Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I had an exchange with "fls" (Linda) about this. She pointed out that the public can be more receptive if they don't feel insulted.

Before I get pegged as one of those people that goes around telling skeptics to "play nice"......

My comments during that exchange were directed at sincere discussions.

Once someone has demonstrated that they are not sincerely trying to understand your position, it doesn't matter what you do. We called it on homeopaths long ago. We called it on Rodney here, although Billy Joe tried to argue that we called it too early (or maybe he still thinks we shouldn't have called it at all). And now we're wondering when to call it on Mini.

There are other issues to take into consideration (like not alienating lurkers that are sincere). And there's nothing wrong with being polite just for the heck of it. :) It'd be boring if everyone did it, though.

I believe this is a challenge to us- to politely set matters straight; normally, I am not considered polite. On the other hand, we don't seem to be making much headway.

It may be more fruitful to direct arguments at whether Mini is sincere then at whether we should try to be polite.

I must say that "Deus," and many other posts just prior to this, are quite on target.

Yeah.

Linda
 
For Linda and Mini

When it comes down to it, most of what we now know is ridiculous. Many people accept ideas that are ridiculous. Skeptics, on the other hand, only accept ideas when it would be more ridiculous if they weren't valid.
Never thought of it that way. :)
Quantum Theory is ridiculous, but it would be more ridiculous if it was not true.
Homoeopathy is ridiculous, but it would be less ridiculous if it was not true

I use the term "open-minded" to refer to whether or not someone makes assumptions "a priori" - i.e. do they come to conclusions about the validity of a particular idea before assessing the information. However, I notice that you seem to be using it to refer to someone is uninformed and credulous. When I say I am open-minded about homeopathy, it means that I didn't come to the conclusion that it was ridiculous until after my review of the evidence led to that conclusion. But in order to think that it is possible homeopathy is not ridiculous (in light of all the available evidence), one must start with an assumption that homeopathy is a credible idea (which shifts the type of evidence that would be needed), and one must be ignorant of the available evidence and what it means. And this is a very common and very easy position to take. It requires expertise to adequately evaluate the evidence for yourself, and most people do not have that expertise. And most people allow their biases to determine what they want to find credible.
I don't know mini's level of intelligence and understanding, but I certainly had trouble with this one. :D
I think I've got it after a few re-reads...

The following types of people are NOT open-minded about homoeopathy:
Those who conclude that it is not valid before examining the evidence
Those who conclude that it is valid before examining the evidence.
The only way that you can accept Homoeopathy as being valid is if..
- You are unaware that the available evidence is against homoeopathy.
- You are unaware how ridiculous the idea of homoeopathy really is (see my post :) )
It is easy to just accept homoeopathy, because it requires expertise, which most people don't have, to evaluate the evidence for yourself.

It is hard work to overcome cognitive biases. It has been incredibly rewarding, as that forms the basis of the scientific method that has led to a vast increase in our understanding of the universe. But it does not come naturally to most.
In fact there are people who reject the scientific method. Some as a result of not understanding what it is, some because they don't understand why it is important, some because they like to go with their own feeling about what is right and think that this is equally valid and at least it makes them feel good.
So, mini, you have to make a decision about whether you go with the scientific method or with your feelings/desires/biases. The second option is the easy way out. The first is difficult and requires understanding of why it is important (to separate the wheat from the chaff)

"homeopathic cures" have not been demonstrated to be due to anything but already well-established known mechanisms independent of the idea of homeopathy.
In other words, trials that seem to show an effect from homoeopathy have not taken into account the placebo effect, so it could be the result of either homoeopathy or the placebo effect.
Trials that do take into account the placebo effect show no effect from homoeopathy.

I think you are mischaracterizing our mindset in order to make it appear that your position is less ridiculous.
Yes, it would be helpful if you pointed to specific examples.
Why should we be interested in your opinion? (serious question)
:(

You have identified the heart of the issue. For a long time, pseudoscience and non-science have been ignored because they were assumed to be mostly harmless. We may bemoan the waste of time, money and effort, but after all, it is individual patients and practitioners that are wasting their resources, right? I think that we are coming to the realization that that may be an erroneous assumption. The waste of resources is spreading to me because my money is being used to support it - through government support of CAM research or health insurance payments to CAM practitioners. Large numbers of people die (I'm thinking of treatment for AIDS in Africa) because officials in charge of public policy base their decisions on pseudoscience. Municipalities put their residents at risk of losing money and health by buying various unproven water treatments for their municipal water supply. The list goes on and on. And there may be a greater intellectual danger to allowing the growth of a population of people that are unwilling or unable to critically examine their beliefs - making them prone to manipulation and worse.
:)
 
Once someone has demonstrated that they are not sincerely trying to understand your position, it doesn't matter what you do. We called it on homeopaths long ago. We called it on Rodney here, although Billy Joe tried to argue that we called it too early (or maybe he still thinks we shouldn't have called it at all). And now we're wondering when to call it on Mini.
First of all, it does matter because of the lurkers and mini has identified as one of them.
Secondly, I try to give people the benefit of the doubt.
Thirdly, if you think a person is insincere, you can speak through them to the lurkers.
Fourthly, why are you wondering when to call it on mini?

There are other issues to take into consideration (like not alienating lurkers that are sincere).
Yes.

And there's nothing wrong with being polite just for the heck of it. :) It'd be boring if everyone did it, though.
Strangely I agree! :(
After all, what would this thread be without our friend Moochie?
(Ummm...don't answer that. :D )

It may be more fruitful to direct arguments at whether Mini is sincere then at whether we should try to be polite.
But we should at the very least be polite unless and until we determine whether or not mimi is sincere. I see no evidence yet that (s)he is not. Maybe I'm not good at smelling a rat (then again I had Moochie pegged right from the start :D )

Yeah. [about Deus' post]
Perhaps I should take another look....
 
For Linda and Deus

Why should these people [homoeopaths] be treated with anything other than complete and utter scorn?
Because most homoeopaths are earnest in their belief. They are not charlatans. They really do want to help people and they earnestly believe that they are.

If someone wishes to sell water (which is what a homeopathic 'medicine' is) as a cure for a medical condition should they not, at least, be challenged for proof of their assertion? And should they not have to provide it before being allowed to advertize? Is there anything at all unreasonable in that?
It is as essential for homoeopathy, as it is for conventional medicine, to provide evidence that their treatments work. Of course, homoeopaths think they have done so, therefore you have to show them that this is not so.

The BBC earlier this year ran an article about the increase in Malaria cases from people vacationing in Africa.

Why was there an increase? Because tourists had opted for the "homeopathic remedy" and found themselves with malaria.

When quacks advertize "cures" they don't have and persuade people to take them instead of real, tested, medicine, it may not matter very much when it's the common cold. But such behavior can endanger lives when it comes to disease like malaria.

I do not see what virtue there can possibly be in being polite about this.
Agreed, homoeopathy can be dangerous when it is used to treat a condition for which there is an evidenced-based effective treatment. This is why we speak out. The question is what is the best way to do this? The wrong way -denigration, impoliteness and rudeness - can be very counterproductive.

They have made their claims and they have refused to even test them.
This is incorrect. They have not refused to test them. And they have tested them. The problem is to show convincingly how the testing that has been done is flawed.

It seems the only way they wish to test is on people and damn the consequences.
A mischaracterisation of the attitude of the vast majority of homoeopaths, surely.

That may be something you consider worthy of politeness. I don't.
But you are speaking to wider audience whether you like it or not. You may win the battle but lose the war.

And I don't care if people like you get put off by it.
Then you will lose the argument with people like mini.
If you want to let off steam, why don't you just open the window and shout into the wind. At least that will do no damage.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
First of all, it does matter because of the lurkers and mini has identified as one of them.

Not all conversations are public. And when considering the unknown, unseen lurkers, I can't help but be reminded of Paul's sig...."If the existence of a thing is indistinguishable from its nonexistence, we say that thing does not exist. ---Yahzi"

Secondly, I try to give people the benefit of the doubt.

As do I.

Thirdly, if you think a person is insincere, you can speak through them to the lurkers.

Evidence?

Fourthly, why are you wondering when to call it on mini?

Why not?

But we should at the very least be polite unless and until we determine whether or not mimi is sincere. I see no evidence yet that (s)he is not.

I'm really, really, really not into telling people how they should behave.

Maybe I'm not good at smelling a rat (then again I had Moochie pegged right from the start :D )

I must have missed something.

Linda
 
originally Posted by fls
Why should we be interested in your opinion? (serious question)

I'm an incredibly fabulous person and even I don't presume that anyone should care about my opinion. Isn't it the obvious question if someone walks up to a group of strangers and tells them they're a bunch of gits?

Linda
 
...snippy snip...

There are other issues to take into consideration (like not alienating lurkers that are sincere). And there's nothing wrong with being polite just for the heck of it. :) It'd be boring if everyone did it, though.


It may be more fruitful to direct arguments at whether Mini is sincere then at whether we should try to be polite.



Yeah.

Linda

Actually, I think Mini may be sincere... but may not actually really know what homeopathy is. Many people still think herbal meds and homeopathy are equivalent. More than once on these forums has someone come into a homeopathy thread aghast that homeopathy was being talked about with so much derision... only to be doubly aghast when the serial dilutions were explained. Then they hopped on to the anti-homeopathy bandwagon.

Which is why my questions on the 12C dilution was posed to Mini (and answered by BillyJoe). I'm not quite sure he/she understands the chemistry behind it, especially the extreme dilutions.

Oh, and I cut and pasted the numbers from something I saw on the misc.health.alternative newsgroup on Usenet. It is a recipe for Nat Mur 30C... that takes 90 steps:
http://groups.google.com/group/misc.health.alternative/msg/40f463880303fa9e?hl=en&
 
Not all conversations are public. And when considering the unknown, unseen lurkers, I can't help but be reminded of Paul's sig...."If the existence of a thing is indistinguishable from its nonexistence, we say that thing does not exist. ---Yahzi".
These converstions are not public?
And why do you misquote Yahzi?

[BJ: if you think a person is insincere, you can speak through them to the lurkers]
Evidence?
At any one time there are usually twice as many guests on the forum as members. For example, at the present time, there are 201 guests and only 88 members. I suppose they might all avoid homoeopathy threads though.

[BJ: why are you wondering when to call it on mini?]
Why not?
Beacause it might be "if" ;)

I'm really, really, really not into telling people how they should behave.
Maybe I wouldn't have added in all those "really"s, but otherwise I agree.
But it was really only meant as a suggestion.

[BJ: then again I had Moochie pegged right from the start :biggrin:]
I must have missed something.
It's just a joke. But I think me and Moochie played this out on another thread, sorry.

I'm an incredibly fabulous person and even I don't presume that anyone should care about my opinion. Isn't it the obvious question if someone walks up to a group of strangers and tells them they're a bunch of gits?
Because mini didn't do that, in my opinion. My frown was because I thought you were doing great till those couple of comments. Again, you can handle it the way you want of course, but I can frown if I want if I disagree.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Actually, I think Mini may be sincere... but may not actually really know what homeopathy is. Many people still think herbal meds and homeopathy are equivalent. More than once on these forums has someone come into a homeopathy thread aghast that homeopathy was being talked about with so much derision... only to be doubly aghast when the serial dilutions were explained. Then they hopped on to the anti-homeopathy bandwagon.
Someone on the video referenced above (I think) quoted a survey which said that nearly 50% of people respond with "herbs" (or something like that) when they were asked if they know what homoeopathy is. However, I don't think mini is one of them. However (s)he may still not fully understand the implications of homoeopathy. On the other hand, there are some very intelligent, educated people who do understand and still support homoeopathy - like the first speaker on that video (sorry, I lost the reference). I find that difficult to understand.
 
Actually, I think Mini may be sincere... but may not actually really know what homeopathy is. Many people still think herbal meds and homeopathy are equivalent. More than once on these forums has someone come into a homeopathy thread aghast that homeopathy was being talked about with so much derision... only to be doubly aghast when the serial dilutions were explained. Then they hopped on to the anti-homeopathy bandwagon.

Which is why my questions on the 12C dilution was posed to Mini (and answered by BillyJoe). I'm not quite sure he/she understands the chemistry behind it, especially the extreme dilutions.

She/he claims to have read most/all of this thread, which should make accidental ignorance unlikely.

I was also questioning the sincerity of Mini's (mis)characterization of "outrage and abuse".

Oh, and I cut and pasted the numbers from something I saw on the misc.health.alternative newsgroup on Usenet. It is a recipe for Nat Mur 30C... that takes 90 steps:
http://groups.google.com/group/misc.health.alternative/msg/40f463880303fa9e?hl=en&

That was clever. :)

Linda
 
From fls:
I use the term "open-minded" to refer to whether or not someone makes assumptions "a priori" - i.e. do they come to conclusions about the validity of a particular idea before assessing the information. However, I notice that you seem to be using it to refer to someone is uninformed and credulous. When I say I am open-minded about homeopathy, it means that I didn't come to the conclusion that it was ridiculous until after my review of the evidence led to that conclusion. But in order to think that it is possible homeopathy is not ridiculous (in light of all the available evidence), one must start with an assumption that homeopathy is a credible idea (which shifts the type of evidence that would be needed), and one must be ignorant of the available evidence and what it means. And this is a very common and very easy position to take. It requires expertise to adequately evaluate the evidence for yourself, and most people do not have that expertise. And most people allow their biases to determine what they want to find credible.

It is hard work to overcome cognitive biases. It has been incredibly rewarding, as that forms the basis of the scientific method that has led to a vast increase in our understanding of the universe. But it does not come naturally to most.

Again, excellent exposition from fls. This should be posted on all sCAM sites everywhere. :)

M.
 
Last edited:
Oh, come on, Moochie, I had to read that three times to make sense interpret it.

...oh, I'm sorry, you're referring to the highlighted bit.

:D
 

Hi BJ, when discussing these issues with people face to face I am terribly polite (yes, you read right :) ). But, as we have had demonstrated to us again and again, people who have so much invested in their cherished beliefs are unlikely to be swayed by reason or rationality. That certainly is the case with my cousin-in-law. She's invested much energy into the study of homeopathy and sCAM in general, and cannot be bothered to look at anything that contradicts the views she has formed.

It's tragic, really.

M.
 
These converstions are not public?

I said "not all conversations are public". In logic-speak, that means there is at least one conversation that is not public. Which means that I did not exclude the possibility that "these converstions [sic] are...public". So there is no necessity to assume I said something ridiculous (only your desire).

And why do you misquote Yahzi?

Did I? I just cut and pasted Paul's sig rather than finding the original, but it really seemed to be the same as what I remember Yahzi saying. I don't want to misquote Yahzi. Do you have a link to the original handy?

At any one time there are usually twice as many guests on the forum as members. For example, at the present time, there are 201 guests and only 88 members. I suppose they might all avoid homoeopathy threads though.

That isn't evidence of lurkers, as I am a "guest" most of the time until I log in to respond to a post (if I do it, chances are that others do it). Also, it is not evidence that you have any idea what the characteristics of lurkers are, and what the most effective way to speak to them would be.

Beacause it might be "if" ;)

You live in an imaginary world. ;)

And for the record, of course I realize that there is always doubt, so what I really mean is "it has exceeded my probability threshold".

Because mini didn't do that, in my opinion.

Alright. Since you agree with Mini, and since she/he hasn't bothered to provide an indication of what she/he considers "outrage and abuse", please provide links to specific examples within this thread - preferably involving more than one poster.

My frown was because I thought you were doing great till those couple of comments. Again, you can handle it the way you want of course, but I can frown if I want if I disagree.

So it is inappropriate and impolite for me to ask for specific examples when someone comes here and makes vague claims? It's not impolite for someone to come here and call us names, but it's impolite for me to ask why she/he thinks we'd be interested in knowing about it?

Honestly, I'm clearly too poorly socialized to figure out your rules for polite conversation. Consider me a lost cause and I will chastize my parents for you.

Linda
 
originally Posted by fls
I'm an incredibly fabulous person...
First mistake I've seen you make.

I prefer to think of you as fabulously incredible.

Please do not make this mistake in future.
 
Before I get pegged as one of those people that goes around telling skeptics to "play nice"......

Linda
I was trying to tread a fine line between crediting the source, and putting words in your mouth. For the others, I should point out that I had complained about the neutrality in an article on quackery, and Linda observed that a too-negative article might be simply dismissed by the target audience. Sometime later, at another venue, someone claimed that Quackwatch is unreliable because it is relentlessly negative.
 
Because most homoeopaths are earnest in their belief. They are not charlatans. They really do want to help people and they earnestly believe that they are.

I do not care about "earnestness". I care about effectiveness. When my son was very ill I cared about the effectiveness of the medical work, not the earnestness of the doctors and nurses.

If someone, anyone, is earnest about getting into diagnosing, prescribing and advising on health then they should be prepared to put the work into studying the basics of it and be able to apply it.

Let me put it another way - would you allow someone to pilot a jetliner with your children on board merely because they were "earnest" about it?

It is as essential for homoeopathy, as it is for conventional medicine, to provide evidence that their treatments work. Of course, homoeopaths think they have done so, therefore you have to show them that this is not so.

No I do not. Up to this point Homeopathy has not done the research and obtained the proven results. Until they do they are quacks, pure and simple.

Agreed, homoeopathy can be dangerous when it is used to treat a condition for which there is an evidenced-based effective treatment. This is why we speak out. The question is what is the best way to do this? The wrong way -denigration, impoliteness and rudeness - can be very counterproductive.

Based on what? Being polite about it does not seem to have made much headway at all - in fact quite the opposite. Where is the evidence for "counter productive"?

This is incorrect. They have not refused to test them. And they have tested them. The problem is to show convincingly how the testing that has been done is flawed.

You have a point. However I do not believe they need to be shown the flaws in their "tests" - what needs to be done is to show the world at large how valid tests should be done so they can judge the "worth" themselves.

A mischaracterisation of the attitude of the vast majority of homoeopaths, surely.

Not really. There is a point where ignorance becomes wilful neglect.

But you are speaking to wider audience whether you like it or not. You may win the battle but lose the war.

total twaddle. You are attempting to gauge the reaction of people who, by definition, you have no idea who they are.

I am not writing for the "lurkers" or some wider and mythical audience - I am expressing my views in a forum for sceptics.

If, by expressing my views about the dangers of homeopathy and other quack nostrums I piss off one person enough so that they go "hold it, there must be something in this crap because this guys hates it so much" and they go off and try it? So what? That isn't losing a "war".

Then you will lose the argument with people like mini.

Nice prediction based on - what?

If you want to let off steam, why don't you just open the window and shout into the wind. At least that will do no damage.

regards,
BillyJoe

Damage? You arrogant poser. What damage? Do you seriously think there are legions of lurkers who come to this site and who are suddenly going to convert to Wiccan merely because someone says it's twaddle? What sort of assumption is that?

Hey, if you want to be polite about homeopathy or whatever - then go argue on their sites and be nice and polite.

See how far that wins the "war"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom