Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Again, there is some evidence that homeopathic remedies work, so it's a question of what standard of evidence is used.

There is only one standard of evidence: either there is evidence, or there isn't.

As far as homeopathy is concerned, there is no evidence. There isn't even any evidence it has any effect at all.

And to counter your predictable "but no effect is better than a bad side effect", yes, that's true, but at least with regular medicine, we know what's causing the "bad side effects", with homeopathy, the "aggravations" are simply discarded as the remedy being the right one but at the wrong dilution. In other words, people are far more likely to suffer serious injury or even death as a result of homeopathic medicine than they are as a result of regular medicine, because bad stuff happening isn't recognised as being bad stuff.
What's more, regular medicine has regulations in place to deal with events like that. Homeopathy just sweeps 'em under the rug I suppose, and tries something else instead, and keeps the patients dragging along until it hopefully goes away all on its own.
Or they may just get a slap on the wrist and a warning not to try and cure that kind of illness again.

Real medicine is taking its products off the shelves. Homeopathy is still happily chugging along making money for nothing.
 
Last edited:
There's no mechanism proposed to reset the memory of water; distilling or filtering will only make your medication more dillute and therefor stronger.

Seems to me, the ramifications of this is that industrial run-off, mercury, bird droppings, shark sperm, cremated ashes thrown into the ganges, remnants from the exxon-valdez oil spill and all sorts of silliness will completely overpower your homeopathic ingredients.
 
There's no mechanism proposed to reset the memory of water


I think homoeopaths suggest that distilling the water does this, hence they use distilled, or double distilled, water to prepare potentised remedies.

However, because nobody has yet been able to detect the memory of water, they have no way of knowing whether this works.
 
Welcome Mr. Green.

There's no mechanism proposed to reset the memory of water; distilling or filtering will only make your medication more dillute and therefor stronger.


Yeah, distilling the water re-sets the dial and succussion loads the dice.
There is no mechanism proposed or possible.
It cannot work.
The idea was just pulled out of someone's ass!

...which reminds me of that joke about homoeopathic toilet paper.


ac005_choccyfingers.JPG


 
Last edited:
Being a homeopath must be awesome. You basically give out water with people. Sometimes the water has salt in it, sometimes it has sand in it. Most of the time it's just water. Also, you talk to them, and you tell them that the water will somehow heal them. You need no education whatsoever and your salary is somehow higher than what a nurse would make.

Also, you get to lie to people right in their face without getting sued. I don't know if I'm psychopathic or just really amused by other people's stupidity and ignorance, but that would be the perfect job for me.
 
Zicam is homeopathic?

I think it says on the box that it's homeopathic, but by my understanding of what homeopathy is, it's not homeopathic. I'm not sure. I do swear by the stuff though, I take the RapidMelts, I don't stick crap up my nose, especially after they got sued by people losing their sense of smell. For me it works exactly as it claims, my colds are shorter than usual and the symptoms are MUCH more bearable.
 
I think it says on the box that it's homeopathic, but by my understanding of what homeopathy is, it's not homeopathic. I'm not sure. I do swear by the stuff though, I take the RapidMelts, I don't stick crap up my nose, especially after they got sued by people losing their sense of smell. For me it works exactly as it claims, my colds are shorter than usual and the symptoms are MUCH more bearable.

How do you know what the duration and symptoms of your cold would be without the Zicam? I don't think I've ever had two colds that were exactly the same.

Linda
 
It says on the box that the active ingredient is Zincum Gluconicum. Apparently, if this site is to be trusted where they claimed to have run a double blind test confirms that it actually does something, but this site claims some tests show that, and some don't. However, a vast, vast majority of products that I could find that contain that stuff are homeopathic remedies, and according to the second site the loss of smell thing with zinc has been known since the 30's or earlier, so it does strike me as somewhat irresponsible regardless of it's effectiveness.

Alright, but here's the thing where my lack of education on the topic gets me: the test there uses 33mmol/l amount, which I have no idea what that is. The Zicam uses 2x amount, which again I have no idea what that is either. Could be that 2x is a lot less than 33mmol/l?
 
Alright, but here's the thing where my lack of education on the topic gets me: the test there uses 33mmol/l amount, which I have no idea what that is. The Zicam uses 2x amount, which again I have no idea what that is either. Could be that 2x is a lot less than 33mmol/l?


The X refers to a tenfold dilution, and the 2 refers to the number of times it has been diluted (it's also shaken at each stage). 2X means that it is a one in one hundred dilution of whatever initial preparation (referred to as a "mother tincture") they used. Without knowing the concentration of the mother tincture, it is impossible to know from the label how much "Zincum Gluconicum" there is in it, although there is going to be at least some present so it's possible it has some sort of effect. Of course, to provide support for homoeopathy it would need to do a little more than that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom