exarch
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 2003
- Messages
- 7,184
I was assuming that being abusive to posters on an internet forum, results in them switching off from what you have to say to them. If I now examine that assumption, I do not find it wanting (short of a double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over trial). Perhaps I'm not examining it deeply enough though. Let's just say I'm not the sort of person who is inclined to readily accept the views of someone who's just hit me over the head. Let's just say, that I think that that person will have done me a disfavour if his view is correct and he has made if difficult for me to accept that correct view because of the fact that he has hit me over the head with it. Also, I don't think I'm that unusual in this regard. But that is an assumption, I know.
I think one major difference is that even here, people don't start calling you names the moment you confess belief in some type of woo.
They will shower you with evidence and slap you in the face with facts, and if you consider that abuse, well, then you'll never really learn anything I suppose. While you may be overwhelmed, I think it's pretty rare that someone will actually be disgusted by JREF-ers providing them with tons of information, resources and links and whatnot to counter the uncritical point of view you hold, unless you're not really willing to change that view to begin with (which is another matter altogether).
While homeopathy was being laughed at from the very start of this thread, adherents of homeopathy posting here were not. Not initially anyway. Rodney was instantly thrust knee-deep in facts, and questions meant to get him to think about the lack of support for his position. Same thing happened in the Edgar Cayce thread.
But after several pages, it became clear to one and all that Rodney wasn't actually here to have questions answered, he was only here to kick up dust. At that point the gloves were removed and everybody stopped pulling their punches.
While we've been discussing the merits of polite discussion for a couple of pages now, one question remains unanswered: was our reaction to Rodney coming up with the same argument for the umpteenth time excessively hostile? Does anyone really think that there's one lurker out there who's read this entire thread (if they've even read it entirely) and think "man, they're really treating that Rodney fellow unfairly"?
What I think they'll see is what we've pointed out again and again, that Rodney was recycling his old refuted arguments, or rephrasing them so they looked different but weren't. In a way, it's Rodney who was discussing unfairly. I don't think anyone will consider our reaction rude, unless they already sided with Rodney from the start and think we should condone such underhand discussion tactics.