Homeopathic Cough Medicine

If some guy says he's going to fix your roof and then just messes around a bit up there, replaces a few shingles, then charges you $400 for it, having fixed nothing at all, that's your problem? Not the government's? Not mine? What if I'm his next customer? I don't want to pay some shyster $400 for doing a piss-poor job.

Your attitude sucks Rodney. You're basicvally condoning theft.
I someone steals your wallet or your car? Well, that's your problem isn't it?
Tell you what, next time it happens to you, tell the police to sod off and mind their own business why don't you?

Meanwhile, I'll be reporting the theft in the hopes that the criminals can be brought to justice. Whether they're stealing cars or selling quackery and snake-oils.
Again, you are equating homeopathy and fraud with no evidence. If you have evidence that homeopaths know that their treatments don't work and are still charging for them, let's hear the evidence.
 
First, you assume that homeopathy is a scam or a con game. Do you have evidence that, not only does it not work, but that its proponents know that it does not work?

Whether or not the proponents know it's nonsense is not important to the fact that it's still a scam. Homeopathy is being marketed and sold as something it's not. This is a scam.

And there's plenty of evidence that homeopathy doesn't work. Tons of evidence. And no decent evidence that shows homeopathy to be effective at all. But its proponents, rather than looking at the evidence and realizing it's a scam, prefer to turn a blind eye and keep on happily making loads of money selling water and sugar tablets and pretend it's medication.

Second, do you disagree that homeopathic medicines can have a placebo effect?

Of course not. The only effect they have is a placebo effect.
But to go selling it and saying it's medication when it's only a placebo is just plain criminal.
And in case you didn't know, even doctors aren't allowed to prescribe placebo without their patient's knowledge. It sounds silly, because once the patient knows, the placebo effect is gone, right? But even so, they're not allowed to, because then they'd be scamming their patients, which is immoral.
The only placebo they can prescribe is for kids, if they tell the parents. Or they could prescribe aspirin for something that they know (but the patient doesn't) cannot be cured by aspirin.

Third, if the government bans homeopathic medicines on the grounds that their efficacy has not been demonstrated, do you want all products banned when their efficacy has not been demonstrated?

Isn't that how it is already? With real medications anyway? They have to undergo rigourous testing. Only when they pass all the safety and efficacy tests can they be sold.
This is the main reason why so many people are upset by the free pass that homeopathy is getting. They haven't undergone any testing at all. And when they are tested, they show no effect.

So yes dammit, they need to be banned.
The moment they're being prescribed as "medicine", the prescriber should be fined for swindling their patient.
The moment they make therapeutic claims on their packaging, the manufacturer should be fined for fraud.
The moment they make any kind of claim about their product that has not yet been proven in a test, they should get the pants sued off them for being bloody liars. Because that's what they are.
The only thing that's going to put a stop to this nonsense is hard action in response to any transgression of the rules. And for that we need to have some holes in the rules patched up first.
 
I already have: All OTC cough medicines.

Uhm, no, the common cold is known to currently be uncurable. What cold medicine does is alleviate the symptoms. What homeopathy does is ... nothing at all.

Care to give another example? Perhaps this time one that actually proves your point?
 
I think you'll find that dying people who take "real medicine" will also still die. ;)

Now you're just being silly. What about diabetes for starters?
Tetanus?
Rabies?
Apendectomy?
Heart surgery?

Now that's "real medicine" saving lives every day. All problems that would kill if left untreated. All problems that homeopathy has luckily left alone for now. Would that perhaps be because they know that once they get into that, their odds of being accepted as a "safe" alternative will rapidly dwindle and disappear altogether? Hmmm ...
 
Isn't that how it is already? With real medications anyway? They have to undergo rigourous testing. Only when they pass all the safety and efficacy tests can they be sold.
Are you now trying to draw a distinction between "real medications" and other medications, such as OTC cough medicines? If not, you have to explain how all of the OTC cough medicines got on the market with government approval. If so, where do you draw the line? For example, if a new cancer drug is claimed by a reputable manufacturer to cure pancreatic or liver cancer, but it has not yet undergone rigorous testing that has established its efficacy, should that drug be banned?
 
Again, you are equating homeopathy and fraud with no evidence.

Define "no evidence". If you consider 200 years of testing showing that homeopathy performs no better than placebo to be "no evidence", then yes, you're absolutely right.

Of course, if we used that same definition of "no evidence", we'd still be into things like bloodletting. So luckily, we're using another definition than yours.

If you have evidence that homeopaths know that their treatments don't work and are still charging for them, let's hear the evidence.

As said before, whether or not homeopaths know their treatments are ineffective is unimportant. The fact that their treatments are ineffective and being sold as if they are, is what makes it a scam.
Further more, homeopaths have already been told this over and over, and they're just not listening. The only possible explanations are that they either don't care they're ripping people off, or they're deluded and think they personally know better than 200 years of medical and scientific advancement.
 
Are you now trying to draw a distinction between "real medications" and other medications, such as OTC cough medicines? If not, you have to explain how all of the OTC cough medicines got on the market with government approval.

Are you suggesting that over the counter medication has not been tested for safety and efficacy? Tell me, in which country do you live right now? Is it below the equator? In Asia? Mexico maybe?

If so, where do you draw the line? For example, if a new cancer drug is claimed by a reputable manufacturer to cure pancreatic or liver cancer, but it has not yet undergone rigorous testing that has established its efficacy, should that drug be banned?

It should not be banned, it should be tested. Which is exactly what happens when it's used in a trial run in hospitals. People with pancreatic cancer are entered into a testing program for this new drug, then a bunch of them get the new drug, the rest get the old treatment, or if no old treatment exists, a placebo. Then the test results show if the drug is effective compared to placebo, or more effective than the old one, or has less undesirable side effects than the previous treatment, etc...

Should it be banned from being sold over the counter or for general use?
You bet.

Should it be banned from being used?
Not at all. The very testing of the drug requires it being used on real live patients. So this is what happens with new, experimental drugs. They get used in experiments that decide whether it's safe and effective or not.

But you see Rodney, none of this matters, because the few homeopathic remedies that have even made it this far (i.e. get tested for efficacy) have never gotten beyond this stage. There is no homepathic treatment on the face of this earth that has passed a properly designed double blind placebo controlled drug trial. And the ones that did were later found to be in trials so badly designed so as not to be worthy of the name "double blind" or "controlled".
 
Uhm, no, the common cold is known to currently be uncurable. What cold medicine does is alleviate the symptoms. What homeopathy does is ... nothing at all.
Uhm, this thread is titled "Homeopathic Cough Medicine" and so my example could not be more relevant. Also, what makes you think that non-homeopathic cough medicines alleviate symptoms better than homeopathic ones? Can you cite a study?

Care to give another example? Perhaps this time one that actually proves your point?
Again, my point is already proven. ;) However, as you note, the common cold is known to currently be uncurable and yet billions of dollars are spent on non-homeopathic cold medications. Again, do they work better than homeopathic ones? And again, if you say yes, can you cite a study?
 
Uhm, this thread is titled "Homeopathic Cough Medicine" and so my example could not be more relevant. Also, what makes you think that non-homeopathic cough medicines alleviate symptoms better than homeopathic ones? Can you cite a study?

I don't think there has ever been a study comparing OTC cold medication against homeopathy. You see, in general, drug manufaturers are only interested in finding out the efficacy of their own medications, and so they're not really interested in doing the homeopath's work for them. Seeing how these kinds of drug trials are a rather costly matter, I can't say I blame them. Maybe they should though, so we could finally put this matter to rest and bury homeopathy alongside all the other quack medications that got out of style.

But, right, I forgot: the homeopaths are just going to ignore this trial, like they have all the others that have so far shown that homeopathy does jack-diddly.

Again, my point is already proven. ;)

Is it?

However, as you note, the common cold is known to currently be uncurable and yet billions of dollars are spent on non-homeopathic cold medications. Again, do they work better than homeopathic ones? And again, if you say yes, can you cite a study?

I think there actually has been a study done testing a homeopathic cold remedy against placebo. I can't cite it right away though. Maybe someone else has a link to it handy.
But I'm pretty sure one conclusion was made: They found that the homeopathic remedy cured people's cold in one week, while the placebo group took 7 days to get better.

I know what I'm going to do next time I have a cold:
drink lots of fluids and keep warm.
 
Whether OTC cough medicines work or not has absolutely no bearing on whether OTC homeopathic remedies work or not. The point is irrelevant.

It was used recently in the House of Lords debate here in the UK by Baroness Barker who stated, “Most of the orthodox equivalents for those conditions would be over-the-counter medicines, which probably have efficacy rates that are equally contentious” whilst defending the sale of homeopathic remedies for minor self-limiting conditions.

It’s simply the ‘two wrongs make a right’ fallacy.

If manufacturers of cough medicines are making false or exaggerated claims for their products then that should be put right; however, if they are making false or exaggerated claims, it is not a justification for selling other products with false claims about their efficacy (and this certainly is the case with homeopathic remedies).
 
Instructions on how to learn homeopathy. Take a book on homeopathy and grind it up into little pieces. Do 30 serial dilutions of 1 to 100 (initially one part book to 100 parts water). Be very careful when taking the resulting liquid since it may make you so smart your brains might fall out of your head.
Peter Bowditch has a much better training course for homoeopaths, outlined in his article Homeopathy - all the idiocy that fits:
1. Remove the brain. It does not have to come out in one piece, so any method may be used which does not damage the skull too much.
2. Blend the brain with 10 times its weight in sand.
3. Take 10% of the mixture and blend that with 10 times its weight in sand.
4. Repeat step 3 20 times.
5. Pour the final mixture back into the cavity where the brain was.
6. If the brain was removed by trepanning or arthroscopy, seal the hole in the skull with a cork (do not use a rubber bung). If the entire top of the skull was removed, put the top back on carefully and apply an electric current vertically until the bone knits again.
7. Succuss the head twice on each side with a brick.
8. Award certificate of competence.
He also notes that some courses miss out steps 1 to 6...
 
It’s simply the ‘two wrongs make a right’ fallacy.

Absolutely true. Nevertheless...

Also, what makes you think that non-homeopathic cough medicines alleviate symptoms better than homeopathic ones? Can you cite a study?

There have been many studies into the effects of non-homeopathic, non-antiviral or antibacterial cough and cold treatments. Seven Cochrane reviews have been conducted to summarise the research, and these were themselves reviewed by Arroll (2005) in Respiratory Medicine.

Long story short:

Many OTC cough/cold treatments contain decongestants such as oxymetazoline, phenylpropanolamine, norphedrine and pseudoephedrine. In single-dose studies, each of these chemicals, delivered orally or nasally depending on the advised method ingestion) showed a decongestant benefit above placebo. Not enough data exist to evaluate multi-dose administration.

Antitussives (for acute cough) were found to have more equivocal evidence in favour of their efficacy: codeine showed no effect above placebo for the cough itself (though probably makes people feel better in other ways), and dextromethorphan was shown to be effective in two studies, whilst a third showed no benefit over placebo. Moguisteine showed benefit only in a subgroup of patients (those with a more severe acute night cough).

Guaifenesin, an expectorant, was shown to decrease self-reported cough when compared to placebo, and also significantly reduced sputum thickness. Bisolvon linctus, a mucolytic, was found to reduce cough compared with placebo - albeit in only one study. Another mucolytic, letosteine, was found to show reduce coughing in children.

In addition to all of these, various combinations of these medications, sometimes with an antihistamine, were shown to have varying levels of effectiveness.

So, whilst more high-quality evidence is required, it is clear that some of the ingredients of common OTC cough and cold remedies do have reasonable clinical trials supporting their efficacy.

If you like, I could give you the references of the Cochrane reviews, and the individual trials, but only if you're going to actually do domething with them. I can also give you a copy of the Arroll paper if you wish.

So Rodney, perhaps now you could cite a study supporting homeopathic cough/cold remedies, or admit that non-homeopathic cough/cold remedies do indeed have considerably more evidence in their favour?





(Incidentally, the reason I'm replying like this is that, although John Jackson and others are absolutely right in saying that it's a 'two wrongs make a right' fallacy to say that 'OTC medicines don't work, therefore we should continue to sell homeopathic remedies', I do think there is a potential point there for hypocrisy on our part. I personally think all OTC medicines should have gone through proper clinical trials before they can make claims to treat certain conditions, homeopathic or not. So, I oppose the sale of those which have not. However, it is also the case that homeopathy, as an entire 'system' of medicine, with no evidence in its favour, yet growing in popularity and in direct contradiction to modern science, is an infinitely more insidious and subverting influence than many other things which are poorly evidenced. So, my priorities would be towards addressing homeopathy more urgently, but of course it is a false dilemma - we should be addressing all such things.)
 
Last edited:
There have been many studies into the effects of non-homeopathic, non-antiviral or antibacterial cough and cold treatments. Seven Cochrane reviews have been conducted to summarise the research, and these were themselves reviewed by Arroll (2005) in Respiratory Medicine.

Long story short:

Many OTC cough/cold treatments contain decongestants such as oxymetazoline, phenylpropanolamine, norphedrine and pseudoephedrine. In single-dose studies, each of these chemicals, delivered orally or nasally depending on the advised method ingestion) showed a decongestant benefit above placebo. Not enough data exist to evaluate multi-dose administration.

Antitussives (for acute cough) were found to have more equivocal evidence in favour of their efficacy: codeine showed no effect above placebo for the cough itself (though probably makes people feel better in other ways), and dextromethorphan was shown to be effective in two studies, whilst a third showed no benefit over placebo. Moguisteine showed benefit only in a subgroup of patients (those with a more severe acute night cough).

Guaifenesin, an expectorant, was shown to decrease self-reported cough when compared to placebo, and also significantly reduced sputum thickness. Bisolvon linctus, a mucolytic, was found to reduce cough compared with placebo - albeit in only one study. Another mucolytic, letosteine, was found to show reduce coughing in children.

In addition to all of these, various combinations of these medications, sometimes with an antihistamine, were shown to have varying levels of effectiveness.

So, whilst more high-quality evidence is required, it is clear that some of the ingredients of common OTC cough and cold remedies do have reasonable clinical trials supporting their efficacy.

If you like, I could give you the references of the Cochrane reviews, and the individual trials, but only if you're going to actually do domething with them. I can also give you a copy of the Arroll paper if you wish.

So Rodney, perhaps now you could cite a study supporting homeopathic cough/cold remedies, or admit that non-homeopathic cough/cold remedies do indeed have considerably more evidence in their favour?
Thanks for the information. However, it remains unclear whether any OTC cough medicine is efficacious above placebo. Has any study ever found that? Again, consider this quote from the Feb. 2002 Web MD article: "We found that there is little evidence for or against the effectiveness of over-the-counter cough medicines," says lead author Knut Schroeder, MD, researcher at University of Bristol, England. The fact that some ingredients of OTC cough medicines appear to be slightly useful does not necessarily mean that any specific OTC cough medicine is efficacious. And it is also unclear whether there has been a study of homeopathic versus non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines. If there has been, please advise.
 
Math has been used to show that all kinds of things that we now know are true couldn't possibly happen; rogue waves, to name one.
Do you have any evidence for this? I remember a thread discussing a now defunct oceanograpic model that predicted that rogue waves would be very much rarer than they now appear to be, but I don't remember any mention of a mathematical proof that they are impossible.
 
Last edited:
My experience with those who use medicines that say they are homeopathic generally think it means "herbal" or "all natural" or some variation of that.

Those who would allow me to explain homeopathy's claims have, with rare exception, said "You've got to be kidding." I think some of them even stopped using the stuff, or at least reduced their usage. Or at least reduced their usage that is visible to me...

Yeah, my mother-in-law did that. She had no idea. I explained it, she flipped out, and stopped buying it.
 
Thanks for the information. However, it remains unclear whether any OTC cough medicine is efficacious above placebo.
How about reading what Nucular posted?
Nucular said:
So, whilst more high-quality evidence is required, it is clear that some of the ingredients of common OTC cough and cold remedies do have reasonable clinical trials supporting their efficacy.
 
Uhm, this thread is titled "Homeopathic Cough Medicine" and so my example could not be more relevant. Also, what makes you think that non-homeopathic cough medicines alleviate symptoms better than homeopathic ones? Can you cite a study?

Again, my point is already proven. ;) However, as you note, the common cold is known to currently be uncurable and yet billions of dollars are spent on non-homeopathic cold medications. Again, do they work better than homeopathic ones? And again, if you say yes, can you cite a study?

you haven't managed to cite a study that shows anything about homeopathy other than it "may" have some placebo effect.

As homeos don't want any studies done (of course) then there is nothing to compare.

On the other hand you yourself may go to the websites of any of the manufacturers of cold and flu remedies and look up their studies. Go ahead - knock yourself out. You can find the studies.

You won't have any homeo studies to compare them with of course..
 
How about reading what Nucular posted?
How about reading what I posted? "The fact that some ingredients of OTC cough medicines appear to be slightly useful does not necessarily mean that any specific OTC cough medicine is efficacious." If I'm wrong, let me know the name of a specific OTC cough medicine that has been shown to be efficacious, so that I can buy it the next time I have a cough.
 
Do you have any evidence for this? I remember a thread discussing a now defunct oceanograpic model
Funny how the conventional wisdom often becomes defunct. ;)

that predicted that rogue waves would be very much rarer than they now appear to be, but I don't remember any mention of a mathematical proof that they are impossible.
Okay, fine. The "now defunct" models predicted a rogue wave every 10,000 years, which is why well-documented accounts of rogue waves were discounted by the oceanographic establishment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom