Homeopathic Cough Medicine

That's like saying the jury is still out on Fox sister style spiritualism because while nearly all practicioners have been shown to be fraudulent, there remain a couple not positively refuted. And please ignore the fact they haven't replicated anything either.
"A couple not positively refuted"? Must homeopathy study conclusions are along the lines of this, as cited in the Wikipedia article:

"In January 2006 the European Journal of Cancer published a meta-analysis of six trials of homeopathic treatments for recovery from cancer therapy, including radio- and chemo-therapy. Three of the trials included were randomised double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trials. The authors were from the Department of Complementary Medicine at the Universities of Exeter and Plymouth. Their analysis found insufficient evidence to support the use of homeopathic remedies in cancer treatment recovery. They wrote that 'In conclusion, the evidence emerging from this systematic review is encouraging but not convincing. Further research should attempt to answer the many open questions related to homeopathy.'"
 
"A couple not positively refuted"? Must homeopathy study conclusions are along the lines of this, as cited in the Wikipedia article:

"In January 2006 the European Journal of Cancer published a meta-analysis of six trials of homeopathic treatments for recovery from cancer therapy, including radio- and chemo-therapy. Three of the trials included were randomised double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trials. The authors were from the Department of Complementary Medicine at the Universities of Exeter and Plymouth. Their analysis found insufficient evidence to support the use of homeopathic remedies in cancer treatment recovery. They wrote that 'In conclusion, the evidence emerging from this systematic review is encouraging but not convincing. Further research should attempt to answer the many open questions related to homeopathy.'"
I stand by what I said.

The bolding is mine. It says the studies found nothing.

The italics are also mine. It says that the authors think more research is indicated. They say this despite none of the studies demonstrating anything. As someone else has said recently on this board (maybe it's in this thread) the Conclusion section of the paper is where the authors try to justify their biases.

I'll paraphrase what the authors are saying:

Our review showed that no rigorous studies of homeopathic remedies demonstrate efficacy. However, as our careers are tied to the promotion of complementary medicine we will make the standard call for more research (and more funding) even though all the research is negative and the studies never get better.
 
... Overall, I agree that the jury is still out. But that's a long way from saying that homeopathy has been demonstrated to be ineffective or is quackery.

Then demonstrate how it's not quackery. What else do you call the homeopathic principle that water has a "memory," suggesting that a homeopathic concoction can be efficacious although any active ingredient has been diluted out of it? The water "remembers" the active ingredient, therefore the homeopathic preparation works?

This is not quackery?

M.
 
I stand by what I said.

The bolding is mine. It says the studies found nothing.

The italics are also mine. It says that the authors think more research is indicated. They say this despite none of the studies demonstrating anything. As someone else has said recently on this board (maybe it's in this thread) the Conclusion section of the paper is where the authors try to justify their biases.

I'll paraphrase what the authors are saying:

Our review showed that no rigorous studies of homeopathic remedies demonstrate efficacy. However, as our careers are tied to the promotion of complementary medicine we will make the standard call for more research (and more funding) even though all the research is negative and the studies never get better.
So, when the authors say that "the evidence . . . is encouraging", they're being disingenuous? And do you believe that medical doctors who practice complementary medicine are less-qualified than other MDs?
 
So, when the authors say that "the evidence . . . is encouraging", they're being disingenuous?
When, in the same paper in which they say:

Their analysis found insufficient evidence to support the use of homeopathic remedies in cancer treatment recovery

they also say:

the evidence emerging from this systematic review is encouraging but not convincing

then, yes, I think they are being disingenuous. But that wasn't my point.

My point was that when you quote the latter statement while ignoring the first you are being disingenous.

Rodney said:
And do you believe that medical doctors who practice complementary medicine are less-qualified than other MDs?
Practicioner qualifications and legitimacy of practice are two separate things.

I have no idea what the credentials (qualifications) of the two doctors are. They may be Nobel Prize winners for all I know.

But when, regardless of their qualifications, they continue to practice what has never been demonstrated to work, then I call their integrity into question. They may well believe their own flapdoodle, but they should know better.
 
Then demonstrate how it's not quackery. What else do you call the homeopathic principle that water has a "memory," suggesting that a homeopathic concoction can be efficacious although any active ingredient has been diluted out of it? The water "remembers" the active ingredient, therefore the homeopathic preparation works?

This is not quackery?

M.

What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.
 
What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.
That it has nothing to do with water having a memory and that you are still conflating claims for alleviation of symptom with claims for curing of illness.

And that we have readily admitted homeopathic remedies may have a placebo effect.
 
What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.

Here's what I wrote:

Then demonstrate how it's not quackery. What else do you call the homeopathic principle that water has a "memory," suggesting that a homeopathic concoction can be efficacious although any active ingredient has been diluted out of it? The water "remembers" the active ingredient, therefore the homeopathic preparation works?

This is not quackery?

M.
 
What do you say about the proposition that a person who drinks a placebo, such as sugared water, can recover from an illness faster than someone who drinks that same sugared water, but who is told that it is sugared water? Is that quackery? If you say no, please explain how the placebo effect works.

Because the power of suggestion can influence perceptions. For example a study showed that depending on how you ask a question will influence the answer of how something is viewed link.

So with that, you can not really say that they are getting better sooner, just that they are reporting that they are getting better faster. There was a big thread not to long ago debating if there is really a placebo effect or if it is just an expression of the bias of the people taking the thing and the examiners being biased as well. link

So saying it does the same as the placebo is saying that it does nothing. It not some magical effect like the law of similars and the law of contagion that homeopathy operates under.
 
Here's what I wrote:

Then demonstrate how it's not quackery. What else do you call the homeopathic principle that water has a "memory," suggesting that a homeopathic concoction can be efficacious although any active ingredient has been diluted out of it? The water "remembers" the active ingredient, therefore the homeopathic preparation works?

This is not quackery?

Magic. It is clearly the law of contagion at work.
 
This is not quackery?
M.

Not if it works (which, in my opinion, is still an open question). My point about the placebo effect is that, to my knowledge, there is no good explanation of how it works either.
 
Not if it works (which, in my opinion, is still an open question). My point about the placebo effect is that, to my knowledge, there is no good explanation of how it works either.

Read more. Placebo effect is always strongest in things that can only be subjectively measured and not objectively measured. It is easy to convince people that you did something to help them, look into quackwatch and it explains how people can attribute something that did active harm to them as helping
 
Not if it works (which, in my opinion, is still an open question). My point about the placebo effect is that, to my knowledge, there is no good explanation of how it works either.
For the lurkers out there, let's summarize Rodney's position through this whole thread:

Homeopathy might work even though it has never been shown to work. I know this because some cough medicines don't cure respiratory infections and because the placebo effect exists.

I'm being blunt, Rodney, and I recognize you may not actually think that's what you're saying. But if you'll look at your posts objectively, you will find that it is exactly what you're saying.

And also (for Rodney and for lurkers) read the stuff posted by ponderingturtle reference placebo.
 
The studies showing benefits from homeopathy would have to be refuted. As the Wikipedia article notes: "Despite the high percentage of studies that provided evidence of success with homeopathic medicine, most of these studies were flawed in some way or another. Still, the researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

There are several problem with this approach. In anything that follows a normal distribution, there will always be statistical outliers. If you do a hundred sets of 5 coin tosses, there's a good chance that 3 of the sets will be all heads. Do you think that if you just look at those 3 sets (throwing out the other 97) and say "the chance that I could toss all heads is 1 in 32 and yet I did it three times" that you have demonstrated evidence of an ability to alter the results of a coin toss?

The second problem that you have is that the bulk of the published research is equivalent to playing with a weighted coin. The study design/execution (rather than the efficacy of the treatment) makes it more likely than not that you will get a positive result. Out of the thousands of studies published on homeopathy, only 22 were found that weren't played with a weighted coin (sorta) and of those 15 showed effectiveness. And taking into consideration publication bias, realistically, we have no idea what those few positive results represents out of the total research performed in this area.

Furthermore, you selected out the only review which was done in a way that allowed the positive results to stand. Additional meta-analyses that controlled for the effect of the weighted coin (i.e. took into consideration the effect of study design/execution on the results) found that as you eliminate bias the effects get smaller and disappear.

All this is without taking into consideration the biggest problem of all. Positive results in isolation are likely to be false. http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-document&doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124

Linda
 
Not if it works (which, in my opinion, is still an open question). My point about the placebo effect is that, to my knowledge, there is no good explanation of how it works either.

There is a good explanation of how it works. I summarized the main points in another thread here.

Linda
 
For the lurkers out there, let's summarize Rodney's position through this whole thread:

Homeopathy might work even though it has never been shown to work. I know this because some cough medicines don't cure respiratory infections and because the placebo effect exists.

Thank you for summarizing my position; ;) however: Moochie started this thread because he is exercised that someone thinks a "homeopathic" OTC cough medicine works. He absolutely, incontrovertibly knows it can't work because it claims to be homeopathic. Of course, Moochie -- like me, Garrette, and everyone else here -- has no idea if the cough medicine actually even is homeopathic, let alone knowing if it works. I then noted that there is significant doubt whether non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are efficacious. Linda pointed out that there is some evidence that they are, but it still does not seem that there is a significant benefit in taking non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines over placebos. I then noted that the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy in general is not quite as unequivocal as most here seem to believe, and that how homeopathy works is irrelevant to this thread.
 
Thank you for summarizing my position; ;)
This does seem to be a decent sumary of your argument.
however: Moochie started this thread because he is exercised that someone thinks a "homeopathic" OTC cough medicine works. He absolutely, incontrovertibly knows it can't work because it claims to be homeopathic. Of course, Moochie -- like me, Garrette, and everyone else here -- has no idea if the cough medicine actually even is homeopathic, let alone knowing if it works. I then noted that there is significant doubt whether non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are efficacious. Linda pointed out that there is some evidence that they are, but it still does not seem that there is a significant benefit in taking non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines over placebos. I then noted that the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy in general is not quite as unequivocal as most here seem to believe, and that how homeopathy works is irrelevant to this thread.


Got it, you believe in magic. Homeopathys Law of the Infintesmimal is just the Law of Contagion.

You don't seem to be able to explain how it can possibly work, constantly ignore any question about how it is in disagreement with all experiance and experiments in pharmacology and chemistry. Please explain how asprin and homeopathy can both do anything in a single model.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for summarizing my position; ;) however: Moochie started this thread because he is exercised that someone thinks a "homeopathic" OTC cough medicine works. He absolutely, incontrovertibly knows it can't work because it claims to be homeopathic. Of course, Moochie -- like me, Garrette, and everyone else here -- has no idea if the cough medicine actually even is homeopathic, let alone knowing if it works. I then noted that there is significant doubt whether non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines are efficacious. Linda pointed out that there is some evidence that they are, but it still does not seem that there is a significant benefit in taking non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines over placebos. I then noted that the evidence regarding the lack of efficacy of homeopathy in general is not quite as unequivocal as most here seem to believe, and that how homeopathy works is irrelevant to this thread.
Okay, I'll be a bit less flippant.

There are a lot of issues here.

1. Homeopathic remedies of any kind: Have they been shown to work beyond placebo? Answer: No

2. Remedies which are labeled homeopathic but which may not in fact be homeopathic: Do they work? Answer: No way of knowing, but I wouldn't let my kids touch them. If they're not homeopathic then they are likely, imo, either sugar water (harmless) or herbal, the quality control of which is virtually non-existent.

3. OTC cough medicines: Do they cure underlying illness? Answer: Of course not, but they never made that claim. Do they alleviate symptoms: Some have been shown to, both as specific brands and also as generic active ingredients. Those which make claims not supported by findings applicable to their active ingredients should be pulled.
 
Because the product tested must be identical to what is available to consumers.

The active ingredients are the same. It is identical in _every_way_that_matters_.

It doesn't matter who signs your paycheck, dextromethorphan is still the same chemical and still affects your body the same way.

If you are suggesting that, contrary to the belief of those who test and analyze these compounds, that the color of the liquid, or the amount of sugar, or whether they use corn syrup vs. cane sugar, matter, then please, explain yourself.

There are numerous companies that produce the same medicine in the same factories, but merely bottle it with different brands for stores, so it's clear that different _brands_ may not have the same effect.

Equally, the same "brand" may have different forms, different types of pills, etc.

You have repetitively requested "same brand" yet have, so far, refused to explain what relevant differences are. If you want to say "identical", perhaps you should insist on getting your hands on the half-used bottles of cough syrup from any research that yielded positive results - otherwise, it might not be "identical".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom