It’s simply the ‘two wrongs make a right’ fallacy.
Absolutely true. Nevertheless...
Also, what makes you think that non-homeopathic cough medicines alleviate symptoms better than homeopathic ones? Can you cite a study?
There have been many studies into the effects of non-homeopathic, non-antiviral or antibacterial cough and cold treatments. Seven Cochrane reviews have been conducted to summarise the research, and these were themselves reviewed by Arroll (2005) in
Respiratory Medicine.
Long story short:
Many OTC cough/cold treatments contain decongestants such as oxymetazoline, phenylpropanolamine, norphedrine and pseudoephedrine. In single-dose studies, each of these chemicals, delivered orally or nasally depending on the advised method ingestion) showed a decongestant benefit above placebo. Not enough data exist to evaluate multi-dose administration.
Antitussives (for acute cough) were found to have more equivocal evidence in favour of their efficacy: codeine showed no effect above placebo for the cough itself (though probably makes people feel better in other ways), and dextromethorphan was shown to be effective in two studies, whilst a third showed no benefit over placebo. Moguisteine showed benefit only in a subgroup of patients (those with a more severe acute night cough).
Guaifenesin, an expectorant, was shown to decrease self-reported cough when compared to placebo, and also significantly reduced sputum thickness. Bisolvon linctus, a mucolytic, was found to reduce cough compared with placebo - albeit in only one study. Another mucolytic, letosteine, was found to show reduce coughing in children.
In addition to all of these, various combinations of these medications, sometimes with an antihistamine, were shown to have varying levels of effectiveness.
So, whilst more high-quality evidence is required, it is clear that some of the ingredients of common OTC cough and cold remedies do have reasonable clinical trials supporting their efficacy.
If you like, I could give you the references of the Cochrane reviews, and the individual trials, but only if you're going to actually do domething with them. I can also give you a copy of the Arroll paper if you wish.
So
Rodney, perhaps now you could cite a study supporting homeopathic cough/cold remedies, or admit that non-homeopathic cough/cold remedies do indeed have considerably more evidence in their favour?
(Incidentally, the reason I'm replying like this is that, although John Jackson and others are absolutely right in saying that it's a 'two wrongs make a right' fallacy to say that 'OTC medicines don't work, therefore we should continue to sell homeopathic remedies', I do think there is a potential point there for hypocrisy on our part. I personally think all OTC medicines should have gone through proper clinical trials before they can make claims to treat certain conditions, homeopathic or not. So, I oppose the sale of those which have not. However, it is also the case that homeopathy, as an entire 'system' of medicine, with no evidence in its favour, yet growing in popularity and in direct contradiction to modern science, is an infinitely more insidious and subverting influence than many other things which are poorly evidenced. So, my priorities would be towards addressing homeopathy more urgently, but of course it is a false dilemma - we should be addressing all such things.)