What Zep says is of course true, but I think Badly Shaved Monkey is making a more subtle point.
The homoeopaths like to maintain in public that their remedies are safe - how could they be otherwise, since there's nothing in them? Therefore, of course, there's no need at all to think about safety tests and regulation and licensing. We know this is really true, but think about it. If a preparation actually has a biological effect, it is at least theoretically possible that it may have undesirable effects. We accede to the "harmless" point of view because we don't believe the remedies have any biological effect at all, but the homoeopaths don't see it that way.
If you read the thread BSM linked to, you'll see the classic spectacle of homoeopaths fighting like ferrets in a sack because essentially they all just make it up as they go along, and over the years contradictions have built up and become firmly embedded in their literature. Some take one point of view, others another, and because there's no way of getting an objective answer they just go on fighting.
Poor Kumar (Vijay 0507)! He comes here and we beat up on him, he goes to H'pathy where you'd think they'd be more in tune with his mad thinking, and they beat up on him too. Remember that Naturalhealth is "our" Homeoskeptic, in its natural environment.
The discussion in the thread is about unpleasant and unwelcome effects which follow the giving of a homoeopathic remedy, believed to be caused by the remedy. However (as we teased out earlier in a different thread), by torturing the English language, these are defined as not being side-effects, because side-effects is something only "allopathic" medicine will produce, homoeopathy doesn't produce side-effects, these are aggravations or provings.
They still believe the remedies can cause unpleasant effects, though, even if they dress it up as a "healing crisis". I know John Hoare, a veterinary homooepath, believes that 30C remedies should be prescription only because of their potential for harm. One homoeopath (Anna Bryant) was very reluctant to consider the JREF Challenge because she believed that "proving" a remedy multiple times would be dangerous to her health.
When they get on to challenging sceptics to do a self-proving (as they do with monotonous regularity), it gets even more marked. Much gleeful speculation as to whether the sceptic might actually be made ill with the remedy. There's even a thread where one of them tried to figure out how to make Starburn ill (though as it all degenerated into suggestions of 1X arsenic in 10g doses, we can't take it too seriously). There's another good example from last year in
the Guardian's Bad Science column too.
There's no doubt they all agree that their remedies can make peple very unwell, and it's possible to do this deliberately if you're so inclined. They don't agree as to whether they can actually kill, but as I've seen a book review of a homoeopathic veterinary text which includes a homoeopathic method for "gentle euthanasia", I guess some people are confident that they can.
So should these preparations, which their users believe can be harmful or even dangerous, really be made freely available without any need for safety evaluation?
Rolfe.