Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I was assuming that being abusive to posters on an internet forum, results in them switching off from what you have to say to them. If I now examine that assumption, I do not find it wanting (short of a double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over trial :D ). Perhaps I'm not examining it deeply enough though. Let's just say I'm not the sort of person who is inclined to readily accept the views of someone who's just hit me over the head. Let's just say, that I think that that person will have done me a disfavour if his view is correct and he has made if difficult for me to accept that correct view because of the fact that he has hit me over the head with it. Also, I don't think I'm that unusual in this regard. But that is an assumption, I know.

I think one major difference is that even here, people don't start calling you names the moment you confess belief in some type of woo.

They will shower you with evidence and slap you in the face with facts, and if you consider that abuse, well, then you'll never really learn anything I suppose. While you may be overwhelmed, I think it's pretty rare that someone will actually be disgusted by JREF-ers providing them with tons of information, resources and links and whatnot to counter the uncritical point of view you hold, unless you're not really willing to change that view to begin with (which is another matter altogether).

While homeopathy was being laughed at from the very start of this thread, adherents of homeopathy posting here were not. Not initially anyway. Rodney was instantly thrust knee-deep in facts, and questions meant to get him to think about the lack of support for his position. Same thing happened in the Edgar Cayce thread.

But after several pages, it became clear to one and all that Rodney wasn't actually here to have questions answered, he was only here to kick up dust. At that point the gloves were removed and everybody stopped pulling their punches.

While we've been discussing the merits of polite discussion for a couple of pages now, one question remains unanswered: was our reaction to Rodney coming up with the same argument for the umpteenth time excessively hostile? Does anyone really think that there's one lurker out there who's read this entire thread (if they've even read it entirely) and think "man, they're really treating that Rodney fellow unfairly"?

What I think they'll see is what we've pointed out again and again, that Rodney was recycling his old refuted arguments, or rephrasing them so they looked different but weren't. In a way, it's Rodney who was discussing unfairly. I don't think anyone will consider our reaction rude, unless they already sided with Rodney from the start and think we should condone such underhand discussion tactics.
 
No problem BillyJoe; hopefully people can see that no-one's arguing outright for a nasty approach; I think we all agree that reason and politeness are the first recourse in all but the most extreme circumstances. But at the same time I refuse to feel guilty for losing my rag with the wilfully ignorant and getting embroiled in pointless abusive circular arguments in a vain attempt to make the other person's position look silly. Hang on a minute.. :catfight:

I think you ment:

...Therefore it's more reasonable that you verbally abuse those who refuse to acknowledge this despite the lack of evidence for their position...

Resorting to verbal abuse is very rarely reasonable. Funny sometimes, but not reasonable.

I agree, that's why I phrased it as "more reasonable". As in, more reasonable than not at all.
 
Last edited:
going back to the nature of placebos, it seems to be a common misunderstanding that the placebo effect is a "real" effect, a cure if you like when in fact it is a psychological mechanism, that is , in the case of homeopathic "treatment" the patient will say they "feel" better. this does not mean they are in fact any better than before swallowing their individually prescribed sugar pill. placebos dont cure anything. this is also one of the dangers of quackery like homeopathy, a person may feel (subjectively) better after a nice chat and a sugar pill ,and the homepath telling them that any worsening of their symptoms means they are getting better, leading them to avoid or delay seeking appropriate medical treatment.
on the issue of whether us mean ole skeptics should play a bit nicer with the poor misunderstood charlatans, who apparently are incapable of evaluating some fairly basic flaws in their pet woo before inflicting it upon the public and may be really nice and earnest and love bunnies and kittens , i think that to its credit, the JREF forums are generally very tolerant but robust. i get a bit tired of the woos crying foul and complaining about how nasty we are anytime they get asked for some evidence. extraordinary claims etc...
 
Excuse me, people, does it not occur to you that one might not be spending one’s entire life logging on?
Right here, not running, not hiding behind skirts. Just behind computer.
Oops, didn’t know I was being nasty myself by telling you some of you often are – if I didn’t make that distinction, I apologize and correct myself.
What, am I supposed to be a homeopath in hiding, insidiously out to defend homeopathy? Are you maybe paranoid?
Please let me clarify my reason for ‘un-lurking’. While there’s no reason anyone should give a damn what I think, my purpose was to inform you that you are putting off people with the attitude you sometimes display. And that should someone not immediately succumb to your reasoning, it should not brand him/her as unworthy of your courtesy or patience.

If you had cared to invest some time in reading the multifarious opinions expressed in this forum, you might have gathered that this opinion of yours has been expressed umpteen times, and that it no longer washes with those of us who have developed calluses massaging the underdeveloped intellects of the lily-livered "lurkers" who are are waiting to be convinced.

Let these erstwhile imbeciles do their own research and arrive at an informed opinion, rather than come here and be spoon-fed others' opinions.

SOLELY my OPINION. Feel free to ignore it, as I believe I am free to state it.

Of course you are. That would be evident to you if you had got off your gluteus maximus of a brain and actually read the forum.

I am in no way an anti-vaxxer nor am I supporting substituting homeopathy in any serious problem except in case of ‘last resort’.

Doesn't that make you a proselytizer for quackery?

I just don’t see that IF people are duly informed about the unlikelihood of homeopathy working, and if they choose to try it nonetheless, where is the harm?

That is for the fool to discover. Most of us aim to avert tragedy.

If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree?

It remains to be proven that homeopathy has actually prevented anything, including suffering.

Maybe because a lot of homeopaths spend TIME with their clients and let them unburden or whatever – there’s probably great value in letting someone talk about themselves.

Listen, you mo**n, friends, assuming you have any, allow you to "unburden or whatever." What's more, they do it free of charge.

What about ‘last resort’ – someone has some disease that conventional medicine says cannot be cured. What if ayurveda or homeopathy offer some hope? Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?

Do you honestly expect an answer? Show us some clear, unambiguous (read non-anecdotal) evidence for your preposterous suggestions, please. Evidence rules, remember?

Oh dear – okay, since I said I would, if you would like me to, I shall go over the whole bally 20-odd pages again and offer bits I think indicate eye-rolling and sighing. Will take me time, so please don’t think I’ve vanished into dark night.

Please, oh please do! And remember, BJ plays Devil's Advocate because he can. :D

And thank you, BillyJoe.

M.
 
i get a bit tired of the woos crying foul and complaining about how nasty we are anytime they get asked for some evidence. extraordinary claims etc...
Important point: we've not been asking for "extraordinary evidence" for homoeopathy. All we've been asking is that it comes up to the same standard as real medicine.
 
A few months ago I did not know what homeopaths were. After watching some James Randi on Youtube and reading these postings, I saved myself from being swindled. Tonight my daughter was experiencing ear pain and I rushed over to the pharmacy to see what was available. I was looking at ear drops and could not find any for pain. Then I stumbled on one that claimed it cured pain, wax build up, and a couple of other things. As always I looked at the active ingredients and noticed that the percentages were written in this funny manner (parts per milion or billion). I continued to read more of the label and there it was, "Homeopathic Medicine." Knowing now that homeopaths are more than 99% water, I quickly put the label down in disgust, grabbed some childrens' Tylonol (for the pain) and will await her condition in the morning (possibly followed up by a doctor's visit). I can't help but to point out two red flags, which I hope will help others as they have helped me. First is the fact that it was the only medicine (so to speak) that had multiple healing effects, unlike all the others. The second is the quantities for the active ingredients were written in a different manner than all the other medications. I hope pharmacies don't start carrying multiple brands of homeopaths, this could make spotting red flags, like these, very difficult.

Interesting story :)

Here in Australia, pharmacists, and the industry in general, have received the 2006 Bent Spoon Award from the Australian Skeptics for selling garbage to their customers.

http://www.skeptics.com.au/

Well deserved, IMO.

I have told our pharmacist, whom we see monthly at least, that we won't return in 2007 while he continues to sell snake oil along with the regular stuff.

Moves are afoot here to banish this rubbish from pharmacy shelves. It can't come too soon.

M.
 
Linda, with Mini's postings and responses, I think this thread will break 1,000!

Wonderful! :D

I can't respond to much, but I do have an anecdote to offer in response to this assumption.

Several years ago I started lurking on alt.parenting.spanking. There were some interesting cross-posted threads in the group I normally hung out in. The spanking group was dominated by anti-spankers. Their attitude toward spanking was not terribly different than the attitude displayed here towards homopathy. I delurked to express my concern about their attitude towards those who disagreed.

Now you have to understand, I do not believe in spanking as a disciplinary measure.

Between consenting partners I think it is allowable :)

I have never spanked my children. But I don't think everyone who does so is a child-abuser.

What would you call them?

The anti-spankers did and the derision and hostility they displayed towards anyone who disagreed was not only offputting to me as a lurker, once I started posting in support that spanking did not equal child-abuse, I was subject to the same.

Deservedly so, IMO. Shame on you!

ONe person even told me I was worse than the spankers. At some point, I caught myself considering spanking my young son because I was so annoyed with them and their attitude. At that point, I pretty much stopped reading or posting to the newsgroup. I didn't want my annoyance with them to affect my decisions and, ultimately, my relationship with my son.

Showing some native intelligence there, I'm afraid...

My point is that the general attitude they had did affect my own and it was opposite to the affect they would have liked to have had. They never convinced me to ardently object to spanking. Instead, they pushed me towards the other direction because I found them so obnoxious that I didn't want to hold any opinions in common with them.

Oops! Previous comment withdrawn...

Incidently, I found it quite ironic that for people who so ardently argued that the slightest physical discipline constitited abuse, they had no problems with heaping loads of verbal abuse on not just those who disagreed, but on anyone who wasn't strongly enough opposed to spanking in their opinion.

Did it ever occur to your addled brain that these might have been people who were spanked by abusive parents?

Due to that experience of my own, I think Mini's point is valid. I think that scorn, ridicule and derision are not useful because treating others like that does put people off and will push many people in the opposite direction that you are advocating.

I beg to differ. Those adversely affected by such scathing criticism may have a loose screw or two in the first place. Think about it.

I realize that Randi and Dawkins both use such methods and my respect for them has dropped considerably because of that.

Your inestimable loss.

M.
 
i get a bit tired of the woos crying foul and complaining about how nasty we are anytime they get asked for some evidence. extraordinary claims etc...
Just, at least, be careful not to generalise the particular.
 
um....happy new year Moochie. I think you need it. ;)

And me too....
We'll will be off tomorrow to Sandy Point for about a week, ten days if the weather is fine. I may post from there but my online time will be very limited.

And happy new year to everyone else. :)
 
um....happy new year Moochie. I think you need it. ;)

And me too....
We'll will be off tomorrow to Sandy Point for about a week, ten days if the weather is fine. I may post from there but my online time will be very limited.

And happy new year to everyone else. :)


A peaceful and prosperous 2007 to you and your family, too.

(Got bugger all in the $33M lottery Saturday night :( )

In the overall scheme of things, it was a tiny wager.

We have our health and contentment to abide with, no thanks to god, homeopaths, or any other woo element.

Kitty's doing well after his recent bout of constipation, too :D

Cheers,

M.
 
Here in Australia, pharmacists, and the industry in general, have received the 2006 Bent Spoon Award from the Australian Skeptics for selling garbage to their customers.

http://www.skeptics.com.au/

Well deserved, IMO.

I have told our pharmacist, whom we see monthly at least, that we won't return in 2007 while he continues to sell snake oil along with the regular stuff.

Moves are afoot here to banish this rubbish from pharmacy shelves. It can't come too soon.
Pharmacists around here are much the same. In fact, the one two doors down from my local pub has a bloody great neon sign reading "HOMOEOPATHIC PHARMACY" in the window, and a practitioner on the SoH's list of homoeopaths working there. Fortunately they're not generally open around the time I leave the pub, or they might have learned something about hostility, and perhaps even abuse. ;)

All the others in the immediate area have nice big sCAM sections. I've managed to find one (ironically, perhaps, the oldest established one in the area, as far as I can tell) that doesn't, but it's quite inconvenient for me to get to.
 
Pharmacists around here are much the same. In fact, the one two doors down from my local pub has a bloody great neon sign reading "HOMOEOPATHIC PHARMACY" in the window, and a practitioner on the SoH's list of homoeopaths working there. Fortunately they're not generally open around the time I leave the pub, or they might have learned something about hostility, and perhaps even abuse. ;)

Heh heh heh... Do try to be civil and polite, and restrict your understandable vitriol to verbal complaints only. Our pharmacist, of Asian descent, was very polite in his reply to our threat of taking our business elsewhere -- presumably because he knows they're all money-grubbing little shites and that we won't find a pharmacist who doesn't sell snake oil.

Still, we try. This individual has had our business, worth a couple of thousand per annum, at least, for the past three years. Let's see how he responds when he can no longer count on our part of his regular income.

I would recommend this strategy to all who disapprove of their pharmacist selling snake oil.

All the others in the immediate area have nice big sCAM sections. I've managed to find one (ironically, perhaps, the oldest established one in the area, as far as I can tell) that doesn't, but it's quite inconvenient for me to get to.

Up to you whether you trade convenience for supporting crapola.

Unfortunately, at present we have no such choice -- they're all shysters!

BTW, they're all "shysters" because no one's bothered to tell them that they are -- shows how backward we are as an outpost of supposed "civilization."

M.
 
going back to the nature of placebos, it seems to be a common misunderstanding that the placebo effect is a "real" effect, a cure if you like when in fact it is a psychological mechanism, that is , in the case of homeopathic "treatment" the patient will say they "feel" better. this does not mean they are in fact any better than before swallowing their individually prescribed sugar pill. placebos dont cure anything. this is also one of the dangers of quackery like homeopathy, a person may feel (subjectively) better after a nice chat and a sugar pill ,and the homepath telling them that any worsening of their symptoms means they are getting better, leading them to avoid or delay seeking appropriate medical treatment.

Not quite true actually. Placebo effect can be a real curative effect. Someone could have a fever, and after taking a placebo their fever subsides a bit, while it might not have if they hadn't received anything.
There are a number of things that are controlled by the body but cannot (as far as I know) be consciously controlled, like body temperature, blood pressure, heart rate, etc... If you manage to fool the brain into thinking it's getting better, then perhaps the brain can change these variables to match this.

Of course, this is only a small part (and overall, a minor contributor) of all the factors that are commonly grouped under the term "placebo effect". Most of those factors include various biases and subjective observations.
 
Not quite true actually. Placebo effect can be a real curative effect. Someone could have a fever, and after taking a placebo their fever subsides a bit, while it might not have if they hadn't received anything.
There are a number of things that are controlled by the body but cannot (as far as I know) be consciously controlled, like body temperature, blood pressure, heart rate, etc... If you manage to fool the brain into thinking it's getting better, then perhaps the brain can change these variables to match this. ...
See:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2006/12/a_belated_response.php
[/quote]As for placebos, remember that the placebo effect has never, to my knowledge, been demonstrated to have an objectively measurable therapeutic effect against the really nasty diseases. For example, no placebo will shrink a tumor or prolong life in a patient with cancer. Even in less life-threatening conditions, the placebo effect produces no objective alterations. For example, placebos do not alter blood pressure. Whatever "neurophysiological" effect that may be attributable to placebos only seems to work when it comes to subjective symptoms with a significant psychological component, like pain, or diseases with a significant psychological overlay. And, even though it can't be said that we fully understand the placebo effect, it does not require the invocation of biologically or physically implausible mechanisms to explain, as does homeopathy. Either way, the evidence for the existence of the placebo effect in conditions having to do with pain or subjective discomfort or suffering is strong, which is reason enough to accept its existence while studying its mechanism.[/quote][Bold added] The author is a professor of surgery, I checked on that. His Blog just won an award for best medblog.

It would be interesting to know if any study showed a placebo effect in a measurable condition. Note, the Blogger says "to the best of my knowledge" (as in he has not done a specific search)- has anyone here done so?
 
Most homeopaths do not "pretend" to have competence, they "think" they do have it. There is a big difference. Most homoeopaths are not "willing to risk the lives and well being of others", they earnestly believe thay are helping people in need. Most homoeopaths do not believe their beliefs are "untested", they believe they have been tested and found valid. They may be wrong, but that is what they believe.

And this is why medicine has regulatory bodies that review evidence and require it's members to make sure their certification is up to date. If someone is wrong in their belief it's a very simple situation, they're treating people who should be going to the Doctor.

The problem with quack medicine (not just homeopathy) is that if it does have a regulatory body their sole job seems to be to muddy the waters regarding evidence, decry 'Western' medicine and run popularity campaigns or rally for political pressure.
 
No problem BillyJoe; hopefully people can see that no-one's arguing outright for a nasty approach; I think we all agree that reason and politeness are the first recourse in all but the most extreme circumstances. But at the same time I refuse to feel guilty for losing my rag with the wilfully ignorant and getting embroiled in pointless abusive circular arguments in a vain attempt to make the other person's position look silly.

Personally I think there is absolutely no value in according the "theory" of homepathy anything but scorn.

I am not posting on here to convince some mythical "lurkers" who cannot be bothered to post. Nor am I seeking to "convert" anyone. I am merely expressing my opinion in a forum that suits my views.

Homeopaths peddle quack nostrums. They do it repeatedly. IMHO they are not searching for proof but merely for "recognition" and they and their apologists will use every slithery little argument to try and achieve that.

Instead of trying to persuade, obfuscate and wriggle to get some sort of "government" imprimatur on their quackery - they could be spending their time and effort in research and experimentation demonstrating unequivocally how "effective" their treatments are. Now that is an endeavor in which I would support the homeopathic community.
 
No there is not. Someone who pretends to a competence that they do not have and is willing to risk the lives and well being of others to further their untested "belief" deserves nothing but contempt and scorn.

We'll just have to agree to disagree I guess. My perception is that homeopaths are about as much of a threat to the health and well-being of members of our society as liquor store clerks.

Your example is relevant if you consider the amount and kind of abuse on this thread directed towards Rodney to be similar to the amount and kind of abuse you experienced. And if you seriously think that you could have been persuaded to be an ardent anti-spanker had you received a more courteous and patient response.

I don't generally like to share personal experiences here because the atmosphere is so hostile but I'll try to answer this. I don't think this thread is particularly bad, but the general tone in the forum as a whole to those with a slightly different viewpoint is similar. While I doubt I would ever have been an ardent anti-spanker, I might have been persuaded to be an advocate for non-spanking disciplinary measures if they had responded differently to my point that making spanking illegal was a solution far worse than the problem they were trying to fix.
My point with respect to Mini was that it was possible that she/he was simply looking to complain. That she/he wasn't looking at whether there was excessive abuse, but only at whether there was any abuse. And that Mini's opinion of homeopathy and skeptics would not have changed even if she/he was not put off (i.e. her/his opinion would have been exactly the same (unchanged) at the end of a perfectly warm and fuzzy condemnation of homeopathy).

Mini's opinion of homeopathy might not have been any different, but his/her opinion of skeptics and this forum might well have been. I hope Mini will post again and hasn't given up completely on us. This is a hostile place to post dissenting opinions and I've learned to avoid posting certain of my opinions for that reason. I also deal with it by using the ignore feature with posters I find so negative and unpleasant that I don't care what they've written or to interact with them at all.
I guess what I'm saying is that while I am more comfortable with respect and patience, I don't think I can justify suggesting that others change, and I will defend the possibility that the perspective of Deus Ex Machina is just as valid as mine.

Linda

I like this forum because a lot of very intellegent and well-educated people post here and the discussions are quite lively. I can withstand a fairly large amount of hostility myself. But I would like to see less of the insults and ad hom arguments that are plentiful here. I can't control what other people do, but I can make my own likes and dislikes known and try to persuade others, through rational argument, to be more rational in their arguments. I consider it my small contribution to making this forum a better place. :)
 
It would be interesting to know if any study showed a placebo effect in a measurable condition. Note, the Blogger says "to the best of my knowledge" (as in he has not done a specific search)- has anyone here done so?

An analysis of the placebo effect in 2001 did not show a difference in objective measurements. I do not know of anything beyond that.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom