Homeopathic Cough Medicine

In the past I have printed up business cards with information and weblinks about the uselessness of homeopathic remedies and left the cards on the shelf next to the products. I don't know how well it works, but here's hoping. One of my friends says that in the past he has printed up information half-sheets of cardstock, run them through one of those card laminators to make a nice, stiff (And most important, official-looking) card. He then attaches them to the shelf near the items.

Because it's laminated, it's official, right? He says that sometimes the cards remain for weeks before somebody figures out they are not official company documents and remove them. I may try this in the future...

That's a cool idea. I may try this at my local Walgrens.

Linda
 
How come, when I have replied 200 times to a really important thread, I don't get a single email notification from start to finish, and can't even pursuade it to do so by unsubscribing and re-subscribing to it, but this little piece of $#!+ of a thread is still sending me notifications after 8 months?

:D
 
Rodney,

I resurrected this thread to point out that now that Ioannidis' work is in the news again, numerous science bloggers are subjecting alt med therapies to the same kind of analysis and criticism that I applied to homeopathy in this thread. The same kind of analysis and criticism that you insisted was not a valid approach.

http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php?p=8
http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2005/09/why_most_publis.html
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/09/the_cranks_pile_on_john_ioannidis_work_o.php

So there. :seP:

Linda

I still insist that it is invalid to pull a percentage out of the air as the "prior probability" that a finding is likely to be true. That's simply a way to discredit ideas that don't comport with the current conventional wisdom.

So, stick that in your witch's brew of OTC cough medicines, sister! ;)
 
I still insist that it is invalid to pull a percentage out of the air as the "prior probability" that a finding is likely to be true. That's simply a way to discredit ideas that don't comport with the current conventional wisdom.

You are right. Since there is no a priori distinction between conventional and unconventional ideas except on the basis of supporting evidence, it is absolutely correct to say that methods of understanding the world that are based on gathering facts and forming useful explanations discredit those ideas that form useless explanations for questionable or non-existant facts. Or put another way, ideas that are useless and unsupported by facts are useless and unsupported by facts.

Of course, there are other ways of understanding the world that are not based on gathering facts and forming useful explanations, and you are welcome to use them. I just like the products of my way better.

Linda
 
This is an interesting article:



This is the conclusion of the studies:

...John Ioannidis has published a series of studies that demonstrate that most published medical studies turn out to be wrong...


This is what it means:

.....Ioannidis compared single studies to the later literature - using the literature as its own gold standard. This does not mean that medical research is wrong. It just means that a research question has to mature, that multiple studies by independent researchers are required before we arrive at a reliable conclusion...


This is the practical implication:

...The implications for the practicing physician are clear...don’t overreact to every study....
...The implications for society are also clear...any single study must be put into the context of the broader literature...


This was no shock:

...One of the best ways to minimize false positives is to carefully consider the plausibility of the intervention being studied. CAM proponents are deathly afraid of such consideration for they live in the world of infinitesimal probability...
....[it] would also kill, in a single stroke, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, which is ostensibly dedicated to researching medical treatments that have little or no scientific plausibility...


This was a shock:

...the Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) movement...does not consider prior probability...
 
Last edited:
This was a shock:
...the Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) movement...does not consider prior probability...

Yup. One of my main complaints about EBM. Most of the time, when applied to conventional topics, it makes no difference. I think it'll probably have to evolve a bit as it starts to expand its range.

Linda
 
Yup. One of my main complaints about EBM. Most of the time, when applied to conventional topics, it makes no difference. I think it'll probably have to evolve a bit as it starts to expand its range.

Linda
If EBM does not consider prior probability, Linda, then I may be more of an EBMer than you are. :) However, according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence-based

"Evidence-based medicine attempts to express clinical benefits of tests and treatments using mathematical methods. Tools used by practitioners of evidence-based medicine include:

"Likelihood ratios. The pretest probability of a particular diagnosis, multiplied by the likelihood ratio, determines the posttest probability."
 
If EBM does not consider prior probability, Linda, then I may be more of an EBMer than you are. :) However, according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence-based

"Evidence-based medicine attempts to express clinical benefits of tests and treatments using mathematical methods. Tools used by practitioners of evidence-based medicine include:

"Likelihood ratios. The pretest probability of a particular diagnosis, multiplied by the likelihood ratio, determines the posttest probability."

The 'pretest probability of a particular diagnosis' is the conditions incidence in the population, which is often reliably know.

The probability of a drug being effective is much harder to estimate a priori.
 
If EBM does not consider prior probability, Linda, then I may be more of an EBMer than you are. :)

Huh?

However, according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence-based

"Evidence-based medicine attempts to express clinical benefits of tests and treatments using mathematical methods. Tools used by practitioners of evidence-based medicine include:

"Likelihood ratios. The pretest probability of a particular diagnosis, multiplied by the likelihood ratio, determines the posttest probability."

That isn't even remotely what I or the quoted material was referring to.

Linda
 
Huh?

That isn't even remotely what I or the quoted material was referring to.

Linda
To clarify, if a prior probability percentage is estimated in a situation in which that percentage is reliably known, that makes sense to me. However, if a prior probability percentage is estimated in a situation in which that percentage is not reliably known, that does not make sense to me.
 
To clarify, if a prior probability percentage is estimated in a situation in which that percentage is reliably known, that makes sense to me. However, if a prior probability percentage is estimated in a situation in which that percentage is not reliably known, that does not make sense to me.


There seem to be two different meanings of "prior probability":


First there is "prior probability", better known as "pretest probability".
This is the known incidence of a disease in the community and is used to assess the reliability of a particular test for the disease.

Here is a good summary:

http://www.musc.edu/dc/icrebm/sensitivity.html



Then there is "prior probability", as applied in the above linked articles.
Here, the phrase, "prior probability" refers to "the scientific plausibility or likelihood based on basic science and previous data".

For example, the "prior probability" of homoeopathic treatments is essentially zero, because there is no plausible scientific mechanism for homoeopathy; and a metanalysis of previous clinical trials demonstrates that the ratio [trials with positive outcomes for homoeopathy] / [trials with negative outcomes for homeopathy] is what would be expected by chance alone.


At least that is my understanding.
 
There seem to be two different meanings of "prior probability":


First there is "prior probability", better known as "pretest probability".
This is the known incidence of a disease in the community and is used to assess the reliability of a particular test for the disease.

Here is a good summary:

http://www.musc.edu/dc/icrebm/sensitivity.html



Then there is "prior probability", as applied in the above linked articles.
Here, the phrase, "prior probability" refers to "the scientific plausibility or likelihood based on basic science and previous data".

For example, the "prior probability" of homoeopathic treatments prior probability" of homoeopathic treatments is essentially zero, because there is no plausible scientific mechanism for homoeopathy; and a metanalysis of previous clinical trials demonstrates that the ratio [trials with positive outcomes for homoeopathy] / [trials with negative outcomes for homeopathy] is what would be expected by chance alone.


At least that is my understanding.
Thanks, BillyJoe. I now recognize that the Wikipedia article is discussing only the first type of "prior probability." And again, applying a "pretest probability" percentage to a disease test makes sense to me because that percentage can be reliably estimated. However, applying a "prior probability" percentage to alternative medicine does not make sense to me because that percentage cannot be reliably estimated. Yes, skeptics may conclude that the percentage is zero because they see no plausible mechanism for how the alternative medicine could work, but they may be missing something. If the percentage really is zero, why do any tests at all?
 
Yes, skeptics may conclude that the percentage is zero because they see no plausible mechanism for how the alternative medicine could work, but they may be missing something.


Well, no plausible mechanism and only chance positive results in a metanalysis of clinical trials.

If the percentage really is zero, why do any tests at all?


That is a good question.
 
I haven’t read all of the posts on this thread, so apologies if this issue has been raised before:

FDA Advisers Urge Ban on Cold Medicines for Young Children​

By Steven Reinberg, HealthDay Reporter
posted: 29 September 2007 12:20 pm ET

(HealthDay News) -- U.S. health experts on Friday urged the federal Food and Drug Administration to consider banning the sale of over-the-counter cough and cold medicines for young children.

The recommendation, from FDA safety officials, would apply to decongestant use in children under 2, and antihistamines in those younger than 6, according to agency documents released Friday, the Associated Press reported.

The products include approximately 800 popular medicines that are sold in the United States under names like Toddler's Dimetapp, Triaminic Infant and Little Colds, The New York Times reported.

FDA advisers will consider the recommendation during a meeting on Oct. 18 and 19, and will then offer their opinion to the full agency.

More...

http://www.livescience.com/healthday/608744.html


Does anyone know if this would include homeopathic cough medicine? Because if it doesn’t, wouldn’t the proposed ban see an increase in the use of homoepathic cold remedies for young children?
 
I haven’t read all of the posts on this thread, so apologies if this issue has been raised before:

Does anyone know if this would include homeopathic cough medicine? Because if it doesn’t, wouldn’t the proposed ban see an increase in the use of homoepathic cold remedies for young children?

The ban is about reducing the harm associated with some specific drugs that are used in cough/cold medicines. It wouldn't include all cough/cold remedies, so it wouldn't include homeopathic cough/cold remedies (partly because there isn't a proper system in place to identify harm from homeopathic remedies or "food" supplements, and it is far more difficult to get harmful supplements off the market - in yet another irony of the DIM industry). If you've ever been the parent of a coughing child, the desire to "do something" can be overwhelming, so I suspect that parents will still give cough medicines to their young children. Whether that means more use of the cough medicines that would not be affected, off-label use of the affected cough medicines, or more use of DIM, I don't know.

Linda
 
The ban is about reducing the harm associated with some specific drugs that are used in cough/cold medicines. It wouldn't include all cough/cold remedies, so it wouldn't include homeopathic cough/cold remedies (partly because there isn't a proper system in place to identify harm from homeopathic remedies or "food" supplements, and it is far more difficult to get harmful supplements off the market - in yet another irony of the DIM industry). If you've ever been the parent of a coughing child, the desire to "do something" can be overwhelming, so I suspect that parents will still give cough medicines to their young children. Whether that means more use of the cough medicines that would not be affected, off-label use of the affected cough medicines, or more use of DIM, I don't know.

Linda
"Over-the-counter cough and cold medications have long been a mainstay of parents trying to comfort children fighting common colds, coughs and other upper respiratory infections. Although many leading medical groups, including the American Academy of Pediatrics, have long questioned the usefulness of such products and recommended against their use, they remain popular, especially for distraught parents desperate to do anything they can to help a sick child.

"But critics have long questioned the usefulness of the products, arguing there is virtually no good evidence to support their effectiveness, and good evidence that they can be dangerous.

"'Given that there are serious consequences, including death, associated with the use of these products without compelling reason to use them, why are they being marketed for children?' [Joshua M.] Sharfstein [Baltimore's health commissioner] said. 'The contrast between the state of the evidence and the displays in drugstores could not be more stark.'

"Sharfstein noted that some of these products have been sold in packages that depict babies and include droppers designed to administer doses supposedly safe for infants.

"No one know how many children have suffered adverse reactions to the products, but the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported earlier this year that at least 1,500 children under the age of 2 suffered complications in 2004 and 2005 after being treated with over-the-counter cough and cold medicines. An FDA review prepared for next week's meeting describes dozens of cases of convulsions, heart problems, trouble breathing, neurological complications and other reactions from a variety of products, including at least 54 deaths involving decongestants and 69 involving antihistamines.

"Many doctors advise their patients against using such products, and instead suggest they try Tylenol to alleviate pain, use dehumidifiers and salt water solutions to alleviate congestion, and give plenty of fluids to keep the child hydrated."

See http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/11/AR2007101100853.html?hpid=topnews
 
And this. (Picked the first link on Google out of sheer laziness.)

"The makers of Robitussin, Dimetapp, Tylenol Little Drops, Little Colds, Pedia-Care and Triaminic Cough and Cold Medicines for infants are voluntarily recalling their products."

What has this to do with the price of chocolate?

Linda
 
And this. (Picked the first link on Google out of sheer laziness.)

"The makers of Robitussin, Dimetapp, Tylenol Little Drops, Little Colds, Pedia-Care and Triaminic Cough and Cold Medicines for infants are voluntarily recalling their products."

What has this to do with the price of chocolate?

Linda
Quite a lot. When it is pointed out that mainstream medicinal products have no effect or potentially harmful effect, they get pulled.

Comparison to homeopathic products which have been repeatedly pointed out as having no effect: When are they voluntarily pulled?
 
Quite a lot. When it is pointed out that mainstream medicinal products have no effect or potentially harmful effect, they get pulled.

Comparison to homeopathic products which have been repeatedly pointed out as having no effect: When are they voluntarily pulled?
Assuming that homeopathic products have no effect, isn't that better than "at least 1,500 children under the age of 2 suffer[ing] complications in 2004 and 2005 after being treated with over-the-counter cough and cold medicines"?
 
Assuming that homeopathic products have no effect, isn't that better than "at least 1,500 children under the age of 2 suffer[ing] complications in 2004 and 2005 after being treated with over-the-counter cough and cold medicines"?
I have no problem in comparing the two, but let's be fair and complete about it:

1. Traditional cough and cold medicines: X billions in sales annually. Large majority of children unaffected beyond placebo. Small minority helped. Smaller minority harmed. Voluntarily recalled when the evidence of harm and little help is released.

2. Homeopathic medicines: Y billions in sales annually. Zero children helped. Possibly no children harmed but unknowable as the industry has no quality standards and some products labeled homeopathic are actually herbal. Rabid refusal to address these long-known facts.

I'll still go with evil traditional mainstream big pharma.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom