Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Kumar said:
Btw, what is this-- 100 molecules per liter?;) Badly Shaved Monkey, thanks for the working. However, it is accepted by all that there can be no material(atomic or molecular) existance above 12C or 24X potency as per A. Law. One more thing: suppose we pass electricity through the water, or apply heat or any other form of energy--Will it leave any effect on quality of water ( obiously after it cools down or settled)?

"Contagious magic" belief of Sir Frazer is quite intresting. I shall try to find some logic. It can be true belief. I again come here probably due to "Contagious magic/effect".:D
To repeat what Badly Shaved Monkey said another way, the fact is that 1 kg of sugar in the entire volume of the world's oceans is not as dilute as 12C.

It's quite difficult to get your brain round it, because of the small volumes used to make homoeopathic dilutions, but in fact while the sugar in the ocean comes to one molecule in 10 ml solvent, 30C comes to one molecule in a container many times the volume of the entire earth. (That's not very accurate, but maybe someone else can do better. It's impossible to be absolutely accurate though, because unlike the kilo of sugar, where we can calculate the exact number of molecules very easily, we don't know the exact concentration of a homoeopathic mother tincture - not only that, many of the remedies aren't pure compounds, but for example whole plants or even animal parts, with all sorts of different proteins, nucleic acids, lipids and carbohydrates all mixed up together.)

So while there might well be a few suger molecules in that sample of sea water (though it would be extremely difficult to detect it at that level), we can be quite confident that the probability of getting even one molecule in a dose of a 30C remedy is so remote as to be not worth considering.

Treating water with heat or electricity is a very different matter. Homoeopathy doesn't do that of course. Electrolysis can, in the right circumstances, split water into hydrogen and oxygen, which are both gases. This is an elementary experiment done by all junior science classes at school. However, the water that doesn't split isn't significantly changed so far as I know.

If you heat water, you get hot water. If you heat it some more, you get steam, which is a gas. If you let the steam cool, you get water again, water which has significantly less impurities in it than the original. This is the best way to get very pure water if you need it for something, such as servicing your car battery. You could use this water (distilled water) to make homoeopathic remedies if you wanted to, but as Naturalhealth just pointed out, there's no real need to do so.

By the way, Sir James Frazer didn't "believe" in sympathetic magic - quite the contrary. He studied it as an interesting primitive superstition. He said things like "In short, magic is a spurious system of natural law as well as a fallacious guide of conduct; it is a false science as well as an abortive art."
the primitive magician knows magic only on its practical side; he never analyses the mental processes on which his practice is based, never reflects on the abstract principles involved in his actions. With him, as with the vast majority of men, logic is implicit, not explicit: he reasons just as he digests his food in complete ignorance of the intellectual and physiological processes which are essential to the one operation and to the other. In short, to him magic is always an art, never a science; the very idea of science is lacking in his undeveloped mind.
If my analysis of the magician’s logic is correct, its two great principles turn out to be merely two different misapplications of the association of ideas. Homoeopathic magic is founded on the association of ideas by similarity: contagious magic is founded on the association of ideas by contiguity. Homoeopathic magic commits the mistake of assuming that things which resemble each other are the same: contagious magic commits the mistake of assuming that things which have once been in contact with each other are always in contact.
they are familiar in the concrete, though certainly not in the abstract, to the crude intelligence not only of the savage, but of ignorant and dull-witted people everywhere.
No, he certainly didn't believe in this!

This may summarise our discussion. Do we follow the superstitious beliefs which have nothing but custom and ignorant assumption to commend them, or do we use our logical gifts to examine the actual evidence, look for demonstrable cause and effect, and so discover the truth about how the universe really is?

The homoeopaths prefer the former, the scientists the latter. At some point, everyone has to choose.

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
No. This is not anecdotal evidence. This is clinical experience and clinical cases.
homeopathy.gif
 
Rolfe said:
To repeat what Badly Shaved Monkey said another way, the fact is that 1 kg of sugar in the entire volume of the world's oceans is not as dilute as 12C.

Surprising, it means Dr.jkr was absolutely wrong in telling no presence of sugar. :D.

It's quite difficult to get your brain round it, because of the small volumes used to make homoeopathic dilutions, but in fact while the sugar in the ocean comes to one molecule in 10 ml solvent, 30C comes to one molecule in a container many times the volume of the entire earth. (That's not very accurate, but maybe someone else can do better. It's impossible to be absolutely accurate though, because unlike the kilo of sugar, where we can calculate the exact number of molecules very easily, we don't know the exact concentration of a homoeopathic mother tincture - not only that, many of the remedies aren't pure compounds, but for example whole plants or even animal parts, with all sorts of different proteins, nucleic acids, lipids and carbohydrates all mixed up together.)So while there might well be a few suger molecules in that sample of sea water (though it would be extremely difficult to detect it at that level), we can be quite confident that the probability of getting even one molecule in a dose of a 30C remedy is so remote as to be not worth considering.


Just calculate by taking 1g of Salt(NaCl)+ 9g of lactose = 1X, then 1g of above mix.=9g lactose again = 2X.....count upto 24X. OR 1g NaCl+ 99g water = 1C......count upto 12C.


Treating water with heat or electricity is a very different matter. Homoeopathy doesn't do that of course. Electrolysis can, in the right circumstances, split water into hydrogen and oxygen, which are both gases. This is an elementary experiment done by all junior science classes at school. However, the water that doesn't split isn't significantly changed so far as I know.

What do you mean by--" isn't significantly changed", are you saying that some insignificant changes can be possible? What about magnetic fields & other radiations or rays(like sun rays/X-rays etc.) can these effect the quality of distilled water?


This may summarise our discussion. Do we follow the superstitious beliefs which have nothing but custom and ignorant assumption to commend them, or do we use our logical gifts to examine the actual evidence, look for demonstrable cause and effect, and so discover the truth about how the universe really is?

The homoeopaths prefer the former, the scientists the latter. At some point, everyone has to choose.

Rolfe.


It can be moe appropriate if taken like that: Do we follow beliefs followed by severals millions or not, or go on finding its reasoning & science till it ends in itself. However, we can split homeopathy in two parts: Materialistic (Atomic/molecular) & Energetic( Sub-atomic/energized). Now can we deny its materialistic part scientifically? Smaller molecules of any substance can be more effective than its bigger molecules.
 
Kumar,

Please read the two books that I suggested to you by Dr Colin Lessell - The Companion to Homeopathic Studies and The New Physics of Homeopathy. This has just the same science based stuff that you are looking for and is very informative.

There are still a lot of people around who are working on the science behind homeopathy. Jacques Benveniste has never stopped his studies ever since the 1980's. His work still continues. There is then Madelaine Ennis and also a lot of Korean scientists doing a lot of valuable work on this.

There is another version of the Organon that is slightly easier to interpret if you wish. This has been annotated by Wendy Brewster O'Reilly. It is still the same basically, but the English is a little easier to understand and you may find this more helpful. I find that the original is better though.


"From all the exposure recently (e.g., the BBC Horizon program, 'negative trial results on Arnica, and associated bad press reportage), one could be forgiven for thinking that any attempt to reconcile homeopathy with science is simply a waste of time. After all, even though plenty of trials have been done, many of which support homeopathy, it must be patently obvious to anyone with even half a brain, that no amount of testing is going to persuade non- believers that homeopathy works or, on the contrary, dissuade believers that it doesn't. So, why bother? Scientifically speaking, we haven't even begun to scratch the surface of what homeopathy is really about and to predict that ultimately when we do, homeopathy and science will both benefit.

OK, in the context of homeopathy, what is 'science'? Bigger and better double blind placebo-controlled trials (DBPCTS) on potentised remedies, as the conventional scientific community would wish? I don't think so.
There would be a deafening outcry for ever more DBPCTs if they should favor homeopathy, and "Nya, nya, we told you so!” if they shouldn't, simply underlining the strength of feeling that homeopathic issues generate (and objectivity can sometimes be the first casualty in this debate). In my view, ever more DBPCTs merely prolong a stultifying and inconclusive ideological trench warfare between two opposing factions - on the one hand, conventional biomedicine and its hard-line reductionist (i.e., Newtonian) determinism, and on the other, homeopathy and any other CAM whose mechanism of healing doesn't neatly fit in with bio-medicine's reductionist paradigm.

Homeopathy, though rightly seen as a healing art, is in my view wrongly bracketed with the biomedical
sciences. This includes the latter's reductionist tendency to equate the overall effects of remedial substances solely with their pharmacological action, specifically on bio-molecular receptor sites on cells. Thus, the presence of palpable drug molecules at these sites is seen as the prime cause of any healing effect. "So," homeopathy's detractors argue, "how can a remedy containing no drug molecules have any effect, let
alone a healing one? You are asking us to believe in magic!" And seen from the deterministic standpoint of conventional reductionist biomedicine, you have to admit the detractors have a point. After all, pharmacology - the science of the properties of drugs and their effects on the body - has a history almost as long as homeopathy's, so it is perfectly valid to ask how 'nothing' (i.e., a highly potentised homeopathic remedy) can do something, and explains the dogged refusal by many to believe the results of any DBPCT that suggests a positive outcome for homeopathy. Result deadlock".

Kumar, read and inwardly digest, plus the two books that I suggested.

Good lucki
 
homeopathy would require a major rewrite of the standard modle and of most of chemistry and biology. There is no method of action that does not vilolate some fairly fundimental laws of physics.
 
Homeoskeptic, since you clearly are an expert on all things homeopatic, how could a homeopathic remedy help a woman who has Turner's syndrome?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
There are still a lot of people around who are working on the science behind homeopathy. Jacques Benveniste has never stopped his studies ever since the 1980's. His work still continues. There is then Madelaine Ennis and also a lot of Korean scientists doing a lot of valuable work on this.

Referance? Jacques Benveniste seems to keep being discredited.

There is another version of the Organon that is slightly easier to interpret if you wish. This has been annotated by Wendy Brewster O'Reilly. It is still the same basically, but the English is a little easier to understand and you may find this more helpful. I find that the original is better though.

The orginal? You read german?

"From all the exposure recently (e.g., the BBC Horizon program, 'negative trial results on Arnica, and associated bad press reportage), one could be forgiven for thinking that any attempt to reconcile homeopathy with science is simply a waste of time. After all, even though plenty of trials have been done, many of which support homeopathy, it must be patently obvious to anyone with even half a brain, that no amount of testing is going to persuade non- believers that homeopathy works or, on the contrary, dissuade believers that it doesn't. So, why bother? Scientifically speaking, we haven't even begun to scratch the surface of what homeopathy is really about and to predict that ultimately when we do, homeopathy and science will both benefit.

You would be amased what properly controled studies can atchive in terms of changeing people's minds. Scientificly homeopathy is a pain to investigate since there is no one thing called homeopathy just a number of belife systems that spring from a common source. Personly I don't think homeopathy will benefit much due to contact with science. It's total destruction wont help it much. fell free to prove me wrong. You could start be reliving JREF of $1million.
OK, in the context of homeopathy, what is 'science'? Bigger and better double blind placebo-controlled trials (DBPCTS) on potentised remedies, as the conventional scientific community would wish? I don't think so.
There would be a deafening outcry for ever more DBPCTs if they should favor homeopathy, and "Nya, nya, we told you so!”

Prove it.
if they shouldn't, simply underlining the strength of feeling that homeopathic issues generate (and objectivity can sometimes be the first casualty in this debate). In my view, ever more DBPCTs merely prolong a stultifying and inconclusive ideological trench warfare between two opposing factions - on the one hand, conventional biomedicine and its hard-line reductionist (i.e., Newtonian) determinism, and on the other, homeopathy and any other CAM whose mechanism of healing doesn't neatly fit in with bio-medicine's reductionist paradigm.

You don't know much about medcine these days do you?
Homeopathy, though rightly seen as a healing art, is in my view wrongly bracketed with the biomedical
sciences. This includes the latter's reductionist tendency to equate the overall effects of remedial substances solely with their pharmacological action, specifically on bio-molecular receptor sites on cells.

Hey what happene to enzymes and anti cancer drugs? You seem to have missed out a massive area


Thus, the presence of palpable drug molecules at these sites is seen as the prime cause of any healing effect.

Wrong

"So," homeopathy's detractors argue, "how can a remedy containing no drug molecules have any effect, let
alone a healing one? You are asking us to believe in magic!" And seen from the deterministic standpoint of conventional reductionist biomedicine, you have to admit the detractors have a point. After all, pharmacology - the science of the properties of drugs and their effects on the body - has a history almost as long as homeopathy's, so it is perfectly valid to ask how 'nothing' (i.e., a highly potentised homeopathic remedy)

12C is highly potentised?


can do something, and explains the dogged refusal by many to believe the results of any DBPCT that suggests a positive outcome for homeopathy. Result deadlock".

Show me a well conduted trial that produces a posertive result for homeopathy.

BTW that lot had better be you own work. You wouldn't want to be breaking forum rules on copy write would you?
 
Hello HS,

Nice to see your sentiments about me. Thanks for furthur informations. In this respect, I just say that when we know that higher potencies can't yet be tested with current technologies, why we say it is scientifically true. I know these are working in observations, but still we have to satisfy to the current science to make it scientific. Otherwise, we should accept like this:-

"Higher potencies in homeopathy are found to be effective on observations made on several/millions patients by homeopaths, but its science/reasons that, being ultamolecular how these works/can work could not be yet found/known with current science technologies. Its results may or may not be consistant, in consideration of 'every individal is differant & every remedy can effect differantly on every individual. However, materialistic lower potencies are molecular/atomic which can be tested with CST."

It may be displayed on every homeopathic clinic & seems to be of no harm. Scientific community ,then, should be satisfied like other spritual/energy/sub-atomic etc., alternative healing systems.

One thing is very important to do by homeopathic community;

All homeopathic theories & its applications other than, 'how ultra molecular/higher potencies can work' , should be pursued to standardize it & make it in accordance with current science. I am finding some other aspects which are needed to be looked into *seriously & deeply.

We have not yet done ash analysis/ direct analysis of our complex molecular/organic based remedies, without which i think nothing scientific can be pursued. We have big personalities at HHBB, but they accept but don't take up this analysis. Ash analysis of humans has created such an important therapy' Twelve Tissue Salts', why we then don't do these analysis of remedy substances. Ash analysis in important to know the salts(compounds) in it, not its ionic/elemental basis unabling us to compare properly. This analysis may probably unable us to know the effects or remedies suitably & scientifically.

I just indicate you a *2nd example, on which we needed to look very seriously & deeply i.e.:-

*It is said that there are some 'Mantras(religious recitals) which have healing effect & benificials to humanity but there are another types which can have some damaging/destructive effects. It is important to understand this aspect that how these damaging mantras can effect ?

Regards.
 
Kumar and his "Tissue Salts"! Hooray! We knew you would get around to it sooner or later, Kumar.

And, like homeopathy, it remains complete and utter rubbish whichever way you care to test it. Really, it does. We explained this patiently to you months ago, and there is nothing that has been revealed since then that changes that fact.

"Ash analysis"? Oh dear, such silliness does not suit you, Kumar.
 
Same comments as in 'Suppressions, ?? on Homeopathy' topic.

This message was for HS, to be understood by him & other ++++.
 
Empty superstition - and here comes a supporter spouting the usual mystical / religious / quack response:

"All science would do is shed a negative light on what I do, but if it did show something positive, they'd keep trying until they found a negative, ad-infinitum, and besides I like not having science tell me I'm wrong, so we don't need science."

If what you say is true, Homeo, then the Flat Earth Society would still be conducting hundreds of tests for determining the shape of hte Earth - for that matter, every scientifically verified system would be under unending barrage by those who believed in the old way.

No, you don't want science too deeply involved in your snake oil remedies because eventually, after properly controlled testing, the only result is going to be that you're peddling placebos and causing people to think they don't need valid treatments. Sooner or later, some government is going to take note, run a government-controlled and fully functioning test, and debunk the whole thing on an official level, the FDA will properly reclassify Homeopathy as 'food', i.e. water and candy, and then ban the homeopsychos who are adding contamination into the food like some kind of pharmacological russian roullette. For all our discussions of there being 'nothing' in highly potentised remedies, there is still a chance that some poor sucker is going to be the one to take a dose containing a clump of molecules and end up dying from it. An astronomically small chance, to be true, but in an infinite universe, still a chance.

This is the standard thread homeopaths give if people push too hard. "Well, science doesn't know everything, and tests won't make believers out of anyone, so there's no point." If there's no point, then do the tests anyway. If negative results won't change believer's minds, what does it hurt? It hurts your business, because negative results will lead to you getting shut down and properly labelled as 'quacks'.
 
zaayrdragon said:

If what you say is true, Homeo, then the Flat Earth Society would still be conducting hundreds of tests for determining the shape of hte Earth - for that matter, every scientifically verified system would be under unending barrage by those who believed in the old way.

No, you don't want science too deeply involved in your snake oil remedies because eventually, after properly controlled testing, the only result is going to be that you're peddling placebos and causing people to think they don't need valid treatments. Sooner or later, some government is going to take note, run a government-controlled and fully functioning test, and debunk the whole thing on an official level, the FDA will properly reclassify Homeopathy as 'food', i.e. water and candy, and then ban the homeopsychos who are adding contamination into the food like some kind of pharmacological russian roullette. For all our discussions of there being 'nothing' in highly potentised remedies, there is still a chance that some poor sucker is going to be the one to take a dose containing a clump of molecules and end up dying from it. An astronomically small chance, to be true, but in an infinite universe, still a chance.

Mostly, it may not be really bad or irrelevant.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
OK, in the context of homeopathy, what is 'science'? Bigger and better double blind placebo-controlled trials (DBPCTS) on potentised remedies, as the conventional scientific community would wish? I don't think so.
There would be a deafening outcry for ever more DBPCTs if they should favor homeopathy, and "Nya, nya, we told you so!” if they shouldn't, simply underlining the strength of feeling that homeopathic issues generate (and objectivity can sometimes be the first casualty in this debate). In my view, ever more DBPCTs merely prolong a stultifying and inconclusive ideological trench warfare between two opposing factions - on the one hand, conventional biomedicine and its hard-line reductionist (i.e., Newtonian) determinism, and on the other, homeopathy and any other CAM whose mechanism of healing doesn't neatly fit in with bio-medicine's reductionist paradigm.
Apparently you don't realize how science actually operates. You seem to think it is monolithic rather than composed of many individuals all going for the gold ring -- to make a name for themselves by showing the others wrong. By bringing something new to the textbooks.

Apparently you also don't realize that the medical community is not the only one that would be keenly interested in the results. The chemists and physicists who theoretical frameworks would have to be overturned for homeopathy to work would also be keenly interested. Apparently you don't realize that you have to extend your bizarre conspiracy theory beyond the medical community into these other disciplines as well.

You have to believe that the conspiracy includes non-medical biologists, all chemists, physical chemists and physicists. Each and every one has to agree to the conspiracy to keep your "truth" about homeopathy at bay.

Do you really expect any sane person to buy into this poppycock?
 
BillHoyt said:

Apparently you don't realize how science actually operates. You seem to think it is monolithic rather than composed of many individuals all going for the gold ring -- to make a name for themselves by showing the others wrong. By bringing something new to the textbooks.

Apparently you also don't realize that the medical community is not the only one that would be keenly interested in the results. The chemists and physicists who theoretical frameworks would have to be overturned for homeopathy to work would also be keenly interested. Apparently you don't realize that you have to extend your bizarre conspiracy theory beyond the medical community into these other disciplines as well.

You have to believe that the conspiracy includes non-medical biologists, all chemists, physical chemists and physicists. Each and every one has to agree to the conspiracy to keep your "truth" about homeopathy at bay.

Do you really expect any sane person to buy into this poppycock?

Not to mention a large number of skeptical laymen. Believe me, if I thought there was even a 1% chance that homeopathy had any truth to it, I would be funding research and even doing it myself. If it worked as claimed, that would be the cash cow of the century. I could finally buy my own private island!!! Best part, I could feel good about it because I made my money helping cure diseases.

Of course, it's all hogwash, which kinda kills the dream. I knew I should have never agreed when that door-to-door conspiracy recruiter showed up.
 
Nyah Nyah Nyah - Oh how mature we are...

HA HA HA HA HA HA HEH hack hack cough cough...

I'm getting too old for this...

:D
 
I deny it! I deny it!! I deny looking goofy... er, no, never mind.

Well, I don't look goofy 'cuz I just took a 20C dilution of Goofy on Sports today... in fact, I'm immortal and in perfect health 'cuz I drank a wonderful mixed remedy of dilutions of every known thing on earth. Tap water - gotta love it.

Oh, but I made sure it was filtered twice and underwent reverse osmosis first, to be safe you know...

One question for Homeo... does the technique of succussion matter? One of the sites I found insisted you had to smack the container on a leather book, preferably a bible. What's the pseudo-science on this one? or is there a more valid surface to smack? Or is it more of a shaking motion, like choking the chicken? What method, in fact, do you find works best?
 
Originally posted by Rolfe
More fun. After that single post (which said stuff I've said, but in very few words (for me) and with no specific detail), Bach attacked by answering a different question based on the assumption that the controlled trial is a poor tool for examining homoeopathy, val_drjkr said something completely woo-woo in line with the drivel we've just been discussing, Divina was rude (no change there then), someone called "Fopper", also a first post, asked them to address the question (of why there are no positive controlled trials for homoeopathy), and JanZy said Rolfe deserved no answer as he had given no details of the negative studies he referred to (completely ignoring the multiple threads also in that forum where the studies were cited and linked to in detail and the homoeopaths beseeched to come and have their say...), closed the thread to further discussion, and banned both "Rolfe" and Fopper before either could post a second time.

Totally mysterious. Would anyone here care to admit to being either Rolfe or Fopper, since it sure as hell wasn't me?
Son of a ... !!!!!

They banned fopper??!! Dang, I hadn't even got around to checking responses to that post. I mean, geez, I just asked them to address the question posed, in a rather polite and friendly manner. These guys are pathetic !!!

I have no idea who Rolfe is though ...

One post. I got banned after one post. Is that a new record?
 
exarch said:
One post. I got banned after one post. Is that a new record?

Nope there are a number of people who have posted sceptical stuff and got banned after one post. At short notice the only sceptic I can think of there who has a post and who has not been banneed is starburn3 and I can't see that lasting.
 
zaayrdragon said:
I deny it! I deny it!! I deny looking goofy... er, no, never mind.

Well, I don't look goofy 'cuz I just took a 20C dilution of Goofy on Sports today... in fact, I'm immortal and in perfect health 'cuz I drank a wonderful mixed remedy of dilutions of every known thing on earth. Tap water - gotta love it.

Oh, but I made sure it was filtered twice and underwent reverse osmosis first, to be safe you know...

One question for Homeo... does the technique of succussion matter? One of the sites I found insisted you had to smack the container on a leather book, preferably a bible. What's the pseudo-science on this one? or is there a more valid surface to smack? Or is it more of a shaking motion, like choking the chicken? What method, in fact, do you find works best?

:D

Just wanted to say I enjoy your posts immensely!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom