Homeopathic Cough Medicine

What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.

That is actually very insightful Rodney. It is a sign that you might be starting to understand.

Yes someone given sugar water and told it is medicine is more likely to "report" feeling better than someone given sugar water and told it is sugar water. It seems crazy, but that is what a placebo will do.

Funny story: When I was a teenager we pulled a nasty trick on a friend. At a party we kept giving him glasses of beer. He and several other people eventually became more and more intoxicated the more they drank. The only problem was; the beer this particular person was drinking was non-alcoholic! We were secretly filling his glass with non-alcoholic beer from the refrigerator instead of the keg that everyone else was drinking from.

LLH
 
What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.
Hooray! Now you are getting it! That is exactly how placebo works, provided the patient believes that the sugared water is an effective medicine (called the verum) for the ailment. And it works in reverse as well - if the patient is told that the substance is not effective, the effect can be less, even though it is the medicine that does work (this is called the "nocebo effect").

To confuse this further, sometimes the patients believe they feel better (or worse) even though objective measurements show they have not changed at all.

And therein lies a basic problem of testing medicines and some medical procedures: If the testing subjects become aware in any way that the substance or procedure they are testing is not what they are expecting to get, the placebo/nocebo effect can easily kick in and distort the results. So to get a "true picture" of the effect of a medicine (or even procedures), the subject needs to be "blinded" as to what it is they are being given (verum or placebo). The practice of "double blinding" is to blind the test substance selection from the physician/tester as well, to eliminate any subliminal messages to the subject indicating placebo/verum substances.

You need to be aware that the placebo/nocebo effect is very powerful, and no-one is immune from it. I have experienced it myself when I was a guinea-pig for asthma medication trials. Fortunately I was not unpleasantly surprised when the blinding was uncovered on the studies - I knew that I may well have been affected by placebo effect.

But more importantly in the case of homeopathy, the patients' wellbeing relies very much on this placebo effect. Although some homeopaths are so pathetically uneducated that they do not understand the maths or science involved in their deception, the unconscionable part is that many do. And yet they continue to take money off patients under blatantly false pretenses of medical ability. They also claim homeopathy is cheaper than "conventional" medicine...perhaps a glance at Boiron's accounts gives that a lie. Forecast 400 million Euros sales in 2006 is not chickenfeed (that's more than half a billion US dollars, btw). And that's just one homeopathic manufacturer...!
 
They also claim homeopathy is cheaper than "conventional" medicine...

A good point. Even if homeopathic "medicine" is much cheaper than "regular medicine", that says nothing about its effectiveness.

Also I'd bet the profit margins on homeopathic medicine is much higher. One drop of active ingrediant would likely produce enough 30C "medicne" to provide a lifetime supply to every human that has ever lived.

LLH
 
Also I'd bet the profit margins on homeopathic medicine is much higher. One drop of active ingrediant would likely produce enough 30C "medicne" to provide a lifetime supply to every human that has ever lived.
I’m sure the “20-million dollar duck” story has done the rounds here before, but for those not familiar with it, here it is again:

Oscillococcinum, that 200C product "for the relief of colds and flu-like symptoms," involves dilutions that are even more far-fetched. Its "active ingredient" is prepared by incubating small amounts of a freshly killed duck’s liver and heart for 40 days.

Were a single molecule of the duck’s heart or liver to survive the dilution, its concentration would be 100200. This huge number, which has 400 zeroes, is vastly greater than the estimated number of molecules in the universe (about one googol, which is a 1 followed by 100 zeroes). Quackwatch—a website well named for a duck authority—quotes the February 17, 1997, issue of U.S. News & World Report as reporting that only one duck per year is needed to manufacture the product, which had total sales of $20 million in 1996. The magazine dubbed that unlucky bird "the $20-million duck."

http://www.fasebj.org/cgi/content/full/20/11/1755
 
There are several problem with this approach. In anything that follows a normal distribution, there will always be statistical outliers. If you do a hundred sets of 5 coin tosses, there's a good chance that 3 of the sets will be all heads. Do you think that if you just look at those 3 sets (throwing out the other 97) and say "the chance that I could toss all heads is 1 in 32 and yet I did it three times" that you have demonstrated evidence of an ability to alter the results of a coin toss?

The second problem that you have is that the bulk of the published research is equivalent to playing with a weighted coin. The study design/execution (rather than the efficacy of the treatment) makes it more likely than not that you will get a positive result. Out of the thousands of studies published on homeopathy, only 22 were found that weren't played with a weighted coin (sorta) and of those 15 showed effectiveness. And taking into consideration publication bias, realistically, we have no idea what those few positive results represents out of the total research performed in this area.

Furthermore, you selected out the only review which was done in a way that allowed the positive results to stand. Additional meta-analyses that controlled for the effect of the weighted coin (i.e. took into consideration the effect of study design/execution on the results) found that as you eliminate bias the effects get smaller and disappear.

All this is without taking into consideration the biggest problem of all. Positive results in isolation are likely to be false. http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-document&doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124

Linda
So why doesn't the above logic apply to the few tests that have shown that some OTC cough medicines are efficacious?
 
There is a good explanation of how it works. I summarized the main points in another thread here.

Linda

How do you explain this:

"DON'T try this at home. Several times a day, for several days, you induce pain in someone. You control the pain with morphine until the final day of the experiment, when you replace the morphine with saline solution. Guess what? The saline takes the pain away.

"This is the placebo effect: somehow, sometimes, a whole lot of nothing can be very powerful. Except it's not quite nothing. When Fabrizio Benedetti of the University of Turin in Italy carried out the above experiment, he added a final twist by adding naloxone, a drug that blocks the effects of morphine, to the saline. The shocking result? The pain-relieving power of saline solution disappeared.

"So what is going on? Doctors have known about the placebo effect for decades, and the naloxone result seems to show that the placebo effect is somehow biochemical. But apart from that, we simply don't know."
See http://space.newscientist.com/article/mg18524911.600-13-things-that-do-not-make-sense.html
 
Never mind exactly how the placebo effect works: do you have any evidence that any homoeopathic cough medicine works better than placebo?
 
Not if it works (which, in my opinion, is still an open question). My point about the placebo effect is that, to my knowledge, there is no good explanation of how it works either.

The "placebo" effect isn't owned by homeopathy. Any quackery will do.

There is probably a real basis for it, but homeopathy ain't it.

M.
 
The "placebo" effect isn't owned by homeopathy. Any quackery will do.
The placebo effect isn't owned by quackery. It will also operate alongside any medicine that actually works. And there you get not only the placebo effect but also the effect of the medicine.
 
Never mind exactly how the placebo effect works: do you have any evidence that any homoeopathic cough medicine works better than placebo?
I don't even know if any homeopathic cough medicine has been subjected to a controlled study. Does anyone know?
 
The placebo effect isn't owned by quackery. It will also operate alongside any medicine that actually works. And there you get not only the placebo effect but also the effect of the medicine.


Indeed, but quack remedies like to arrogate the positive (not the negative) results to themselves.

M.
 
So why doesn't the above logic apply to the few tests that have shown that some OTC cough medicines are efficacious?

The same logic does apply.

There are thousands of studies on non-homeopathic drugs and thousands of those studies show an effect above placebo. There are thousands of studies on homeopathic drugs and a handful show effect above placebo. This provides evidence that non-homeopathic drugs have a specific physiologic effect, and evidence that homeopathic drugs do not have a specific physiologic effect. We expect to see a few homeopathic drug studies with positive results (above placebo) due to chance, and the amount that we see is what we expect to see if the null hypothesis (i.e. no effect) is true.

The OTC cough medicines studies do not exist in isolation. The homeopathic studies do. The OTC cough medicine studies are the tip of the iceberg. They are built on painstakingly gathered knowledge about the physiology of the human body and various effects that chemicals can have on these processes. Research that meticulously documents every steps in the process of how a particular chemical can lead to a particular effect builds to the point where the clinical trial is simply the final step in showing what happens. Also, in addition to the RCT's that have been mentioned, there are numerous other types of controlled studies on cough medicines that do show an effect above placebo. All that information taken together serves to re-inforce the paradigm behind the standard model (to borrow a term).

Homeopathic studies exist in a vaccuum. There is no demonstration of any step in the process. There's no physiologic basis for the proposed effects (above placebo) and there's no evidence for an alternate paradigm. What you see instead is a collection of studies that follows a normal distribution - exactly what you'd expect to see if any differences were due to chance - and someone has drawn a circle around one of the tails. That positive results can't be duplicated also follows exactly what you'd expect to see due to chance.

The comparison between homeopathy and standard medicine isn't a matter of pulling out a few clinical trials and saying that some homeopathy trials are equivocable and some standard trials are equivocable, therefore both are equally valid. It completely misses the point that there are a billion bits of information that underlie the clinical trials and zero bits of information that underlie the homeopathic trials.

Linda
 
How do you explain this:

"DON'T try this at home. Several times a day, for several days, you induce pain in someone. You control the pain with morphine until the final day of the experiment, when you replace the morphine with saline solution. Guess what? The saline takes the pain away.

"This is the placebo effect: somehow, sometimes, a whole lot of nothing can be very powerful. Except it's not quite nothing. When Fabrizio Benedetti of the University of Turin in Italy carried out the above experiment, he added a final twist by adding naloxone, a drug that blocks the effects of morphine, to the saline. The shocking result? The pain-relieving power of saline solution disappeared.

"So what is going on? Doctors have known about the placebo effect for decades, and the naloxone result seems to show that the placebo effect is somehow biochemical. But apart from that, we simply don't know."
See http://space.newscientist.com/article/mg18524911.600-13-things-that-do-not-make-sense.html

Articles written for lay people like to manufacture mystery where none exists. Those results build on our knowledge of endogenous opioids.

Linda
 
The same logic does apply.


The comparison between homeopathy and standard medicine isn't a matter of pulling out a few clinical trials and saying that some homeopathy trials are equivocable and some standard trials are equivocable, therefore both are equally valid. It completely misses the point that there are a billion bits of information that underlie the clinical trials and zero bits of information that underlie the homeopathic trials.

Linda

What fls is saying here is that you can fool some of the people some of the time...

M.
 
The same logic does apply.

There are thousands of studies on non-homeopathic drugs and thousands of those studies show an effect above placebo. There are thousands of studies on homeopathic drugs and a handful show effect above placebo. This provides evidence that non-homeopathic drugs have a specific physiologic effect, and evidence that homeopathic drugs do not have a specific physiologic effect. We expect to see a few homeopathic drug studies with positive results (above placebo) due to chance, and the amount that we see is what we expect to see if the null hypothesis (i.e. no effect) is true.

The OTC cough medicines studies do not exist in isolation. The homeopathic studies do. The OTC cough medicine studies are the tip of the iceberg. They are built on painstakingly gathered knowledge about the physiology of the human body and various effects that chemicals can have on these processes. Research that meticulously documents every steps in the process of how a particular chemical can lead to a particular effect builds to the point where the clinical trial is simply the final step in showing what happens. Also, in addition to the RCT's that have been mentioned, there are numerous other types of controlled studies on cough medicines that do show an effect above placebo. All that information taken together serves to re-inforce the paradigm behind the standard model (to borrow a term).

Homeopathic studies exist in a vaccuum. There is no demonstration of any step in the process. There's no physiologic basis for the proposed effects (above placebo) and there's no evidence for an alternate paradigm. What you see instead is a collection of studies that follows a normal distribution - exactly what you'd expect to see if any differences were due to chance - and someone has drawn a circle around one of the tails. That positive results can't be duplicated also follows exactly what you'd expect to see due to chance.

The comparison between homeopathy and standard medicine isn't a matter of pulling out a few clinical trials and saying that some homeopathy trials are equivocable and some standard trials are equivocable, therefore both are equally valid. It completely misses the point that there are a billion bits of information that underlie the clinical trials and zero bits of information that underlie the homeopathic trials.

Linda
Do the results of studies of non-homeopathic cough medicines follow approximately the same normal distribution as studies of homeopathic medicines?
 
Articles written for lay people like to manufacture mystery where none exists. Those results build on our knowledge of endogenous opioids.
Linda
Since most of us here are not doctors, an explanation of why the saline solution works to block pain when the naloxone is not added to it, but fails to work to block pain when the naloxone is added to it, would be appreciated.
 
Since most of us here are not doctors, an explanation of why the saline solution works to block pain when the naloxone is not added to it, but fails to work to block pain when the naloxone is added to it, would be appreciated.
What's this got to do with whether homoeopathic cough medicines have any effect above placebo? Has a similar experiment been performed with a homoeopathic remedy, a placebo and something that blocks the effect of the homoeopathic remedy (NB: you'd have to prove the homoeopathic remedy had any effect first, of course)?
 
If not, why not? Don't they want to find out whether or not their nostrums work?
Doesn't "they" include most major drug manufacturers? I would think, if companies such as Procter & Gamble (manufacturer of Vicks) are confident that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are superior to homeopathic ones, they would want to see that fact proven in controlled tests.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom