What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.
Hooray! Now you are getting it! That is exactly how placebo works,
provided the patient
believes that the sugared water is an effective medicine (called the verum) for the ailment. And it works in reverse as well - if the patient is told that the substance is
not effective, the effect can be less, even though it is the medicine that
does work (this is called the "nocebo effect").
To confuse this further, sometimes the patients
believe they feel better (or worse) even though objective measurements show they have not changed at all.
And therein lies a basic problem of testing medicines and some medical procedures: If the testing subjects become aware
in any way that the substance or procedure they are testing is not what they are expecting to get, the placebo/nocebo effect can easily kick in and distort the results. So to get a "true picture" of the effect of a medicine (or even procedures), the subject needs to be "blinded" as to what it is they are being given (verum or placebo). The practice of "double blinding" is to blind the test substance selection from the physician/tester as well, to eliminate any subliminal messages to the subject indicating placebo/verum substances.
You need to be aware that the placebo/nocebo effect is very powerful, and no-one is immune from it. I have experienced it myself when I was a guinea-pig for asthma medication trials. Fortunately I was not unpleasantly surprised when the blinding was uncovered on the studies - I knew that I may well have been affected by placebo effect.
But more importantly in the case of homeopathy, the patients' wellbeing relies very much on this placebo effect. Although some homeopaths are so pathetically uneducated that they do not understand the maths or science involved in their deception, the unconscionable part is that many do. And yet they continue to take money off patients under blatantly false pretenses of medical ability. They also claim homeopathy is cheaper than "conventional" medicine...perhaps a glance at
Boiron's accounts gives that a lie. Forecast
400 million Euros sales in 2006 is not chickenfeed (that's more than half a
billion US dollars, btw). And that's just one homeopathic manufacturer...!