Homeopathic Cough Medicine

The REAL problem, as I have discovered, is not the mathematics of the situation, or even the ludicrously bad chemistry that accompanies it. It's the appalling lack of basic understanding (i.e. knowledge) by the people who peddle this sort of thing.

Zep, I agree with you completely. The people who swear by this will always swear by this. My crunching out some numbers and presenting issues one way or another will not convince these people of anything. My digging up numbers and going back to old chem books is more because I was asked to do some research for my family, since I have more of a scientific background than anybody else in my family.

A bit of a background... My family's from a small island on the west coast of Canada full of hippies, elderly folk, etc. In summer, they have a farmer's market to sell crafts and local goods. A few people are now out there selling homeopathic remedies, and getting a fair bit of sales (on the local scale). My mom wanted to know if this worked, if she should get involved and help out, and even invest time and money making remedies with her friends. I 'm just trying to piece together a full and complete description of everything involved. As an investment, though, selling a bottle of water for $20, and people buy it? Legally? That's decent ROI.

Her biggest shock, and I've seen this a number of times talking to other people, is confusion in the terms. People confuse "homeopathic" with "holistic" or "herbal". I've been yelled at quite a number of times for trying to state that there's a difference between these terms.

Just one quick example: One homeopath was absolutely certain that a 12C dilution was 1:1024. A bit of intuitive thinking and it became clear - what he thought was the value 1,024 was actually written as 1024 but he thought it was simply a printing error. Alas, his stubborn pride refused to let him acknowledge the error, and he stuck to his guns and INSISTED we skeptic allopath-lovers were totally incorrect...and he looked even more stupid for doing so as a result.
*bangs my head on my desk*
My brain hurts...
 
That last part is the crux of the matter.

Even presuming that a homeopathic manufacturer makes and sells 18 tons of remedy, say, in 50ml bottles, that still means 360'000 bottles (if my math is correct). In other words, the odds that you have a bottle with one molecule of mother tincture left in it is 1 in 32'727 (or 0.003%).

And generally, this 30X (or, if diluted 100 to 1 at every stage 15C) is only half the length they go to. Usually, remedies are 30C or beyond at 200C, and then there's LM potencies too (dilutions of 50'000 to 1 if I have my Roman numerals correctly) that also go up to 200.

Just for fun, we quickly calculated about a year ago, that dropping a 1 kg bag of sugar into the Pacific ocean would still result in an overall higher sugar content in all the worlds oceans than the amount of mother tincture left in a 10C homeopathic remedy (IIRC). In other words, if you scooped out a 10 liter bucket of sea water several years afterwards, you might have minute but perhaps actually detectable levels of sugar molecules as a result.

But homeopaths actually can't tell what a remedy used to be once they've diluted it beyond 15C (30X).

LM potencies????? I'll have to keep my eyes out for that one.

That's part of what I was trying to do was to spit out some real world numbers to make some sense. I've seen the "grain of salt in a solar system sized sphere" argument, but most people can't fathom just how much volume that sphere is. One number that I wanted to figure out was if we used the entire amount of fresh water on Earth, just what is the maximum dilution factor we can have while still having one molecule of "thingie" remaining. I'll have to remember your bag of sugar calculation -- that's a good one. :D

The reason why I was working on the 18 tons starting point question had to do with leaving out any gaps. One side states that it is impossible to have a 24X or more dilution without going into fractions of molecules remaining. The other side can simply state, "Aha! But you can! Just increase the starting volume! It isn't impossible, therefore your entire argument is crap!" To close that back door, I just wanted to make sure to figure out just how large that starting volume has to be.
 
Her biggest shock, and I've seen this a number of times talking to other people, is confusion in the terms. People confuse "homeopathic" with "holistic" or "herbal". I've been yelled at quite a number of times for trying to state that there's a difference between these terms.

*bangs my head on my desk*
My brain hurts...

Yelled at? Why would that warrant yelling?

Maybe I don't want to know.

Linda
 
Yelled at? Why would that warrant yelling?

Maybe I don't want to know.

Linda

It usually starts with me being irritated that a pharmacy sells homeopathic remedies (and not a Wal-Mart drug section, Wal-Mart sells anything and everything), that turns into the other person talking about being one with the Earth and using natural sources, and finally into a whole Monty Python skit of

"Oh no it isn't!"
"Oh yes it is!"

Plus, I think at that time, I may have accidently used the word "quackery" about 8 times, so I'm a little to blame as well. :P
 
The reason why I was working on the 18 tons starting point question had to do with leaving out any gaps. One side states that it is impossible to have a 24X or more dilution without going into fractions of molecules remaining. The other side can simply state, "Aha! But you can! Just increase the starting volume! It isn't impossible, therefore your entire argument is crap!" To close that back door, I just wanted to make sure to figure out just how large that starting volume has to be.

Well, I can't remember exactly how we calculated the volume of water on the planet. But if you'd like a link to that thread, I could search for it ...

OK, post #344 on this page, and worked out further in posts #346 and #350. With a link in post #346 referring to this website for a starting point to the planet's water content.

I suggest you read at least all the posts by Rolfe and Badly Shaved Monkey on that page, because they contain a wealth of information.
 
Well, I can't remember exactly how we calculated the volume of water on the planet. But if you'd like a link to that thread, I could search for it ...

OK, post #344 on this page, and worked out further in posts #346 and #350. With a link in post #346 referring to this website for a starting point to the planet's water content.

I suggest you read at least all the posts by Rolfe and Badly Shaved Monkey on that page, because they contain a wealth of information.

(Note: edited to remove links)

I was being lazy and just checking the wiki for water tables. Under the page titled Water_distribution_on_earth, fresh water is 0.35% of ocean water. Under the title of Hydrosphere, it states that there is about 1.35 × 1018 tonnes of water in the oceans. However, that same second page also says 3% of the water is fresh water. (I apologize for the badly defined links, I'm still too new to post proper links and such.) I'll check out the forums you suggested, thanks!
 
So after more thinking, I thought it best to summarize some of the main points. Do these sound about right to everybody?

1) Homeopaths use dilutions to pass on "information" from the MT to pure water to get to their final solution

2) Passing on the "information" can occur in one of two ways:
i) Directly, via MT to pure H2O interaction, and creating a memory on the water molecule
ii) Indirectly, via "reactive" H2O to pure H2O interaction
​
3) At some point in the dilution process, approximately 23X/12C, the probability that even one molecule of MT remains in the solution is rare. Further dilutions make this probability even more remote. Therefore, most of the transmission at this and future stages is due to 2.ii) memory to memory

4) The more diluted the solution, the more powerful the medicine

5) In almost every known aspect in the world, making a copy of a copy of a copy leads to imperfections from the original. Think of making photocopies, recording videos, the "broken telephone" game, cast impressions, etc. Therefore, in homeopathy, this copy to copy mechanism must be extremely powerful and extremely difficult to destroy.

6) While homeopaths have an explination as to how the MT passes "information" to the water molecule, there is insufficient information on how the memory effect is removed. Since the supposedly pure water may and more likely be contaminated, all mixtures are unreliable.

I'm trying here to solidify both sides of the argument. If the MT is the key to all homeopathic remedies, then the final solution is no different than normal water since no MT remains. However, if the memory effect is the key, there is still no difference since normal water must already be a super charged remedy.
 
So after more thinking, I thought it best to summarize some of the main points. Do these sound about right to everybody?

1) Homeopaths use dilutions to pass on "information" from the MT to pure water to get to their final solution

2) Passing on the "information" can occur in one of two ways:
i) Directly, via MT to pure H2O interaction, and creating a memory on the water molecule
ii) Indirectly, via "reactive" H2O to pure H2O interaction
​
3) At some point in the dilution process, approximately 23X/12C, the probability that even one molecule of MT remains in the solution is rare. Further dilutions make this probability even more remote. Therefore, most of the transmission at this and future stages is due to 2.ii) memory to memory

4) The more diluted the solution, the more powerful the medicine

5) In almost every known aspect in the world, making a copy of a copy of a copy leads to imperfections from the original. Think of making photocopies, recording videos, the "broken telephone" game, cast impressions, etc. Therefore, in homeopathy, this copy to copy mechanism must be extremely powerful and extremely difficult to destroy.

6) While homeopaths have an explination as to how the MT passes "information" to the water molecule, there is insufficient information on how the memory effect is removed. Since the supposedly pure water may and more likely be contaminated, all mixtures are unreliable.

I'm trying here to solidify both sides of the argument. If the MT is the key to all homeopathic remedies, then the final solution is no different than normal water since no MT remains. However, if the memory effect is the key, there is still no difference since normal water must already be a super charged remedy.

I think you have hit on the solution to the puzzle :)

Rodney remains visible by his absence.

M.
 
So after more thinking, I thought it best to summarize some of the main points. Do these sound about right to everybody?

I presume this is the information you would present to your family?

You have not made it clear that some of these steps are complete fabrications and some are well-established science. By putting them in a list like this, it gives the false impression that all of these steps have been established.

1) Homeopaths use dilutions to pass on "information" from the MT to pure water to get to their final solution

2) Passing on the "information" can occur in one of two ways:
i) Directly, via MT to pure H2O interaction, and creating a memory on the water molecule
ii) Indirectly, via "reactive" H2O to pure H2O interaction
​

It is not clear that it has never been demonstrated or explained how information could be passed by either of those methods, and the idea is not possible based on our current, detailed knowledge of chemistry and physics.

3) At some point in the dilution process, approximately 23X/12C, the probability that even one molecule of MT remains in the solution is rare. Further dilutions make this probability even more remote.

That represents the progress of scientific understanding since homeopathy was first proposed, and is based on our ability to know the number of molecules of a substance contained within 1 mole - well-established science.

Therefore, most of the transmission at this and future stages is due to 2.ii) memory to memory

4) The more diluted the solution, the more powerful the medicine

Again, not only have these ideas not been established, they make no sense based our detailed understanding of chemistry, physics, and physiology.

5) In almost every known aspect in the world, making a copy of a copy of a copy leads to imperfections from the original. Think of making photocopies, recording videos, the "broken telephone" game, cast impressions, etc. Therefore, in homeopathy, this copy to copy mechanism must be extremely powerful and extremely difficult to destroy.

Since any copying mechanism is unknown, we cannot guess as to what the characteristics of that copying mechanism would be, or even whether copying is necessary. And I can think of examples where information can always be transferred accurately - specifically information transferred through entanglement (and you know how homeopaths love quantum mechanics stuff). You shouldn't bother trying to discredit the idea of accurate copying, because the idea of copying has not been established in the first place.

6) While homeopaths have an explination as to how the MT passes "information" to the water molecule,

The "explanation" is not due to an established mechanism, though.

there is insufficient information on how the memory effect is removed. Since the supposedly pure water may and more likely be contaminated, all mixtures are unreliable.

Again, arguing against homeopathy in this manner makes it seem like their original premise is somehow valid. You don't need to argue that the water memory is contaminated, because there's no such thing as water memory in the first place.

I'm trying here to solidify both sides of the argument. If the MT is the key to all homeopathic remedies, then the final solution is no different than normal water since no MT remains. However, if the memory effect is the key, there is still no difference since normal water must already be a super charged remedy.

That's the problem with trying to make rational arguments against made-up stuff. You are limited to stuff that has the possibility of being true, whereas those who make-up the stuff can just make-up something new to get around your criticisms. If you play that game, you will always lose. And if you are trying to persuade your family that homeopathy is without value, it gives the impression that as long as homeopaths can respond to your criticism with something using science-words, they (your family) are justified in keeping an "open-mind".

I think it would be more valuable to simply differentiate between what is established knowledge, and what is pure conjecture - maybe a list similar to what you just wrote, but with a disclaimer similar to what I wrote after every step that has no scientific basis. And if you still want to include your arguments against accurate copying and water memory, preface them with "and even if these mechanisms were plausible...." Then you can focus on persuading your family that making stuff up is a poor way to arrive at the truth (i.e. that's what we used for the thousands and thousands of years before the scientific method was developed). Hopefully, they recognize the value of what we have learned over the last few hundred years.

As to whether or not a homeopath would consider your summary (excluding the criticism) accurate, I don't know.

Linda
 
Since any copying mechanism is unknown, we cannot guess as to what the characteristics of that copying mechanism would be, or even whether copying is necessary. And I can think of examples where information can always be transferred accurately - specifically information transferred through entanglement (and you know how homeopaths love quantum mechanics stuff). You shouldn't bother trying to discredit the idea of accurate copying, because the idea of copying has not been established in the first place.
Linda
[Bold added] Linda, catch up with the program :) - homeopaths love thermodynamics, too.
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/01/your_friday_dose_of_woo_woo_even_more_po.php#more
 
Baron Samedi,

Unless your family are interested in learning about science in general, give up. I've tried many, many times with my own family. They will like you less for your effort.

Just make sure they go to a trained doctor if you think there's something really wrong with them.

No doubt everyone else here will disagree:)
 
Baron Samedi,

Unless your family are interested in learning about science in general, give up. I've tried many, many times with my own family. They will like you less for your effort.

Just make sure they go to a trained doctor if you think there's something really wrong with them.

No doubt everyone else here will disagree:)

Oooooooh god yes. If someone in my family was really sick, and this is why I was being asked about homeopathy, I don't think I would be anywhere near this polite.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom