Homeopathic Cough Medicine

However, is Vicks Medinite an over-the-counter medicine? I never recall seeing it on any shelves in U.S. drugstores.
I don't know if it's in the U.S., but yes, it is OTC in the UK. And it is manufactured by Proctor and Gamble.


Also, I note that the BMJ article concludes:

"It remains unclear whether over the counter cough preparations are helpful in acute cough. We therefore cannot yet recommend these medicines as first line treatment for cough associated with upper respiratory tract infection. The NHS encourages self treatment for acute self limiting illnesses, and the use of over the counter cough preparations as a home remedy.
In other words, don't use the medicine for what it is not designed for. Instead, use it only for what it is designed for.


Although these medicines are generally well tolerated, their purchase could lead to unnecessary expense for the healthcare consumer.
Isn't it refreshing that the evil big-pharma conspiracy would publicize cautions about its own products so that consumers don't waste their money or risk their health?

Tell me where the same concern is demonstrated in the big-homeo industry.


The advice to use over the counter cough medicines should therefore be restricted until more evidence becomes available on their effectiveness."
Ditto above.

Do you think "restricted" means "prohibited?" Or does it more probably mean "dispensed judiciously?"


I have to commend you, Rodney. You've done an admirable job of turning this thread from a discussion of bs homeopathic remedies to a labeling issue about cough medicines. Even when people agree with some of your points, you keep the discussion away from homeopathy.

Why do you feel the need to avoid discussing homeopathic remedies?

Don't tell me. I think I know.
 
Okay, thanks, (Dr.) Linda. I have found this sentence in the BMJ article: "In a crossover trial of Vicks Medinite syrup, 58% of participants rated active treatment good or better in relieving cough symptoms compared with 32% for placebo." However, is Vicks Medinite an over-the-counter medicine? I never recall seeing it on any shelves in U.S. drugstores.

I didn't know where you were from. It appears to be a preparation available in the UK. The equivalent in the US would be Vicks 44 Cold (or Tylenol Flu Night Time). (Both OTC)

Also, I note that the BMJ article concludes:

"It remains unclear whether over the counter cough preparations are helpful in acute cough. We therefore cannot yet recommend these medicines as first line treatment for cough associated with upper respiratory tract infection. The NHS encourages self treatment for acute self limiting illnesses, and the use of over the counter cough preparations as a home remedy. Although these medicines are generally well tolerated, their purchase could lead to unnecessary expense for the healthcare consumer. The advice to use over the counter cough medicines should therefore be restricted until more evidence becomes available on their effectiveness."

The only people that really care about the conclusion section of a research article are the authors. It is the point at which the authors try to justify their own biases. In this case, there are several equally valid conclusions that could be reached, depending upon your own inclinations.

Linda
 
I don't know if it's in the U.S., but yes, it is OTC in the UK. And it is manufactured by Proctor and Gamble.
However, when I clicked the link, I received this message:

"The product you have selected (Vicks Medinite 180ml) is a Pharmacy Medicine, the supply of which is controlled by strict government regulations. For your safety, these regulations require that you complete the short form below, so we can ensure that the medicine is suitable for you. Our Pharmacist will view the information you enter before your medicine is dispensed. By law, all online pharmacies must follow this procedure."

So, Vicks Medinite in the UK does not appear comparable to OTC cough medicines in the United States.

Isn't it refreshing that the evil big-pharma conspiracy would publicize cautions about its own products so that consumers don't waste their money or risk their health?
I never said big drug companies are evil, but I'm not sure they want rigorous testing of their OTC cough medicines.

I have to commend you, Rodney. You've done an admirable job of turning this thread from a discussion of bs homeopathic remedies to a labeling issue about cough medicines.
My points are: (a) The "homeopathic" cough medicine cited by Moochie in the opening post has, in all probability, never been tested, and so we can't assume it is not efficacious. In fact, we can't even assume it's homeopathic. However, anything labeled as homeopathic incurs the wrath of most folks here. (b) When I first posted on this thread, I was not aware that any OTC cough medicine had been proven efficacious above placebo. Thanks to Linda, it appears that I was wrong, but the evidence regarding the efficacy of OTC cough medicines still appears tenuous.

Even when people agree with some of your points, you keep the discussion away from homeopathy.

Why do you feel the need to avoid discussing homeopathic remedies?

Don't tell me. I think I know.
As far as I know, I've never used a homeopathic product, but I don't agree with the consensus here that homeopathy has been completely discredited.
 
I didn't know where you were from. It appears to be a preparation available in the UK. The equivalent in the US would be Vicks 44 Cold (or Tylenol Flu Night Time). (Both OTC)
Okay, thanks.

The only people that really care about the conclusion section of a research article are the authors. It is the point at which the authors try to justify their own biases. In this case, there are several equally valid conclusions that could be reached, depending upon your own inclinations.
Linda
So what's your overall evaluation of OTC cough medicines? When do you recommend taking them and when do you recommend avoiding them? Any favorites?
 
...but I don't agree with the consensus here that homeopathy has been completely discredited.
Oh, I know of a major killer that any ultra-molar homeopathic preparation WILL assist with - proven too. Diarrhea. The only thing you need to ensure it works is to administer an hourly dosage: one drop diluted in 400ml of clean water each time. The same remedy also helps with dehydration.

;)
 
Rodney are you trying to say that cough medicine is not effective at suppressing coughing, or that it is not effective at curing a cough?

LLH
 
...As far as I know, I've never used a homeopathic product, but I don't agree with the consensus here that homeopathy has been completely discredited.

So tell us which particular type of homeopath cough medicine does work. Give us the brand, list of ingredients and the study that showed it to work on coughs.
 
As far as I know, I've never used a homeopathic product, but I don't agree with the consensus here that homeopathy has been completely discredited.

Then you will need to provide some explanation on how it can possibly work with out making everything we know about chemistry and biology invalid.

How about this, next time you are feeling down, start administering electric shocks to yourself to recharge your immune system. The jury is still out on that, it has not been conclusively shown not to work.

And if you don't feel it is discredited please answer the question about water memory. That is an important part toward providing a mechanism for how it could possibly work.
 
But for now, Rodney, just provide the name of a brand of homoeopathic cough medicine that has been shown to work, along with references to the studies that have demonstrated this.
 
However, when I clicked the link, I received this message:

"The product you have selected (Vicks Medinite 180ml) is a Pharmacy Medicine, the supply of which is controlled by strict government regulations. For your safety, these regulations require that you complete the short form below, so we can ensure that the medicine is suitable for you. Our Pharmacist will view the information you enter before your medicine is dispensed. By law, all online pharmacies must follow this procedure."

So, Vicks Medinite in the UK does not appear comparable to OTC cough medicines in the United States.

Let's be complete about this, Rodney. Here are the questions the pharmacist must ask:

Age of person who this medicine is for

Gender

Has the person used this medicine before?

If taken before, were there any side-effects?

Please describe the condition that the medicine will be used for, including how it was diagnosed (or what the symptoms are) and the severity of the condition. Government regulations require that this question is answered fully so that our pharmacist can ensure that the medication is appropriate.

Please provide details of any other medicines currently being taken, either prescribed or purchasedAny existing medical conditions?
(e.g. heart problems, diabetes, asthma, pregnancy, breast feeding)


Now I agree this is a step beyond US OTC, but only insofar as you have to tell the pharmacist the answer to the same questions that here in the US we answer for ourselves.

There is no medical diagnosis. It's simply a warning label with a person attached.

Rodney said:
I never said big drug companies are evil, but I'm not sure they want rigorous testing of their OTC cough medicines.
Perhaps not, but you've not demonstrated that here.

Rodney said:
My points are: (a) The "homeopathic" cough medicine cited by Moochie in the opening post has, in all probability, never been tested, and so we can't assume it is not efficacious.
It's more than that. We can assume it's not because no homeopathic medicine has ever been shown efficacious at all.

And you're still not acknowledging the difference between these medicines. The OTC stuff only claims to alleviate symptoms. The homeopathic stuff claims to cure illness.

Rodney said:
In fact, we can't even assume it's homeopathic.
True. Which is another strike against homeopathy. The industry is so unregulated that anyone can slap a homeopathic label on any product. It is set up specifically to take advantage of the public's ignorance about homeopathy whereas conventional medicine is set up to get people informed.

Rodney said:
However, anything labeled as homeopathic incurs the wrath of most folks here.
Quite rightly.

Rodney said:
(b) When I first posted on this thread, I was not aware that any OTC cough medicine had been proven efficacious above placebo. Thanks to Linda, it appears that I was wrong,
Very good of you to acknowledge this. (I mean that sincerely)

Rodney said:
but the evidence regarding the efficacy of OTC cough medicines still appears tenuous.
I'm not sure I agree with you, particularly since you still seem to be trying to erroneously conflate a claim about alleviating symptoms with a claim about affecting a cure.

But I'll leave this part to Linda and others.

Rodney said:
As far as I know, I've never used a homeopathic product,
Wise of you.

Rodney said:
ut I don't agree with the consensus here that homeopathy has been completely discredited.
What would convince you it has been?
 
What would convince you it has been?
The studies showing benefits from homeopathy would have to be refuted. As the Wikipedia article notes: "Despite the high percentage of studies that provided evidence of success with homeopathic medicine, most of these studies were flawed in some way or another. Still, the researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
 
Don't you think you should provide a little more than a link to wikipedia's entry on homeopathy that mentions a 15 year old meta-analysis? Reposting it doesn't help much, either.
 
The studies showing benefits from homeopathy would have to be refuted. As the Wikipedia article notes: "Despite the high percentage of studies that provided evidence of success with homeopathic medicine, most of these studies were flawed in some way or another. Still, the researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
I've never uderstood why homeopathic researchers design their experiments to detect efficacy rather than mere existence. Proving the existence of a homeopathic effect of any sort would seem to be a much simpler undertaking, with a much more definitive outcome, than attempting to apply homeopathy to a specific goal or task.

Actually... I understand perfectly well why homeopaths avoid simplicity at all costs.
 
Don't you think you should provide a little more than a link to wikipedia's entry on homeopathy that mentions a 15 year old meta-analysis? Reposting it doesn't help much, either.
Have the 11 (of the best 15) studies that showed homeopathy to be efficacious been refuted? If so, please supply a link.
 
Have the 11 (of the best 15) studies that showed homeopathy to be efficacious been refuted? If so, please supply a link.
2005 Lancet Study of 110 homeopathic trials and 110 conventional medicine trials
The prediction was supported by the study - whereas the conventional tests showed a real effect independent of sample size, the homeopathy studies did not. The study does not prove that homeopathy is never effective or that all its findings are placebo effects, but does show that the totality of tests analysed show outcomes consistent with the interpretation that all of the reported effects are placebo effects.

Second, here is the context of your bit about the 11 high quality studies:
1991 British Medical Journal study of 107 controlled homeopathy trials
Despite the high percentage of studies that provided evidence of success with homeopathic medicine, most of these studies were flawed in some way or another. Still, the researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy.
The meta-analysis on homeopathy concluded, "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."[
Italics mine to highlight what appears to be a contradiction to me. 15 trials showed homeopathy is effective, but only 11 of those 15 showed efficacy. The other 4 were effective but not efficacious?
---

So then. Best case for homeopathy: The larger study shows no effect beyond placebo.

Of the smaller study, there are, at most, 11 trials which indicate further evaluation might be desirable.

Even with your own source, we’re back to: Homeopathy is not demonstrated as efficacious.
 
The studies showing benefits from homeopathy would have to be refuted. As the Wikipedia article notes: "Despite the high percentage of studies that provided evidence of success with homeopathic medicine, most of these studies were flawed in some way or another. Still, the researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

Could you please find something that has more than a random cite on wikipedia to support your side.

Note that they refer to the 22 best studies, that does not actualy mean that any of those used procedure that was properly blinded and such to get a real measurement.
 
15 trials showed homeopathy is effective, but only 11 of those 15 showed efficacy. The other 4 were effective but not efficacious?
I think what the Wikipedia article is saying is that, of 22 high-caliber studies, 15 showed homeopathy to be efficacious. Narrowing down those 22 studies to the 15 best, 11 showed homeopathy to be efficacious.

So then. Best case for homeopathy: The larger study shows no effect beyond placebo.
No. The meta-analysis on homeopathy concluded, "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."

Of the smaller study, there are, at most, 11 trials which indicate further evaluation might be desirable.
Again, my interpretation of the Wikipedia article is that 11 of the 15 best studies showed homeopathy to be efficacious.

Even with your own source, we’re back to: Homeopathy is not demonstrated as efficacious.
Overall, I agree that the jury is still out. But that's a long way from saying that homeopathy has been demonstrated to be ineffective or is quackery.
 
Overall, I agree that the jury is still out. But that's a long way from saying that homeopathy has been demonstrated to be ineffective or is quackery.


Just like all those people with their propetual motion machines, the jury is still out on that too.
 
I think what the Wikipedia article is saying is that, of 22 high-caliber studies, 15 showed homeopathy to be efficacious. Narrowing down those 22 studies to the 15 best, 11 showed homeopathy to be efficacious.
Okay, I can buy that. So of 107 studies, 11 show efficacy but have not been replicated. Therefore, the meta-analysis shows: No efficacy.

Rodney said:
No. The meta-analysis on homeopathy concluded, "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."
This is from the British Journal study, not the Lancet study I was referring to, which is larger than the BJ and showed no effect at all beyond placebo.


Rodney said:
Again, my interpretation of the Wikipedia article is that 11 of the 15 best studies showed homeopathy to be efficacious.
Okay. Again, that leaves 11 of 107 trials show efficacy, but none have been replicated.


Rodney said:
Overall, I agree that the jury is still out. But that's a long way from saying that homeopathy has been demonstrated to be ineffective or is quackery.
That's like saying the jury is still out on Fox sister style spiritualism because while nearly all practicioners have been shown to be fraudulent, there remain a couple not positively refuted. And please ignore the fact they haven't replicated anything either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom