Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Moochie

Philosopher
Joined
Aug 12, 2005
Messages
5,491
Location
Australia
My wife has a recurring cough that won't go away. She's a nonsmoker.

A work colleague suggested a "wonder remedy" which had been recommended to her by someone else. The colleague duly went out and bought the remedy and has waxed lyrical about its healing qualities ever since.

Describing this amazing substance, the colleague dropped the "H" word -- the cough medicine was homeopathic.

My wife, innately skeptical, although more so since I've been regaling her with the often humorous stories found right here in this forum, politely declined the recommendation, and asked her colleague if said colleague knew what "homeopathy" is. The colleague had no idea.

Seems to me that there are many people who have no idea what homeopathy is, and buy homeopathic products because these products are on the shelves alongside less suspect and even legitimate products, such as in health food stores and pharmacies. Seeing these bogus products in a pharmacy -- quite common here in Australia -- lends these products a legitimacy they do not deserve.

I have become so peeved at seeing this rubbish at my local pharmacy that I have threatened to withdraw my custom, declaring the pharmacy owner a seller of snake oil.

M.

P.S. My wife is seeing her doctor about the cough tomorrow.
 
Get em! It is just as bad here in the states...Head on...Zicam....

See a dollar grab it right?

:mad:
 
And (if she hasn't already) have your wife explain to her colleague(s) what homeopathy is right away, before they've been absorbed by the nonsense too far to admit they just fooled themselves.
 
My experience with those who use medicines that say they are homeopathic generally think it means "herbal" or "all natural" or some variation of that.

Those who would allow me to explain homeopathy's claims have, with rare exception, said "You've got to be kidding." I think some of them even stopped using the stuff, or at least reduced their usage. Or at least reduced their usage that is visible to me...
 
And (if she hasn't already) have your wife explain to her colleague(s) what homeopathy is right away, before they've been absorbed by the nonsense too far to admit they just fooled themselves.

I've suggested my wife do just that, but with loving kindness. The colleague is rather young, and blithely follows fads just like we once did. :)

M.
 
... and asked her colleague if said colleague knew what "homeopathy" is. The colleague had no idea.

... before they've been absorbed by the nonsense too far to admit they just fooled themselves.

These two statements probably are the gist of 99,9% of my personal encounters with people who use homeopathic stuff or talk about homeopathy as "alternative" medicine. :mad:
 
My experience with those who use medicines that say they are homeopathic generally think it means "herbal" or "all natural" or some variation of that.
If the colleage had no idea what homoeopathy actually is, it's quite possible that the cough medicine wasn't actually homoeopathic. Moochie, did your wife actually see the label?
 
My wife has a recurring cough that won't go away. She's a nonsmoker.

A work colleague suggested a "wonder remedy" which had been recommended to her by someone else. The colleague duly went out and bought the remedy and has waxed lyrical about its healing qualities ever since.

Describing this amazing substance, the colleague dropped the "H" word -- the cough medicine was homeopathic.
If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem? And is your solution to have the government ban the cough medicine?
 
If the colleage had no idea what homoeopathy actually is, it's quite possible that the cough medicine wasn't actually homoeopathic. Moochie, did your wife actually see the label?


No, the colleague did not have the bottle with her. She was, however, thrilled to be able to recommend a homeopathic medicine to someone senior in the company, and presumably thought she may have impressed by knowing a 5-syllable word.

M.
 
If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem? And is your solution to have the government ban the cough medicine?

Nope. My goal is education.

I happen to think it's wrong to sell water as "medicine," at any price.

If people know what homeopathy is, and why it might seem to "work," they'll be less likely to be suckered. And the snake-oil salespeople will have to find legitimate employment.


M.
 
If the colleage had no idea what homoeopathy actually is, it's quite possible that the cough medicine wasn't actually homoeopathic. Moochie, did your wife actually see the label?
There are a couple of issues at work here:

1. Products are labled homeopathic

2. Products may or may not actually be prepared homeopathically, either because the producer doesn't himself/herself realize what it is or because they know it's bunk and diluting something 30M times isn't possible.

3. Customer knows the product is labeled homeopathic but doesn't find out what that means, nor what 30M or 10X or 20L mean.

The people I talk to are the customers described in #3.
 
There are a couple of issues at work here:

1. Products are labled homeopathic

2. Products may or may not actually be prepared homeopathically, either because the producer doesn't himself/herself realize what it is or because they know it's bunk and diluting something 30M times isn't possible.

3. Customer knows the product is labeled homeopathic but doesn't find out what that means, nor what 30M or 10X or 20L mean.

The people I talk to are the customers described in #3.
There's at least a fourth possibility: product is not labeled as homoeopathic, but customer confuses homoeopathy with herbalism or other types of "naturopathy" and describes it as homoeopathic.
 
Nope. My goal is education.

I happen to think it's wrong to sell water as "medicine," at any price.

If people know what homeopathy is, and why it might seem to "work," they'll be less likely to be suckered. And the snake-oil salespeople will have to find legitimate employment.M.
And are you also crusading against all non-homeopathic products -- including those recommended by medical doctors -- that don't work?
 
Have any non-homeopathic cough medicines been shown to be efficacious in controlled tests? See http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929
I wasn't thinking specifically of cough medicine, but of homeopathy in general when posting that remark with a :D at the end. And for this discussion here it seems irrelevant to me if - for whatever medical condition - there does exist an effective non-homeopathic medicine or not.
 
I wasn't thinking specifically of cough medicine, but of homeopathy in general when posting that remark with a :D at the end. And for this discussion here it seems irrelevant to me if - for whatever medical condition - there does exist an effective non-homeopathic medicine or not.
First, the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy is not as clear-cut as most people here seem to think. For example, according to -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy -- "In 1991, three professors of medicine from the Netherlands, none of them homeopaths, performed a meta-analysis of 25 years of clinical studies using homeopathic medicines and published their results in the British Medical Journal. This meta-analysis covered 107 controlled trials, of which 81 showed that homeopathic medicines were effective, 24 showed they were ineffective, and 2 were inconclusive."

Second, it is a well-established fact that a placebo effect exists with respect to many medicines. So why crusade against unproven, but otherwise harmless homeopathic medicines, while giving a free pass to unproven, but otherwise harmless non-homeopathic medicines?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom