Rolfe
Adult human female
To repeat what Badly Shaved Monkey said another way, the fact is that 1 kg of sugar in the entire volume of the world's oceans is not as dilute as 12C.Kumar said:Btw, what is this-- 100 molecules per liter?Badly Shaved Monkey, thanks for the working. However, it is accepted by all that there can be no material(atomic or molecular) existance above 12C or 24X potency as per A. Law. One more thing: suppose we pass electricity through the water, or apply heat or any other form of energy--Will it leave any effect on quality of water ( obiously after it cools down or settled)?
"Contagious magic" belief of Sir Frazer is quite intresting. I shall try to find some logic. It can be true belief. I again come here probably due to "Contagious magic/effect".![]()
It's quite difficult to get your brain round it, because of the small volumes used to make homoeopathic dilutions, but in fact while the sugar in the ocean comes to one molecule in 10 ml solvent, 30C comes to one molecule in a container many times the volume of the entire earth. (That's not very accurate, but maybe someone else can do better. It's impossible to be absolutely accurate though, because unlike the kilo of sugar, where we can calculate the exact number of molecules very easily, we don't know the exact concentration of a homoeopathic mother tincture - not only that, many of the remedies aren't pure compounds, but for example whole plants or even animal parts, with all sorts of different proteins, nucleic acids, lipids and carbohydrates all mixed up together.)
So while there might well be a few suger molecules in that sample of sea water (though it would be extremely difficult to detect it at that level), we can be quite confident that the probability of getting even one molecule in a dose of a 30C remedy is so remote as to be not worth considering.
Treating water with heat or electricity is a very different matter. Homoeopathy doesn't do that of course. Electrolysis can, in the right circumstances, split water into hydrogen and oxygen, which are both gases. This is an elementary experiment done by all junior science classes at school. However, the water that doesn't split isn't significantly changed so far as I know.
If you heat water, you get hot water. If you heat it some more, you get steam, which is a gas. If you let the steam cool, you get water again, water which has significantly less impurities in it than the original. This is the best way to get very pure water if you need it for something, such as servicing your car battery. You could use this water (distilled water) to make homoeopathic remedies if you wanted to, but as Naturalhealth just pointed out, there's no real need to do so.
By the way, Sir James Frazer didn't "believe" in sympathetic magic - quite the contrary. He studied it as an interesting primitive superstition. He said things like "In short, magic is a spurious system of natural law as well as a fallacious guide of conduct; it is a false science as well as an abortive art."
the primitive magician knows magic only on its practical side; he never analyses the mental processes on which his practice is based, never reflects on the abstract principles involved in his actions. With him, as with the vast majority of men, logic is implicit, not explicit: he reasons just as he digests his food in complete ignorance of the intellectual and physiological processes which are essential to the one operation and to the other. In short, to him magic is always an art, never a science; the very idea of science is lacking in his undeveloped mind.
If my analysis of the magician’s logic is correct, its two great principles turn out to be merely two different misapplications of the association of ideas. Homoeopathic magic is founded on the association of ideas by similarity: contagious magic is founded on the association of ideas by contiguity. Homoeopathic magic commits the mistake of assuming that things which resemble each other are the same: contagious magic commits the mistake of assuming that things which have once been in contact with each other are always in contact.
No, he certainly didn't believe in this!they are familiar in the concrete, though certainly not in the abstract, to the crude intelligence not only of the savage, but of ignorant and dull-witted people everywhere.
This may summarise our discussion. Do we follow the superstitious beliefs which have nothing but custom and ignorant assumption to commend them, or do we use our logical gifts to examine the actual evidence, look for demonstrable cause and effect, and so discover the truth about how the universe really is?
The homoeopaths prefer the former, the scientists the latter. At some point, everyone has to choose.
Rolfe.