Kumar said:
I read this news paper several times but could not understand any logic behind it. This only made me irritated & furthur aggravation. No one had said a single apprecition word inspite of his big claims. I was thinking to mention much more, but it was his so many year's (l)earning-as he indicated. But I think it is JUST a ???? i can't slect the word.
Hmm, I can think of a few. Most of which are on the banned list.
Kumar, good for you for reading it so carefully, and good for Hans too. I read it quickly, for a laugh, but addressing it point by point takes work.
The reason you cannot understand any logic behind it is that there is none. You yourself made some excellent observations, and in case you didn't see them, you received some very favourable comments from people on this forum for your replies. I'm only sorry Naturalhealth ignored and (deliberately?) misunderstood your points so blatantly, and "Humble", a newbie, was inexcusably rude to you. Then you were banned. This was not nice, and they should be ashamed of themselves.
In case anyone hasn't read it, here is what Kumar himself observed, I think the post for which he was banned....
You didn't get the sample tested. If sample is collected just immediately after sugar thrown in sea water from the same place where sugar is thrown-there is probability of getting its effect in sample testing ( along with its reaction with sea water if any) as its quantitative existance . But if its molecules are dispersed in sea, then you may not get any molecule at a particular place. But it does not mean sugar molecule's quantitative existance are not present in sea as a whole inspite of the fact that these may not be present at one particular place. Eg. if a bunch of flower in thrown in sea water & if a bucket of sea water is taken- it may or may not contain any flower. It does not mean its quantitative existance is not there in sea water as a whole.
Kumar, this is sensible, it is well-written, and it is well-argued. It also gets straight to the heart of the matter. If you write like this on this forum you will gain much respect.
Yes. If you throw the sugar in the sea, then immediately take a sample from that spot, of course you will get sugar. But if you take the sample only a minute later, from the other side of the ocean, of course you will not get sugar in it - even though it is all part of the same body of water. Such a large amount of water isn't uniform, and substances take a while to mix and disperse. If you come back a year later and sample from the spot where the sugar was thrown, perhaps there will be none in the sample. Not because there's none in the sea, but because there is a finite number of molecules in 1 kg of sugar, and they may well all be elsewhere by the time you came back (including metabolised by sea creatures, but that's another story - you could do the same "thought experiment" with a stable, indigestible substance if you wanted to, so let's assume that the sea creatures aren't feeling hungry).
If I've got this right, sugar (sucrose) has a molecular weight of 364 daltons. That means a mole (Avogadro's number) of sugar weighs 364 grammes. Therefore there are about 2.75 moles of sugar molecules in a kilogramme. That is 16.54 x 10 <SUP>23</SUP> molecules, or
1,653,846,100,000,000,000,000,000 molecules. Approximately.
Now if someone will only tell me the volume of water in all the world's oceans, we can work out the probability of getting one molecule in a sample of say (to make it easy) a litre in volume, once complete mixing has occurred. Yes, you could say that the sugar is "present" in the sea as a whole, but once you have separated out your one-litre sample from the rest, there is no special "presence" of the sugar in that litre in its jug.
That's all there is to it, and Kumar seems to have been the only person on H'pathy bright enough to realise it. What this eminent homoeopath is trying to say is, since we put some of the remedy into the first dilution of the sequence, then of course there must still be some there at the end - you've seen it go in with your own eyes. So if science can't detect this, science must be wrong. He then chooses a false analogy, a system where none of the solution is discarded, to try to trick his readers into agreeing with him. All he succeeds in doing is demonstrating his own ignorance, and lack of understanding of basic molecular theory.
As we all know, and even most homoeopaths know, there is no mysterious "disappearing remedy" to produce mythical white holes or trace energies. The molecules are simply gradually discarded with each successive dilution until there are none left. You could do the same trick yourself very easily with a jug of water with (now I can't think of a suitable substance, but can we imagine marbles of the same specific gravity as water so that they disperse evenly in it?). Say you had 64 marbles. You pour out half the water, and half the marbles go with it. Now you have only 32. You fill the jug up again and mix it. Again you pour out half the water and half the marbles. 16 left. Next time, 8 left. Then 4. Then 2. Then one.
Now where do you go? At the next dilution step, there is a 50% chance the marble will stay, and a 50% chance it will go. Maybe it stays. But you dilute again, again with the same 50% chance. By the fourth or fifth dilution past the one-marble stage, you're pretty much certain to have discarded the marble. And then there were none. Nothing can bring the marbles back if all you do is keep topping up with water. And all you have is water.
This is so simple a concept, so childish almost, that I'm embarrassed to explain it. It was a real shock to me that there were some homoeopaths who just didn't understand this simple concept, and would invent strange theories and even stranger analogies to complicate what is a very straightforward process.
No mysterious energies, no white holes, and honestly, no bits of marbles. Stable molecules don't split easily, and stable atoms, fortunately, take an enormous amount of energy to get them to split. All there is in the final remedy is water, and there is no mystical connection of the water to the molecules it no longer contains.
Then you drop some of that on a sugar pill and let it evaporate.
Kumar, you say the person who posted this is very senior and has many years of learning. Or he says he does. This matters nothing if his learning is false, and his understanding is faulty. You were able to see how his reasoning was at fault, therefore you are the better thinker on that matter. You were right, and the people on H'pathy were too closed-minded to see it.
A lot of what is said on H'pathy is just as silly as this sea-water stuff. In fact more so. If it doesn't seem to make sense to you, then maybe it isn't sense. Congratulations.
Now, you came here saying that you were convinced that homoeopathic remedies had a biological effect, and the only mysterious part was how. You can see why there is a problem with that.
But we start earlier. We want to talk about whether there is any effect there in the first place. We've talked quite a lot about it on this thread already. Are you prepared to go back a step and open your mind a bit more, and examine whether the effect you think you see is real, or whether you could be mistaking coincidence and wishful thinking for effect?
Rolfe.