Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Halleluiah and Praise the Lord, for I have seen the light- no, Light. I believe, I believe, how could I not, when ‘everyone’ says I should?
Is this what you want? It’s obviously more acceptable to you than the truth – or would be if I disguised its true nature sufficiently. I wonder how many people of the scores – or whatever – of converts just give in because they are consciously or subconsciously looking for a cessation to being told what morons they are or just for a warm, fuzzy feeling of acceptance.
I had not – and have not - made up my mind because I happen to think there may be something we do not understand about homeopathy. NOT CONVINCED IT WORKS. NOT CERTAIN IT DOESN’T. NOT here because I’ve decided something and only want to “complain”. Why would I do that? I rather enjoy reading posts on the forum. I know the numbers, I know about dilution. I have read a load of ridiculous nonsense on some homeopathic forums. I also know of what seem like cures from homeopathy. Your arguments are that it cannot be, so it’s not. I say maybe – because yes, on the face of it, there seems no justification for homeopathy to work, but what if there’s more we don’t know? If that makes me moronic or irritates you, not much I can do, unless you want me to lie.
If you’d actually got what I was trying to say, you might have realized that I was trying to tell you that smacking down or showing contempt is not quite your best bet if you’re trying to sway opinions (as Beth explained). I was not advocating sweetness and light all around. And that someone persisting in a view you THINK you’ve done enough to tear to bits might have their reasons for their doubts. Not your problem, I reckon.
What you seem to be saying that EVEN if they are informed, people should not have the right to choose homeopathy. Hmmm.
I apologize for wasting your time on my repetitive nonsense. No, really – I guess you’ve all gone down this road before. I apologize for saying what you did not want to hear, because for many of you it seems to be preferable to exchange views with each other that fit snugly into the grooves you’ve laid.
P.S. BTW, that was amusing “yeah, like you and BillyJoe aren’t in collusion”. I rather suspected that BillyJoe was playing good cop, but since he said much that I wanted to, I decided to accept him at face value.
 
BTW, Moochie, I'm not playing, being mentally retarded and all. And because I love your post. I have changed my mind - I rather be entertained than be bothered with the tone of posters or even with the content of their posts.
 
Halleluiah and Praise the Lord, for I have seen the light- no, Light. I believe, I believe, how could I not, when ‘everyone’ says I should?
Is this what you want? It’s obviously more acceptable to you than the truth – or would be if I disguised its true nature sufficiently. I wonder how many people of the scores – or whatever – of converts just give in because they are consciously or subconsciously looking for a cessation to being told what morons they are or just for a warm, fuzzy feeling of acceptance.
I had not – and have not - made up my mind because I happen to think there may be something we do not understand about homeopathy. NOT CONVINCED IT WORKS. NOT CERTAIN IT DOESN’T. NOT here because I’ve decided something and only want to “complain”. Why would I do that? I rather enjoy reading posts on the forum. I know the numbers, I know about dilution. I have read a load of ridiculous nonsense on some homeopathic forums. I also know of what seem like cures from homeopathy. Your arguments are that it cannot be, so it’s not. I say maybe – because yes, on the face of it, there seems no justification for homeopathy to work, but what if there’s more we don’t know? If that makes me moronic or irritates you, not much I can do, unless you want me to lie.
If you’d actually got what I was trying to say, you might have realized that I was trying to tell you that smacking down or showing contempt is not quite your best bet if you’re trying to sway opinions (as Beth explained). I was not advocating sweetness and light all around. And that someone persisting in a view you THINK you’ve done enough to tear to bits might have their reasons for their doubts. Not your problem, I reckon.
What you seem to be saying that EVEN if they are informed, people should not have the right to choose homeopathy. Hmmm.
I apologize for wasting your time on my repetitive nonsense. No, really – I guess you’ve all gone down this road before. I apologize for saying what you did not want to hear, because for many of you it seems to be preferable to exchange views with each other that fit snugly into the grooves you’ve laid.
P.S. BTW, that was amusing “yeah, like you and BillyJoe aren’t in collusion”. I rather suspected that BillyJoe was playing good cop, but since he said much that I wanted to, I decided to accept him at face value.


So - what exactly would be conclusive evidence for you that homeopathy either works, or is bunk?

As yet, despite controlled testing, no effect has been shown to exist. And, as yet, there is no known mechanism by which homeopathy could work.

So we have no explanation as to HOW it could work, and no proof that it even DOES work.

So, what else exactly needs to be done? Wouldn't you agree that money going to homeopaths could be better diverted to science that has shown some sort of promise?
​
 
What you seem to be saying that EVEN if they are informed, people should not have the right to choose homeopathy. Hmmm.
Ah yes, the "consumer rights" argument. Well, obviously I can't speak for anyone else, but my position is that people have a right to make informed decisions, and that therefore homoeopaths should not be able to advertise their services as if it worked, unless they can demonstrate that it does. In this respect it shouldn't be any different from any other type of medicine, or indeed any other type of product.

If people want to choose something that doesn't work, that is their right, I suppose, but if they're choosing it because they are assured that it works, then they're being swindled. This applies to any product or service. People have a right not to be defrauded.
 
Your arguments are that it cannot be, so it’s not.
If you read the thread, you will see that to a large extent the argument presented in it is not "it cannot be, so it’s not". The argument in this thread has largely been "it has failed to demonstrate efficacy in properly controlled trials, so it is not". The issue of the sort of dilutions involved has been mentioned, but most of the argument has been about the results of trials, and analysis of the data from trials. Another strawman, and another attempt to characterise skeptics as closed-minded.
 
Last edited:
Halleluiah and Praise the Lord, for I have seen the light- no, Light. I believe, I believe, how could I not, when ‘everyone’ says I should?
Is this what you want? It’s obviously more acceptable to you than the truth – or would be if I disguised its true nature sufficiently. I wonder how many people of the scores – or whatever – of converts just give in because they are consciously or subconsciously looking for a cessation to being told what morons they are or just for a warm, fuzzy feeling of acceptance.
I had not – and have not - made up my mind because I happen to think there may be something we do not understand about homeopathy. NOT CONVINCED IT WORKS. NOT CERTAIN IT DOESN’T. NOT here because I’ve decided something and only want to “complain”. Why would I do that? I rather enjoy reading posts on the forum. I know the numbers, I know about dilution. I have read a load of ridiculous nonsense on some homeopathic forums. I also know of what seem like cures from homeopathy. Your arguments are that it cannot be, so it’s not. I say maybe – because yes, on the face of it, there seems no justification for homeopathy to work, but what if there’s more we don’t know? If that makes me moronic or irritates you, not much I can do, unless you want me to lie.
If you’d actually got what I was trying to say, you might have realized that I was trying to tell you that smacking down or showing contempt is not quite your best bet if you’re trying to sway opinions (as Beth explained). I was not advocating sweetness and light all around. And that someone persisting in a view you THINK you’ve done enough to tear to bits might have their reasons for their doubts. Not your problem, I reckon.
What you seem to be saying that EVEN if they are informed, people should not have the right to choose homeopathy. Hmmm.
I apologize for wasting your time on my repetitive nonsense. No, really – I guess you’ve all gone down this road before. I apologize for saying what you did not want to hear, because for many of you it seems to be preferable to exchange views with each other that fit snugly into the grooves you’ve laid.

See? I was right. You took a legitimate issue (whether smack downs sway opinion) and pretended that it could be applied to this thread (it can't) as an excuse to insult and harass. You had no real interest in determining whether or not your characterization was relevant. All you were looking for was just enough abrasiveness to allow the lies you were about to spread to stick. A very reasonable and considered discussion followed. Did you participate in that discussion? No. You flung poo.

How about the other issues you raised? Maybe you were truly interested in an examination of the other points you brought up, rather than scoring "Attack the Skeptics" points. Let's see what your post says.

We say "whether or not something may be true does not depend upon the manner of the presentation. (Nice people may be lying or deluded. Abrasive people may be presenting objective evidence.)" You say, "you seem to think you can browbeat me into belief."

We say "considering that we are fooled by ourselves and others into believing things that turn out not to be true, homeopathy should be evaluated by the same standard. So far the evidence (of which there is more than enough and has been covered in detail already) shows that when you take away the opportunity to be fooled by yourself or by others, homeopathy does not demonstrate any effect." You say, "I don't care and quit calling me a moron for ignoring the evidence."

We say, "by any ordinary standards we use to determine what ideas may or may not be true (the moon is made of green cheese, the earth revolves around the sun), it can be determined that the idea of homeopathy is not true." You say, "I am going to make an exception for homeopathy and require extraordinary standards to say it's not true. I am not going to justify my use of extraordinary standards in this case, though. I am only going to insult you for not going along."

We say, "we should not make it easy for people to be unknowingly defrauded." You say, "people should be able to choose to be unknowingly defrauded."

We say, "you are resonding to a mischaracterization of 'what skeptics say' instead of actually paying attention and responding to what is really said here." You say, "why do you hate America?"

Your motivation? Not malice or stupidity, just carelessness and the selection of an easy out.

Did I exaggerate and mischaracterize? Yup. Can I defend everything I said anyway? You betcha.

Linda
 
We'll just have to agree to disagree I guess. My perception is that homeopaths are about as much of a threat to the health and well-being of members of our society as liquor store clerks.

I guess the difference is that when we look at that situation, we realize that people don't go to liquor store clercks to inquire about the best way to protect themselves against malaria. People generally also don't ask liquor store clercks to check out some rash or lump they suddenly developped. Many forms of cancer can be treated if they're found early enough. If a homeopath first spends several months or even years trying to make it go away with water and sugarpills, then people might end up dying of cancer because they didn't do the sensible thing and have their health checked by a health specialist instead of a liquor store clerck.

You're right about one thing though, both homeopaths and liquor store clercks have about the same qualifications to treat a sick person.
 
I had not – and have not - made up my mind because I happen to think there may be something we do not understand about homeopathy. NOT CONVINCED IT WORKS. NOT CERTAIN IT DOESN’T.

Well, nobody here is absolutely 100% certain it doesn't work. But so far, homeopathy has been unable to even show it works. Whatever exotic-quantum-water-memory mechanisms you want to dream up to explain how it could work are irrelevant, since up until now, it hasn't actually been shown that there's anything that needs to be explained at all.

Whatever you personally may have experienced that causes you to resist making a judgement either way, is merely a testament to the power of placebo, and the mind's fallibility in judging matters completely objectively without proper precautions (like blinded testing).

Don't feel stupid for being fooled though. Put your ego aside and look at the matter and the evidence presented as objectively as you can.
1. There is no healing effect taking place as a result of homeopathy.
2. There is no known mechanism by which it could work either.
Common sense compels you to realize that this means there is nothing there at all.
 
... I had not – and have not - made up my mind because I happen to think there may be something we do not understand about homeopathy. NOT CONVINCED IT WORKS. NOT CERTAIN IT DOESN’T...

"We" do not understand? Or is it you who does not understand?

There's a guy here in Melbourne, Ian Gawler, who recovered from cancer some years ago, although he had to have a leg amputated as a result of the disease.

http://www.gawler.org/html/s01_home/home.asp?dsb=10

Since then, he has devoted his life to helping cancer sufferers and other terminally ill people.

He does this by helping people in a variety of ways, principal among them being meditation.

Some of those largely given up on my the medical profession have seen their cancers go into lengthy remission; some not. I think some have fully recovered, and are leading regular lives.

Reading through the site, it becomes apparent that the "placebo effect," when combined with other therapies, can sometimes work where other approaches have a much more difficult time of it. This is nothing new.

Rather than spend millions on testing homeopathy again and again, the time and money might be better spent on if, when, and how the "placebo effect" might be used to good purposes, and if, ultimately, they can produce long-lasting health benefits.

There is much to be learned in this area, but throwing money at claptrap like homeopathy isn't the way. Remember, people claim to have been cured by visions of religious icons, yet we don't waste millions on testing the icon, do we?

M.
 
http://www.gawler.org/html/s01_home/home.asp?dsb=10

Reading through the site, it becomes apparent that the "placebo effect," when combined with other therapies, can sometimes work where other approaches have a much more difficult time of it. This is nothing new.

Rather than spend millions on testing homeopathy again and again, the time and money might be better spent on if, when, and how the "placebo effect" might be used to good purposes, and if, ultimately, they can produce long-lasting health benefits.

Umm....

It kinda undermines your message when you support your suggestion with the same kind of (non)evidence that you just dismissed when it was used to support homeopathy.

Linda
 
Umm....

It kinda undermines your message when you support your suggestion with the same kind of (non)evidence that you just dismissed when it was used to support homeopathy.

Well, he's using it to support the idea, not using the site as proof that the placebo effect is good medicine.
 
An analysis of the placebo effect in 2001 did not show a difference in objective measurements. I do not know of anything beyond that.

Linda

I changed the link to the abstract. I got the full text yesterday without signing in, but I can't get it today.

Linda
 
Linda,

Where do talking therapies such as CBT fall on the treatment to placebo scale? Doesn't this depend on what you class as placebo, or have I misunderstood?
 
Linda,

Where do talking therapies such as CBT fall on the treatment to placebo scale? Doesn't this depend on what you class as placebo, or have I misunderstood?

"Placebo" is a hodge-podge category that represents regression, changes in subjective measures, and some psychological effects.

So I would say something like, "occasionally placebo effects may be due to the same processes that are part of CBT".

Linda
 
Ah yes, the "consumer rights" argument. Well, obviously I can't speak for anyone else, but my position is that people have a right to make informed decisions, and that therefore homoeopaths should not be able to advertise their services as if it worked, unless they can demonstrate that it does. In this respect it shouldn't be any different from any other type of medicine, or indeed any other type of product.

If people want to choose something that doesn't work, that is their right, I suppose, but if they're choosing it because they are assured that it works, then they're being swindled. This applies to any product or service. People have a right not to be defrauded.

I think one way might be to have homeopathic remedies conform to packaging rules that show the actual percentages of the "active" ingreadients. They should not use the confusing "12C"... for instance somthing like Nat Mur 12C should have on the ingredients list:
NaCl - 0.0000000000000000000001 % (or there abouts).
 
I think one way might be to have homeopathic remedies conform to packaging rules that show the actual percentages of the "active" ingreadients. They should not use the confusing "12C"... for instance somthing like Nat Mur 12C should have on the ingredients list:
NaCl - 0.0000000000000000000001 % (or there abouts).

I think that negative percentage would be way higher. Like, for a 13C dilution (one past avogadro), that would be -90% (i.e. 10 percent chance there's one molecule left). 30 C would be -99.99999...% i.e. almost certainly no molecules present.



Hey, fls, what happened to your avatar?
 
I think that negative percentage would be way higher. Like, for a 13C dilution (one past avogadro), that would be -90% (i.e. 10 percent chance there's one molecule left). 30 C would be -99.99999...% i.e. almost certainly no molecules present.

The chance would have to be positive (1-the chance). Then you'd have to multiply that chance by the chance that the molecule(s), which happen to remain despite the dilution, could act by the principles of sympathetic magic (the reason why they were introduced in the first place).

The result will be small - but non-zero. So we'll have people saying that homoeopathy is not impossible, therefore it's worth giving it the benefit of the doubt.

No-one's proved it false: the classic Argument to Ignorance.

The answer to such dilemmas such as 'does homoeopathy work?' (even though it's a naive question) often can be resolved by looking at logical fallacies.

The question should be, "why should we accept homoeopathy?" rather than, "why should we reject homoeopathy?"

Is there any reason, after 200 years of failure, that we should accept homoeopathy as a viable system of medicine?
 
”So, what else exactly needs to be done? Wouldn't you agree that money going to homeopaths could be better diverted to science that has shown some sort of promise?”

Yes. I am not arguing for homeopathy at all. However, when you say “money going to homeopaths”, is that going to be diverted into research into more promising avenues anyway?

”Well, obviously I can't speak for anyone else, but my position is that people have a right to make informed decisions, and that therefore homoeopaths should not be able to advertise their services as if it worked, unless they can demonstrate that it does. In this respect it shouldn't be any different from any other type of medicine, or indeed any other type of product.”

No problem with that. From what I’ve read, the major player of a homeopathic franchisee in this country provokes nothing but complaints -- and nothing is done about this apart from sympathetic noises on a forum.

fls, (not sure of protocol – so will not use your name) I did not intend to refer to this thread alone. The main point I wanted to raise was that abrasiveness beyond a point serves to alienate – if mine has alienated you that only proves my point. What would be your standard for “participating”? I read what everyone says. Now, with limited time, I take what I can respond to without too much repetition, and post back.
What is your definition of ‘poo’?
“All you were looking for was just enough abrasiveness to allow the lies you were about to spread to stick.”
And this from you, who asks for evidence everywhere? Please do tell me how you divined this alleged intention on my part.
“We say "whether or not something may be true does not depend upon the manner of the presentation. (Nice people may be lying or deluded. Abrasive people may be presenting objective evidence.)" You say, "you seem to think you can browbeat me into belief."”
Of course nice people may be lying or deluded – the best con-people are charming and ‘sincere’ as can be. And of course nasty people may be perfectly reliable. The fact remains that if you’re looking to reason with those who have few facts or those who are undecided, your arguments are lost in the two-fold issues of feeling somewhat pro-underdog and because some of you tend to get carried away to fairly unpleasant heights as though driven by your own wit and wisdom (or desire to exhibit it?). If you don’t care what people like me think, then that means you are only writing for the people who already agree with you or whom you can convince.
Yes, allowing for skewed views, it does appear that you (collective ‘you’) want to browbeat those who disagree. You may not intend to, but that’s how it seems to be.
“We say "considering that we are fooled by ourselves and others into believing things that turn out not to be true, homeopathy should be evaluated by the same standard. So far the evidence (of which there is more than enough and has been covered in detail already) shows that when you take away the opportunity to be fooled by yourself or by others, homeopathy does not demonstrate any effect." You say, "I don't care and quit calling me a moron for ignoring the evidence."… You say, "I am going to make an exception for homeopathy and require extraordinary standards to say it's not true. I am not going to justify my use of extraordinary standards in this case, though. I am only going to insult you for not going along."”
I am NOT asking for anything (lowering of standards or acceptance) for homeopathy. What I think is besides the issue and I’m actually ‘defending’ it more than I believe it should be defended.
Did I object to being called a moron? Since there’s no evidence against it, I can hardly do that. :)
Well, if that’s insulting you, what do you call other things that’re said here? Or is it that a set of standards are applicable to regular posters who are in agreement with you, and another for lurkers who wonder why they ever un-lurked?
“We say, "we should not make it easy for people to be unknowingly defrauded." You say, "people should be able to choose to be unknowingly defrauded."”
No, I posited that maybe people should have the right to choose to be ‘defrauded’ – but certainly should be given the facts. And I add that the facts indicate that homeopathy does not have any reason to work.
We say, "you are resonding to a mischaracterization of 'what skeptics say' instead of actually paying attention and responding to what is really said here." You say, "why do you hate America?"
Explain, please?
Your motivation? Not malice or stupidity, just carelessness and the selection of an easy out.
More divination? Miss Trelawney would be so proud of you.
Did I exaggerate and mischaracterize? Yup. Can I defend everything I said anyway? You betcha.”
What if you can defend what you say and I can defend what I say – each in our own view at least? You have alleged more than once that I came here with an agenda or preconceived views that I will not shake no matter what. Not a preconceived view on your part? I certainly came with ‘preconceived’ views from what I read, but I don’t think there are monsters here nor am I provoking arguments to parade as proof of my beliefs.
This very lengthy response is especially to tell you I am PARTICIPATING.
And BTW, late in the day – forgot to say this earlier - I agree with you when you said to Billy Joe that its kind of insulting to talk down to people or soften your arguments because they might not be as informed or smart as you.
 
The chance would have to be positive (1-the chance). Then you'd have to multiply that chance by the chance that the molecule(s), which happen to remain despite the dilution, could act by the principles of sympathetic magic (the reason why they were introduced in the first place).

The result will be small - but non-zero. So we'll have people saying that homoeopathy is not impossible, therefore it's worth giving it the benefit of the doubt.

Except, I wasn't talking about odds, I was talking about ratios.

In a 1C dilution, your remedy content will be 1%. In a 12C solution, your remedy content will be almost 0.
At 13C, the odds of having even one molecule present are 1/100 (not 1/10 as I said in my previous post, which would be an X dilution). In other words, the content of solution cannot be less than one atom, which at 12C is already 0.00...001% (21 zeroes followed by a 1). That's the lowest possible content the substance can have. After that we're talking odds that there's still one atom left. What are those odds at 13C? A hundred to one, or 1% chance that the content is 0.0...01% (21 zeroes) That doesn't make the content 0.0...(23 zeroes)...1, it makes the content 0 in 99 out of 100 cases.
Hence the -99% content.

It was just a joke anyway.
 
”So, what else exactly needs to be done? Wouldn't you agree that money going to homeopaths could be better diverted to science that has shown some sort of promise?”

Yes. I am not arguing for homeopathy at all. However, when you say “money going to homeopaths”, is that going to be diverted into research into more promising avenues anyway?

Money going to homeopaths = Money NOT going to other research

Sure the other research may ALSO turn out to be a dead-end. If that were the case, then that research should also be abandoned, and the money diverted once again.

But there is absolutely NO reason to keep feeding money into research that has already been shown to be a dead end.


As for the rest of your post - yes, you do bring up some valid points. But the simple fact is that on these forums, explanations are often broken down in the simplest manner possible and evidence is produced. Evaluate THIS, and not the attitudes, and then you will find the information you require. Then read the responses given to said arguments - a plethora of logical fallacies, ignoring responses, moving goalposts.

Short of actually being Mahatma Ghandi himself, few would have the patience to deal with this for long. I have on rather a few occasions myself witnessed even the most patient forum members crack and go off at particularly provoking individuals.

There's only so long one can bang one's head against a brick wall before the effects start to show...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom