Homeopathic Cough Medicine

It seems that the problem begins with your belief that fraud isn't a crime.
No. Fraud is a crime, but homeopathy isn't, unless the homeopath knows the treatment will not work, but still attempts to profit from it.
 
And the name of the commercial cough remedy that produces an effect above placebo is . . .

I'm holding back from just naming one which contains one of the ingredients which have been shown to have a small but significant effect because you're ignoring the point that trade names are immaterial. If you disagree, please explain why; if not, please concede the point.
 
No. Fraud is a crime, but homeopathy isn't, unless the homeopath knows the treatment will not work, but still attempts to profit from it.

Even if it was true what you say above, we have a neat proverb over here which fits quite well:

Unwissenheit schützt vor Strafe nicht. Ignorance is no excuse.
 
No. Fraud is a crime, but homeopathy isn't, unless the homeopath knows the treatment will not work, but still attempts to profit from it.

Rephrase: I think the problem begins with your belief that quackery is okay. Way to duck the point, by the way.

If you're just going to ignore everything but the part you can jump on, then forget it. It's not even worth the time it takes to type this.
 
I'm holding back from just naming one which contains one of the ingredients which have been shown to have a small but significant effect because you're ignoring the point that trade names are immaterial. If you disagree, please explain why; if not, please concede the point.
I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.
 
Even if it was true what you say above, we have a neat proverb over here which fits quite well:

Unwissenheit schützt vor Strafe nicht. Ignorance is no excuse.
So, in the recent case of spinach contamination in the United States, a grocer who unwittingly sold the spinach was guilty of fraud?
 
So, in the recent case of spinach contamination in the United States, a grocer who unwittingly sold the spinach was guilty of fraud?

Rodney, don't try to make me fall for cheap tricks you obviously learned at the discussion school of the stone age.
 
So, in the recent case of spinach contamination in the United States, a grocer who unwittingly sold the spinach was guilty of fraud?
If the grocer should have known that the spinach was contaminated, he is certainly be guilty of something. He's either fraudulent or grossly negligent. There was a case a few years back over here where a butcher was prosecuted for selling meat products contaminated with E. coli.

But before people became ill, nobody knew that the spinach was contaminated. There was no way the grocer could have known.

On the other hand, it is well known that homoeopathy consistently fails in DBPC trials. That is why you get homoeopaths making excuses, pretending that homoeopathy cannot be tested by DBPC protocols, and running customer satisfaction surveys while pretending that they are proper trials.
 
I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.
Can you cite a study in which a single homoeopathic ingredient of a homoeopathic cough medicine has been shown to be effective (never mind the fact that many homoeopaths would say that the "polypharmacy" employed in OTC homoeopathic nostrums would render them ineffective)?
 
I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.

I'm still not following you, could you explain more fully? The brand does not affect the chemical action of the constituents.
 
Your argument about the ingredients reminds me of something that happened when I was on a camping trip with a group of boys when I was 14 years old. Our counselor made us pancakes for breakfast one morning and then informed us that, while he did not have any pancake syrup, he was going to make his own syrup with sugar and water. He was adamant that "syrup is just sugar and water." I still remember how his blend of sugar and water ruined the pancakes. So, I'm not really interested in hearing the mantra that "cough medicines composed of these ingredients SHOULD do exactly the same thing"; rather I'm interested in the name of a cough medicine that has actually been proven to WORK. And, I feel confident that most folks here who live above the tropics in the Northern Hemisphere also would like to know the name of an OTC cough medicine that works before the winter cold season sets in. Just one name would be fine.

I could make a nice caramel syrup with just sugar and water. Yes he left out ingredients to make what you where thinking of, but what on earth does that matter to how chemical X responds with in the body? They are not leaving out the ingredients that are effective(you know the medications) when cough syrup is made.

What you seem to be trying to ask for is that every formulation of a medicine be fully tested, even if it is identical to one that already has been tested. This is unnecessary and going to be very expensive, do you really want all medicine to cost what non generic prescription drugs cost? Has Walmart brand aspirin ever been shown to do anything in proper scientific tests? Why should it matter that everything in it has been tested that brand has not.
 
No. Fraud is a crime, but homeopathy isn't, unless the homeopath knows the treatment will not work, but still attempts to profit from it.

So if I believe that by defecating on your roof will fix it, and you only tell me to fix the roof, you deserve what you get?
 
I disagree because consumers purchase a bottle of cough medicine, not a bottle of cough medicine ingredients. To my knowledge, not a single brand (including generic brands) of cough medicine has been proven to be efficacious in a controlled study. If I'm wrong, please cite the study.

And no brand of vegetables has been shown to be part of a balanced diet. How can I know what vegetables to eat if I don't know the brands used in various testing?
 
So, in the recent case of spinach contamination in the United States, a grocer who unwittingly sold the spinach was guilty of fraud?

Well, where is the backgrounds of testing that show that spinach is infected with e-coli as a general rule? The principle you are missing here is that generally spinach is safe, homeopathy has never been shown to do anything effective. So anyone who looked and actually knew anything about the backgrounds of spinach and homeopathy would know that that there is no reason for the grocer to think that the spinach as contaminated as that is no the normal state of spinach, and there is no reason for the homeopath to think his formations will do anything as there is no evidence that it does.
 
I'm still not following you, could you explain more fully? The brand does not affect the chemical action of the constituents.

No it is just like with water, I knows if it is lowly tap water, or is Aquafina. It does not matter than the one is the other put into bottles.

Never question the validity of brand names ever single atom knows if it is a name brand or a generic brand and acts accordingly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom