Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I have no problem in comparing the two, but let's be fair and complete about it:

1. Traditional cough and cold medicines: X billions in sales annually. Large majority of children unaffected beyond placebo. Small minority helped. Smaller minority harmed.
Please document that more have been helped than harmed.

2. Homeopathic medicines: Y billions in sales annually. Zero children helped.
Please document that zero have been helped.
 
Assuming that homeopathic products have no effect, isn't that better than "at least 1,500 children under the age of 2 suffer[ing] complications in 2004 and 2005 after being treated with over-the-counter cough and cold medicines"?

These things also did not result in children under the age of 2 suffering complications:

drinking water
playing peek-a-boo
eating mashed bananas
farting

Co-incidentally, they also, like homeopathic medicines, did not have any effect on cough and cold symptoms.

Linda
 
Assuming that homeopathic products have no effect, isn't that better than "at least 1,500 children under the age of 2 suffer[ing] complications in 2004 and 2005 after being treated with over-the-counter cough and cold medicines"?
It is quite definite that some homoeopathic remedies have harmful side effects. Most remedies come in the form of lactose pills, and a small minority of people have lactose malabsorption which will cause severe pains. The boisterous claim that homoeopathy has no side effects come only from the complete lack of studies in this area by homoeopaths.
 
Why?

Linda
Because this thread is about the efficacy of homeopathic cough medicines vis-a-vis other OTC cough medicines. If you or Garrette has evidence that no children have been helped by homeopathic cough medicines and that more children have been helped than hurt by other OTC cough medicines, I'll score a point for other OTC cough medicines. But where is the evidence?
 
It is quite definite that some homoeopathic remedies have harmful side effects. Most remedies come in the form of lactose pills, and a small minority of people have lactose malabsorption which will cause severe pains. The boisterous claim that homoeopathy has no side effects come only from the complete lack of studies in this area by homoeopaths.
That depends on what you mean by "homoeopathic remedies." Many have argued on this and other threads that, by definition, a true homoeopathic remedy cannot have any effect, positive or negative.
 
Because this thread is about the efficacy of homeopathic cough medicines vis-a-vis other OTC cough medicines. If you or Garrette has evidence that no children have been helped by homeopathic cough medicines and that more children have been helped than hurt by other OTC cough medicines, I'll score a point for other OTC cough medicines. But where is the evidence?

This is the evidence. If I buy a lottery ticket, should it be assumed that I have the winning ticket - i.e. should I be able to purchase a car and house, and take money out of the bank, by offering the lottery ticket in return?

Given that pharmaceutical research on plant extracts offers a less than one percent yield for any given condition, if I have chosen one of those extracts at random, should I (without any testing) be able to act on the assumption that it will be effective by offering it in exchange for money?

Linda
 
Last edited:
That depends on what you mean by "homoeopathic remedies." Many have argued on this and other threads that, by definition, a true homoeopathic remedy cannot have any effect, positive or negative.

The problem is that what is sold in the store under the label "homeopathic remedy" may or may not be homeopathic, but may instead contain active ingredients or poisons. And that the use of additional carriers, such as lactose pills and alcohol, have their own effects, although fortunately those effects will be known.

If the manufacturers hadn't been shown to be untrustworthy, you could possibly assume no harm. Since that isn't the case, the assumption is foolish.

Linda
 
That depends on what you mean by "homoeopathic remedies." Many have argued on this and other threads that, by definition, a true homoeopathic remedy cannot have any effect, positive or negative.
The definition only covers the active ingredients, of which there are none. If I get a stomach ache after having taken a pill, I would call it a harmful effect of the pill, even if it is not from the part of the pill that is homoeopathic.
 
I don't suppose possible litigation had anything to do with the recall.
Very possible, but is it not so that alternative medicine is exempt from litigation in the U.S.?

Very possible, but I was not comparing the two or defending one against the other, just commenting about possible motives behind the recall in this particular instance.

I haven't seen any litigation against alternative medicine but, here in Australia, an alternative medicine supply company (Pan) was closed down in recent times for failing to control the ingredients of their products (resulting in overdose symtoms).
 
Very possible, but is it not so that alternative medicine is exempt from litigation in the U.S.?
I am not sure where you got that impression. We have a law allowing one to sell anything by calling it a "dietary supplement" without any criminal repercussions. However, the purveyors often lose civil suits when customers are hurt.

Licensed chiropractors (every state), naturopaths and homeopaths (a few states) are often protected by their licensing boards. License to practice is often a license to kill with (criminal) impunity. Once again, they may face civil penalties.

Many sCAM purveyors work unnoticed. In my town, there are two naturopaths practicing medicine without a license. One even says she only is licensed in a neighboring state; but you can come to her home office ...

Even when quacks are brought to the attention of the authorities, if they have not seriously harmed anyone (yet) the authorities often cannot be bothered to act.

As much as all this annoys me, I would not go so far as to say "alternative medicine is exempt from litigation ..."
 
Surely the burden of proof can rest on the one claiming an exception?Linda
Garrette has asserted that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have helped a "small minority" of children and hurt a "smaller minority," whereas homeopathic cough medicines have helped "zero children." Is there any evidence for these assertions?
 
Garrette has asserted that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have helped a "small minority" of children and hurt a "smaller minority," whereas homeopathic cough medicines have helped "zero children." Is there any evidence for these assertions?

It is somewhat interesting, but moreso disappointing, that you are willing to be so dishonest as to pretend that you have not been given information about non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines already.

Garrette is not the one claiming an exception. You are. When the chance of hitting upon the right substance (we won't even get into the dilution thing) is less than one in a thousand, we would expect to get it wrong on the first try. Why would this be any different?

Linda
 
For the truly logical response to your request for proof, Rodney, see fls' posts. She is correct.

For a less logical response, but one which I think will help lurkers realize the emptiness of your position, try this:

I withdraw the claim that homeopathic cough remedies have helped zero children. That leaves us with either no claim at all that they have helped anyone or your claim that they have. Do you claim homeopathic remedies have helped any children, Rodney?

For the other part, I repeat my question: to demonstrate that traditional cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed, may I use the same standard of evidence that homeopathy uses?
 
For the truly logical response to your request for proof, Rodney, see fls' posts. She is correct.
I somehow missed that logic, but feel free to explain it.

For a less logical response, but one which I think will help lurkers realize the emptiness of your position, try this:

I withdraw the claim that homeopathic cough remedies have helped zero children.
Which is nice of you, considering you had zero evidence for that claim.

That leaves us with either no claim at all that they have helped anyone or your claim that they have. Do you claim homeopathic remedies have helped any children, Rodney?
I don't know whether it's the remedy or the power of suggestion, but it's clear that children have reported feeling better after taking homeopathic cough medicine, just as they have after taking other OTC cough medicines.

For the other part, I repeat my question: to demonstrate that traditional cough medicines have helped more children than they have harmed, may I use the same standard of evidence that homeopathy uses?
As long as you have some numbers from a study. Do you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom