximately.

Hey I just worked it out by geometry based on a vaguely remembered figure that the world's oceans are an average of 2 miles deep and cover 2/3 of the Earth's surface (Radius= roughly 4000miles. Area 4piR<sup>2</sup>)= 1.1x10^21 litres

Googled and came up with 1.37x10^21 litres (http://www.geocities.com/ultrastupidneal/Knowledge-Geography-World-Ocean.html). Ain't that cool.

So you would have about 100 molecules per litre.
 
Rolfe said:
More fun. After that single post (which said stuff I've said, but in very few words (for me) and with no specific detail), Bach attacked by answering a different question based on the assumption that the controlled trial is a poor tool for examining homoeopathy, val_drjkr said something completely woo-woo in line with the drivel we've just been discussing, Divina was rude (no change there then), someone called "Fopper", also a first post, asked them to address the question (of why there are no positive controlled trials for homoeopathy), and JanZy said Rolfe deserved no answer as he had given no details of the negative studies he referred to (completely ignoring the multiple threads also in that forum where the studies were cited and linked to in detail and the homoeopaths beseeched to come and have their say...), closed the thread to further discussion, and banned both "Rolfe" and Fopper before either could post a second time.

Totally mysterious. Would anyone here care to admit to being either Rolfe or Fopper, since it sure as hell wasn't me?

Rolfe.

That whole thread just makes them look like frickin' weirdos, so what's new.
 
Hmmm, I'm on a small roll here, so bear with me.

We've just been through why there are no molecules in the finished homoeopathic remedies. Very simple process. A finite number of molecules are there to start with, and they are gradually thrown away with the discards until there are none left. The only "special" thing about the water is that it was once in contact with the remedy. Or in contact with some water that was once in contact with the remedy, if you go on diluting long enough!

Is this "special"?

This touches on a very old belief among humans, that things which were once in contact retain influence on each other even after they are separated. It is found in almost all cultures and through many different time periods. It is one of the things studied in depth by anthropologists, who call it "contagious magic".

It is one half of a system collectively known as "sympathetic magic". The other half of the system is sometimes known as imitative magic, and is briefly described as "like affects like". Anthropologists even use the phrase similia similibus to describe these practices. The person who first described and codified this type of magical belief (Sir James George Frazer) actually called this practice "homoeopathic magic", for reasons which you may well take a guess at.

If you want to read Frazer's original treatise on the subject, you can find it here.

Anthropologists believe that these ancient beliefs are in some way "hard-wired" into the human brain, and represent a primitive form of reasoning, active and useful before the more useful cause-and-effect reasoning came to be dominant. We have a deep-seated inclination to believe that like affects like, and that things that have once in contact with each other continue to influence each other even after they are separated.

But are such beliefs true? You only have to go through Frazer's meticulous description of the very many forms of sympathetic magic to be found in primitive societies to realise that the answer is no. This is essentially superstition, like not walking under a ladder, or throwing salt over your left shoulder. We know it's nonsense, but we still feel the impulse to comply.

So, is this part of the reason homoeopathic beliefs are so tenuous (OK, BSM, I meant "tenacious"!) even in the absense of any objective evidence for their validity? Like affects like. Similia similibus curentur. Imitative magic, very clearly and explicitly. And the molecules that were once in contact with the water continue to affect it even though they were thrown down the drain months ago. Contagious magic. Both halves of sympathetic magic neatly wrapped up in one package.

(It has been pointed out that voodoo is very similar - the doll is similar to the subject, similia similibus, and the ousia is a part of the subject's body or an intimate possession which is incorporated into the doll for greater effect, that is it includes something which was once in contact with the subject.)

I often puzzle as to why homoeopathic beliefs survive, and even educated people who should know better are drawn in and completely swallowed by the whole thing. Could it be that they are obeying the same part of the brain that makes us not walk under ladders, or (where I come from) insist on leaving a house by the same door we entered by, or avoid crossing with another person on the stairs? We're hard-wired to be inclined to think by the laws of similarity and contagion, and some people are a little bit harder wired than others?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
So, is this part of the reason homoeopathic beliefs are so tenuous even in the absense of any objective evidence for their validity?

We think it's 'tenuous'. Did you mean to write 'tenacious'?
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Googled and came up with 1.37x10^21 litres (http://www.geocities.com/ultrastupidneal/Knowledge-Geography-World-Ocean.html). Ain't that cool.

So you would have about 100 molecules per litre.
Gosh. Wow! :eek: :eek:

So the great and mighty woo-woo was totally wrong! even assuming you had perfect mixing, and also assuming all the sugar stays in solution and isn't metabolised, you still end up with an appreciable amount in solution. One molecule, on average, in a 10 ml sample. Even a 1 ml sample still has a 10% chance of having a molecule in it.

(Trying frantically to convert 100 molecules/litre to a molar concentration, bear with me here....)

1 mole/litre is 602,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 molecules in a litre.

602 molecules in a litre would be 1 zeptomole/litre, 0.6 molecules in a litre would be 1 yactomole/litre (special thanks to _Q_ for this, in a thread from last December).

So I guess 100 molecules per litre is 0.166 zeptomoles/litre, or 166 yactomoles/litre.

OK, this would be a tad tricky to detect. I usually measure glucose at about the mmol/litre range. Of course this is because that's the level it is in the blood, and I know that there are assays for trace substances that can get down to femtomoles (10<SUP> -15</SUP>) or even attomoles (10<SUP> -18</SUP>) per litre. Four more orders of magnitude further than that is a difficult one. On the other hand, if one is theoretically allowed to evaporate away this water until there's only about 10 microlitres left, with an incredibly sensitive probe or assay, well, theoretically I'd have to say it's possible. We're not at the no-marble jug stage quite yet. For a one-litre jug, we'd need the waters of ten earths all combined!

This is an interesting subject for contemplation. Even a single kilo of sugar, in all the world's oceans, and on average you'd still expect a molecule to be there if you took a 100 ml sample. Reminds us of the true magnitude of the real homoeopathic potencies like 30C. People throw around lines like "all the world's oceans" and "a container of water 30 times the volume of the earth" or "the volume of the known universe", but sometimes its just words.

You're already at the 10 ml of seawater having one molecule in it by the time you get to 12C. That's less than half way to 30C, and these dilutions are exponential.

It's either magic or malarkey. I know which I think.

Rolfe.
 
Hi, I'm new, don't mind me, just making an observation on Olaf's "100,000s of doctors"...

Reminds me of a line from that Adam Sandler song about Thanksgiving.::

"Fifty million Elvis fans can't be wrong..."

Think about it...

Then think about this: I have to admit, I actually think there's a possibility that SOME of the Woo-woo theories might have SOME sort of basis that may, ONE DAY, be discovered to be real (slim chance, but I'm willing to entertain the thought until someone disproves it to me)... but this? This is offensive even to that lovely insane bit of me that thinks crystals have auras and souls reincarnate infinitely. How awful is it that even someone willing to tolerate the idea of 'alternate realities' can't accept the idea of homeopathy?? In fact, the moment I mention to ANY of my full-on, Tarot-reading, astral-projecting associates the fact that homeopathy consists of water or sugar pills WITH ABSOLUTELY NOTHING ELSE IN THEM, they quickly come to their senses and run back to their herbs, acupuncture, and aural chakra healing crystals... Pretty sad situation for the homeopaths, no?

I wrote an e-mail to a couple of manufacturer's websites, asking a few of the same question that NH/HS has rigidly avoided. The first refused to answer any questions at all, and redirected me to Homeopathy.org... who are not answering emails until the 20th on the grounds of some national conference. The second gave me much the same garbage answer about using 'reverse osmosis, triple-filtration water of the highest purity' to which I wrote back, "You mean, like Dasani and other popular bottled waters?" No response, as I expected.

I wonder, does Penta water have an effect on the homeopathic remedies, or vice-versa? Or, to put it another way, if you breed two imaginary giant rabbits, what will you get?

he he he he he

Anyway, looks like I'll have fun here - I love the rigorous and thorough debunking you folks regularly offer to those of ill sense and reason. Please, keep it up!
 
The reason you cannot understand any logic behind it is that there is none. You yourself made some excellent observations,
Hello Rolfe,

Frankly, my observations were common, just a common logic. I thought there may be some science in it & therefore asked from you- well qualified to understand this story. May be, My intention was to to know that was it my mistake or not? But if you say so then I am convinced. Every thing is getting banned what is posted by him & at 'Scientific Research in Homeopathy' Forum., there. Anyway, Thanks for presenting such a nice truth word by word. Probably, I am now going parlell with you.

Btw, what is this-- 100 molecules per liter?;) Badly Shaved Monkey, thanks for the working. However, it is accepted by all that there can be no material(atomic or molecular) existance above 12C or 24X potency as per A. Law. One more thing: suppose we pass electricity through the water, or apply heat or any other form of energy--Will it leave any effect on quality of water ( obiously after it cools down or settled)?

"Contagious magic" belief of Sir Frazer is quite intresting. I shall try to find some logic. It can be true belief. I again come here probably due to "Contagious magic/effect".:D


:D
 
Kumar/vijay,

Perhaps you would like to read two books. The first is called A Companion to Homeopathic Studies and the other is called A New Physics of Homeopathy. Both books are buy Dr Colin B Lessel and are recent. He is a doctor, a dentist and is also a dental homeopath with the Faculty of Homeopathy.

These two books should be able to answer all of the questions that you pose. I have just finished reading both of them and they offer very full and clear explanations. He is a scientist too, so remember that.

Also, you don't need to use pure water to make remedies. Hahnemann did not. The reason the homeopathic pharmacies use nuclear grade water is that it is available. Hahnemman himself never used it, so it really makes no difference.

Also, there is no requirement either that one must use alcohol in making remedies either. A lot of the remedies are still just made using water. Vodka is used if it is needed. It helps the remedies last longer, especially the liquid remedies that we use, but is not a requirement.

Lots of people of Hanemann's day were told to read the Organon and then discredit it. People such as Hering did this, but then continued on as homeopaths and then went onto prove remedies, as Hering also did. He proved a lot of the snake remedies.

'A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it'. (Max Planck)
 
Kumar said:
Btw, what is this-- 100 molecules per liter?;) Badly Shaved Monkey, thanks for the working. However, it is accepted by all that there can be no material(atomic or molecular) existance above 12C or 24X potency as per A. Law

Errr..it's to do with the volume Kumar. If there 100molecules in 1 litre and you take a 1ml sample there is roughly a 1 in 10 chance of getting 1 molecule (someone else might wish to work out the proper binomial probability for 1 molecule when p=0.1). If you take 0.1ml then there is only a 1 in 100 chance of having a molecule in your sample.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Kumar/vijay,

Perhaps you would like to read two books. The first is called A Companion to Homeopathic Studies and the other is called A New Physics of Homeopathy. Both books are buy Dr Colin B Lessel and are recent. He is a doctor, a dentist and is also a dental homeopath with the Faculty of Homeopathy.

These two books should be able to answer all of the questions that you pose. I have just finished reading both of them and they offer very full and clear explanations. He is a scientist too, so remember that.

Also, you don't need to use pure water to make remedies. Hahnemann did not. The reason the homeopathic pharmacies use nuclear grade water is that it is available. Hahnemman himself never used it, so it really makes no difference.
So why do they do it and why did you paade it for us if not for some pretence of extra scientificness?

...
Lots of people of Hanemann's day were told to read the Organon and then discredit it.

We've done that. See Hans' site for a good example (http://www.hans-egebo.dk/Skeptic/).

People such as Hering did this, but then continued on as homeopaths and then went onto prove remedies, as Hering also did.


You can take the woo to water but you can't make him think. Becoming a homeopath rather detracts from their credibility

...
'A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it'. (Max Planck)


Of course homeopathy did nearly die out and certainly has no general respectability. The new generation does need to be right or it will just carry on as a fringe of crank ideas- as we see. If in addition to the Faculty of Homeopathy you also wish to join the Flat Earth Society then follow the link to read more. http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/flatearth.html

While the subject of ther fringe beliefs has come up and we have at least two homeopaths contributing at the moment, I would very much like to hear their views on otehr alt med therapies: crystals, psychic surgery, reflexology etc. What limits are there to what you will believe in? How outlandish does the therapy have to be before you dismiss it as nonsense? It would be very interesting for you to cite a specific example of a therapy that you dismiss as unfounded and explain why you have reached that conclusion.
 
I'd personally more readily believe in crystals, herbology, acupressure/acupuncture, and chakra healing than I do in this utter and complete foolishness. At least with crystals, you can demonstrate (in some cases) that crystals react in unusual ways when exposed to radiation, electricity, etc (not that this justifies crystal healing, but it does suggest that, sometime in our future, we'll be getting some interesting revelations about crystals). Herbs at least actually contain chemical compounds that promote some kinds of healing (although, I'd definitely argue that extracted and purified compounds should have more effect than those that occur naturally)... and so on and so forth.

I am willing to place some faith in any New Age concept, as long as the concept at least includes plausible theories and doesn't contradict existing science. Homeopathy? No plausible theory - the theories don't even mesh with common sense, much less existing sciences.

Homeoskeptic, I also would love to know what other alt-meds you support, and what you don't. Likewise, I'd be curious on your take of other paranormal phenomenon, such as translocation, astral projection, reincarnation, ectoplasmic manifestation, et. al.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
No. Not at all.

Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. I never wrote anything about the fact that homeopathy could cure Turner's Syndrome. This is you reading what you want to into my post.

Read it again. It did not say anything about curing Turner's Syndrome.
Thanks for the info! Now I can tell my girlfriend that she doesn't need to waste a second of her time with homeopathy.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Kumar/vijay,

Perhaps you would like to read two books...


Thanks. You understand me. I will get these. Btw, do these books give chemical analysis(ash analysis) of raw substance of organic based remedies.

Also, you don't need to use pure water to make remedies. Hahnemann did not. The reason the homeopathic pharmacies use nuclear grade water is that it is available. Hahnemman himself never used it, so it really makes no difference.

I am bit understanding this point. Can you exapand it for me pls? Btw, suppose we put some distilled water on any unconsious person--will the effect be the similar if we put common water?

Also, there is no requirement either that one must use alcohol in making remedies either. A lot of the remedies are still just made using water. Vodka is used if it is needed. It helps the remedies last longer, especially the liquid remedies that we use, but is not a requirement.

Be consicious. Just think about other chemical constituents in ordinary water & Vodka?.

"Lots of people of Hanemann's day were told to read the Organon and then discredit it. People such as Hering did this, but then continued on as homeopaths and then went onto prove remedies, as Hering also did. He proved a lot of the snake remedies."

I felt both discouraged & encouraged to see This. 65% for revised edition!! Snake remedies are bit hetrogenous.

'A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it'. (Max Planck)

It is ok, I feel bit sorry for In house, non clearences. But suppressions are to be treated in homeopathic sense. It is bit aggravation of same, bit serious, may effect but benificial to most. It is not good time there. Biochemic system do not favour injustice- as directly & the only indicated by 'HIM', mostly.

Regards.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom