Homeopathic Cough Medicine

fls, (not sure of protocol – so will not use your name)

I can't think of any reason not to use my name, which of course will now make me worry about why I do not seem to be sufficiently paranoid. :)

I did not intend to refer to this thread alone. The main point I wanted to raise was that abrasiveness beyond a point serves to alienate

I have not seen anyone argue against that point. I still don't understand why you think you need to harp on something that everyone already seems to agree on.

– if mine has alienated you that only proves my point.

If I am alienated by yours it actually contradicts your point, as I am continuing to pay attention to what you write, give it serious consideration, and respond.

What would be your standard for “participating”?

Something like, giving careful consideration to what other people have said and addressing their points.

I read what everyone says. Now, with limited time, I take what I can respond to without too much repetition, and post back.

It's that your responses were variations on your original post while others here moved on.

What is your definition of ‘poo’?

Material from which the nutritive value has been removed.

“All you were looking for was just enough abrasiveness to allow the lies you were about to spread to stick.”

And this from you, who asks for evidence everywhere? Please do tell me how you divined this alleged intention on my part.

You have already stated that you were not referring to this thread specifically when you gave your characterization of skeptics, and you have yet to provide evidence of "abrasiveness beyond a point" within this thread. This indicates that you were not driven to alienation and then delurked to tell us that, by this thread. It indicates that you were already alienated and you just happened to choose this thread.

It has already been pointed out that the statements you made are inaccurate and you have yet to support them with evidence (i.e. they remain "untruths").

I don't think there was anything magical or excessively intuitive in the process I used to figure this out.

If you don’t care what people like me think, then that means you are only writing for the people who already agree with you or whom you can convince.
Yes, allowing for skewed views, it does appear that you (collective ‘you’) want to browbeat those who disagree. You may not intend to, but that’s how it seems to be.

Bolding mine.

I have suggested that the browbeating is directed at those whom (it has already been demonstrated) we cannot convince.

“We say "considering that we are fooled by ourselves and others into believing things that turn out not to be true, homeopathy should be evaluated by the same standard. So far the evidence (of which there is more than enough and has been covered in detail already) shows that when you take away the opportunity to be fooled by yourself or by others, homeopathy does not demonstrate any effect." You say, "I don't care and quit calling me a moron for ignoring the evidence."… You say, "I am going to make an exception for homeopathy and require extraordinary standards to say it's not true. I am not going to justify my use of extraordinary standards in this case, though. I am only going to insult you for not going along."”

I am NOT asking for anything (lowering of standards or acceptance) for homeopathy. What I think is besides the issue and I’m actually ‘defending’ it more than I believe it should be defended.

You made it the issue by telling us what you think and using it to support your insults. It can only be considered valid support for your insult if it is reasonable to consider the jury still out on homeopathy. It is only reasonable to consider the jury still out on homeopathy if you are using a completely different kind of jury than the kind that is used to determine everything else that we think we know about the natural world. This means that you should either try to persuade us that homeopathy deserves a completely different type of jury, or withdraw your insults.

Did I object to being called a moron?

Yes.

"What you’re implying is IF I had read this thread or sundry discussions on homeopathy, I would be a brainless twit not to be convinced that’s it’s BS. But I’m not – so what then?"

"BTW, Moochie, I'm not playing, being mentally retarded and all." (said sarcastically)

Since there’s no evidence against it, I can hardly do that. :)

Sometimes I think the entirety of the internet experience can be summed up as "a collection of people attempting to provide evidence for and against the fact that they are morons." :)

Well, if that’s insulting you, what do you call other things that’re said here? Or is it that a set of standards are applicable to regular posters who are in agreement with you, and another for lurkers who wonder why they ever un-lurked?

Nope. The same standards apply to all.

“We say, "we should not make it easy for people to be unknowingly defrauded." You say, "people should be able to choose to be unknowingly defrauded."”
No, I posited that maybe people should have the right to choose to be ‘defrauded’ – but certainly should be given the facts. And I add that the facts indicate that homeopathy does not have any reason to work.
We say, "you are resonding to a mischaracterization of 'what skeptics say' instead of actually paying attention and responding to what is really said here." You say, "why do you hate America?"
Explain, please?

It's a reference to a red herring in common use in the US over the last few years when any criticisms of the administration's methods/competence arises.

When we said basically the same thing that you just said (about people being given the facts) you responded with...."What you seem to be saying that EVEN if they are informed, people should not have the right to choose homeopathy. Hmmm."....another common red herring (appealing to the issue of choice).

Your motivation? Not malice or stupidity, just carelessness and the selection of an easy out.

More divination? Miss Trelawney would be so proud of you.

"Malice and stupidity" were the possible explanations (paraphrased) you presented for why somebody may disgree with us. I just wanted to let you know that I didn't think it applied to you (just in case you thought I did :)). The carelessness was a guess based on your style, but I'm not committed to it. Reverting to sarcasm instead of directly addressing the issues raised is an easy out.

Did I exaggerate and mischaracterize? Yup. Can I defend everything I said anyway? You betcha.”

What if you can defend what you say and I can defend what I say – each in our own view at least? You have alleged more than once that I came here with an agenda or preconceived views that I will not shake no matter what. Not a preconceived view on your part?

Definitely a preconceived view on my part.

I certainly came with ‘preconceived’ views from what I read, but I don’t think there are monsters here nor am I provoking arguments to parade as proof of my beliefs.
This very lengthy response is especially to tell you I am PARTICIPATING.

Yes, you are. Hmmm....

And BTW, late in the day – forgot to say this earlier - I agree with you when you said to Billy Joe that its kind of insulting to talk down to people or soften your arguments because they might not be as informed or smart as you.

Thank you.

Linda
 
Umm....

It kinda undermines your message when you support your suggestion with the same kind of (non)evidence that you just dismissed when it was used to support homeopathy.

Linda

Hmmm... It was late, I was inebriated. Might have stated things more clearly.

Gawler has long fascinated me because of his seeming "miraculous" recovery. As far as I know, he was expected to die of the disease.

It's never been satisfactorily explained how he beat the Big C.

Stories like his surface from time to time -- they require closer scrutiny.

M.
 
... Gawler has long fascinated me because of his seeming "miraculous" recovery. As far as I know, he was expected to die of the disease.

It's never been satisfactorily explained how he beat the Big C.

Stories like his surface from time to time -- they require closer scrutiny.

M.
Excellent points. There are at least four possible explanations:
A) Misdiagnosis
2) Anomalous, spontaneous remission (can be 0.5-2% of cases, depending on cancer type)
iii) Uncredited use of conventional therapy
IV) An anomalous prognosis. For example, after diagnosis- inoperable pancreatic cancer usually kills 50% within six months. But, 10% live a year, and 2% live five years.

I suppose one could entertain a fifth possibility- that some, as yet, unproven therapy actually worked.
 
Gawler has long fascinated me because of his seeming "miraculous" recovery. As far as I know, he was expected to die of the disease.

"As far as I know" = "He said"

It's never been satisfactorily explained how he beat the Big C.

He received conventional treatment which often leads to beating the Big C.

Stories like his surface from time to time -- they require closer scrutiny.

It took less than 5 minutes and Google to scrutinize the story.

ETA: That was perhaps too abrupt. :)

I don't believe information that comes only from the patient - they never relay correct information, even when they are sincerely trying (harsh, but very, very true). Miracle cures that have been checked out turn out to have ordinary explanations - conventional treatment was received, recovery is one of the likely outcomes, the diagnosis of cancer was not confirmed (just suspected (maybe even a very low suspicion)), they did not recover they just felt better for a little while which was falsely assumed to be evidence of recovery, in addition to the obvious.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Excellent points. There are at least four possible explanations:
A) Misdiagnosis
2) Anomalous, spontaneous remission (can be 0.5-2% of cases, depending on cancer type)
iii) Uncredited use of conventional therapy
IV) An anomalous prognosis. For example, after diagnosis- inoperable pancreatic cancer usually kills 50% within six months. But, 10% live a year, and 2% live five years.

I suppose one could entertain a fifth possibility- that some, as yet, unproven therapy actually worked.

My knowledge of the case would make me think number the 2 the most likely. Gawler had had conventional therapy and appeared to be on the mend, but some time later a secondary cancer was diagnosed and he was told he had two weeks to live. It was then that he began to experiment with other ways of combating the disease.

What he offers is an adjunct to conventional therapy -- not a replacement for it. It's the physicians of gravely ill people who refer their patients to Gawler.

There's nothing to say that his cure wasn't related to his prior conventional treatment although I'm not qualified to say that it was or wasn't.

Since then (he was 24 when first diagnosed; he's now 56) he has helped many people survive their disease.

He doesn't claim to cure cancer -- only to help a person obtain a better quality of life for whatever time they have left.

M.
 
"As far as I know" = "He said"



He received conventional treatment which often leads to beating the Big C.



It took less than 5 minutes and Google to scrutinize the story.

ETA: That was perhaps too abrupt. :)

I don't believe information that comes only from the patient - they never relay correct information, even when they are sincerely trying (harsh, but very, very true). Miracle cures that have been checked out turn out to have ordinary explanations - conventional treatment was received, recovery is one of the likely outcomes, the diagnosis of cancer was not confirmed (just suspected (maybe even a very low suspicion)), they did not recover they just felt better for a little while which was falsely assumed to be evidence of recovery, in addition to the obvious.

Linda

Gulp! :(

Please see:

http://www.cosa.org.au/documents/Cancer_Forum_NOV05_FINAL.pdf

particularly the article entitled "Snake oil, coffee enemas and other famous nostrums for cancer – a recent history of cancer quackery in Australia"

I promise to be more scrupulous in my research in future -- particularly when it comes to my (largely) unverified thoughts on matters such as this.

M.
 
Gulp! :(

Please see:

http://www.cosa.org.au/documents/Cancer_Forum_NOV05_FINAL.pdf

particularly the article entitled "Snake oil, coffee enemas and other famous nostrums for cancer – a recent history of cancer quackery in Australia"

And this, "Can cancer be cured by meditation and “natural therapy”?"

I promise to be more scrupulous in my research in future -- particularly when it comes to my (largely) unverified thoughts on matters such as this.

M.

Now I feel like a meanie.

Linda
 
Now I feel like a meanie.

Linda

Please don't! You're a very good barometer for when I'm off track in my thinking.

Regarding Gawler, I'd sort of bought his story from reading articles in the press and "Gosh, isn't it mahvelous!" segments in misnamed "Current Affair" programs on TV.

I should know better.

Regards,

M.
 
Except, I wasn't talking about odds, I was talking about ratios.

It was just a joke anyway.

Hi, exarch.

I wasn't trying to contradict you. In fact, I agree with what you were saying and I was only trying to expand upon it.

Sorry if it looked otherwise.

John
 
the maths involved

I was hoping you folk could help out, and I apologize if this has been asked before. I’m trying to put together some information for my family regarding these homeopathic remedies. I have a fair bit now, but there are still some issues that I can’t quite track down. These are all about how the remedies are prepared, and the math that comes out from it. You seem like the experts to ask, or at least know where to point to The Official Experts (as opposed to second-hand or 40th-hand information)

1) In the initial mixture, when they say 1 part active ingredient to 10 parts water (assuming an X type dilution), is that by mass or by volume?

2) A question about further mixtures. Let's say that the dilution factor is 5X. Does this mean that for steps 2 through 5, we continue to mix at 1 part previous solution to 10 parts water, or is it now mixed at a 1:9 ratio? I'm just wondering if the mixture is now 0.001% active ingredient, or 0.00062% ingredient.

3) Is there always a fixed amount in the initial mixture of active ingredient? I’ve seen a number of people say 23X and 12C would violate Avogadro, but wouldn’t that only be the case if I start with 1mol of ingredient? I mean, I can start with 10 molecules as my base point, but then past 3X my expected number of molecules remaining is now less than 1. By the same argument, if I start with 1 ton of ingredient, I should be able to go past 23X. Which leads me to…

4) Does the mixing always have to be by hand by the homeopath? Where do they claim the water memorization comes from, the actual physical shaking or by THE HOMEOPATH shaking the solutions?

5) Does anybody know of an official source that states that the mixture must be shaken 10 times up and down, 10 times side to side, and 10 times back and forth? I remember reading that somewhere, but can’t track it down now.

Whew, okay, this is longer than I thought… :P But I've been asked to look into it, and being the crazy math geek that I am, I like to be as accurate as possible.
 
I was hoping you folk could help out, and I apologize if this has been asked before. I’m trying to put together some information for my family regarding these homeopathic remedies. I have a fair bit now, but there are still some issues that I can’t quite track down. These are all about how the remedies are prepared, and the math that comes out from it. You seem like the experts to ask, or at least know where to point to The Official Experts (as opposed to second-hand or 40th-hand information)

1) In the initial mixture, when they say 1 part active ingredient to 10 parts water (assuming an X type dilution), is that by mass or by volume?

2) A question about further mixtures. Let's say that the dilution factor is 5X. Does this mean that for steps 2 through 5, we continue to mix at 1 part previous solution to 10 parts water, or is it now mixed at a 1:9 ratio? I'm just wondering if the mixture is now 0.001% active ingredient, or 0.00062% ingredient.

3) Is there always a fixed amount in the initial mixture of active ingredient? I’ve seen a number of people say 23X and 12C would violate Avogadro, but wouldn’t that only be the case if I start with 1mol of ingredient? I mean, I can start with 10 molecules as my base point, but then past 3X my expected number of molecules remaining is now less than 1. By the same argument, if I start with 1 ton of ingredient, I should be able to go past 23X. Which leads me to…

4) Does the mixing always have to be by hand by the homeopath? Where do they claim the water memorization comes from, the actual physical shaking or by THE HOMEOPATH shaking the solutions?

5) Does anybody know of an official source that states that the mixture must be shaken 10 times up and down, 10 times side to side, and 10 times back and forth? I remember reading that somewhere, but can’t track it down now.

Whew, okay, this is longer than I thought… :P But I've been asked to look into it, and being the crazy math geek that I am, I like to be as accurate as possible.

One mustn't forget to give the water some decent electro-convulsive therapy before use, otherwise its memory may be contaminated by all manner of strange traces.

M.
 
One mustn't forget to give the water some decent electro-convulsive therapy before use, otherwise its memory may be contaminated by all manner of strange traces.

M.

Ha, seriously, is that what they do? That was another thing that was puzzling me -- how exactly do they remove the 'memory' from the water? The whole process is absolutely dependent upon the water being pure. At some point, somehow, somewhere, all water must have been in contact with said ingredient or with another water molecule with the memory effect. So according to homeopaths, the more dilute, the better the remedy. If your solution is at 20X, and you now mix 1 part to 10 parts normal water, the normal water may actually have a base concentration of 5X (0.001%). Therefore the mixed concentration is 0.0009% ingredient, just above 5X and 'weaker' than 20X. The same logic applies to the 'memory' effect on water molecules interacting with the ingredient. So what is this amazing electro-convulsive therapy they use?
 
I was hoping you folk could help out, and I apologize if this has been asked before. I’m trying to put together some information for my family regarding these homeopathic remedies. I have a fair bit now, but there are still some issues that I can’t quite track down. These are all about how the remedies are prepared, and the math that comes out from it. You seem like the experts to ask, or at least know where to point to The Official Experts (as opposed to second-hand or 40th-hand information)
I don't know whether people here are experts, but they seem to know as much about this stuff as the homoeopaths do. ;)

1) In the initial mixture, when they say 1 part active ingredient to 10 parts water (assuming an X type dilution), is that by mass or by volume?
It would usually be by volume from a mother tincture, a solution prepared directly from the allegedly active ingredient, by infusion of a herb in an alcohol/water mixture, for example. There's a description of this being done somewhere on the forum, posted by one of the MAS collective (Dr. A. Sheikh, I think).

2) A question about further mixtures. Let's say that the dilution factor is 5X. Does this mean that for steps 2 through 5, we continue to mix at 1 part previous solution to 10 parts water, or is it now mixed at a 1:9 ratio? I'm just wondering if the mixture is now 0.001% active ingredient, or 0.00062% ingredient.
It seems to be done 1:9. See here, for example:
1 part medicinal substance (dry or tincture), mixed with 9 parts diluent (lactose or alcohol), and then succussed (shaken), yields the 1X(D) potency. Taking 1 part of that potency mixed with 9 parts diluent, then succussed, yields the 2X(D) potency. This is continued until the desired potency is reached.

3) Is there always a fixed amount in the initial mixture of active ingredient? I’ve seen a number of people say 23X and 12C would violate Avogadro, but wouldn’t that only be the case if I start with 1mol of ingredient? I mean, I can start with 10 molecules as my base point, but then past 3X my expected number of molecules remaining is now less than 1.
Generally, there doesn't seem to be any indication as to what the concentration of the mother tincture (MT) was. But we can say that 12c is the point beyond which there is going to be less than one molecule from the MT present, whether of "active" ingredient or solvent.
By the same argument, if I start with 1 ton of ingredient, I should be able to go past 23X.
Not if you're diluting it one in ten each time. If you start with a ton of MT you're going to need to dilute it with nine tons of solvent, and then throw away nine tenths of it at each stage...
Which leads me to…

4) Does the mixing always have to be by hand by the homeopath? Where do they claim the water memorization comes from, the actual physical shaking or by THE HOMEOPATH shaking the solutions?
If prepared by the "Hahnemann method", as originally decreed by Sam Hahmenmann, it is strictly speaking done by hand, with the mixture being succussed at each stage by tapping it on a leather-bound book or the palm of a hand. There are automated machines available (again, one of the MAS collective posted a photograph of one as proof that homoeopathy works), which are often used when preparing remedies commercially, and especially for high potencies, and these generally seem to use the "Korsakov method". In this, a single container is used, and it is repeatedly emptied and refilled with solvent. It is assumed that one hundredth of the solution sticks to the side of the bottle at each stage. See this page for a description of both methods.

I love that last sentence:
It is believed that by using the same container the final remedy contains the energy pattern of all the potencies up to and including the final potency, allowing the patients body to use the most effective potency for the condition.
"It is believed", huh? Some people will believe anything!

5) Does anybody know of an official source that states that the mixture must be shaken 10 times up and down, 10 times side to side, and 10 times back and forth? I remember reading that somewhere, but can’t track it down now.
The "official source" is Hahnemann's Organon, the holy book of homoeopathy, but he doesn't seem to have rigidly specifed a particular number of succussions. He did, apparently, recommend succussing by tapping the container on a leather-bound book such as a Bible (or even a copy of the Organon ;) ).
 
Last edited:
I don't know whether people here are experts, but they seem to know as much about this stuff as the homoeopaths do.

It would usually be by volume from a mother tincture, a solution prepared directly from the allegedly active ingredient, by infusion of a herb in an alcohol/water mixture, for example. There's a description of this being done somewhere on the forum, posted by one of the MAS collective (Dr. A. Sheikh, I think).

It seems to be done 1:9. See here, for example:
This is absolutely awesome. Thanks for the long reply, Mojo. The mixing ratio was a big one for me. I've read Randi mention in his commentaries a number of times saying that an X-type dilution is a 10 to 1 ratio. As a statistician, I see ratios differently than chemists. (People hate me at work when I corrent their use of ratio when they mean proportion :P ) So this is cool, it makes all my calculations a heck of a lot easier. ^_^

Generally, there doesn't seem to be any indication as to what the concentration of the mother tincture (MT) was. But we can say that 12c is the point beyond which there is going to be less than one molecule from the MT present, whether of "active" ingredient or solvent.
Not if you're diluting it one in ten each time. If you start with a ton of MT you're going to need to dilute it with nine tons of solvent, and then throw away nine tenths of it at each stage...
Here's my logic on this one. Let's actually start with 18 tons of MT. MT is, for the most part, water, so 18,000 kg = 18,000,000 grams = 1.08 x 10^31 molecules of MT. Each dilution will have an expected return of 1/10th the number of molecules, so at 30X we should still, on average, expect to see 11 molecules left of MT, and not less than one.

But who in their right mind would buy 18tons of remedy at once? A typical store bought remedy is... what? 50mL?

I will admit, my chemistry is a little on the rusty side, and these estimates are assuming that the MT is mostly water. If it's mostly alcohol, the number of molecules are completely different (is it mostly CHOOCH?). Would it be isopropyl? I'll have to look at those links and try to find just how much herb and stuff to start with in the MT.

There are automated machines available (again, one of the MAS collective posted a photograph of one as proof that homoeopathy works), which are often used when preparing remedies commercially, and especially for high potencies, and these generally seem to use the "Korsakov method". In this, a single container is used, and it is repeatedly emptied and refilled with solvent. It is assumed that one hundredth of the solution sticks to the side of the bottle at each stage.
Here's my stupid question of the day. If this device can indeed be used, then why can't the pipes under my apartment also be used? I was thinking that I could be of great service to humanity and cause the Great Lakes to become one giant homeopathic remedy to... well... everything. No need to buy at the store, just go swimming!

I love that last sentence: "It is believed", huh? Some people will believe anything!
I'll have to remember that arguement the next time my performance review comes up with my boss. "It is believed that me sitting on my chair and drinking coffee all day has saved us millions of dollars!"
 
Here's my logic on this one. Let's actually start with 18 tons of MT. MT is, for the most part, water, so 18,000 kg = 18,000,000 grams = 1.08 x 10^31 molecules of MT. Each dilution will have an expected return of 1/10th the number of molecules, so at 30X we should still, on average, expect to see 11 molecules left of MT, and not less than one.

But who in their right mind would buy 18tons of remedy at once? A typical store bought remedy is... what? 50mL?

That last part is the crux of the matter.

Even presuming that a homeopathic manufacturer makes and sells 18 tons of remedy, say, in 50ml bottles, that still means 360'000 bottles (if my math is correct). In other words, the odds that you have a bottle with one molecule of mother tincture left in it is 1 in 32'727 (or 0.003%).

And generally, this 30X (or, if diluted 100 to 1 at every stage 15C) is only half the length they go to. Usually, remedies are 30C or beyond at 200C, and then there's LM potencies too (dilutions of 50'000 to 1 if I have my Roman numerals correctly) that also go up to 200.

Just for fun, we quickly calculated about a year ago, that dropping a 1 kg bag of sugar into the Pacific ocean would still result in an overall higher sugar content in all the worlds oceans than the amount of mother tincture left in a 10C homeopathic remedy (IIRC). In other words, if you scooped out a 10 liter bucket of sea water several years afterwards, you might have minute but perhaps actually detectable levels of sugar molecules as a result.

But homeopaths actually can't tell what a remedy used to be once they've diluted it beyond 15C (30X).
 
Last edited:
Ha, seriously, is that what they do? That was another thing that was puzzling me -- how exactly do they remove the 'memory' from the water?
I have seen homoeopaths claim that they use distilled water. When they use alcohol as solvent, I assume this alcohol has been recently distilled anyway. However, I have also heard about homoeopaths actually using tap water.
This opens for a test to see if homoeopath remedies work differently if they use tap water or distilled water.
 
The REAL problem, as I have discovered, is not the mathematics of the situation, or even the ludicrously bad chemistry that accompanies it. It's the appalling lack of basic understanding (i.e. knowledge) by the people who peddle this sort of thing.

For a start, many of them have no idea how to work with powers of ten in arithmetic - a very basic concept in understanding just about anything in the modern world, let alone a pseudo-scientific discipline like homeopathy, I think we all agree. Many of them have even been shown to have trouble dealing with any numbers bigger than one million, or sizes smaller than they can see with the naked eye... :eye-poppi: So more stratospheric concepts like molecules and high dilutions and arithmetic involving exponents is way beyond them. Needless to say, they have a LOT of dangerously wrong misconceptions of what these entail as a result, and take a LOT of information totally on trust and for granted as provided by the quacks flogging the stuff.

Just as dangerous are those who have a little knowledge, and I must emphasise the word "little", and proceed to totally misunderstand and often completely misread technical information, or see it through MT-coloured glasses. ;)

Just one quick example: One homeopath was absolutely certain that a 12C dilution was 1:1024. A bit of intuitive thinking and it became clear - what he thought was the value 1,024 was actually written as 1024 but he thought it was simply a printing error. Alas, his stubborn pride refused to let him acknowledge the error, and he stuck to his guns and INSISTED we skeptic allopath-lovers were totally incorrect...and he looked even more stupid for doing so as a result. :)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom