Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Kumar said:
"..No, it cannot be both. Either it is perfectly save[-] [safe] or it might be dangerous under some circumstances.

Hans"

Why, it can be perfectly safe to remove all clothes of a .... naturally, but can be very dangerous- socially & moreover with the help of other community.

Under what circumstances is homeopathy "perfectly safe" and under what circumstances is it "very dangerous"?
 
Donks said:


Under what circumstances is homeopathy "perfectly safe" and under what circumstances is it "very dangerous"?

Under the premise that the patient is healty, or has a self-healable disease, homeopathy is perfectly safe. If homeopathic remedies are given to sick people that do not have a self-healable disease, then homeopathy could be lethal. And that’s the reason why in some countries, Sweden for instance, homoeopaths are by law not permitted to treat cancer or children under the age of 12 (could be another age, I’m not sure). Homeopaths fall under the law of quacking in Sweden.
 
Rolfe said:
Oh, here we go again. Every time Olaf doesn't understand what I've said, I'm "lying".

*snip*
Rolfe.
Which means that in olaf's world, you are lying a LOT ;).

Kumar: It's just that some people use misspelling of names as an insult (most of us probably do this from time to time). I know this was not your intent, but to avoid misunderstandings...

About switching: Actually, I think we both know that the traffic between conventinal medicine and alternative is very much in favor of conventional medicine. I'm in the diabetes business, and whenever we help opening a diabetes clinic somewhere, people are literally flocking.

Donks (welcome btw :) ): Now the only way I can imagine homeopathy being perfectly safe is by it having absolutely no effect. All experience shows that any medicine that has an effect can be dangerous if applied wrong. However, some of the homeopaths (but certainly not all) do in fact claim that it is safe, apparantly because they think it is magically able to only work on disease.

I might add that Hahnemann does NOT consider homepathy perfectly safe, quite the contrary.

Hans
 
Hi Rolfe,

"but be assured that we're not laughing at what you were saying at H'pathy"

Sorry, you totally misunderstood. I mentioned " on post-me postings" which means posting by others after me. They are really misunderstanding. Frankly, they got irritated because I kept my finger on some weak points which were paining. Btw, who is ' grm1 ' & why they said Hans to Rolfe?

Thanks for other comments. I shall soon post new topics, but I am bit tense for some social function between 29-3rd & some guests are expected. I have to be tense free, but I will take other issue first related to the mother system, otherwise it may not be justified in comparisn.

You can find so many sites by google search-- Tissue Remedies, Cell Salts, Schuessler's Twelve Tissue Remedies, Biochemic homeopathic.

Refer: http://www.indiangyan.com/books/homeopathybooks/biochemic_treatment/twelve_tissue.shtml

http://homeoinfo.com/08_non-classical_topics/minimal/schuesslers_cell_salts.php

http://www.arrowroot.com/cellinfo.htm

http://www.ibiblio.org/herbmed/eclectic/journals/elth1909/01-tissue-rem.html

http://www.homeoint.org/books5/dewey/chapter6-6.htm

http://www.google.co.in/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=Twelve+Tissue+Remedies&btnG=Search&meta=
 
Hans: Thanks.

Hans and Anders: I was hoping to get the "homeopathic" answer (i.e. from Kumars), to get some sort of testable claim, by drinking a couple of glasses of the stuff or whatever :).
 
Donks: Testable claims? From homeopaths?? Hehehe, I can see you are new at this game. Good try, however, just don't hold your breath.

Kumar: I don't know who grm1 is. And I dont know who is using the name Rolfe and a slightly rephrased version of my signature, heheh. Bach immidiately jumps to conclusions, but then, that's just Bach ;).

Let me say right now, though, that if any of these people want to talk to me (fat chance btw :rolleyes: ), they can find me here.

Hans
 
Donks said:
Hans: Thanks.

Hans and Anders: I was hoping to get the "homeopathic" answer (i.e. from Kumars), to get some sort of testable claim, by drinking a couple of glasses of the stuff or whatever :).
Ok, good luck Donks: Hpaths are not that good in submitting testable claims or test results, but they seem very keen on dismissing negative test results
 
olaf said:
"It's a good omen, because it's saying quantum entanglement can survive when you might not expect it to," says Bill Barnes, a photonics expert at the University of Exeter. "If they can survive this, what else can they survive?"
I wrote that quantum effects don't have any measurable effect in the macroscopic world. i.e quantum effects work their thing on stuff like leptons and quarks. Nobody has seen any entanglement between anything larger then a lepton, which I pointed out earlier. And, yes, there are a discipline called quantum chemistry. And that discipline exists because all bindings in chemistry include the electromagnetic force, which is caused be the positive positrons and the negative electrons. To explain a why some reactions take place and why some reactions are so darn fast, we need quantum physics.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Donks: Testable claims? From homeopaths?? Hehehe, I can see you are new at this game. Good try, however, just don't hold your breath.
Hans

Oh :) Yeah, I'm pretty new to this homeopathy deal.
I do work next door to Boiron, maybe I can go over and ask them if they are quacks :)
 
You do? Cool! Could you find out if they use the single vial method?

That is, for each dilution step, instead of extracting part of the solution, putting it in a new vial and filling up with medium before the next succussion, the vial is simply emptied and refilled. It is then assumed that a suitable portion is sticking to the sides of the vial.

Needless to say this method is much easier and cheaper. And needless to say, it is wildly imprecise.

Hans
 
Donks said:


Oh :) Yeah, I'm pretty new to this homeopathy deal.
I do work next door to Boiron, maybe I can go over and ask them if they are quacks :)

Considering the amount of money they are making from their products (they are an impressively profitable company) I would sincerely hope that they do at least believe in what they are selling.
 
Mr.Hans, Rolfe & other science personalities,

One senier member had previously presented some scientific basis of vital force & scientific experiment with justification of proving the higher potencies at:

http://www.hpathy.com/forum/display_topic_threads.asp?ForumID=8&TopicID=1309&PagePosition=1

Being knowing least science( not logics), I could not understand his theory & claims. Since you are scientific personalities, can you give your comments on same. HS & other pros pl participate.

Sorry to bother you. Regards.
 
On Boiron:

I think not. They talk a lot about scientific testing on their webpage, but I have not seen one report of a test funded by them. .... And I don't have any difficulty in quessing why :rolleyes:. Since they MUST know that their already nice income would skyrocket if they could present scientific proof of the function of their produce, there can only be two reasons for the absense of tests from them:

1) They are pretty sure it doesn't work.

2) They DID test it and the tests were negative (and were binned).

They HAVE, however, supplied the medicines for some of the tests out there, which I find highly suspect. Any test protocol that I would find acceptable would surely include some way to ensure that the supplier did not slip some active ingredient into the stuff supplied.

Hans
 
Donks said:
Under what circumstances is homeopathy "perfectly safe" and under what circumstances is it "very dangerous"?
Hi Donks!

In another vain attempt to drag this thread back on-topic, could I be forgiven for reposting something I posted a couple of pages back? It went....

Now, if the remedies really do have a biological effect, I think we can all agree fairly easily that it is dangerous. Nobody understands the effect, "powerful" remedies are available with virtually no instructions over-the-counter, and we only have to look at the homoeopaths' own forums for tales of nasty aggravations and unpleasant proving effects and amateur wannabees messing things up. Not to mention Souresh Ebrahimi, who wanted to make Ben Goldacre very ill with homoeopathy.

Funny there aren't multiple reports of serious harm being caused by all these little sugar pills Boots sells, isn't it?

But even if they don't have any biological effect, can we say homoeopathy is safe? Of course not.
  • Real illness may go untreated, long enough to compromise the patient's health, if content-free remedies are relied on.
  • Unregulated remedies may be irresponsibly prepared by rougue pharmacies, and instead of being content-free, something quite nasty might unwittingly be dispensed.
  • The lack of regulation around the whole area opens the door for unscrupulous vendors to label as homoeopathic preparations which should be licensed as real medicine, with dangerous consequences - as happened in the Zicam affair.
Wow, back on-topic after all these pages!

[End quote.] This summarises my feelings on the matter, which pretty much add up to "potentially very dangerous".

Kumar, understand that when we say something is dangerous, that doesn't mean harm will inevitably result every time. You may cross a very dangerous road many times without coming to harm, but that doesn't mean it is safe. You wouldn't say, "this road is perfectly safe to cross except on those occasions when someone is actually hit by a car," would you?

If homoeopathic remedies really do have a biological effect as claimed, then you are risking your health every time you take one, because virtually nothing is known about how they work and how they affect the body. In particular, the sale of such remedies over the counter to anyone at all, with almost no instructions on the bottle, is surely extremely hazardous.

And even if the remedies have no biological effect, as I've explained above, there are circumstances where they could easily cause harm and are known to have caused harm, either by serious illnesses going untreated, or the bottle not actually containing the nothing at all that it's supposed to contain.

So, just because quite a lot of the time no harm seems to come from popping a few sugar pills, my vote is still with "dangerous".

Rolfe.
 
MRC_Hans said:
And I dont know who is using the name Rolfe and a slightly rephrased version of my signature, heheh.
Hey, is someone calling themselves "Rolfe" on H'pathy? How come I never noticed? Since when? Can you show me where?

For the record, I don't post on the homoeopaths' forums. And I don't post anywhere else using the name "Rolfe". (Oh, I did once, about last September, when I first adopted the handle, BSM knows where that was as he was there too - but apart from that, nothing labelled "Rolfe" is me.) I don't have any copyright on the name, but I do reject anything said by whoever that is.

Seems a bit pointless really - I'd always assumed that "Rolfe" would get an instant banning order at either HH or H'pathy, anyway.

Rolfe (the real one!) :c1:
 
Kumar said:
One senier member had previously presented some scientific basis of vital force & scientific experiment with justification of proving the higher potencies at:

http://www.hpathy.com/forum/display_topic_threads.asp?ForumID=8&TopicID=1309&PagePosition=1
Sorry, Kumar, I don't mean to be dismissive, but I've already read that post you link too because BSM nominated it for "woo of the week" very recently. We appreciated it very much because it was so very funny.

I'm afraid, though, that it is a complete pile of nonsense. Nothing of any sense or reality is said throughout the entire stream of words. It's not science at all, it's just a story he has made up.

Actually, I thought what you said at the time was very sensible.
I previously had long discussions about various possibilities as per physics like Potential Energy stored on applying kinetic Energy, Molecular Forces, Electrostatic energy, memory of water, energy due to orbit change etc. But all these were denied on scientific grounds. Frankly, we can not think of going beyond atomic level materialistically as it is not easy to divide an atom
Rolfe.
 
Ah, good, Kumar! I was almost tempted to register a sockpuppet there to answer that nonsense, but they'd just delete my post.

By somebody called val_drjkr:

“ My own artistic and scientific understanding of the vital force, the dynamic power and its activities in health and diseases.” This is my conclusion of thirty-five years of continuous study of organon of medicine.

He must be a pretty slow reader. The OOM is long, for sure, but 35 years??? .... Sorry, couldn't resist that little joke. I shall try to be more serious ;).

(1) The dynamic power is an abundant force, which are the cause and the result of nature.

If it is abundant, how come we haven't noticed it. The forces of nature have been researched VERY thoroughly.

(2) The dynamic power is same in living and non-living things.

(3) The dynamic power is same in health and disease.

(4) The dynamic power has exclusive presence, acquiring different types of sizes and shapes. It is smaller than smallest and bigger than biggest.

Excuse me, but isn't this really the same as saying that it it is invisible and undetectable? Then why should we suppose it exists?

(5) In the form of morbific power, the dynamic power is the cause of disease and in the form of similimum, the dynamic power becomes the cause of cure.

That is just mumbo-jumbo.

Our Master has already stated that Homoeopathy is an art of healing and a science too. Why?

Enter the religious angle. "Our master" indeed.

Because he knew that lot of criticism will have to be faced regarding the efficacy and the material existence of homoeopathic dilutions by the existing medical world. It was important to prove the efficacy of homoeopathy than to prove the material existence of homoeopathy in those days. Hence he kept the question of material existence un-touched and worked through out the life to prove the efficacy of homeopathy.

Too bad he did not leave any reports of all that testing.

Modern science believes in the results of experiments performed by mathematical and the laboratory experiments.

Not entirely true, but accepted for the time being.

The basic experiments of homoeopathy are the results of observations of nature by eyes-only.

Which is exactly why we challenge them.

No one can deny the truth experienced by his own eyes.

This is provably wrong. It is not difficult to design an experiment that proves that you CANNOT always trust your own eyes.

Hence Dr. Hahnemann says that observations and its results experienced by naked eyes are only scientific proof of homoeopathy.

Yes, that is what he says, and he is wrong. Even in his own time, subjective observations were being rejected by science, so he cannot be excued by ignorance.

Today the science does not have such an acute scale which can detect material existence of our dilutions as well as power created in our dilutions by trituration or potentisation.

Just a moment! Even Hahnemann acknowledges that no original substance remains in high potencies. (You see, I read the OOM too, although I took a little less than 35years)

So instead of proving homoeopathy as a science he devoted whole of his life in proving the scientific efficacy of homoeopathy to the medical world of his time.

Apart from being self-contradicting, this statement begs the question: How come he failed, then?

According to the recent molecular theory, science says that there is no material existence of drug in 30th potency of homoeopathic dilutions.

And Hahnemann agrees.

Now I will state a simple naked eye experiment to prove homoeopathy as a science.

Come, we will go to sea with one kg of sugar with us. Now I will throw this sugar in front of all of you in the sea at particular place and I will collect the sample from that particular place containing the thrown sugar in it.

Now I will send this sample of water to laboratory for detecting sugar in it. After performing several tests, according the Avagadro’s law and molecule detecting tests, the laboratory authority gives the report that the sample sent for test does not contain sugar in it. How lies the science? So homoeopathy believes in truth observed by naked eyes only. An observing eye does not need any Laboratory to detect the truth. Many, many years after the time will come that these scientists will become successful in inventing that acute machine which will detect the sugar in the sample provided by me. Then they will have to admit the dynamic existence of homoeopathic drugs. Till then we will have to say that homoeopathy is more an art of healing than a science.

Ye olde sugar in the ocean nonsense. OK let's pick this one apart once and for all:

If you put a kg of sugar into the ocean, the ocean contains a (at least) kg of sugar, period. Science does not deny or refute this. What science DOES say is that once that sugar is distributed over the ocean, the probability that a molecule of it is present in "ONE SAMPLE" is low. But if you somehow analyzed the whole ocean, you would find all your sugar (unless some micro-organisms had eaten it in the mean-time, of course).

However, this has NOTHING WHATSOEVER to do with the way homeoathic drugs are prepared, because here, the major part of the solution is discarded at each step, so that at each step, most of the original substance is REMOVED from the sample.


(1) The dynamic power is an abundant force, which is the cause and result of nature.

Yes, the dynamic power is an abundant force. According my own study and naked eye observation of nature through homoeopathic eyes. I understand that all the planets, even the sun is in continuous motion. The sun is moving around itself. All the other planets are also moving around themselves and while doing this all of them are moving around the sun too. Why, who is enabling them to do so?

Uhhh, what has this to do with the subject at hand? The powers that move the sun and the planets are well understood and has nothing to do with homeopathy.

It is that dynamic power which is doing all this. *snip*

No. Simply put, no.

Our master advocated the doctrine of trituration and potentisation in minus dilution and gave anti-clockwise motion with stroke to create the negative dynamic power in homoeopathic drugs.

Ehr, no he did not. Not in the version I read, that is. And even if he did somewhere, since we lack any evidence of the dynamic power, this is moot.

Hence homoeopathic drugs are full of negative dynamic power which makes them immortal, abundant. If kept in proper environmental conditions homoeopathic drugs never expires.

No they will always remain what they are: Water.

This naked eye observation of mine enables me to state that the dynamic power is an abundant force, which is the cause and result of nature.

I must assume that he refers to his naked eye observation of Hahnemann's text. I'm less than impressed.

(2) The dynamic power is same in living and non-living things.

According to molecular theory of physics the substance, a non-living thing is a bunch of particular molecules. A force known as intra-molecular force binds theses molecules with each other to form a particular substance. What this intra-molecular force is? It is nothing but the same dynamic power recognized by other name. About living things, Dr. Hahnemann has already cleared the role of this dynamic power, the vital force in Organon of medicine. Hence the dynamic power is same in living and non-living things.

In the process of claiming all natural forces for the "dynamic force". OK, fine, lets play it that way (after all, what's in a name?). However, if that be the case, then your "dynamic force" is very well explored by science, and I can tell you with great assurance that it cannot do what homeopathy claims it to do.

(3) The dynamic power is same in health and disease.

When we are healthy, the dynamic power keeps each and every organ in well functioning conditions means the harmony. Even all the minute Physiological metabolisms of our bodies are also governed by this dynamic power only.

Disease means the disturbance created by morbid dynamic power in health. It is the other face of a coin. It is the different mode of action of the same dynamic power. According to Organon of medicine, it is this morbid dynamic power which is the only cause of diseases. Not the bacteria or the viruses. When we are healthy this dynamic power works as an army for us. Whenever these bacteria or the viruses try to enter in our body, the army I mean the white blood corpuscles attack these bacteria and viruses and kill them to maintain the health. Now how these bacteria get entry in our body?

Claiming the immune system for the "dynamic power" too, now. Sorry, but that doesn't fly. If you acknowledge the role of the immune system, you must also acknowledge micro organisms as pathenogens, and as comes clear in the following, you don't. You cannot have your cake and eat it.

According to homeopathy the morbid dynamic power affects the body at three different layers. First the mental layer is disturbed by morbid dynamic power producing the symptoms like loss of interest in daily work, uneasiness, anxiety, depression, disturbances in sleep etc. Secondly this morbid dynamic power affects the emotional layer Producing symptoms like sudden anger, causeless quarrelling with others, weeping, beating others, anorexia, delusions etc. This is the layer where your susceptibility gets deviated and your vital force (dynamic power) becomes weak, the army of your body put its weapons down and the other morbid agents like bacteria and viruses enter your body. This is the time where the morbid dynamic power enters the third layer, the physical layer giving all sorts of physical sings and symptoms. Your physiological laboratory reports go wrong and discharges of your body shows the presence of different bacteria when stained for microscopic examinations. So it is wrong to consider bacteria and viruses are the actual cause of the disease. It is the morbid dynamic power, which is the actual cause of the diseases. Hence the dynamic power is same in health and diseases.

Basically reiterating what Hahnemann says, but that won't fly either. If that was so, how come inocculation with cowpox will protect against smallpox? Curiously, Hahnemann knew and acknowledged this, even though it proves that the micro-organism is the CAUSE of the disease.

(4) The dynamic power has exclusive presence, acquiring different types of sizes and shapes. It is smaller than smallest and bigger than biggest.

As we all know whole of this universe is full of dynamic power.

Ehr, no. We all don't know this. Claiming it doesn't make it so.

Each and every thing is saturated with this dynamic power only. So it acquires the different sizes and different shapes everywhere. Even the space between the two things is not empty. The looking eye must be a homeopathic eye only. The dynamic power is smaller than smallest. Yes, look at Amoeba, the unicellular life on the earth. It is also governed by this dynamic power only. Saturation of biggest amount of this dynamic power is the Sun.

So I say that the dynamic power is smaller than smallest and bigger than biggest.

And I disagree.


(5) In the form of morbific power, the dynamic power is the cause of disease and in the form of similimum, the dynamic power becomes the cause of cure.

We all know that the cause of all the diseases is the other face of the same dynamic power known as morbid dynamic power.

No we do not all know this. It is the claim of homeopathy, but that calim has to be substantiated. To use this as proof of homeopathy, is circular argumentation.

Now we will see how our master succeeded in eliciting this dynamic power in a curative dynamic power through qualities of the drug, capable of producing the similar disease in a healthy person during drug proving. We all know that Dr. Hahnemann was an eminent pharmacist as well as the eminent physician of his time.

Actually, we have no evience that he was especially eminent.

After discovery of homeopathy he knew that the cinchona bark has qualities of producing malaria like symptoms in a healthy person, which only can cure the similar totality of symptoms in a diseased person.

Not quite right. It seems that it was the observation that cinchona bark produced malaria-like symptoms AND relieved malaria that, at least partly, gave him the idea of homeopathy.

Cinchona bark was capable of reliving malaria in huge and repeated doses. These huge and repeated doses of cinchona bark started causing side effects like fibrosis of liver and spleen resulting in death of the patients. So Dr. Hahnemann minimized the dose while treating malaria like symptomatology. He observed that the minimization of doses did not work in curing malaria. He did not stop but remained firm in his findings of qualities of cinchona bark and started experimenting of improving the preparation of dugs and testing them on diseased persons.

Uhh, aren't you saying here that the diluted version FAILED? ..Interesting.


Both of you know that I meditate daily at 3 a.m. So one day, thinking about why our master advocated anticlockwise rotation for potentising the drugs, I went in deep concentration and the following chain of thoughts appeared in my mind.

As we all know Dr. Hahnemann had God gifted observing eye, while experimenting, one day he might have thought that whole of this world is in constant motion.

Speculating wildly here....

So why not to apply one of these laws of motions to cinchona to elicit the qualities of cinchona bark in minutely diluted solution and test that preparation on the diseased? He being gifted with observing eye, Noticed that each and every thing of this universe is in a definite motion from right to left means the clockwise motion. He considered zero as the healthy stage of dynamic power. So zero stage means the When the morbid dynamic power gets added to this zero stage, means to the health, this zero stage advances towards + side disturbing the susceptibility to +1, +3, +6, +12, +30, +200, till +1M, +10M, +50M, +CM, +DM, +MM. Here at +MM stage (ending stage of life), the dynamic power of the patient becomes weaker than weakest and leaves the body for ever resulting the death.

Entirely private speculations. Hahnemann says nothing of this. And, it is basically mumbo-jumbo.

So the logical mind of Dr. Hahnemann might have thought that if I can create the Negative artificial dynamic power in the diluted solution of cinchona bark, may help in curing malaria like symptomatology of the patients. So the observing eye of Dr. Hahnemann might have noticed, the clockwise motion of whole of the universe as + ve motion and he might have thought that to create artificial negative dynamic power in drug I must rotate the diluted solution of cinchona bark in anti-clockwise direction. He might have diluted cinchona bark powder by 1 in 9 part of lactose and might have given 100 times anti-clockwise trituration to make the first potency of our cinchona bark (China). He repeated the same procedure to prepare the 6th potency.

Might have.... maybe... :rolleyes:

When he gave this potenticed dose of cinchona to the patient suffering from malaria, cured malaria within no time. That might be the golden day in the history of homeopathy.

Uhh, do explain why this did not have any impact on malaria treatment? If Hahnemann really di find a miraculois cure back in the early 19th century, how come malaria is still a problem t othis day? You know, a homeoath once told me: The proof of the pudding is in the eating it; so where is the pudding?

Here I will not forget to tell you how Dr. Hahneman might have applied the second law of motion discovered by the great scientist of physics Mr. Newton.

Do I have to explain to anybody why this is nonsense?

“ The action and reactions are equal and opposite”

And this is homeopathy?????

Disease means weakening of vital force, the dynamic power by natural morbid dynamic power. We call this as susceptibility. Now according to day today practice of homeopathy, when a patient comes to you for treatment. You collect the totality of symptoms and decide which potency of the similium is to be given.
According to your own experience and judgment, you decide the susceptibility (weakness of vital force, the natural dynamic power) and give -30th potency of the similimum. Your patient is having +30th potency of disease (weakness of his own dynamic power) and you gave him –30th potency means you introduce –30th type of similar artificial dynamic disease in him. Here, the reaction takes place. The natural +30th dynamic power clashes with your –30th artificial dynamic power. Second law of motion of Newton says that two equal and opposite forces are equal and opposite. That means when two opposite and equal forces meet to-gather they cause the reaction so the same reaction occurs in your patient. +30th potency of natural susceptibility clashes with –30th potency of your artificial susceptibility induced by similimum making both of these forces to causes a reaction to make the effect of first force opposite, neutral. Zero. That is called the health.

All this - and + potencies are new to me. Certainly, Hahnemann does not mention it and it plays no part in the way HE explains how homeopathy works. Actually it sounds more like antipathy. I think this writer is trying to rewrite homeopathy.

*snip*
Hence, my enthusiastic children I appeal to you both that God has already given you the biggest homeopathic laboratory to experiment. This laboratory is your own two eyes and the nature. Try to co-relate your findings with physics. Apply any law of physics to your naked eye observations of nature and discover other hidden laws of homeopathy from the nature for the best cause of homeopathy. These are my blessings to both of you on this occasion of my fifty-ninth birthday.

Excuse me while I barf.

Note that this is evidently a letter from somebody, addressed at two persons. We can only hope that val_drjkr has the right to publish it.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
On Boiron:

I think not. They talk a lot about scientific testing on their webpage, but I have not seen one report of a test funded by them. ....
Actually, it is my information that they were the people who funded Benveniste. :nope:

Nice, safe project. If he managed to find something, hey, great! But if not, or if it all turned out to be a horrible mistake (as it did), well, what does it matter? We've just drawn a blank on that particular theory of mode of action.

The tests they are prepared to do start from the premise that there is an effect there. What they are not prepared to test is whether or not that effect exists. This is odd, because it should be a very simple thing to do. There are three basic ways to approach this.
  1. The clinical trial. Simply take a fairly large group of patients with fairly comparable clinical presentations, and send them all to the homoeopaths. Allow as much individualisation and so on as the homoeopaths think appropriate. However, only half the group actually gets their prescribed remedy, while the other half gets a placebo. NOBODY knows who got what until all the measurements and assessments of clinical response have been done. Then look to see if the people who got their remedy on average did significantly better that those who didn't. I only know two published trials that did this, and both were completely negative. Neither was funded by Boiron.
  2. The group proving. Get a large enough group of healthy volunteers, the sort of people who usually do homoeopathic provings, and do a proving on them. Only, once again, half of them get the real remedy and the other half just think they're getting the remedy. See whether the group that got the real remedy have any more interesting symptoms in their diaries than the sham group. This has been done five times (though two of these were pilot studies for two of the others), results negative. None funded by Boiron. (All these studies are dismissed by the homoeopaths, because although the scientists who carried them out got the proving protocols designed or approved by homoeopaths, no homoeopaths agree on what the protocol should be, so of course if the result was negative the protocol must have been at fault.)
  3. The self-proving. This is the easiest one of all. Just ask an experienced homoeopath to choose any remedy they think they can reliably prove, and see whether they can tell by proving it whether they've been given the remedy they chose, or a placebo. Of course this has to be repeated often enough to be sure that the homoeopath isn't just a lucky guesser - 15 or 20 repetitions would settle it very conclusively. However, many homoeopaths insist that proving a remedy 7 or 10 times would in all likelihood make them very ill, so they will not try it - even though they could win the Million Dollar Challenge if they succeeded. (Yeah, real safe stuff, this!) Anyway, the way round that is to recruit 15 or 20 homoeopaths, and give each one either the remedy they chose or a placebo, at random. If a significant majority got it right, this would by very good evidence in favour of homoeopathy having an effect. This experiment, despite its simplicity, has never been tried. Why not? Because experienced homoeopaths cannot be found who will agree to participate. I wonder why not?[/list=1]A decent level of statistical significance in any one of these tests, which was found to be free from cheating and which was reproducible by multiple centres, would convince the entire world that homoeopathic remedies have a biological effect. Chemists and physicists would be all over the phenomenon looking for the mechanism of action which would change our entire basic understanding of how the universe works.

    The snag is of course that these experiments also potentially falsify homoeopathy. Repeated negative results from well-conducted trials wouldn't just mean we had to design different tests or look somewhere else for the effect, they would actually provide proof of the NON-effect of homoeopathic remedies.

    So of course Boiron don't mind throwing some money at Benveniste to count basophils, because if he fails, this doesn't falsify their basic moneymaking assumption. But it's left to the non-homoeopaths to do the potentially falsifying experiments, because the homoeopaths have a vested interest in not falsifying their beliefs.

    Of course real science is all about testing the falsifyability of beliefs. Hypotheses become accepted precisely because they have resisted everyone's best efforts to knock them over. A good scientist will relish trying to knock his own hypothesis over, because it is only by trying to do this that he can develop confidence that he's on the right track. Homoeopaths, on the other hand, simply declare that they know they're right, and studiously avoid the simple tests which would reveal whether or not that is true.

    Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
Hey, is someone calling themselves "Rolfe" on H'pathy? How come I never noticed? Since when? Can you show me where?

For the record, I don't post on the homoeopaths' forums. And I don't post anywhere else using the name "Rolfe". (Oh, I did once, about last September, when I first adopted the handle, BSM knows where that was as he was there too - but apart from that, nothing labelled "Rolfe" is me.) I don't have any copyright on the name, but I do reject anything said by whoever that is.

Seems a bit pointless really - I'd always assumed that "Rolfe" would get an instant banning order at either HH or H'pathy, anyway.

Rolfe (the real one!) :c1:

Here

Seems I get all the credit. But then they hardly know you over there ;).

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Here

Seems I get all the credit. But then they hardly know you over there ;).
Oh. Well, it's not me. I'm surprised it isn't banned yet.

Hey, I wonder if it's Prester John? We played "Spartacus" at one point, with him announcing "I am Rolfe", and I suggested after he was banned he go over there as "Rolfe" and really confuse the poor dears. Who knows?

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom