Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

olaf said:
let it be known here and now that i am looking over your shoulder from now until doomsday. there is no escape; i am your shadow. everything you say will be put under the microscope. welcome to your worst nightmare. :D
Oh wow!

Have a nice life.

Rolfe.
 
He was talking about treatment length and I was talking about a remedy response. No patient that I have ever treated has taken that long to respond to a remedy. I normally get a response at least within a week with the longest that I have had to wait being 2 weeks.

I see, so when you say that a remedy "works", you don't mean "works" in the sense that your patient is cured, or even that his/her symptoms are relieved. By "work" you're referring to the patient showing some sort of reaction, be it good or bad. So if a patient actually feels worse after they are given a remedy, this still means that the remedy is "working" in that the patient is reacting to the remedy in the form of an "aggravation", correct? Not a side effect, oh no... bite my tongue... that's something different altogether.

A patient's condition can deteriorate for periods of as long as nearly a month after the remedy is given, and this is STILL a sure-fire sign that the remedy is "working", correct?

http://www.vithoulkas.com/library_EN/research/research04.html

A very long period of aggravation in the beginning of the treatment (even more than four weeks in some cases) if the remedy was correct.
So, a prolonged period of aggravation, that is to say a worsening of a patients symptoms, is actually a sign that a remedy is "working" correctly? Now, if a patient experienced an immediate lessening of their symptoms after being treated, would that indicate that the remedy is not working?

Or do you get to have your cake and eat it to?
 
Kumar said:
I was not expecting but you learnt a lot about homeopathy. I have to be bit more prepared. Your posting has really impressed me & probably to all including HS. I do agree that whatever you have mentioned is not completely wrong. Actually, I studied very deeply- the biochemic system/cell salts or Tissue remedies. If you remember I gifted to you all as 'New Year Gift'. I don't know whether you have yet opened the gift box or not. ;)
Kumar, I knew all that about homoeopathy when we conversed before. If I have managed to express it better, then I have this forum to thank for helping me improve my debating skills.

I have learned more about you though, from reading your posts on the homoeopathy forums. I can see that you're sincere, and genuinely trying to understand. I can also see that you are sometimes frustrated by other people's responses. Here, your frustration is because most people will not accept that "it works" (for any definition of "it") simply because a lot of people think that it does. No matter how apparently convincing their experiences were to them. In the homoeopathy forums, you are obviously frustrated because whenever you try a line of thinking which you perceive to be logical, but which the homoeopaths believe to be heretical, they turn on you and call you names rather than trying to address your points.

Nobody here will ever turn on you for trying to think clearly, or for saying straightforwardly what your opinion is. You were only roughed up last time because you posted cryptic questions with hidden agendas. "Does rubbing and grinding produce potential energy?" - that one obviously about potentisation by triturition, which Naturalhealth says isn't done, by the way. Answer, no. Then all about fluoride and silica, and nobody could fugure out what you were talking about.

If you had simply come and announced that you wanted to discuss this cell salts thing (oh, Naturalhealth says it's not cell salts it's tissue salts, or maybe the other way round, maybe you need to tell her that either term will do), you might have got some difficult argument, but at least you'd have been respected for being honest, and we might all have learned something because we'd have known what we were talking about.

Never mind, I've realised from your H'pathy posts what your subject matter really was, and you've now told us this yourself too. So, let's discuss the cell salts knowing what we all mean.

Do we need a new thread?

By the way, Kumar, please stay away from the word "biochemistry" or similar terms to describe this. Biochemistry is a very large subject indeed, which describes the workings of the living organism at the molecular level, and the reactions that make the organism function, and how these reactions are controlled and facilitated. I happen to have both a BSc and a PhD degree in it. It's got nothing to do with your subject.

Stick to cell salts or tissue remedies or something like that and we'll be fine.

Rolfe.
 
Calling all physicists! Who wants to take first shot at explaining why this is pure imaginative fiction?

Rolfe
still waiting to hear why it is PURE fiction.
 
Kumar said:
Anyway, I use/follow this system only. It is considered as a part of homeopathy with some hesitations & repulsions. In my opinion-- it is the daughter of homeopathy its essence or real gems of it. It is mostly taken in molecular doses. These are similar to about 98% inorganic biochemicals of our body & therefore may represent 'the true Similimums'. .....
Kumar, will you start a new thread with this post, specifically to discuss the cell salts? This thread is now on page 11, and you have raised a very different subject which is worthy of its own thread.

Rolfe.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
I don't even know what Planck's constant is. Could you explain it for me, or point me somewhere I can learn?
Planck's constant

It would be better to ask a physicist about this, though.

The problem about quantum mechanics is that it is essentially a mathematical construct. Any verbal description doesn't really describe what's going on. The correct reply to anyone claiming that quantum theory can explain any peculiar effect is, "have you got the maths for that?" Because if the claimant can't describe what they are talking about in mathematical terms, then they're not saying anything meaningful.

This is why Lionel Milgrom has published these papers - they look like they've got maths in them. The problem is that his maths only works if you remove Planck's constant from the equations. This is a problem, because Planck's constant is essential for many of the equations that are fundamental to real quantum theory. No physicist seriously believes that Planck's constant doesn't exist, or has any value other than the recognised one.

You'll note that this is an extremely small number indeed, 6.626x10<SUP> -34</SUP> J/sec. Because it has that value, it entirely negates the possibility of anything happening over the sort of distances Lionel Milgrom would like to have them happen.

Rolfe.
 
Originally posted by olaf
let it be known here and now that i am looking over your shoulder from now until doomsday. there is no escape; i am your shadow. everything you say will be put under the microscope. welcome to your worst nightmare. :D
You would do well to scrutinize your own writings the same way. It would perhaps enable you to see the truth some day ...
 
olaf said:
(snipped)

rolfe rolfe rolfe, haven't you just learned your lesson about being careful what you say.

let it be known here and now that i am looking over your shoulder from now until doomsday. there is no escape; i am your shadow. everything you say will be put under the microscope. welcome to your worst nightmare. :D

Ah, I see. Rolfe is a liar and a liar and a liar with an "agenda," but the moment Rolfe may or may not be correct about something, you'll be all over like mongrel piss on a fire hydrant. So, either Rolfe is right and is not quite the liar you attempt to portray, or Rofe is wrong, and yet....
One major difference betwee Olaf and Rolfe though, is if Rolfe is wrong, there will be an admission and an adjustment of information henceforth.
That's some good sharp shooting there Olaf. Maybe one day you'll actually hit the hydrant.
 
HS >-< Rolfee,

Thanks for the postings about me. Rolfee, you seems to be attracting me-- just a honest politics. I am also a politician/indirect type person but never plays bad politics. It is beneficial for the humanity. It is also in my astrology like 'Naarad' in hindu cult.

I shall post ' Tissue Remedies' topic sooner or later in a new thread. It is bit scientific & absolutely clear. I think I had previously mentiond that when this system & CMS will join hands then whole medical system & humanity can be much benefited in true sense but can loose in other sense.

Frankly, I feel that 'rather than going against 'HIM' , one must try to go with or in accordance with 'HIM'. 'HE' or 'HER' are pure basic scientific entity/ies & is/are the first & basic to be understood.

Rolfee & Mr.Hans, I know you are laughing/radiculing/smiling in the back of curtain-- on post-me postings at Hpthy. Rolfee as Hans, grm1 as vijay/kumar, troll, frauds etc. But just poor or mis- understandings. Just a post-me effect, or an side- effect of injustice to truth. My friends & enemies(?):D , never tollerated injustice to me as all are really honest alike.

HS, just try to stop this furthur non-sense & bad show of our poor understandings.

Btw, what is this topic meant for-- Homeopathy: safe or dangerous, cant it be both-just to think & find????:)

The other news--See the future plans at HHBB. in 'Cofee Shop' forum(not in discussion forum).

Rolfee, Have you read 'Silicea & its biological role' topic at HHBB? It may now make some sense to you.:D
 
Rolfe said:
But you told us Kumar had been welcomed back among you with a new identity before he even posted here.Edited to add: and look, he's back. Hi, Kumar!

Do look at Lionel Milgron's papers, folks.
The first one.
And the second one.
And the third.
If there's a fourth, I'd be pleased to have a link to it.

Now, note the definitive word there. "Metaphor." None of this quantum entanglement stuff has the slightest thing to do with homoeopathy. All dear Lionel is saying is, what if the universe worked differently, and the mental processes of the homoeopath were somehow able to influence the patient through the remedy? Sort of quantum, like. That's all the pages of equations and diagrams boil down to.

I've had opinions on this lot from a number of physicists, and the hardest thing was to get them to stop laughing for long enough to tell me what was so funny.

Mostly what was so funny was that in order for any of that maths to work you have to eliminate Planck's constant, and if you do that, the whole of the rest of quantum theory falls to pieces.

In fact this "weak quantum theory" thing was simply dreamed up by some homoeopaths, including Harald Walach, whose "Magic of Signs" paper is heavily drawn on by Milgrom, with the specific purpose of providing them with an "explanation" they could talk about which is far enough removed from most people's understanding to sound impressive and avoid challenge. It's completely self-referencing, and completely ignored and discounted by real physicists.

Rolfe.
Rolfe, you are lying again. I can always tell when you are doing it.
 
olaf said:
Rolfe, you are lying again. I can always tell when you are doing it.
"you're going to have to do a lot better than that."

You've made the claim that Rolfe is lying, now I ask you substantiate this claim.
 
Kumar said:
*snip*
Mr.Hans, if it is entirely empty, so many people will not pose the drinking OR they will not even keep the glass in their hand.

Well, actually, a lot of people are not keeping the glass. Even in countries where homeopathy (and other alternative treatments) are very widespread, people seem very keen on switching to conventional medicine whenever they get the chance.


Dear Rolfee,

Try to avoid misspelling people's names, please.

*snip* as per 'HIS' desire. *snip*

I could guess, but this is not a guessing game; who exactly is "HE"?

Hans
 
Kumar said:
*snip*
Btw, what is this topic meant for-- Homeopathy: safe or dangerous, cant it be both-just to think & find????:)

*snip*
The subject of this thread is the mixed signals we get from homeopaths: Some say homeopathy is perfectly save with no side effects, yet talk about "aggavation", others say that it can be dangerous.

No, it cannot be both. Either it is perfectly save, or it might be dangerous under some circumstances.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
Rolfee & Mr.Hans, I know you are laughing/radiculing/smiling in the back of curtain-- on post-me postings at Hpthy. Rolfee as Hans, grm1 as vijay/kumar, troll, frauds etc. But just poor or mis- understandings. Just a post-me effect, or an side- effect of injustice to truth. My friends & enemies(?):D , never tollerated injustice to me as all are really honest alike.
Again, I'm not sure I entirely understand what you're saying here, but be assured that we're not laughing at what you were saying at H'pathy. (Oh all right, when you immediately accepted that nonsense about the approach of Mars, perhaps there was a small smile, but not generally.) You have been saying some very sensible things, and in fact your writing there has often been easier to understand than it is here.

I'm looking forward to you starting the thread about the cell salts. Please post some links to places where we can find out more about the theory. If the preparations are mostly molecular, we may be able to avoid all the pages of trying to explain why there's nothing in the "high-potency" stuff.

Rolfe.
 
olaf said:
Rolfe, you are lying again. I can always tell when you are doing it.
Oh, here we go again. Every time Olaf doesn't understand what I've said, I'm "lying".

Please quote the statement I've made which you believe to be a lie, and then demonstrate that it is untrue.

Rolfe.
 
Mr. Hans,

Thanks for indicating the spelling mistake. If all of you can mention my mistakes I could be able to improve. Actually, long back my brother was having a firiend & i think spelling of his name was Rolfee. However, I accept & apologize for the big mistake, Rolfe.

"..people seem very keen on switching to conventional medicine whenever they get the chance."

You just not completed. Just add & 'vice versa' because opposite is also evident.

"..No, it cannot be both. Either it is perfectly save[-] [safe] or it might be dangerous under some circumstances.

Hans"

Why, it can be perfectly safe to remove all clothes of a .... naturally, but can be very dangerous- socially & moreover with the help of other community.

Furthur, 'HE, HIS & HIM' are related to similar entity in my sense. We need to fear.;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom