Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Perhaps the name applied to a formulation can somehow change its properties? :rolleyes:
Sure, just like water crystals look different under the microscope depending on how you labeled the bottle two weaks earlier ;)
 
Because the product tested must be identical to what is available to consumers.
Presumably that would be covered by "either the specific brand name preparation used in the study, or were the same as the formulation used in the study". Unless you are contending that the name somehow changes the properties.
 
Rodney, I can't see this already rather fruitless discussion getting any further unless you give a detailed rationale for your objections to the existing research being transferable to identical preparations sold commercially.

So far, the only thing you've produced is a WebMD article which is painfully substandard. Do you have anything else, or shall we just stop?
 
So you're saying that Vicks Medinite, Vicks 44-D, Robitussin DM, Dimetapp DM,
Benylin Adult Formula Cough Suppressant, Triaminic Cough, and Tylenol Cough and Cold were specifically tested in these studies? Where are these brand names mentioned in the studies?

The brand names are specified in the original research articles. The Vicks preparations were specifically tested. The other preparations have the same ingredients (i.e. the same combination) as the preparations tested in the studies (the Tylenol product should be Tylenol Flu Night Time), but the brand name isn't always specified.

Linda
 
Thanks for the tip. The point I'm making, however, is that it's not enough to assume that ingredients that have been shown to be marginally effective in treating a cough will combine to produce an efficacious cough medicine. The only way to demonstrate whether a cough medicine is efficacious is to do a controlled test of it versus a placebo.

Seeing as you are avoiding reading the links that fls (Linda) posted on the top of this page, I can just assume you are being purposely obtuse.

But I will just add one thing: Learn what the ingredients are by their actual names (ibuprofen, pseudoephedrine, diphenydramine, etc), and find out what they do (just click the hyperlinks to go to the page that was obtained by using www.medlineplus.gov ). Then go to the store and READ THE LABELS!!! You will find that they are used sometimes singly or combined with others in a variety of brand name and store brand over the counter medications. You will also see that the actual amount of med per dose is on the label (eg: 100 mg guaifenensen and 10 mg dextromethorphan hydrobromide). You will notice this information is missing from any homeopathic remedy.
 
Since you're still here, Rodney, explain for us, if you will, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."

M.

P.S. This is the fifth time I am asking.

Conventional meds do not make such asinine claims. Only homeopathy does.

Please answer the question.
 
The brand names are specified in the original research articles. The Vicks preparations were specifically tested. The other preparations have the same ingredients (i.e. the same combination) as the preparations tested in the studies (the Tylenol product should be Tylenol Flu Night Time), but the brand name isn't always specified.
Linda
Okay, although I would still like to know exactly where Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D are mentioned in the research articles and what the specific findings of the research were. For example, was the conclusion that "Vicks Medinite, Vicks 44-D, and similarly-formulated over-the-counter cough medicines have been proven to relieve coughs beyond any placebo effect"? I would think that, if that was the finding, the manufacturer of Vicks would advertise that fact. To my knowledge, it doesn't. And here is another link that questions the efficacy of OTC cough medicines -- http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/10777506/

Excerpt: "Despite the billions of dollars spent every year in this country on over-the-counter cough syrups, most such medicines do little if anything to relieve coughs, the nation’s chest physicians say.

"Over-the-counter cough syrups generally contain drugs in too low a dose to be effective, or contain combinations of drugs that have never been proven to treat coughs, said Dr. Richard Irwin, chairman of a cough guidelines committee for the American College of Chest Physicians."
 
Since you're still here, Rodney, explain for us, if you will, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."

M.

P.S. This is the fifth time I am asking.

Conventional meds do not make such asinine claims. Only homeopathy does.

Please answer the question.
I don't know if water has a memory, but that question is irrelevant to this discussion. The issue is whether OTC homeopathic cough medicines are less efficacious than OTC non-homeopathic cough medicines.
 
I had some bleach under the sink and was worried about the kids being harmed by ingesting such a hazardous chemical concoction.

To protect them, I’ve changed the label to strawberry jam.

“Rodney Logic”: you know it makes sense. :D

 
I don't know if water has a memory, but that question is irrelevant to this discussion. The issue is whether OTC homeopathic cough medicines are less efficacious than OTC non-homeopathic cough medicines.

I wrote the OP. If you want to derail, start your own thread. You're asking questions that have been answered here and elsewhere heaps of times. It's about time you answered a question:

Explain for us, if you can, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."

The question is germane because the homeopathic principle of water having a "memory" is one of the most obvious quack notions in homeopathy -- a debunked quackery which you have chosen to defend.

M.
 
Okay, although I would still like to know exactly where Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D are mentioned in the research articles

Have you read the research articles?

and what the specific findings of the research were.

I told you in my first post that these were controlled trials showing effectiveness. That means "proven to relieve coughs beyond any placebo effect".

For example, was the conclusion that "Vicks Medinite, Vicks 44-D, and similarly-formulated over-the-counter cough medicines have been proven to relieve coughs beyond any placebo effect"?

Yes. See above.

I would think that, if that was the finding, the manufacturer of Vicks would advertise that fact. To my knowledge, it doesn't.

Pretty much every commercial I've seen for Vicks advertises that it is effective.

And here is another link that questions the efficacy of OTC cough medicines -- http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/10777506/

Reporters do not have the knowledge or experience to evaluate medical research. I do. Reporters also rarely transmit what is told to them by experts accurately. I undertook an informal study of this issue, once. I found that all of the articles that I evaluated contained errors. Half of them contained major errors, and in one-third of those, the errors were so egregious that the research actually said the opposite of what was reported.

I don't know if your ignorance is feigned or real, but it is interesting to see how long you can drag this out.

Linda
 
More stuff:
http://www.mrw.interscience.wiley.com/cochrane/clsysrev/articles/CD001831/frame.html

It covers 24 studies... Where is the equivalent for homeopathic cough remedies?

Oh... and ...
...It's about time you answered a question:

Explain for us, if you can, the homeopathic principle of how water has a "memory."

The question is germane because the homeopathic principle of water having a "memory" is one of the most obvious quack notions in homeopathy -- a debunked quackery which you have chosen to defend.

M.
 
Have you read the research articles?
I've read the abstracts that you have supplied, but have not been able to access the articles on-line. How about if you supply a page cite to where Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D are mentioned in the research articles?

I told you in my first post that these were controlled trials showing effectiveness. That means "proven to relieve coughs beyond any placebo effect".
Effectiveness of specific products, including Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D, or just the effectiveness of one or more of the ingredients found in those two products?

Pretty much every commercial I've seen for Vicks advertises that it is effective.
Sure, but that's far different than stating on the label: "Proven effective in clinical trials. For further information, see ______________"

Reporters do not have the knowledge or experience to evaluate medical research. I do.
And your profession is . . .

I don't know if your ignorance is feigned or real, but it is interesting to see how long you can drag this out. Linda
Oh, it's real. ;)
 
Oh, it's real. ;)

And greatly exaggerated to the point of deliberate obtuseness. No one can be that dense and still be able to tie their own shoes without help.

The problem is your magical thinking. The names of the products are meaningless. Read the studies and read the ingredients levels. That's all that matter -- specific ingredients and specific quantities of those ingredients. They don't change simply because you use more blue dye in one brand and more yellow die in another. And it doesn't matter how many times you shake the bottle.
 
I've read the abstracts that you have supplied, but have not been able to access the articles on-line. How about if you supply a page cite to where Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D are mentioned in the research articles?

The BMJ review mentions the Vicks Medinite about half-way down the page.
http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/324/7333/329

I could not find generally accessible sites for the other studies.

Effectiveness of specific products, including Vicks Medinite and Vicks 44-D, or just the effectiveness of one or more of the ingredients found in those two products?

I've already said this several times - not just for the individual ingredients, for the combination of ingredients. The same combination as found in the brand name products or the actual brand name product.

Sure, but that's far different than stating on the label: "Proven effective in clinical trials. For further information, see ______________"

No it's not. If a medication makes claims of effectiveness, that means that data was presented to the FDA that backed up those claims - i.e. "proven effective in clinical trials".


And your profession is . . .

I am a physician specializing in Internal Medicine with a Masters degree in Public Health and 10 years (so far) experience in an academic position at a university hospital.

Originally Posted by fls
I don't know if your ignorance is feigned or real, but it is interesting to see how long you can drag this out.

Oh, it's real. ;)

:)

Linda
 
The BMJ review mentions the Vicks Medinite about half-way down the page.
http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/324/7333/329

I could not find generally accessible sites for the other studies.
Okay, thanks, (Dr.) Linda. I have found this sentence in the BMJ article: "In a crossover trial of Vicks Medinite syrup, 58% of participants rated active treatment good or better in relieving cough symptoms compared with 32% for placebo." However, is Vicks Medinite an over-the-counter medicine? I never recall seeing it on any shelves in U.S. drugstores. Also, I note that the BMJ article concludes:

"It remains unclear whether over the counter cough preparations are helpful in acute cough. We therefore cannot yet recommend these medicines as first line treatment for cough associated with upper respiratory tract infection. The NHS encourages self treatment for acute self limiting illnesses, and the use of over the counter cough preparations as a home remedy. Although these medicines are generally well tolerated, their purchase could lead to unnecessary expense for the healthcare consumer. The advice to use over the counter cough medicines should therefore be restricted until more evidence becomes available on their effectiveness."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom