For Linda and Mini
When it comes down to it, most of what we now know is ridiculous. Many people accept ideas that are ridiculous. Skeptics, on the other hand, only accept ideas when it would be more ridiculous if they weren't valid.
Never thought of it that way.
Quantum Theory is ridiculous, but it would be
more ridiculous if it was not true.
Homoeopathy is ridiculous, but it would be
less ridiculous if it was not true
I use the term "open-minded" to refer to whether or not someone makes assumptions "a priori" - i.e. do they come to conclusions about the validity of a particular idea before assessing the information. However, I notice that you seem to be using it to refer to someone is uninformed and credulous. When I say I am open-minded about homeopathy, it means that I didn't come to the conclusion that it was ridiculous until after my review of the evidence led to that conclusion. But in order to think that it is possible homeopathy is not ridiculous (in light of all the available evidence), one must start with an assumption that homeopathy is a credible idea (which shifts the type of evidence that would be needed), and one must be ignorant of the available evidence and what it means. And this is a very common and very easy position to take. It requires expertise to adequately evaluate the evidence for yourself, and most people do not have that expertise. And most people allow their biases to determine what they want to find credible.
I don't know mini's level of intelligence and understanding, but I certainly had trouble with this one.
I think I've got it after a few re-reads...
The following types of people are NOT open-minded about homoeopathy:
Those who conclude that it is not valid
before examining the evidence
Those who conclude that it is valid
before examining the evidence.
The only way that you can accept Homoeopathy as being valid is if..
- You are unaware that the available evidence is against homoeopathy.
- You are unaware how ridiculous the idea of homoeopathy really is (see my post

)
It is easy to just accept homoeopathy, because it requires expertise, which most people don't have, to evaluate the evidence for yourself.
It is hard work to overcome cognitive biases. It has been incredibly rewarding, as that forms the basis of the scientific method that has led to a vast increase in our understanding of the universe. But it does not come naturally to most.
In fact there are people who reject the scientific method. Some as a result of not understanding what it is, some because they don't understand why it is important, some because they like to go with their own feeling about what is right and think that this is equally valid and at least it makes them feel good.
So, mini, you have to make a decision about whether you go with the scientific method or with your feelings/desires/biases. The second option is the easy way out. The first is difficult and requires understanding of why it is important (to separate the wheat from the chaff)
"homeopathic cures" have not been demonstrated to be due to anything but already well-established known mechanisms independent of the idea of homeopathy.
In other words, trials that seem to show an effect from homoeopathy have not taken into account the placebo effect, so it could be the result of either homoeopathy or the placebo effect.
Trials that do take into account the placebo effect show no effect from homoeopathy.
I think you are mischaracterizing our mindset in order to make it appear that your position is less ridiculous.
Yes, it would be helpful if you pointed to specific examples.
Why should we be interested in your opinion? (serious question)
You have identified the heart of the issue. For a long time, pseudoscience and non-science have been ignored because they were assumed to be mostly harmless. We may bemoan the waste of time, money and effort, but after all, it is individual patients and practitioners that are wasting their resources, right? I think that we are coming to the realization that that may be an erroneous assumption. The waste of resources is spreading to me because my money is being used to support it - through government support of CAM research or health insurance payments to CAM practitioners. Large numbers of people die (I'm thinking of treatment for AIDS in Africa) because officials in charge of public policy base their decisions on pseudoscience. Municipalities put their residents at risk of losing money and health by buying various unproven water treatments for their municipal water supply. The list goes on and on. And there may be a greater intellectual danger to allowing the growth of a population of people that are unwilling or unable to critically examine their beliefs - making them prone to manipulation and worse.
