Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Mmm, the whole business is supposed to turn over 1 billion EUro per annum. One pack (80) of 30C pills is appr. 6 Euro. That's 167 million packs (:eek:). If we assume each stage (30) uses 0.005 litre, we get 25 million litres of water! Of course, this may be a couple of magnitudes off, still............

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
If we assume each stage (30) uses 0.005 litre, we get 25 million litres of water! Of course, this may be a couple of magnitudes off, still............
Yes, but you don't have to repeat the process from scratch for every pack. You can get pretty much as much as you want simply by keeping more (or all) of the n-1 dilution and creating a large volume of the final potency.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
Yes, but you don't have to repeat the process from scratch for every pack. You can get pretty much as much as you want simply by keeping more (or all) of the n-1 dilution and creating a large volume of the final potency.

Rolfe.

Are you sure about that in "classical homeopathy"? :rolleyes: (the only legitmate use of rolleyes ever).

I thought I read once that Dr H didn't hold with keeping stocks of these toxic substances around?
 
Darat said:


Are you sure about that in "classical homeopathy"? :rolleyes: (the only legitmate use of rolleyes ever).

I thought I read once that Dr H didn't hold with keeping stocks of these toxic substances around?

Most homeopathic pharmercies are not strickly clasical. Most of them use the K method of preperation which isn't strickly clasical (all though it saves a lot of work) and I doubt anything about say 50C is made up by hand (remember 1M is a thousand dilutions. The time that would take to do by hand is simply not posible).
 
Darat said:
Are you sure about that in "classical homeopathy"? :rolleyes: (the only legitmate use of rolleyes ever).

I thought I read once that Dr H didn't hold with keeping stocks of these toxic substances around?
The point is that you can make a large batch of packs all at once from one single run of the dilution. And we don't admit to expiry dates, so it's just a question of storage limitations after that.

I think it's just a logistics calculation to decide whether you keep the mother tinctures and go right up the series every time you need to produce a batch of the product for distribution, or whether you just hold on to the n-1.

Off the top of my head, I think for the big-sale items I'd keep the mother tincture and manufacture a big batch once every so often for distribution to retailers, and for the oddities only requested occasionally I might keep the n-1 dilution and just do the last stage whenever I got an order.

Rolfe.
 
Prester John said:
Quality Control of homeopathic remedies is quite a tricky field :D
I'm betting the process goes something like this:

"Hey, we got four orders for essence of belladonna and three for juniper berries."

"OK, here's seven vials. I'll print up the labels, you fill 'em. Use a clean cup this time, alright?"

Sound of running water...

"Now, box 'em up and send 'em out as soon as the payments clear."

If the preparation is for pills, substitute "Sound of sugar being compressed into tablets" for that running water part...
 
Originally posted by garys_2k
I'm betting the process goes something like this:

"Hey, we got four orders for essence of belladonna and three for juniper berries."

"OK, here's seven vials. I'll print up the labels, you fill 'em. Use a clean cup this time, alright?"

Sound of running water...

"Now, box 'em up and send 'em out as soon as the payments clear."

If the preparation is for pills, substitute "Sound of sugar being compressed into tablets" for that running water part...
Now the question is, who is more unethical here, the pharmaceutical company making its remedies like that, or the homeopath describing stuff he obviously knows is bunk?
 
and a huge problem for homeopathists is how do they know if a pharmacist has just sold them tap water?
 
garys_2k said:
"OK, here's seven vials. I'll print up the labels, you fill 'em. Use a clean cup this time, alright?"

Sound of running water...

"Now, box 'em up and send 'em out as soon as the payments clear."
Obviously time for another link to The Unethical Lab Tech.

Rolfe.
 
Originally posted by Rolfe
Sound of crickets chirping?
And of tumbleweed rolling by as the wind blew around the dust ...
 
Hmm...I was hoping for indignant outrage while blithely refusing to answer any questions.

Crickets and tumbleweed just aren't as much fun as indignant outrage.
 
Well... seems there are a whole lot of crickets in the last bit of posts... I guess the homeopathetics are finally getting tired of dodging the bullets and have crawled back under their rock.

Or perhaps, under a dust molecule, since being so diluted in air, it surely must offer greater protection, yes?

Edit: I just had an idea. The next time a doctor wants to prescribe you a homeopathic remedy, when it comes time to pay the bill, set down a bottle of water and explain that it's a homeopathic remedy of Cuprous Currency 30C - a penny so treated surely is worth a near infinite amount of money at this dilution!
 
zaayrdragon said:
I guess the homeopathetics are finally getting tired of dodging the bullets and have crawled back under their rock.
Well, be fair, not everybody spends every minute on-line.

Now, prediction for when they get back:

O you are so stupid you understand nothing about homeopathy.

O we would always know if we were supplied with a remedy which was not properly potentised.

O you should take a remedy yourself and see the amazing effects it will have.

O I am a real doctor and I have hundreds of patients who prove that HOMEOPATHY WORKS, because after I gave them their correct remedy, something happened.

O you are all so stupid and uneducated and only homeopaths have any intelligence at all.


However, there will still be no evidence presented that a group of people who really do get their properly-potentised prescribed remedy have, on average, a better chance of getting better than a comparable group of people who just got the plain water version.

Neither will there be any concrete protocol described for how one might take a remedy oneself and be sure to notice these all-too-elusive "amazing" effects.

Neither will there be any evidence presented that the poster, or indeed any homoeopath alive, can tell a potentised remedy of their own choice from the plain water version, by any means at all.

Neither will there be any explanation of why the poster, who claims confidently to be able to do this, doesn't seem to want the JREF million, and indeed why, despite there being apparently millions of homoeopaths in the world who are convinced they can do this, nobody has even come forward to give it a shot.

Neither will there be a properly tabulated group of serial cases to allow any sort of judgement on clinical success rates.

Indeed there won't even be a single anecdotal case presented with enough clinical detail to get the faintest idea of what the poster thinks s/he's talking about.

And most particularly, every tricky question from the entire thread will not be dodged, it will simply be serenely ignored. While continuing to rant, O you are all so stupid.... I guess that's where we came in.

Do I get the million for precog abilities when this happens on cue?

Rolfe.
 
Suezoled said:
Hey Rolfe,
can we get the option of " F*ck off, troll" as well?
But where would we be without the woo-woo quacks to liven up the discussion? They may enjoy a diet of everyone singing from the same page in the hymn-book of St. Samuel, but I quite like having a few cat-toys to play with.

Besides, "F*ck off, troll" (ChaChaHeels/Divina's regular retort to any argument she deems uncomfortable for homoeopathy, so as you may imagine it happens a lot) is an instant admission of defeat, and as such is never to be used by any member in good standing of the anti-homeopathy illuminati.

So there.

Rolfe.
 
Sorry Rolfe. I misunderstood. I thought it was the next thing a homeopath would say when they get back here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom