"As is used for homeopathy" in whose opinion?
Not an opinion. The evidence for homeopathic evidence is primarily anecdotal and secondarily dubious experimentation that does not withstand scrutiny. That has already been discussed on this board and in this thread; I do not wish to rehash it.
Rodney said:
But let me make it easy for you: If you can find a study demonstrating your point using the same standard of evidence as was used by the authors of the British Medical Journal article that I quoted, I'll accept that.
Dig through this very thread, Rodney.
Rodney said:
So would you ban all homeopathic products?
Any that don't say:
The evidence overwhelmingly indicates that you are wasting your money buying this product unless you simply want something to give you a nice placebo effect. Homeopathic remedies have never been clinically shown to demonstrate efficacy in any condition that is not self-correcting. In addition, beware of products labeled "homeopathic" which are in fact herbal and therefore present a danger which is not present in homeopathy because homeopathy is really just water or sugar pills.
Rodney said:
Not an apt analogy unless you are alleging that all or most homeopaths are frauds.
Fraudulent or deluded. I do not speculate on the ratio. The analogy remains apt.
I don't think the two studies are at odds. The first find no effect above placebo,
Exactly. Precisely the standard of evidence for homeopathic remedies.
Rodney said:
while the second finds actual harm.
Exactly. I show contrary evidence. How often do you show evidence contrary to your position?
Rodney said:
If your standard for "helped" is the placebo effect, then surely homeopathic cough medicines meet that same standard.
You are bordering on being intentionally deceitful. It is homeopathy that uses placebo as the standard for helped. That has been my whole point.
Rodney said:
So, I still don't understand your initial analysis:
"1. Traditional cough and cold medicines: X billions in sales annually. Large majority of children unaffected beyond placebo. Small minority helped. Smaller minority harmed.
"2. Homeopathic medicines: Y billions in sales annually. Zero children helped."
It's quite clear. I fail to understand how you do not understand it.
Rodney said:
Only because eventually the evidence became so obvious that even the world's most prestigious scientific body could see it.
I see. You are saying that when an organization abandons a strongly held position in the face of overwhelming evidence it is an indication of a flaw with that organization even if the timespan is relatively short. Homeopathy, then, must rank very highly in your eyes given its refusal to abandon its claims in the face of over a century of overwhelming evidence.
Rodney said:
But why the arrogant attitude on the part of the scientific establishment?
They thought they were right. When shown otherwise, they changed. Does arrogance (which you haven't demonstrated the French Academy showed) nullify evidence?
If you want real arrogance, look at the homeopathic community who continue to peddle their magic water despite a century of overwhelming evidence. That's arrogance. That's inexcusable.
One more thing. Who, exactly, do you think convinced the "scientific establishment" to abandon their position on meteorites? It wasn't homeopaths or psychics or mediums or dowsers or alchemists. It was scientists.
I'll take bushels of that kind of arrogance over a tanker of 30C snake oil any day.
Rodney said:
No, traditional OTC cough medicines for children have been pulled only because of evidence of actual harm, not simply a lack of efficacy.
Have you read the links in this thread?
Rodney said:
If it can be shown that homeopathic cough medicines for children cause actual harm, they will be pulled also.
One would hope. The history of the homeopathic community suggests otherwise.
Rodney said:
Again, there is some evidence that homeopathic remedies work, so it's a question of what standard of evidence is used.
Anecdotal evidence, testimonials, and a handful of trials which when scrutinized reveal no statistical significance or reveal fatal methodological flaws.