Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I presume this is the information you would present to your family?

You have not made it clear that some of these steps are complete fabrications and some are well-established science. By putting them in a list like this, it gives the false impression that all of these steps have been established.

...

Thanks fls. I guess I should have started that post with:

If homeopathy works, and what the practitioners say is true, then we have the following:

So far, what I have is:
- Homeopathy is blah blah blah...
- People believe it works because of blah blah blah...
- Critics believe that it doesn't work because of ...

One of the issues I can see possibly coming up is someone saying, "But science hasn't proven everything yet! There are some things we just don't know. Established science is always changing! Why can't the molecules pass on a memory to each other?" I wanted to be able to counter this argument and start with the premise of, "Okay, what if it does work as claimed? Then what?" So these steps listed are me thinking out that even if this works, it's not useful in any way.

Memory effect doesn't exist -> Homeopathy falls apart and is useless
Memory effect does exist -> Homeopathy is useless since all water should have some memory of something from somewhere and is already homeopathic by nature

I agree with your criticisms. And I'll think over your warning on debating the bastardized quantum mechanics as well. It's like debating how ghosts emit their elecromagnetic radiation until we establish that ghosts exist. I'll think it through.
 
So far, what I have is:
- Homeopathy is blah blah blah...
- People believe it works because of blah blah blah...
- Critics believe that it doesn't work because of ...

One of the issues I can see possibly coming up is someone saying, "But science hasn't proven everything yet! There are some things we just don't know. Established science is always changing! Why can't the molecules pass on a memory to each other?" I wanted to be able to counter this argument and start with the premise of, "Okay, what if it does work as claimed? Then what?" So these steps listed are me thinking out that even if this works, it's not useful in any way.

Okay, technically speaking, science HAS proven everything it has incorporated, since theoretically nothing is accepted until it is duely proven to be correct.
That doesn't mean science "knows" everything, but the things it knows/finds out are usually fairly uncontested.
That doesn't mean nothing is ever revised/refined. Far from it actually.

But those instances where something that violated more than one basic law of physics turned out to be correct after all are very, very few and far between. And given the fact homeopathy has already been around for 200 years, I'd say the odds of that still happening anyway are pretty slim by now.
 
First off, I know nothing of quantum mechanics.

I seem toremember someone one this forum posting that the Schrödinger equations were fundamental to quantum theory, so that anyone claiming that this was how homoeopathy worked should be asked how the Schrödinger equations related to their claim.

This could be dangerous if your bluff is called.

Dave
 
I think this thread can now be put to an honorable bed.

What have we learned?

* Homeopathy works, if you believe it does.

* Homeopathy doesn't work, because it relies on belief rather than empirical evidence.

* The only worthwhile and true knowledge is that which every person can validate for themselves; i.e., it does not come down to belief or issues of "trust".

* We all operate on trust, unless a useless car (or other) accident changes our mind.

* Woody Allen is the smartest individual on the planet.

M.
 
We can't put this thread to bed until it's broken 1000 posts, which it is bound to do any moment now.
 
Thanks fls. I guess I should have started that post with:

If homeopathy works, and what the practitioners say is true, then we have the following:

That idea is good. And after you present the "if homeopathy works" part, I think you should also cover "does homeopathy work" by talking about clinical experiments (more later).

So far, what I have is:
- Homeopathy is blah blah blah...

And just making the process of dilution clear is a good way to instill doubt. If one has only a vague idea of what homeopathy is ("something natural") it's easy to cling to the idea of the "open mind". When one has the details, the shear silliness can start to erode the ability to go along with the idea.

Also, I think that adding a description of how homeopaths choose their remedies can add to the silliness factor. For any particular problem (or collection of symptoms), homeopaths have a variety of remedies they can choose to try. When someone comes to them with a problem, they keep trying different remedies until they find one that works. How do they know it works? The patient either gets better or they get worse. If they get better, then it is attributed to the remedy. If they get worse, it is also attributed to the remedy - i.e. whatever is causing the symptoms has been released all at once by the remedy. Since most people either get better or get worse, the one that "worked" is always just the last one that the homeopath guessed would work.

- People believe it works because of blah blah blah...
- Critics believe that it doesn't work because of ...

I think you could say a lot more about why critics are not convinced. One reason is that none of the proposed ways in which it could work have been established (and that is where differentiating between known mechanisms and mechanisms which are pure conjecture, some of which contradict everything we already know, would be useful - as we already talked about). But another reason is that we already have good explanations for why people believe that it works and that these explanations have been confirmed by experiment. The effect is no different from placebo - most people get better or worse on their own, and spending time talking with people and reassuring them makes them feel better in the meantime. So does homeopathy work if the outcome would be exactly the same without homeopathy?

One of the issues I can see possibly coming up is someone saying, "But science hasn't proven everything yet! There are some things we just don't know. Established science is always changing! Why can't the molecules pass on a memory to each other?" I wanted to be able to counter this argument and start with the premise of, "Okay, what if it does work as claimed? Then what?" So these steps listed are me thinking out that even if this works, it's not useful in any way.

Memory effect doesn't exist -> Homeopathy falls apart and is useless
Memory effect does exist -> Homeopathy is useless since all water should have some memory of something from somewhere and is already homeopathic by nature

When you put it that way, it makes more sense - so maybe my criticism just means that you should explicitly state to your family that that's what you are trying to demonstrate with that part of your presentation.

I agree with your criticisms. And I'll think over your warning on debating the bastardized quantum mechanics as well. It's like debating how ghosts emit their elecromagnetic radiation until we establish that ghosts exist. I'll think it through.

This gets back to the "science hasn't proven everything yet" issue. Breakthroughs in science happen when a demonstrated effect cannot be explained by the current theory, not when it can. Sure we don't know everything, but we do know that if the presence or absence of something makes no difference to the outcome, further inquiry is a waste of time, money and effort. We come up with areas to explore either by trying to explain an effect that is currently unexplainable, or by figuring out an effect we should see, based on established explanations, and going looking for it. Homeopathy fails on both counts. The effect is currently explainable, and none of the speculation builds on established science which means that none of the observations can be used to confirm or deny any particular hypothesis. It's like debating whether or not unicorns would be pink - the results of the debate are meaningless.

I'm not trying to criticize your approach, just give some ideas of my own. It sounds like it may be worth your effort - i.e. that you may be able to have some influence with your family.

Linda
 
Plenty of people have made statements that indicate that they don't understand thermodynamics, including at least one professor of thermodynamics.

I wasn't thinking of people demonstrating that they don't understand QM, but rather of people that do understand claiming that the field itself is not understandable.

Eg.
"I think I can safely say that no one understands quantum mechanics." - Richard Feynman

Linda
 
Also, I think that adding a description of how homeopaths choose their remedies can add to the silliness factor. For any particular problem (or collection of symptoms), homeopaths have a variety of remedies they can choose to try. When someone comes to them with a problem, they keep trying different remedies until they find one that works. How do they know it works? The patient either gets better or they get worse. If they get better, then it is attributed to the remedy. If they get worse, it is also attributed to the remedy - i.e. whatever is causing the symptoms has been released all at once by the remedy. Since most people either get better or get worse, the one that "worked" is always just the last one that the homeopath guessed would work.

Let's not forget that when choosing the right remedy, some pretty crazy things are included as symptoms, such as "patient likes sausages".

Perhaps you could also include something against the "but homeopathy is all natural and harmless" argument, since that's very likely to pop up if there's already a convinced homeopathy-follower among your listeners. A good thing would be to explain that many remedies are made of very unnatural products, including "Berlin wall" and various radioactive substances.
 
A good thing would be to explain that many remedies are made of very unnatural products, including "Berlin wall" and various radioactive substances.
Not to mention antimatter.

Mind you, I was somewhat disappointed to discover that the "Bewick Swan" remedy also listed on this page was prepared from a feather from an actual swan and not from a copy of the engraving by Thomas Bewick used as an illustration.
 
Does delusion know no boundaries?
Trust me, delusion, like ignorance, is boundless.

FYI, there is a book- "Homeopathy: How it Really Works" by Jay Shelton (Prometheus, 2004) that is useful. I think it is poorly written; but it has lots of recent references and explains a lot of the "practice" of this quackery. Many homeos have been dismayed, after reading the title, to discover the book is critical of their cult.
 
In fact, never mind moonlight: this person claims to be able to make any remedy just by saying the name of the thing the remedy is supposed to be made from. And for a mere $395.00 (plus $9.50 shipping), so can you!
 
I wasn't thinking of people demonstrating that they don't understand QM, but rather of people that do understand claiming that the field itself is not understandable.

Eg.
"I think I can safely say that no one understands quantum mechanics." - Richard Feynman

Linda
Some of my best friends are quantum mechanics. They are friendly people who are untroubled by this lack of understanding. And I think it is for the best.

In 1971, my organic chemistry professor began the semester by writing "H(psi) = E(psi)" on the chalkboard. Then he said "When they solve this equation, we will be out of business." Fortunately, they are no closer today than they were then.
 
Oldie but goodie from QM jokes:

Werner Heisenberg was pulled over for speeding. The police officer walked up to the car, leaned in the window and asked, “Do you know how fast you were going?”
Doctor Heisenberg replied: “No, but I know exactly where I was.”


Just my attempt to get this thread closer to the 'M' potency. :D
 
Well, only 3 posts to go.

What I wonder though, is how they test homeopathic potions made from moonlight and music?
I don't even mean scientific testing, I mean the "homeopathic proving" that's done to determine exactly what it is the remedy is supposed to cure by exposing healthy people to it.
After all, everyone walking around after dark is exposed to moonlight. So how do you help them by giving them homeopathic moonlight? And what is it supposed to cure (apart from Lycantropy maybe).
 
What I wonder though, is how they test homeopathic potions made from moonlight and music?
I don't even mean scientific testing, I mean the "homeopathic proving" that's done to determine exactly what it is the remedy is supposed to cure by exposing healthy people to it.
They would "prove" the potentised remedy rather than the actual substance. For example, on the page of provings I linked to above, the "Bewick Swan" remedy was proved at potencies of between 6c and 30c, and the "antimatter" and the condom were proved at 30c.
After all, everyone walking around after dark is exposed to moonlight. So how do you help them by giving them homeopathic moonlight? And what is it supposed to cure (apart from Lycantropy maybe).
It is supposed to cure whatever symptoms the provers imagine it causes.
 
After all, everyone walking around after dark is exposed to moonlight. So how do you help them by giving them homeopathic moonlight?
The raw moonlight has not been exposed to the magic of dilutions and succusions. To a homoeopath, there is a world of difference!
 

Why is it that I find this part rather amusing?

Succussion

Succussion, or forceful shaking, was originally done by hand. Nowadays much of it is carried out by machine, but even with mechanical aids it may take up to 10 or 12 weeks to prepare tinctures of the highest potencies. In the nineteenth century this time element led to the work of preparing some of these potencies being entrusted to people like lighthouse keepers, who had long, lonely hours on duty with only their light to tend. The rhythmic, carefully repeated motions required in trituration and succussion helped to keep them awake, while at the same time benefiting homeopathy.
Each succussion should be equivalent to the force exerted by an average healthy man when striking a hand-held phial (a firmly-stoppered test-tube or other laboratory container) forcefully against a firm surface. Hahnemann used a large leather-bound book. At each succussion the phial came to a brief stop, inertia making the liquid jump in the phial. Today machines imitate this action, but they need careful regulating and frequent maintenance to ensure that the succussion is standardized.

(bold mine)

So THAT'S what those lighthouse keepers were doing, all by their lonesome selves.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom