Homeopathic Cough Medicine

"As is used for homeopathy" in whose opinion? But let me make it easy for you: If you can find a study demonstrating your point using the same standard of evidence as was used by the authors of the British Medical Journal article that I quoted, I'll accept that.

Bandolier are a high quality source and they're pretty consistent with the summary
Homeopathy trials and quality said:
As the quality score increases (better studies) the odds ratio (for homeopathy versus placebo) goes down, and goes down to about 1-2. The authors of the letter comment that:

"some (but by no means all) methodologically astute and highly convincing homeopaths have published results that look convincing but are, in fact, not credible. Viewed in this way, the reanalysis.... can be seen as the ultimate epidemiological proof that homeopathic remedies are, in fact, placebos."

More from their archives here
 
Not an opinion. The evidence for homeopathic evidence is primarily anecdotal and secondarily dubious experimentation that does not withstand scrutiny. That has already been discussed on this board and in this thread; I do not wish to rehash it.
Nonetheless, I feel compelled to refresh your memory by referencing post #656 on this thread. A more objective person might conclude that the notion that homeopathy has been completely discredited is erroneous.

Any that don't say: The evidence overwhelmingly indicates that you are wasting your money buying this product unless you simply want something to give you a nice placebo effect. Homeopathic remedies have never been clinically shown to demonstrate efficacy in any condition that is not self-correcting. In addition, beware of products labeled "homeopathic" which are in fact herbal and therefore present a danger which is not present in homeopathy because homeopathy is really just water or sugar pills.
I might be willing to live with that if the FDA will simultaneously require that the following be placed on traditional OTC cough medicines: Note: There is no clinical evidence that this medicine relieves cough, and children's cough medicines similar to this one have been removed from the marketplace due to a number of children suffering adverse consequences, including death, from their use.

You are bordering on being intentionally deceitful.
I pride myself in walking that fine line. ;)

It is homeopathy that uses placebo as the standard for helped. That has been my whole point.
Other than the many studies that have shown homeopathy performing above placebo.

I see. You are saying that when an organization abandons a strongly held position in the face of overwhelming evidence it is an indication of a flaw with that organization even if the timespan is relatively short. Homeopathy, then, must rank very highly in your eyes given its refusal to abandon its claims in the face of over a century of overwhelming evidence.
Contradictory studies constitute "overwhelming evidence"?

They thought they were right. When shown otherwise, they changed. Does arrogance (which you haven't demonstrated the French Academy showed) nullify evidence?
The point is that the French Academy should have been open to the idea of meteorites all along. That's what true skepticism is, as opposed to pseudoskepticism, which is not open to ideas that are too far removed from the conventional wisdom.

If you want real arrogance, look at the homeopathic community who continue to peddle their magic water despite a century of overwhelming evidence. That's arrogance. That's inexcusable.

One more thing. Who, exactly, do you think convinced the "scientific establishment" to abandon their position on meteorites? It wasn't homeopaths or psychics or mediums or dowsers or alchemists. It was scientists.
I think you'll find that it was a French meteor shower that took place in 1803. Without that, who knows how long the French Academy would have clung to its mistaken worldview.

Anecdotal evidence, testimonials, and a handful of trials which when scrutinized reveal no statistical significance or reveal fatal methodological flaws.
So you've examined in detail all of the positive homeopathy studies?
 
Last edited:
Nonetheless, I feel compelled to refresh your memory by referencing post #656 on this thread.
I counter with posts 660, 662, and 666. Several after that, too, but I'm sure you can find them. You've been shot down more than once, Rodney. Don't pull a DOC and pretend it never happened.


Rodney said:
A more objective person might conclude that the notion that homeopathy has been completely discredited is erroneous.
Moi? Not objective? I'm wounded.

A more honest person might admit he has been repeatedly presented with the evidence to show that homeopathy is bunkum.


Rodney said:
I might be willing to live with that if the FDA will simultaneously require that the following be placed on traditional OTC cough medicines: Note: There is no clinical evidence that this medicine relieves cough, and children's cough medicines similar to this one have been removed from the marketplace due to a number of children suffering adverse consequences, including death, from their use.
If this were true, I would have no objection. You have been presented with legitimate evidence of efficacy. Linda and others can speak better to this than I.


Rodney said:
I pride myself in walking that fine line. ;)
Don't fool yourself into thinking that my politeness in not pointing out when you have crossed out means that it hasn't been noticed.


Rodney said:
Other than the many studies that have shown homeopathy performing above placebo.
Many? Hah. Read your own link to post 656. Then read the posts I referenced above.


Rodney said:
Contradictory studies constitute "overwhelming evidence"?
Contradictory studies coupled with a lack of supporting studies except those with serious methodological flaws do constitute overwhelming evidence, yes.


Rodney said:
The point is that the French Academy should have been open to the idea of meteorites all along.
I see. No one should ever make mistakes and everyone should devote limited resources (time, money, etc.) on whatever you deem is appropriate in hindisght. Got it.


Rodney said:
That's what true skepticism is, as opposed to pseudoskepticism, which is not open to ideas that are too far removed from the conventional wisdom.
Poppycock and balderdash. You're demanding every scientist spend time and effort on a fantasy simply because someone fantasized it. What science is not open to is fantasies without reason to suspect there is validity behind them. What science is open to are ideas "far removed from the conventional wisdom" that have at least a whiff of legitimacy to justify the expenditure of non-infinite resources.

What homeopaths and you are not open to is the idea that all those things showing your idea wrong do in fact show your idea wrong. There is closed-mindedness here, Rodney, but it is on your side.


Rodney said:
I think you'll find that it was a French meteor shower that took place in 1803.
Thank heaven all those homeopaths dragged all those reluctant French scientists screaming from their closets into the cold dark night to witness it. No scientist every would have dreamed of seeing a meteor show and saying "Wow. I was wrong about there not being any meteor showers."


Rodney said:
Without that, who knows how long the French Academy would have clung to its mistaken worldview.
Probably till the next one. Step one: Hypothesize. Step two: Observe. Step three: Adjust hypothesis to fit observations.

That's how it appears to have worked for those stuffy Frenchmen. For the homeopaths Step Three is: Adjust observations to fit hypothesis.


Rodney said:
So you've examined in detail all of the positive homeopathy studies?
Rodney, I am truly flattered. I find it quite an honor that only my personal desconstruction of those studies will suffice when people like fls and JJM and others more learned in the topic have already done so.
 
Last edited:
Nonetheless, I feel compelled to refresh your memory by referencing post #656 on this thread. A more objective person might conclude that the notion that homeopathy has been completely discredited is erroneous.

Not a more objective person...a person who wishes to leave the possibility open. If you wish to believe in homeopathy, invisible pink unicorns, and sasquatch, you can always muster up deniability.

I might be willing to live with that if the FDA will simultaneously require that the following be placed on traditional OTC cough medicines: Note: There is no clinical evidence that this medicine relieves cough,


Actually, the cold medicines that were removed were those that did show clinical evidence that they relieved cough.

Other than the many studies that have shown homeopathy performing above placebo.

There aren't 'many' studies showing that homeopathy performs above placebo. Once you take bias into account, there are only a handful of studies - the number that you'd expect due to chance - that show statistically significant differences. And one cannot conclude from that that the differences are due to homeopathy (there are other, more plausible, explanations).

The point is that the French Academy should have been open to the idea of meteorites all along. That's what true skepticism is, as opposed to pseudoskepticism, which is not open to ideas that are too far removed from the conventional wisdom.

Actually, I think psuedoskepticism is pretending that recognizing that there is insufficient evidence to support an idea is the same thing as denying the possibility of the idea.

So you've examined in detail all of the positive homeopathy studies?

He may not have, but I have examined all that anyone could be expected to take seriously (and many that could not), and what he says is correct.

Linda
 
I love reading your summaries, Linda. :)


But are you saying...

Under circumstances where we're likely to be wrong, OTC cough medicines have shown enough adverse effects in infants to warrant withdrawal from the market...


....that it is likely that the evidence of side effects that is leading to (has led to?) the withdrawal of OTC cough medicines aimed at children under two years of age, is likely to be wrong?

The evidence is of convulsions and death which, I assume, is the result of overdosing on these medicines. Even though this is not really a side effect of the medicine (given in recommended doses), it is still a valid reason to withdraw the medicine, is it not? Or do you think the evidence linking the convulsions and death to the medicine is not strong?

Interestingly, here in Australia, there has been no evidence of these sort of problems (according to the FDA), but they are considering the withdrawal of these products based on the US experience.
 
I love reading your summaries, Linda. :)


But are you saying...




....that it is likely that the evidence of side effects that is leading to (has led to?) the withdrawal of OTC cough medicines aimed at children under two years of age, is likely to be wrong?

The evidence is of convulsions and death which, I assume, is the result of overdosing on these medicines. Even though this is not really a side effect of the medicine (given in recommended doses), it is still a valid reason to withdraw the medicine, is it not? Or do you think the evidence linking the convulsions and death to the medicine is not strong?

Interestingly, here in Australia, there has been no evidence of these sort of problems (according to the FDA), but they are considering the withdrawal of these products based on the US experience.

The evidence depends upon adverse event reporting which can, at best, demonstrate association but not causation. And in its raw form, it doesn't even demonstrate association. So the evidence is weak, at best.

Linda
 
Interesting to note that "[a] clinical trial has found that honey is more effective at soothing a sore throat than a common active ingredient in children's cough medicines . . . The team from Pennsylvania State University report today in the Archives of Paediatric and Adolescent Medicine that honey was more effective than dextromethorphan at relieving the severity, frequency and bothersome nature of the cough. The medicine was slightly more effective than no treatment at all." See http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2007/dec/04/health.medicalresearch?gusrc=rss&feed=science

Now, if you really want to cure your cough, try this recipe:

To 1 gallon of distilled water, add 4 ounces of Horehound (dry). Reduce by simmering, so that when it is strained there will be 1 pint. To this add:

Compound Simple Syrup................2 ounces,
Glycerine...........................10 minims,
Honey (strained from honeycomb)....1/2 ounce.

Cut Balsam of Tolu 1 dram in 2 ounces of pure grain alcohol and add to solution.

Shake well together when the dose is taken, which would be half to a teaspoonful only occasionally, or when necessity requires.

And who prescribed the above? Edgar Cayce, in Reading 420-1, given October 14, 1933. According to Cayce: "This would cure anyone's cough!"
 
Last edited:
Interesting to note that "[a] clinical trial has found that honey is more effective at soothing a sore throat than a common active ingredient in children's cough medicines . . . The team from Pennsylvania State University report today in the Archives of Paediatric and Adolescent Medicine that honey was more effective than dextromethorphan at relieving the severity, frequency and bothersome nature of the cough. The medicine was slightly more effective than no treatment at all." See http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2007/dec/04/health.medicalresearch?gusrc=rss&feed=science

Now, if you really want to cure your cough, try this recipe:

To 1 gallon of distilled water, add 4 ounces of Horehound (dry). Reduce by simmering, so that when it is strained there will be 1 pint. To this add:

Compound Simple Syrup................2 ounces,
Glycerine...........................10 minims,
Honey (strained from honeycomb)....1/2 ounce.

Cut Balsam of Tolu 1 dram in 2 ounces of pure grain alcohol and add to solution.

Shake well together when the dose is taken, which would be half to a teaspoonful only occasionally, or when necessity requires.

And who prescribed the above? Edgar Cayce, in Reading 420-1, given October 14, 1933. According to Cayce: "This would cure anyone's cough!"

Soothing a sore throat is not the same as curing a cough.

Nothing like it, in fact.
 
Get em! It is just as bad here in the states...Head on...Zicam....

See a dollar grab it right?

:mad:

Sorry, quoting something off the first page and all, but...

Zicam is homeopathic?

I never tried it because I wasn't about to stick a Q-tip up my nose. I know a lot of people that swear by that stuff though. I think I even have some in the house, I'll dig it out of the medicine cabinet after I'm done posting this and take a look at the box.
 
haha I need to read the boxes more closely before I buy medicine! It says "homeopathic" in small print right on the front of the box. Now I have to convice everyone I know who buys that stuff that it's fraud.

Good thing I popped in to this thread though.
 
Interesting to note that "[a] clinical trial has found that honey is more effective at soothing a sore throat than a common active ingredient in children's cough medicines . . . The team from Pennsylvania State University report today in the Archives of Paediatric and Adolescent Medicine that honey was more effective than dextromethorphan at relieving the severity, frequency and bothersome nature of the cough. The medicine was slightly more effective than no treatment at all." See http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2007/dec/04/health.medicalresearch?gusrc=rss&feed=science


http://dcscience.net/?p=209
 
http://www.library.nhs.uk/rss/newsAndRssArticle.aspx?uri=http%3a%2f%2fwww.library.nhs.uk%2fresources%2f%3fid%3d275788

The conclusion that honey is deemed better by parents than no treatment or dextromethorphan for symptomatic relief of cough and sleep difficulty due to URTI is not supported by the results presented. From the results presented, it seems that the significant difference seen between all three groups for the primary outcome was driven by the difference between honey and no treatment. Pairwise comparisons showed no statistically significant differences in the rating by parents between honey and dextromethorphan. However the small sample size of the trial, particularly in the dextromethorphan group, may account for this lack of statistically significant difference. This therefore indicates that further studies would be needed to investigate the suggested superiority of honey over dextromethorphan.


Anyway, what has this to do with homoeopathy?
 
Last edited:

The most interesting part of the above article is the following statement: "It is already well known, from several good studies, that DM is useless, no better than placebo."

Compare that statement with Linda's post #265 on this thread:

"I will give you an illustrative example using Dextromethorphan.

"Looking only at controlled studies for acute cough (RCT's where appropriate)....

"There were 14 studies in animals and all were positive.
"There were 5 studies in humans using induced cough and all were positive.
"There were 5 studies in humans with acute upper respiratory tract infection and 3 were positive (one of the positive studies was a metanalysis of 6 other studies, but I'm only counting it as 1 instead of 6)."

So is DM useful or useless for cough?
 
Anyway, what has this to do with homoeopathy?
This thread has basically discussed (with a few digressions) whether (non-homeopathic) OTC cough medicines have been proven to be more effective than homeopathic cough medicines.
 
So is DM useful or useless for cough?

Well, given that the normally excellent DC didn't give us a reference to support his assertion that it's useless, and fls and others on this thread have given several papers to show that it isn't, unless you can produce the missing reference(s) yourself then for the purposes of this thread I'd say 'probably moderately useful'.

Which presumably means that honey is 'possibly moderately useful' for coughs, given that this we're talking about one ssmall study, which AFAIK none of us have actually read first hand.

But I'd repeat BillyJoe's question - what has the honey thing to do with homeopathy? And have you done the requisite trials on Cayce's remedy?
 
Well, given that the normally excellent DC didn't give us a reference to support his assertion that it's useless, and fls and others on this thread have given several papers to show that it isn't, unless you can produce the missing reference(s) yourself then for the purposes of this thread I'd say 'probably moderately useful'.

We are all correct. The references I provided were for adults. The study with honey and DM was in children. The DM studies in children show that, in doses which are usually safe, DM is not useful (note that higher doses can show effectiveness but with the cost of undesirable side-effects).

Which presumably means that honey is 'possibly moderately useful' for coughs, given that this we're talking about one ssmall study, which AFAIK none of us have actually read first hand.

Excuse me! I don't talk about stuff I haven't bothered to check out first!
:)

But I'd repeat BillyJoe's question - what has the honey thing to do with homeopathy? And have you done the requisite trials on Cayce's remedy?

I commented on this point on this study in this thread.

"What the alt med people claim is that the traditional ways of identifying effective treatments - careful observation without controls or blinding, subjective perception as a measure of objective change, extrapolating on the basis of analogy rather than theory, etc. - are a useful way of identifying these treatments. However, that these methods can occasionally identify a truly effective treatment is not the issue. The issue is that these methods are unable to identify which treatments are ineffective (a much larger number), and they miss many more effects than they discover. That is, these methods produce a plethora of false-positives and false-negatives for only a few true-positives and true-negatives. And it is only the subsequent application of modern research techniques that sorts out which is which.

This study is actually ammo for the evidence-based crowd. While we were able to identify honey as a true-positive, the methods used by the alt med crowd were unable to distinguish between honey and other treatments that we know to be ineffective, such as vitamin C. We can discover that honey helps and vitamin C does not. The alt med people still cannot make that claim."

To make it relevant, simply substitute "homeopathy" for "vitamin C".

Linda
 
We are all correct.

<snip>

Linda

Heh, apologies to anyone I've similarly slighted by drifting out of this thread and then drifting back in without reading it thoroughly enough - I think I was still a few points behind.

Also, I missed that whole other thread on the subject - interesting points, fls :)
 
Now, if you really want to cure your cough, try this recipe:

To 1 gallon of distilled water, add 4 ounces of Horehound (dry). Reduce by simmering, so that when it is strained there will be 1 pint. [...]

And who prescribed the above? Edgar Cayce, in Reading 420-1, given October 14, 1933. According to Cayce: "This would cure anyone's cough!"


There is some evidence that Horehound was also used by the Romans
as a cough medicine. In their case it was mixed with wine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom