Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I somehow missed that logic, but feel free to explain it.
I cannot improve upon Linda's phrasing.


Which is nice of you, considering you had zero evidence for that claim.
Let's see:

1. Zero evidence homeopathy works
2. Zero evidence homeopathy hurts anyone

Are you advocating homeopathy based on that?


I don't know whether it's the remedy or the power of suggestion, but it's clear that children have reported feeling better after taking homeopathic cough medicine, just as they have after taking other OTC cough medicines.
Before this information came to light, I would have said it is the former for homeopathy and the latter for the OTC stuff. Now I would say it is the former for homeopathy and in at least some cases the former for the OTC stuff as well.


As long as you have some numbers from a study. Do you?
Ah. So I can't use the same standard of evidence as for homeopathy?

Typical.
 
Let's see:

1. Zero evidence homeopathy works
2. Zero evidence homeopathy hurts anyone

Are you advocating homeopathy based on that?
As I said in my first post on this thread (#9 overall):

"If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem? And is your solution to have the government ban the cough medicine?"

Ah. So I can't use the same standard of evidence as for homeopathy?

Typical.
I'm just trying to figure out the basis for your assertion that a small minority of children have been helped by traditional cough and cold medicines and that a smaller minority have been harmed. Did your guru tell you that? ;)
 
As I said in my first post on this thread (#9 overall):

"If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem? And is your solution to have the government ban the cough medicine?"
Contrast this with this:
Rodney said:
I'm just trying to figure out the basis for your assertion that a small minority of children have been helped by traditional cough and cold medicines and that a smaller minority have been harmed. Did your guru tell you that? ;)
You do not see an inconsistency?


Rodney said:
Garrette's guru told me he saw one.
I told you; I'm his sycophant...

But at least you finally admit the level of evidence you require for extraordinary claims. Pink crows. Homeopathy. Psychic detectives.

Somebody told you.
 
You do not see an inconsistency?
No. I don't see any reason for banning homeopathic cough medicines unless they are proven to cause harm. On the other hand, you're making an unsupported assertion about traditional OTC cough medicines having helped more children than they have harmed.

But at least you finally admit the level of evidence you require for extraordinary claims. Pink crows. Homeopathy. Psychic detectives.

Somebody told you.
No, I've examined the evidence on my own, at least regarding homeopathy and psychic detectives.
 
No. I don't see any reason for banning homeopathic cough medicines unless they are proven to cause harm. On the other hand, you're making an unsupported assertion about traditional OTC cough medicines having helped more children than they have harmed.
The inconsistency to which I was referring, and which you say you do not see, is an inconsistency in standards of evidence.

You ask "If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem?" in reference to a homeopathic remedy, indicating that an unsupported anecdote is sufficient evidence to indicate efficacy.

Then, in regard to traditional OTC medicines you say "I'm just trying to figure out the basis for your assertion that a small minority of children have been helped by traditional cough and cold medicines and that a smaller minority have been harmed." Which makes it quite clear that you reject unsupported anecdote as sufficient evidence for traditional medicine's efficacy.

Which is precisely why you keep avoiding my question about whether or not I can use the same standard of evidence as homeopathy does to support my assertions.


Rodney said:
No, I've examined the evidence on my own, at least regarding homeopathy and psychic detectives.
Yes, I know you have. I also know, as do you, that none of your evidence has withstood scrutiny.
 
The inconsistency to which I was referring, and which you say you do not see, is an inconsistency in standards of evidence.

You ask "If the work colleague thinks she has been helped, what exactly is the problem?" in reference to a homeopathic remedy, indicating that an unsupported anecdote is sufficient evidence to indicate efficacy.

Then, in regard to traditional OTC medicines you say "I'm just trying to figure out the basis for your assertion that a small minority of children have been helped by traditional cough and cold medicines and that a smaller minority have been harmed." Which makes it quite clear that you reject unsupported anecdote as sufficient evidence for traditional medicine's efficacy.

Which is precisely why you keep avoiding my question about whether or not I can use the same standard of evidence as homeopathy does to support my assertions.
You're confusing two different issues. The first issue is whether a remedy that has not been proven to be efficacious above placebo should be permitted to be sold over the counter. I say yes, unless that remedy has been proven to be harmful. The second issue is whether traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed. I see no evidence for that claim.

Yes, I know you have. I also know, as do you, that none of your evidence has withstood scrutiny.
That's a matter of opinion. :)
 
You're confusing two different issues.
No. I understand the distinction. I was talking about the second and you decided to talk about the first because it meant you wouldn't have to answer the question you still haven't answered.


Rodney said:
The first issue is whether a remedy that has not been proven to be efficacious above placebo should be permitted to be sold over the counter. I say yes, unless that remedy has been proven to be harmful.
I do not agree, and the reason is that you base your position on a presumption of a new substance being introduced in a vacuum without history. The history of homeopathic remedies includes the substantial point that it is not consistent and not all remedies labeled homeopathic are actually homeopathic. You also ignore financial harm and the harm of ignoring treatments known to be effective. And that doesn't even get into the precedent you are setting. Shall we allow anyone to dispense medical advice up to the point it is proven they do harm? Shall we allow Big Pharma to market any old pill they like until such point they are proven to do harm? And when the harm is proven do we let them off the hook because they did nothing illegal?


Rodney said:
The second issue is whether traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed. I see no evidence for that claim.
If you see any evidence at all that homeopathy has ever helped anyone, then you see evidence that traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed. But this, of course, gets back to the question you won't answer.


Rodney said:
That's a matter of opinion. :)
No. It's a matter of standards. Standards established through a long history of determining the best method for approximating the truth.
 
No. I understand the distinction. I was talking about the second and you decided to talk about the first because it meant you wouldn't have to answer the question you still haven't answered.
And what question might that be?

I do not agree, and the reason is that you base your position on a presumption of a new substance being introduced in a vacuum without history. The history of homeopathic remedies includes the substantial point that it is not consistent and not all remedies labeled homeopathic are actually homeopathic. You also ignore financial harm and the harm of ignoring treatments known to be effective. And that doesn't even get into the precedent you are setting. Shall we allow anyone to dispense medical advice up to the point it is proven they do harm? Shall we allow Big Pharma to market any old pill they like until such point they are proven to do harm? And when the harm is proven do we let them off the hook because they did nothing illegal?
Do you disagree with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's policies on homeopathic drugs? See http://www.fda.gov/ora/compliance_ref/cpg/cpgdrg/cpg400-400.html

If you see any evidence at all that homeopathy has ever helped anyone, then you see evidence that traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed.
Studies on homeopathic remedies have shown mixed results. I'm still looking for a study showing that traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed.

No. It's a matter of standards. Standards established through a long history of determining the best method for approximating the truth.
When the leading 18th Century scientific body (French Academy of Sciences) determined using its standards that there are no meteorites, was that helpful in approximating the truth?
 
{snip} Do you disagree with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's policies on homeopathic drugs? See http://www.fda.gov/ora/compliance_ref/cpg/cpgdrg/cpg400-400.html
The FDA on homeopathy is dictated by law, not science. Credulous legislators were persuaded to endorse it (at least, minimally) by a powerful, homeopath senator (Royal Copeland) 70 years ago.
Studies on homeopathic remedies have shown mixed results. {snip}
The best studies show it is useless, see above. But, feel free to cite any you think are good and support homeopathy.
When the leading 18th Century scientific body (French Academy of Sciences) determined using its standards that there are no meteorites, was that helpful in approximating the truth?
Irrelevant, grasping at straws. We call this the Galileo defense, Galileo was right despite prevailing opinion. In 200 years, homeopaths have never proven themselves "right" (along with astrologers, flat-earthers, phrenologists, Biblical literalists ...).
 
The FDA on homeopathy is dictated by law, not science. Credulous legislators were persuaded to endorse it (at least, minimally) by a powerful, homeopath senator (Royal Copeland) 70 years ago.
The FDA regulation I linked to -- Sec. 400.400, "Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed" -- was established not 70 years ago but in 1988 (and revised in 1995). Do you believe it should be revised? If so, how?

The best studies show it is useless, see above. But, feel free to cite any you think are good and support homeopathy.
An article in the British Medical Journal (1991, 302:316-323) reviewed 105 homeopathy trials, finding that 81 had positive results. Yes, that review can be challenged, but the question is whether homeopathic remedies should be banned if they do no harm and might be beneficial.

Irrelevant, grasping at straws. We call this the Galileo defense, Galileo was right despite prevailing opinion. In 200 years, homeopaths have never proven themselves "right" (along with astrologers, flat-earthers, phrenologists, Biblical literalists ...).
The fundamental issue is whether the prevailing scientific conventional wisdom should be accepted as the ultimate truth. Time and time again, that wisdom has proven to be incomplete, misleading, or flat-out wrong.
 
And what question might that be?
May I used the same standard of evidence in regard to traditional OTC medicine as is used for homeopathy? I have repeated this question a few times. I find it difficult to believe you do not know what it is.


Do you disagree with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's policies on homeopathic drugs? See http://www.fda.gov/ora/compliance_ref/cpg/cpgdrg/cpg400-400.html
Yes, largely for the reason JJM has mentioned. Let us make it clear to the lurkers that the link you posted makes it clear that homeopathic remedies for self-limiting conditions recognizable by the consumer are the only ones allowed to be sold OTC and that homeopathic remedies for serious conditions require a license which most homeopaths do not possess.


Studies on homeopathic remedies have shown mixed results.
Just like Uri Geller's performances show mixed results yet it is clear he is a fraud because there are no positive results beyond placebo except when the performances do not have proper controls.


I'm still looking for a study showing that traditional OTC cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed.
Really? You don't look very hard. No better than placebo, but also no worse, statistically speaking. No one harmed.



Now before you accuse me of cherry-picking, here's a contrary view:


When the leading 18th Century scientific body (French Academy of Sciences) determined using its standards that there are no meteorites, was that helpful in approximating the truth?
Absolutely. You'll note that that position is no longer held because of countervailing evidence. You'll note that traditional OTC cough medicines may be pulled from the shelves because of a lack of efficacy. You'll not that homeopathic remedies continue to be hawked despite a lack of efficacy. I'll stick with the scientific system, thanks; the system homeopathy has opted out of.
 
I think there should be a rule that if you think the process is useless, you don't get access to the results.

Linda
 
The FDA regulation I linked to -- Sec. 400.400, "Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed" -- was established not 70 years ago but in 1988 (and revised in 1995).
Yes, and it limits prescribing homeopathy to individuals licensed in a way that most homeopaths aren't.


An article in the British Medical Journal (1991, 302:316-323) reviewed 105 homeopathy trials, finding that 81 had positive results. Yes, that review can be challenged,
And has been.


but the question is whether homeopathic remedies should be banned if they do no harm and might be beneficial.
It's the "might be" that's problematic along with "beneficial." Drinking water is beneficial, so some homeopathic remedies are by definition beneficial. "Might be" is just wishful thinking. Lots of things "might be" beneficial, but that does not entitle me to profit off their sale if the "might be" is equivalent to a lotto play.


The fundamental issue is whether the prevailing scientific conventional wisdom should be accepted as the ultimate truth.
Straw man. The scientific and medical community do not accept it as the ultimate truth. Your own example of the French and the meteorites demonstrates that quite nicely. It wasn't homeopaths who determined the conventional wisdom was wrong; it was scientists.


Time and time again, that wisdom has proven to be incomplete, misleading, or flat-out wrong.
Exactly. And when shown to be such, it is abandoned, modified, change, and retried. Homeopathy, on the other hand, despite time and time again being shown to be worthless, remains the same.
 
I think there should be a rule that if you think the process is useless, you don't get access to the results.

Linda
I like that. Or you could let people choose one or the other but not both. Here's your choice of medical plans, Rodney. For the rest of your life, you and your family may access either traditional medicine or homeopathic cures. Your choice. No turning back.

I wonder what the choice would be.
 
May I used the same standard of evidence in regard to traditional OTC medicine as is used for homeopathy? I have repeated this question a few times. I find it difficult to believe you do not know what it is.
"As is used for homeopathy" in whose opinion? But let me make it easy for you: If you can find a study demonstrating your point using the same standard of evidence as was used by the authors of the British Medical Journal article that I quoted, I'll accept that.

Yes, largely for the reason JJM has mentioned. Let us make it clear to the lurkers that the link you posted makes it clear that homeopathic remedies for self-limiting conditions recognizable by the consumer are the only ones allowed to be sold OTC and that homeopathic remedies for serious conditions require a license which most homeopaths do not possess.
So would you ban all homeopathic products?

Just like Uri Geller's performances show mixed results yet it is clear he is a fraud because there are no positive results beyond placebo except when the performances do not have proper controls.
Not an apt analogy unless you are alleging that all or most homeopaths are frauds.

Really? You don't look very hard. No better than placebo, but also no worse, statistically speaking. No one harmed.

Now before you accuse me of cherry-picking, here's a contrary view:
I don't think the two studies are at odds. The first find no effect above placebo, while the second finds actual harm. If your standard for "helped" is the placebo effect, then surely homeopathic cough medicines meet that same standard. So, I still don't understand your initial analysis:

"1. Traditional cough and cold medicines: X billions in sales annually. Large majority of children unaffected beyond placebo. Small minority helped. Smaller minority harmed.

"2. Homeopathic medicines: Y billions in sales annually. Zero children helped."

Absolutely. You'll note that that position is no longer held because of countervailing evidence.
Only because eventually the evidence became so obvious that even the world's most prestigious scientific body could see it. ;) But why the arrogant attitude on the part of the scientific establishment?

You'll note that traditional OTC cough medicines may be pulled from the shelves because of a lack of efficacy. You'll not that homeopathic remedies continue to be hawked despite a lack of efficacy.
No, traditional OTC cough medicines for children have been pulled only because of evidence of actual harm, not simply a lack of efficacy. If it can be shown that homeopathic cough medicines for children cause actual harm, they will be pulled also.

I'll stick with the scientific system, thanks; the system homeopathy has opted out of.
Again, there is some evidence that homeopathic remedies work, so it's a question of what standard of evidence is used.
 
Again, there is some evidence that homeopathic remedies work, so it's a question of what standard of evidence is used.

There is no evidence that homeopathic remedies work. There have been no studies where, when the null hypothesis is rejected, that would be a reasonable alternate hypothesis. And the pattern of results, taken as a whole, has been shown to be exactly what you'd expect to see in the presence of chance, bias and fraud, and in the absence of a true effect.

You refer to 'standards', but none of us are really interested in standards. What we are interested in is having some idea of whether or not our observations, conclusions, and explanations are likely to be real or true. All we are saying is that under these circumstances we are more likely to be heading in the right direction, and under those circumstances we often make associations that turn out to be wrong.

Under circumstances where we're likely to be right, OTC cough medicines have helped some while harming a few (as shown by the multiple studies linked to earlier in this thread showing benefit above placebo and few adverse effects confined mostly to very young children), and homeopathic treatments have not shown any specific effect. Under circumstances where we're likely to be wrong, OTC cough medicines have shown enough adverse effects in infants to warrant withdrawal from the market, and homeopathic treatments show a hint of effectiveness. Take your pick.

Linda
 
"As is used for homeopathy" in whose opinion?
Not an opinion. The evidence for homeopathic evidence is primarily anecdotal and secondarily dubious experimentation that does not withstand scrutiny. That has already been discussed on this board and in this thread; I do not wish to rehash it.


Rodney said:
But let me make it easy for you: If you can find a study demonstrating your point using the same standard of evidence as was used by the authors of the British Medical Journal article that I quoted, I'll accept that.
Dig through this very thread, Rodney.


Rodney said:
So would you ban all homeopathic products?
Any that don't say: The evidence overwhelmingly indicates that you are wasting your money buying this product unless you simply want something to give you a nice placebo effect. Homeopathic remedies have never been clinically shown to demonstrate efficacy in any condition that is not self-correcting. In addition, beware of products labeled "homeopathic" which are in fact herbal and therefore present a danger which is not present in homeopathy because homeopathy is really just water or sugar pills.


Rodney said:
Not an apt analogy unless you are alleging that all or most homeopaths are frauds.
Fraudulent or deluded. I do not speculate on the ratio. The analogy remains apt.


I don't think the two studies are at odds. The first find no effect above placebo,
Exactly. Precisely the standard of evidence for homeopathic remedies.


Rodney said:
while the second finds actual harm.
Exactly. I show contrary evidence. How often do you show evidence contrary to your position?


Rodney said:
If your standard for "helped" is the placebo effect, then surely homeopathic cough medicines meet that same standard.
You are bordering on being intentionally deceitful. It is homeopathy that uses placebo as the standard for helped. That has been my whole point.


Rodney said:
So, I still don't understand your initial analysis:

"1. Traditional cough and cold medicines: X billions in sales annually. Large majority of children unaffected beyond placebo. Small minority helped. Smaller minority harmed.

"2. Homeopathic medicines: Y billions in sales annually. Zero children helped."
It's quite clear. I fail to understand how you do not understand it.


Rodney said:
Only because eventually the evidence became so obvious that even the world's most prestigious scientific body could see it. ;)
I see. You are saying that when an organization abandons a strongly held position in the face of overwhelming evidence it is an indication of a flaw with that organization even if the timespan is relatively short. Homeopathy, then, must rank very highly in your eyes given its refusal to abandon its claims in the face of over a century of overwhelming evidence.


Rodney said:
But why the arrogant attitude on the part of the scientific establishment?
They thought they were right. When shown otherwise, they changed. Does arrogance (which you haven't demonstrated the French Academy showed) nullify evidence?

If you want real arrogance, look at the homeopathic community who continue to peddle their magic water despite a century of overwhelming evidence. That's arrogance. That's inexcusable.

One more thing. Who, exactly, do you think convinced the "scientific establishment" to abandon their position on meteorites? It wasn't homeopaths or psychics or mediums or dowsers or alchemists. It was scientists.

I'll take bushels of that kind of arrogance over a tanker of 30C snake oil any day.


Rodney said:
No, traditional OTC cough medicines for children have been pulled only because of evidence of actual harm, not simply a lack of efficacy.
Have you read the links in this thread?


Rodney said:
If it can be shown that homeopathic cough medicines for children cause actual harm, they will be pulled also.
One would hope. The history of the homeopathic community suggests otherwise.


Rodney said:
Again, there is some evidence that homeopathic remedies work, so it's a question of what standard of evidence is used.
Anecdotal evidence, testimonials, and a handful of trials which when scrutinized reveal no statistical significance or reveal fatal methodological flaws.
 
You refer to 'standards', but none of us are really interested in standards.
To be fair, I am the one who introduced the word "standards" when I asked Rodney if I can use the same standard of evidence to demonstrate traditional medicine efficacy as homeopaths use for their remedies. If the term is not applicable in this context, that's my fault.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom