exarch
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 2003
- Messages
- 7,184
HS, let's get one thing straight here:Originally posted by Homeoskeptic
"From all the exposure recently (e.g., the BBC Horizon program, 'negative trial results on Arnica, and associated bad press reportage), one could be forgiven for thinking that any attempt to reconcile homeopathy with science is simply a waste of time. After all, even though plenty of trials have been done, many of which support homeopathy, it must be patently obvious to anyone with even half a brain, that no amount of testing is going to persuade non- believers that homeopathy works or, on the contrary, dissuade believers that it doesn't. So, why bother? Scientifically speaking, we haven't even begun to scratch the surface of what homeopathy is really about and to predict that ultimately when we do, homeopathy and science will both benefit.
OK, in the context of homeopathy, what is 'science'? Bigger and better double blind placebo-controlled trials (DBPCTS) on potentised remedies, as the conventional scientific community would wish? I don't think so.
There would be a deafening outcry for ever more DBPCTs if they should favor homeopathy, and "Nya, nya, we told you so!” if they shouldn't, simply underlining the strength of feeling that homeopathic issues generate (and objectivity can sometimes be the first casualty in this debate). In my view, ever more DBPCTs merely prolong a stultifying and inconclusive ideological trench warfare between two opposing factions - on the one hand, conventional biomedicine and its hard-line reductionist (i.e., Newtonian) determinism, and on the other, homeopathy and any other CAM whose mechanism of healing doesn't neatly fit in with bio-medicine's reductionist paradigm.
Scientists aren't interested in making the homeopaths look like fools. they just want to find out if homeopathy does as claimed. If it does, they will be the first to endorse their findings too.
Unlike you, we don't have any vested interest in it. We don't make our living scamming gullible people with sugar tablets and bottles of water, so we don't care either way if homeopathy is proven to work or not. You however ...
And despite your false claims, there really aren't "many trials which support homeopathy". In fact, the one thing we kept asking you lot over at H'pathy, and which you could never provide, was details or even links to trials which came up favorably for homeopathy. All you could come up with was three measely meta-analyses that just showed that there might have been something there, but it could just have been dumb luck. Conclusion on all three studies "Further study will prove if there really was anything there". Further studies never got published because they probably showed it actually was just coincidence.