Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Badly Shaved Monkey

Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
Joined
Feb 5, 2004
Messages
5,363
http://www.hpathy.com/forum/display...ID=8&TopicID=1280&PagePosition=1&ThreadPage=1

Homeopathy is safe it has no side effects. But what about aggravations? They aren't 'side effects'. But, they make the patient feel worse and sometimes a patient needs to be antidoted. Etc. Etc.

Follow the link to see how they can't keep the story straight even when they talk among themselves.

(Edited to add: Also note that over a year after this thread was started they have just moved it to their 'Science' forum. Could that have something to do with the fact that without scientists posting challenges to them that forum is about to die?)
 
So much hot air over so little cold water.

They are only dangerous if the prevent any sick patient seeking a qualified doctor who DOES know what s/he is talking about and who can offer real medicine.

Otherwise this less relevant to medicine than the Cola Wars.
 
What Zep says is of course true, but I think Badly Shaved Monkey is making a more subtle point.

The homoeopaths like to maintain in public that their remedies are safe - how could they be otherwise, since there's nothing in them? Therefore, of course, there's no need at all to think about safety tests and regulation and licensing. We know this is really true, but think about it. If a preparation actually has a biological effect, it is at least theoretically possible that it may have undesirable effects. We accede to the "harmless" point of view because we don't believe the remedies have any biological effect at all, but the homoeopaths don't see it that way.

If you read the thread BSM linked to, you'll see the classic spectacle of homoeopaths fighting like ferrets in a sack because essentially they all just make it up as they go along, and over the years contradictions have built up and become firmly embedded in their literature. Some take one point of view, others another, and because there's no way of getting an objective answer they just go on fighting.

Poor Kumar (Vijay 0507)! He comes here and we beat up on him, he goes to H'pathy where you'd think they'd be more in tune with his mad thinking, and they beat up on him too. Remember that Naturalhealth is "our" Homeoskeptic, in its natural environment.

The discussion in the thread is about unpleasant and unwelcome effects which follow the giving of a homoeopathic remedy, believed to be caused by the remedy. However (as we teased out earlier in a different thread), by torturing the English language, these are defined as not being side-effects, because side-effects is something only "allopathic" medicine will produce, homoeopathy doesn't produce side-effects, these are aggravations or provings.

They still believe the remedies can cause unpleasant effects, though, even if they dress it up as a "healing crisis". I know John Hoare, a veterinary homooepath, believes that 30C remedies should be prescription only because of their potential for harm. One homoeopath (Anna Bryant) was very reluctant to consider the JREF Challenge because she believed that "proving" a remedy multiple times would be dangerous to her health.

When they get on to challenging sceptics to do a self-proving (as they do with monotonous regularity), it gets even more marked. Much gleeful speculation as to whether the sceptic might actually be made ill with the remedy. There's even a thread where one of them tried to figure out how to make Starburn ill (though as it all degenerated into suggestions of 1X arsenic in 10g doses, we can't take it too seriously). There's another good example from last year in the Guardian's Bad Science column too.

There's no doubt they all agree that their remedies can make peple very unwell, and it's possible to do this deliberately if you're so inclined. They don't agree as to whether they can actually kill, but as I've seen a book review of a homoeopathic veterinary text which includes a homoeopathic method for "gentle euthanasia", I guess some people are confident that they can.

So should these preparations, which their users believe can be harmful or even dangerous, really be made freely available without any need for safety evaluation?

Rolfe.
 
Seriously, I DO think they need safety evaluation. But contrary to what they think might be needed.

First, I would have all homeopathic remedies actually limited to manufacture by registered homeopathic ... searching for the word here ... producers. This is to make sure that the product is truly 10C or 20C or 30C or whatever and contains what it "says" it contains, and not just a few lawn clippings in tap-water, or even actual dangerous concentrations of something bad (inadvertantly).

I would then have any remedies of 25C or higher dilutions from these producers allowed to be sold non-prescription, but with one proviso. There should be a mandatory label on the pack that says to the effect: "This product is unlikely to contain any active ingredient and is thus indistinguishable from plain water/sugar". Enforceable by advertising law - you can't advertise falsely.

Remedies less than 25C dilution should be limited to a medical doctor's prescription only just like real medicine. Given that there are not a lot of actual real doctors that practice homeopathy too (yes, I know there are a few vaunted ones nonetheless), this would tend to actually curtail the distribution of potentially harmful remedies significantly. NB. Homeopaths who are not registered doctors will NOT be allowed to prescribe these remedies!

In summary, if the homeopaths want to play with the big boys, they get to play by their rules too. Stiff cheddar.
 
One problem is that it's not possible to do any quality control checking of the finished product. If only you could analyse a bottle and say, yes that is really 30C Belladonna! The best you could do would be unannounced spot checks to make sure that they really were doing all that diluting and succussing. And what about transport? Is it true that security x-rays inactivate the stuff? If so, should postal distribution be allowed?

The homoeopaths themselves disagree about the reliability of different manufacturers. This was one excuse tendered when Hans' self-proving didn't produce any results. It seems that if someone has a "bad" experience with a particular company's remedies (i.e. fewer patients than usual getting spontaneously better) they will assume that the preparation is at fault. The laugh is that of course this happens to each of them regarding a different manufacturer, so you will get one homoeopath slating a company while another swears by it.

I do agree about the remedies being labelled to make it clear that there is no active ingredient in them. (By the way, I think it's 12C, or 24X, beyond which there's nothing there.) The remedy bottle I had didn't make it clear, though it did list the contents as "sucrose/lactose", and say that it was "a homoeopathic preparation without approved therapeutic indication".

And what about precautions and contraindications? If it's really true that coffee antidotes Belladonna, for example, shouldn't there be an injunction not to drink coffee? And all the other possible interferences and antidotings that get dragged up as excuses when a sceptic's self-proving doesn't work? If all these things can stop the remedy working, they should be spelled out on the label.

You could argue that the "lower" potencies are no different from unregulated herbal remedies, except that they have less in them, but that's a whole new argument. This is a completely different quality of scam from herbal remedies, and needs to be examined on its own.

Rolfe.
 
Homeopathic remedies can have powerful effects. When I was training a long time ago, a tutor told me of an experience she had with a fellow student when she was training. She said that her friend experimented with remedies and gave a remedy to his dog thereby killing it.

Remedies, given in the correct circumstances can aid people to a very comfortable death. A friend of mine when I was training told me about when her father was dying of cancer. He was extremely ill and was going to die, but was also very anxious and restless. This is a strong indication for Arsenicum. She decided to go to the ward and she gave her father an Arsenicum 1M. After he had this, he became extremely lucid for the next 24 hours and was able to say 'goodbye' to his wife and rest of his family and spent a very happy 24 hours with them. After this, he died peacefully in his sleep. The Arsenicum enabled him to have a little more lucid time with his family and then die very peacfully and comfortably indeed.

There are simply hundreds of excellent medical doctors who are also practicing homeopaths. All you have to do is look at the list of the Faculty of Homeopathy and you will see this evidently from it. There are the likes of Brian Kaplan and Charles Forsyth, who have flourishing and very successful practices in Harley Street.

There is also Lionel Milgrom who is a chemist and homeopath, who is now working on some quite ground breaking chemical research now, nothing at all to do with quantum theory. I attended one of his lectures recently and it was brilliant the kind of work he is doing at the moment.

To be able to understand our 'thread', you need to understand and know something about homeopathy, which you don't. All of us studied for at least 3 to 4 years so that we can be enabled to prescribe remedies safely, which we do. We all abide by the code of ethics of our professional organisations too.

I will be inviting vjay at some stage to re-join you. There is not a lot more that we can help him with really. It is just that he really does not understand the very basic concepts of homeopathic philosphy and refuses to study them either. He is trying to change practice without having done any himself and without studying the basics first. Not very clever to my mind anyway.

I think that David Johnson might have told you this already, but I will do so again. THE ONLY WAY TO SEE IF HOMEOPATHY WORKS OR NOT IS TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED.
 
Homeo said:
I think that David Johnson might have told you this already, but I will do so again. THE ONLY WAY TO SEE IF HOMEOPATHY WORKS OR NOT IS TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED.
Horsecrap.

Although, all my friends at the big pharmaceutical companies are just dying to be able to use this concept to market their products. Is it trademarked?

Arsenicum 1M? Is that legal?

~~ Paul
 
Homeoskeptic said:
There is also Lionel Milgrom who is a chemist and homeopath, who is now working on some quite ground breaking chemical research now, nothing at all to do with quantum theory. I attended one of his lectures recently and it was brilliant the kind of work he is doing at the moment.
And Milgrom's work has what to do with homeopathy?


I think that David Johnson might have told you this already, but I will do so again. THE ONLY WAY TO SEE IF HOMEOPATHY WORKS OR NOT IS TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED.
No, the only way is to conduct randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies.
 
This site:

http://sealrescue.org/homeopathy/repertory.html

has a homeopathic repertory page. It says:
EUTHANASIA - Used in conjunction with traditional euthanasia methods, ARSENICUM ALBUM 1m, can ease the transition.
I guess if you're going to die anyway . . .

I wonder if what this page says is true (http://www.inchem.org/documents/pims/chemical/pimg042.htm):
The main sources of human exposure to arsenic are:

- Ingestion of contaminated water and /or food, mainly in
environmentally exposed populations. Many outbreaks of
arsenic poisoning are related to ingestion of water
obtained from contaminated wells.

- Ingestion of medicinal/homeopathic preparations
containing arsenic.

- Malicious or criminal activity, or for suicidal attempts.

~~ Paul
 
Rather than simply repeating those laughably ridiculous assertions, Naturalhealth, would you care to get on to answering some of the questions we've been asking in the other threads?

For my own part, I recall asking:
  1. What sort of water did Hahnemann use to make his remedies? Why is it necessary to use anything of greater purity nowadays?
  2. How pure does the alcohol component have to be, and how is that achieved? Since the nature of the solvent would seem to be critical for any of those "memory" effects you all seem to believe in, what proportion of alcohol should it be? Was the right proportion used in the allegedly successful "memory" experiments you keep telling us about?
  3. Can it be repeatably shown that a group of people who get their prescribed remedy have, on average, a better chance of getting better than a comparable group who only thought they got their remedy? If so, where is you evidence? (And please don't start on Kleijnen, Boissel, Linde and Reilly, they have been discredited many times.)
  4. If you can distinguish between a remedy of your choice and a chemically identical placebo, why don't you want to apply for the million dollars? Why do you think this hasn't been won long ago?
    [/list=1]As a final one, I'd be quite interested in knowing why, if homoeopathy is so superior, it's still hovering around the quack fringes with no disease conquered and not even any agreement among its practitioners as to what to do to demonstrate to the sceptical that the remedies have any biological effect whatsoever.

    How long will it take you to understand that all your selected little anecdotes mean nothing? Just like the tales of heavy smokers who lived to be 95. Controlled studies, properly blinded and statistically valid, please.

    Oh, I forgot. They all came out negative.

    Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Homeopathic remedies can have powerful effects. When I was training a long time ago, a tutor told me of an experience she had with a fellow student when she was training. She said that her friend experimented with remedies and gave a remedy to his dog thereby killing it.

Remedies, given in the correct circumstances can aid people to a very comfortable death. A friend of mine when I was training told me about when her father was dying of cancer. He was extremely ill and was going to die, but was also very anxious and restless. This is a strong indication for Arsenicum. She decided to go to the ward and she gave her father an Arsenicum 1M. After he had this, he became extremely lucid for the next 24 hours and was able to say 'goodbye' to his wife and rest of his family and spent a very happy 24 hours with them. After this, he died peacefully in his sleep. The Arsenicum enabled him to have a little more lucid time with his family and then die very peacfully and comfortably indeed.

Which class do homeopaths take for this? "Validating With Anecdotes 101"

Seems all true believers in homeopathy must start with an validating anecdote before explaining to us simpletons the glory of tap water.

Now today class, we're going to discuss why you NEVER EVER use full names when giving an anecdote. And of course, the most obvious reason is that allopaths might actually track the person down to learn the truth of your story. So, always start your validating anecdotes with "A friend of my cousin's brother's friend"...
 
Homeoskeptic said:

There are simply hundreds of excellent medical doctors who are also practicing homeopaths. All you have to do is look at the list of the Faculty of Homeopathy and you will see this evidently from it. There are the likes of Brian Kaplan and Charles Forsyth, who have flourishing and very successful practices in Harley Street.


There are hundreds of accountants practicing fraud. Does that make it right?

Why do you think a doctor would establish a Harley Street homeopathic practice in the first place, rather than working nearly 50 hours a week in the NHS like I do? How do they guage their success?

Clue - Megabucks!
(a willing, gullible patient population with more money than sense helps).

Docs like that make me sick, anyway - sellouts to pseudoscience who are willing to sacrifice their principles IMHO
 
Rolfe said:
One problem is that it's not possible to do any quality control checking of the finished product. If only you could analyse a bottle and say, yes that is really 30C Belladonna! The best you could do would be unannounced spot checks to make sure that they really were doing all that diluting and succussing. And what about transport? Is it true that security x-rays inactivate the stuff? If so, should postal distribution be allowed?

The homoeopaths themselves disagree about the reliability of different manufacturers. This was one excuse tendered when Hans' self-proving didn't produce any results. It seems that if someone has a "bad" experience with a particular company's remedies (i.e. fewer patients than usual getting spontaneously better) they will assume that the preparation is at fault. The laugh is that of course this happens to each of them regarding a different manufacturer, so you will get one homoeopath slating a company while another swears by it.

I do agree about the remedies being labelled to make it clear that there is no active ingredient in them. (By the way, I think it's 12C, or 24X, beyond which there's nothing there.) The remedy bottle I had didn't make it clear, though it did list the contents as "sucrose/lactose", and say that it was "a homoeopathic preparation without approved therapeutic indication".

And what about precautions and contraindications? If it's really true that coffee antidotes Belladonna, for example, shouldn't there be an injunction not to drink coffee? And all the other possible interferences and antidotings that get dragged up as excuses when a sceptic's self-proving doesn't work? If all these things can stop the remedy working, they should be spelled out on the label.

You could argue that the "lower" potencies are no different from unregulated herbal remedies, except that they have less in them, but that's a whole new argument. This is a completely different quality of scam from herbal remedies, and needs to be examined on its own.

Rolfe.
1. Homeopathic producers to be licensed and controlled so they produce remedies to a homeopathic fully agreed and regulated "standard". Preferably to the same level of production standards as ordinary medicines. That is, good quality control. "Home manufactured" remedies to be outlawed as they will obviously not be consistently high quality (I'm assuming, possibly erroneously, that high quality medicine is not objected to by the homeopathic community).

2. For the high dilution remedies, no restrictions to be placed on sale or transport. No guarantees either, X-rays, postal, thought transference or otherwise. Contraindications can be passed on by labelling or even just word of mouth (why would this even be necessary?). Just like, say, soft drinks or bottled waters.

3. The cutoff point is to be the dilution level equal to Avogadro's Constant, however labelled - 25C?. Higher dilutions allowed free rein, lower get regulated like real medicine.

4. Lower dilution "homeopathic remedies" should be treated IN ALL RESPECTS as proper medicines including controlled manufacture and prescription (controlled substances), and DEFINITELY INCLUDING prosecution for illegal manufacture and/or distribution and/or prescription.

Incidentally, Homeoskeptic, there may be thousands of doctors who are homeopaths, but there are MANY MILLIONS who are not. Playing the anecdote numbers game - you will lose.
THE ONLY WAY TO SEE IF HOMEOPATHY WORKS OR NOT IS TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED
Oh, you just "suck it and see"? That is, you are really just guessing each and every time? Well, THAT sure sounds progressive and reliable... :nope:
 
DangerousBeliefs said:


Which class do homeopaths take for this? "Validating With Anecdotes 101"

Seems all true believers in homeopathy must start with an validating anecdote before explaining to us simpletons the glory of tap water.

Now today class, we're going to discuss why you NEVER EVER use full names when giving an anecdote. And of course, the most obvious reason is that allopaths might actually track the person down to learn the truth of your story. So, always start your validating anecdotes with "A friend of my cousin's brother's friend"...
It would be funny if it weren't so tragically depressing. One minute "it" is claiming to be a twenty-year medical professional, and the next minute "it" is outlining the friend-of-a-friend's dead dog stories on which it bases its conclusions and conducts it's practice.

How scary is that?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
She decided to go to the ward and she gave her father an Arsenicum 1M.


Arsenicum 1M? Do you mean a one molar solution of an arsenic containing compound? Surely a mistake?
 
Paul C. Anagnostopoulos said:
I think "1M" means diluted 1:1000.
Come in Geni! I can never remember this M stuff, because it doesn't seem to be what you'd expect it to be.

A dilution of 1:1,000 isn't ultramolar - it's still very much in the physological range. However, I have a letter in front of me from a homoeopath, one of my favourite "miracle cure" cases, where he asserts that a "10M" preparation of pulsatilla (windflower, I believe) cured a refractory Pasteurella respiratory infection in an elderly dachshund. This 10M preparation is also described as "a dilution with succussion" of 10<SUP> -20,000</SUP>.

The reason he gives for refuting any allegation of coincidental recovery is that the dog apparently required the "lower" potency of 1M of the same remedy as a single dose every 7 to 14 days, or else the symptoms returned. The 1M potency is described as 10<SUP> -2,000</SUP>.

I've no idea how he's calculating that, or how it's prepared either, but since the writer was at the time the President of the British Association of Homoeopathic Veterinary Surgeons, I assume he should know. And 10<SUP> -2,000</SUP> is pretty ultramolar by anyone's reckoning.

I think Geni knows exactly how they get to this, I remember him saying earlier. Care to remind us?

Rolfe.
 
10<sup>-2000</sup>? Wow! Look here:

http://www.hattonandlaws.com.au/homeopatheticlist.htm

Hold on! Is there a difference between 1m and 1M? No, I don't think so.

Look here:

http://www.explorepub.com/articles/shelton_11_6.html

Those two sites have completely different definitions for 1M.

I like this, too:
HOWEVER, in between each serial dilution, in order for the dilution to be truly considered Homeopathic, it has to be VIGOROUSLY SHAKEN against either a leather book (Hahneman used his Bible) or the palm of the hand. This vigorous shaking is called SUCCUSSION, and is an integral part of the Homeopathic process.
A leather book, you say? :eek:

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom