Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I do not care about "earnestness". I care about effectiveness. When my son was very ill I cared about the effectiveness of the medical work, not the earnestness of the doctors and nurses.

If someone, anyone, is earnest about getting into diagnosing, prescribing and advising on health then they should be prepared to put the work into studying the basics of it and be able to apply it.

Let me put it another way - would you allow someone to pilot a jetliner with your children on board merely because they were "earnest" about it?
Let's review the course of the conversation. It can sometimes be hard to remember what a specific comment was referring to over the course of a thread:

Why should these people be treated with anything other than complete and utter scorn?
Because most homoeopaths are earnest in their belief. They are not charlatans. They really do want to help people and they earnestly believe that they are.


There is a great deal of difference between trusting in someone's skills in a potentially life-threatening situation and being willing to treat them with something a bit better than "compete and utter scorn".
 
There is a great deal of difference between trusting in someone's skills in a potentially life-threatening situation and being willing to treat them with something a bit better than "compete and utter scorn".
I rarely go the complete and utter scorn route, but I think you're mischaracterizing Deus' position.

If I had my kids on a plane and a man without pilot uniform, pilot training, or airline certification entered the cockpit, I would want to know about it and I would want to stop him. If that person said "Don't worry. I've been doing the flight-without-practice method for twenty years; it's the same method that was discovered by Mister Schlockman fifty years before the Wright Brothers and which has never been disproved. I can show you letters of many satisfied fliers," I would not only scorn him, I would threaten him with physical harm if he insisted on entering the cockpit.

If another passenger, in all earnestness, argued in favor of the non-pilot, I would scorn that passenger, too.
 
For those who might be missing the point of these analogies, let me state this bluntly.

It cannot be forgotten that homeopaths are really and truly killing people, and it could be prevented. This is not a trivial or academic debate. People, who have (apparently) never learned how to properly reason (or get at the truth of a matter) are selling water as treatment. Additionally, they are trying to spread the delusion that their water is an effective treatment.

Selling water in the stead of a required lifesaving medicine is morally equivalent to selling poison as food.

Scorn is nothing compared to what is deserved.
 
First mistake I've seen you make.

I prefer to think of you as fabulously incredible.

Please do not make this mistake in future.

Now that I think about it, I'd rather see myself as incredible than fabulous.

Never let it be said that I am too bullheaded to reconsider my position. ;)

Linda
 
Well, I guess that Rodney could claim the same thing... but he has noted on this thread that his ignorance (or whatever, it is in the first third of this thread) is "real".

Yup. And I cut him a lot of slack because of that comment (and because I found it clever).

Linda
 
I rarely go the complete and utter scorn route, but I think you're mischaracterizing Deus' position.

Hmmm. I go to the trouble pulling the relevant comments from the previous posts so that the relevant parts of the conversation are shown together and that's 'mischaracterizing' his position? I thought I was clarifying it, or at least what he had posted. Perhaps that isn't what he meant but if so, I don't think my misunderstanding is an unreasonable interpretation of what he wrote. However, I'm sure Dues will provide his own take on it and correct any misunderstanding I might have - no doubt in his typical gracious and polite manner.
If I had my kids on a plane and a man without pilot uniform, pilot training, or airline certification entered the cockpit, I would want to know about it and I would want to stop him. If that person said "Don't worry. I've been doing the flight-without-practice method for twenty years; it's the same method that was discovered by Mister Schlockman fifty years before the Wright Brothers and which has never been disproved. I can show you letters of many satisfied fliers," I would not only scorn him, I would threaten him with physical harm if he insisted on entering the cockpit.

If another passenger, in all earnestness, argued in favor of the non-pilot, I would scorn that passenger, too.

An interesting way to interpret the conversation. It's not an analogy I consider appropriate however.
 
Hmmm. I go to the trouble pulling the relevant comments from the previous posts so that the relevant parts of the conversation are shown together and that's 'mischaracterizing' his position? I thought I was clarifying it, or at least what he had posted. Perhaps that isn't what he meant but if so, I don't think my misunderstanding is an unreasonable interpretation of what he wrote.
I wasn't trying to imply that you had done so intentionally; I rather doubt you did. I was also not trying to imply that I am without-doubt correct.

I was referring to how you closed your post:

Beth said:
There is a great deal of difference between trusting in someone's skills in a potentially life-threatening situation and being willing to treat them with something a bit better than "compete and utter scorn".
Your analysis misses the central point Deus is making (in my own interpretation, anyway), namely that it is an ongoing life-threatening situation and that fact is consistently ignored by both the practicioners of homeopathy and the supporters of the practicioners of homeopathy. Given the two evils (life-threatening situation vs. scorn) and no demonstrated effect for dealing with such people non-scornfully, Deus opts for scorn.


Beth said:
However, I'm sure Dues will provide his own take on it and correct any misunderstanding I might have - no doubt in his typical gracious and polite manner.
We shall see.


An interesting way to interpret the conversation. It's not an analogy I consider appropriate however.[/quote]
 
Hi BJ, when discussing these issues with people face to face I am terribly polite (yes, you read right :) ). But, as we have had demonstrated to us again and again, people who have so much invested in their cherished beliefs are unlikely to be swayed by reason or rationality. That certainly is the case with my cousin-in-law. She's invested much energy into the study of homeopathy and sCAM in general, and cannot be bothered to look at anything that contradicts the views she has formed.

It's tragic, really.
Yes, a total waste of time and effort.
And I do see your soft interior shining through your gruff exterior. :)

(...oops, nearly used the wrong smilie. :D)
 
I said "not all conversations are public". In logic-speak, that means there is at least one conversation that is not public. Which means that I did not exclude the possibility that "these converstions [sic] are...public". So there is no necessity to assume I said something ridiculous (only your desire).
Which then means that your original "not all conversations are public" was irrelevant. I was clearly talking about conversations on this thread, which was why I asked you "These converstions are not public?"
And there is no necessity to assume that I was assuming your response was ridiculous. In fact, I was only asking a clarifying question, because your response didn't make sense to me. ;)

Did I? I just cut and pasted Paul's sig rather than finding the original, but it really seemed to be the same as what I remember Yahzi saying. I don't want to misquote Yahzi. Do you have a link to the original handy?
...."If the existence of a thing is indistinguishable from its nonexistence, we say that thing does not exist." is a philosophical argument. We're just talking about the existence of lurkers, not the existence of God, for heaven's sake. :)

That isn't evidence of lurkers, as I am a "guest" most of the time until I log in to respond to a post (if I do it, chances are that others do it). Also, it is not evidence that you have any idea what the characteristics of lurkers are, and what the most effective way to speak to them would be.
Does everyone do though? I don't. I'm automatically logged on. How often have you seen a first post by a new member who says they have been lurking for a while and decided to come on board? It happens very frequently. And sometimes, like mini, they come on board because they are disturbed by the tone of the postings.
Anyway, it sounds to me that you are saying that, in the broarder public sphere, you do not speak in this manner. Is that right? If so, why would that be, do you think?

You live in an imaginary world. ;)
You said "when", so you had already decided that mini is insincere (or that it exceeded your "probability threshold" as you later qualified your position). From two posts. I don't live in an imaginary world, but I do believe in assuming the best of people unless and until they clearly show themselves to be otherwise. I think mini was commenting generally rather than just specifically about this thread. I think "if" was the correct word to use in the circumstances.

Alright. Since you agree with Mini, and since she/he hasn't bothered to provide an indication of what she/he considers "outrage and abuse", please provide links to specific examples within this thread - preferably involving more than one poster.
Well, I'm obviously not going to wade through 22 pages and, as I said, I think mini was commenting more generally. This thread, I agree, has been more sedate than many others I've read, but there is a tendency to attack on mass. Half a dozen against a single person and to do a bit of point scoring rather than understand where that poster is coming from.

So it is inappropriate and impolite for me to ask for specific examples when someone comes here and makes vague claims? It's not impolite for someone to come here and call us names, but it's impolite for me to ask why she/he thinks we'd be interested in knowing about it?
Well, it's one against many. Cutting a little slack, rather than cutting their throats (okay, exaggeration) couldn't hurt.

Honestly, I'm clearly too poorly socialized to figure out your rules for polite conversation. Consider me a lost cause and I will chastize my parents for you.
It's not a matter of rules for polite conversation (your parents are to blame?), it's a matter of the best way to engage a lone poster delivering a negative impression about what they have read (rightly or wrongly).
 
I wasn't trying to imply that you had done so intentionally; I rather doubt you did. I was also not trying to imply that I am without-doubt correct.

Thanks for that clarification.

I was referring to how you closed your post:

Your analysis misses the central point Deus is making (in my own interpretation, anyway), namely that it is an ongoing life-threatening situation and that fact is consistently ignored by both the practicioners of homeopathy and the supporters of the practicioners of homeopathy. Given the two evils (life-threatening situation vs. scorn) and no demonstrated effect for dealing with such people non-scornfully, Deus opts for scorn.

You're right here. I did miss that point. Mainly because I don't feel it's true. I've read a number of homeopathy threads here. I understand it doesn't work. I don't believe it does. But I don't see it as a grave danger or "an ongoing life-threatening situation". Personally, I just don't find sugar pills and bottled water dangerous. Thus, I see no need to treat people with scorn if they hold a different opinion than I do about the subject.

They aren't trying to force me to take off in a plane with an untrained pilot. Heck, while I have occasionally had friends who recommended homeopathic treatments, no one has ever tried to talk me into using homeopathy instead of real medical treatments. So why are they such a threat that one should forego normal politeness and treat them with scorn and derision instead?
 
Homeopaths regularly urge people to avoid real medicine.

This makes them killers, literally.
 
Just because in your personal experience, no one has suggested using homeopathy instead of proper treatment, doesn't mean that some practitioners wouldn't love to try, given the right climate. Sure, they trot out the "please consult with your GP" line, because they feel they have to. Just as the breakfast cereal makers have to tell you, legally, that their cardboard flakes will only actually help you lose weight as part of a calorie controlled and balanced diet. If the bulk of opinion were swayed as to the efficacy of CAM and homeopathy in particular, and the legal environment became conducive, you can bet they would happily suggest that "allopathy" is the inferior set of treatments, and is run by big pharma etc etc.

I think those who pour scorn see a real threat to the trust people have in medically proven treatment, which they see as being eroded by the ongoing effort to validate CAM as equal to, if not better than, "allopathy". If an anti-homoepathy type feels their "subject" is a lost cause, then they will turn to the "village idiot in the stocks" approach. By which I mean ridicule designed to make an example of the obstinate ignoramous, so that fence-sitters might be swayed. Just like the anti-CTers, the anti-psychics, the anti-religiones, and others on this forum (as well as writers like Dawkins and Randi himself*) do as they argue, fight, rail and/or rant against their own pet hates. Many either prefer, or wish they had the patience to pursue, the softly-softly, catchy-monkey "group-hug" approach to persuading fence-sitters or lurkers, but I see no real harm in either method. As long as it has some small part to potentially play in stemming the slide toward credulity, superstition, irrationality and pseudo-science. And I think most of us here can agree that those things are to be avoided.

*Shameless appeal to authority!
 
Last edited:
I do not care about "earnestness". I care about effectiveness. When my son was very ill I cared about the effectiveness of the medical work, not the earnestness of the doctors and nurses.
"Effectiveness" and "earnestness" are not mutually exclusive, they are mutually reinforcing in this case.

If someone, anyone, is earnest about getting into diagnosing, prescribing and advising on health then they should be prepared to put the work into studying the basics of it and be able to apply it.
The typical homeopathy course is 3 or 4 years. Some homoeopaths earnestly do not believe they will benefit from doing a medical course. They earnestly believe that homoeopathy is the answer to treating illness. Others believe that homoeopathy is complimentary to medicine and work in with medicos (some of whom are very willing and eager to do so). The medico does his bit and the homoeopathy does his bit.

Let me put it another way - would you allow someone to pilot a jetliner with your children on board merely because they were "earnest" about it?
That is not my point. What I am saying is that it is unfair to heap complete and utter scorn on someone who earnestly believes he is helping people in their suffering.

No I do not. Up to this point Homeopathy has not done the research and obtained the proven results. Until they do they are quacks, pure and simple.
The have done the research and they have got the results which, they believe, prove homoeopathy is useful.

Based on what? Being polite about it does not seem to have made much headway at all - in fact quite the opposite. Where is the evidence for "counter productive"?
First of all, I don't think there has ever been a time when everyone was politely arguing against homoeopathy. Do you listen to anyone who abuses and scorns you? Do you think a person who attends a concerned, empathetic homoeopath is likely to be influence by you heaping scorn on him?
In other words, attack homoeopathy, not the homoeopath.

You have a point. However I do not believe they need to be shown the flaws in their "tests" - what needs to be done is to show the world at large how valid tests should be done so they can judge the "worth" themselves.
That as well. But unless you show up the methodological flaws in their tests, you will have your results and they will have theirs. For every negative result, homoeopaths will have a positive result to show their attending public

There is a point where ignorance becomes wilful neglect
Homoeopaths will reply that you are ignorant of the very real beneficial effects of homoeopathy which they demonstrate every day in helping their patients. They will say that it is only ignorance of homoeopathy that prevents it from being much more widely used by medical practitioners and the public alike. Isn't it time you educated yourself and stopped wilfully neglecting the benefits of homoeopathy in relieving suffering?

...total twaddle. You are attempting to gauge the reaction of people who, by definition, you have no idea who they are....I am not writing for the "lurkers" or some wider and mythical audience - I am expressing my views in a forum for sceptics....If, by expressing my views about the dangers of homeopathy and other quack nostrums I piss off one person enough so that they go "hold it, there must be something in this crap because this guys hates it so much" and they go off and try it? So what? That isn't losing a "war"...
Okay, I will concede your point...if you will concede that you have never, and will never speak this way about homoeopaths in the broader public sphere. ;)

[BJ:Then you will lose the argument with people like mini.] Nice prediction based on - what?
Have you seen mini around lately?

Damage? You arrogant poser. What damage? Do you seriously think there are legions of lurkers who come to this site and who are suddenly going to convert to Wiccan merely because someone says it's twaddle? What sort of assumption is that?
I'm saying that someone who has not decided about homoeopathy, but is thinking about it, is unlikely to be persuaded by someone (I wasn't meaning to personalise it, sorry) abusing and ridiculing homoeopaths, especially if they have attended one who has left them with a positive impression.
I'm saying that it is understandable to let your frustration give way to anger, but that it doesn't help to vent it publicly (and, if their are no lurkers here, and you don't do that publicly, fine).

Hey, if you want to be polite about homeopathy or whatever - then go argue on their sites and be nice and polite
I think you are saying that I will get a heap of abuse for my trouble? Have you been there yourself and had this experience perhaps? If you have, maybe you can see how unproductive it is.

See how far that wins the "war
There are people who believe in homoeopathy and believe in it absolutely. I gather people on homoeopathy boards are like this. We can't hope to influence them much. There are lots of people who are undecided. It's a question of how best to influence them, if that's what you are aimimg to do, rather than just let off a bit of steam ;) ).
Just to be clear, I am not immune from that temptation :(

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Originally Posted by fls
Once someone has demonstrated that they are not sincerely trying to understand your position, it doesn't matter what you do. We called it on homeopaths long ago. We called it on Rodney here, although Billy Joe tried to argue that we called it too early (or maybe he still thinks we shouldn't have called it at all). And now we're wondering when to call it on Mini.

Originally Posted by BillyJoe
First of all, it does matter because of the lurkers and mini has identified as one of them.

Originally Posted by fls
Not all conversations are public.

Which then means that your original "not all conversations are public" was irrelevant. I was clearly talking about conversations on this thread, which was why I asked you "These converstions are not public?"

I realize that you were talking about conversations on this thread. But when I made my comment, "it doesn't matter what you do", I was talking about a general strategy, which includes public and not public conversations.

And there is no necessity to assume that I was assuming your response was ridiculous. In fact, I was only asking a clarifying question, because your response didn't make sense to me. ;)

"Didn't make sense", "ridiculous"....same thing in this case. You weren't paying attention. No big deal, you just failed the test. :)

...."If the existence of a thing is indistinguishable from its nonexistence, we say that thing does not exist." is a philosophical argument. We're just talking about the existence of lurkers, not the existence of God, for heaven's sake. :)

Well, you're no fun!

Does everyone do though?

I doubt it. I presume some people take advantage of the "remember me" function.

I don't. I'm automatically logged on. How often have you seen a first post by a new member who says they have been lurking for a while and decided to come on board? It happens very frequently. And sometimes, like mini, they come on board because they are disturbed by the tone of the postings.

Honestly, I strongly suspect that people that choose to delurk to tell us that we're meanies are prejudiced to begin with (i.e. it doesn't serve as a measure of the strength of our meaniness). I may even do an actual study of this issue to prove my point. I'm not denying that some people are mean. But since this seems to be a characteristic that is orthogonal to skepticism, I fail to see why it enjoys such prominence.

Anyway, it sounds to me that you are saying that, in the broarder public sphere, you do not speak in this manner. Is that right? If so, why would that be, do you think?

I do not speak in what manner?

Even without your answer, I can tell you that I try to speak here as I would in the broader public sphere - i.e. I don't consider relative anonymity an excuse to behave differently (specifically, "nastier").

You said "when", so you had already decided that mini is insincere (or that it exceeded your "probability threshold" as you later qualified your position). From two posts. I don't live in an imaginary world, but I do believe in assuming the best of people unless and until they clearly show themselves to be otherwise. I think mini was commenting generally rather than just specifically about this thread. I think "if" was the correct word to use in the circumstances.

I know that's what you think. Since this is a subjective evaluation, it will strongly depend upon individual experience and personality.

Well, I'm obviously not going to wade through 22 pages and, as I said, I think mini was commenting more generally. This thread, I agree, has been more sedate than many others I've read, but there is a tendency to attack on mass. Half a dozen against a single person and to do a bit of point scoring rather than understand where that poster is coming from.

I don't consider that justification for the use of stereotyping.

Originally Posted by fls
So it is inappropriate and impolite for me to ask for specific examples when someone comes here and makes vague claims? It's not impolite for someone to come here and call us names, but it's impolite for me to ask why she/he thinks we'd be interested in knowing about it?

Well, it's one against many. Cutting a little slack, rather than cutting their throats (okay, exaggeration) couldn't hurt.

I think people should take responsibility for their own actions. If they choose to come here to insult, it is dishonest for them to run and hide behind their mother's skirt. You can ask us to cut them a little slack (and I think that in actuality we usually do, including this thread). But I think it is inappropriate to chastize people for sometimes giving back what has been dished out. We are only "many" because we happen to be members of a skeptic forum. At best, that only serves as a loose association. It is unfair and counterproductive to arbitrarily apply a negative stereotype to any and all members.

I only use "us" as recognition that skeptics are being treated as an "us" in this thread, not because I actually think it is a reasonable grouping.

It's not a matter of rules for polite conversation (your parents are to blame?), it's a matter of the best way to engage a lone poster delivering a negative impression about what they have read (rightly or wrongly).

You have yet to provide any evidence as to the "best way". And you are ignoring that sometimes (possibly including this time) "lone posters" are purposely avoiding engagement, which makes our methods irrelevant.

Linda
 
Regarding homoeopathy actually being of potential harm to patients, I assume all concerned have perused this thread, linked in (the apparently absent) Rolfe's sig?

http://www.vetpath.co.uk/jref/snoopy1.html

Doesn't this show the danger of allowing homoeopathy to gain widespread acceptance? And if so, the arguable validity of ridicule as a last-ditch tactic with the "lost causes"?
 
I realize that you were talking about conversations on this thread. But when I made my comment, "it doesn't matter what you do", I was talking about a general strategy, which includes public and not public conversations.
Fair enough then.

"Didn't make sense", "ridiculous"....same thing in this case.
But I said "Didn't make sense to me", so, in order to decide whether the problem was my lack of understanding or you talking nonsense, I asked "for a clarification".
Jesus, you have to be so careful what you write around here. :)

Honestly, I strongly suspect that people that choose to delurk to tell us that we're meanies are prejudiced to begin with...I may even do an actual study of this issue to prove my point.
You may be right. That means you have given up on people with biases? - just asking.

I do not speak in what manner?
Well, you were making a point of differentiating between private and public conversation. I was wondering whether you say things differently in the broarder public sphere (compared to the relatively more private sphere here)

I can tell you that I try to speak here as I would in the broader public sphere
Okay.

I think people should take responsibility for their own actions. If they choose to come here to insult, it is dishonest for them to run and hide behind their mother's skirt. You can ask us to cut them a little slack (and I think that in actuality we usually do, including this thread). But I think it is inappropriate to chastize people for sometimes giving back what has been dished out. We are only "many" because we happen to be members of a skeptic forum. At best, that only serves as a loose association. It is unfair and counterproductive to arbitrarily apply a negative stereotype to any and all members.
I recognise all that. But why does it have to be an eye for an eye (or even a cornea for an eye)? Mini obviously didn't have as much going for him/her as you, for example, but does it really hurt to make allowances for that.

You have yet to provide any evidence as to the "best way".
You want me to find a trial which shows which way is best?
If someone posts a negative impression of the posters on this thread, I can't see how providing further negativity could help.

And you are ignoring that sometimes (possibly including this time) "lone posters" are purposely avoiding engagement, which makes our methods irrelevant.
Well, yes, we haven't seen mini for a while, unfortunately. So, you are possibly (okay, probably) right. I would have liked to have heard more from him/her.
 
Regarding homoeopathy actually being of potential harm to patients, I assume all concerned have perused this thread, linked in (the apparently absent) Rolfe's sig?
Whatever happened to Rolfe?

Doesn't this show the danger of allowing homoeopathy to gain widespread acceptance?
Agreed.

And if so, the arguable validity of ridicule as a last-ditch tactic with the "lost causes"?
You would have to show that this was not counter-productive to the above.
 
Excuse me, people, does it not occur to you that one might not be spending one’s entire life logging on?
Right here, not running, not hiding behind skirts. Just behind computer.
Oops, didn’t know I was being nasty myself by telling you some of you often are – if I didn’t make that distinction, I apologize and correct myself.
What, am I supposed to be a homeopath in hiding, insidiously out to defend homeopathy? Are you maybe paranoid?
Please let me clarify my reason for ‘un-lurking’. While there’s no reason anyone should give a damn what I think, my purpose was to inform you that you are putting off people with the attitude you sometimes display. And that should someone not immediately succumb to your reasoning, it should not brand him/her as unworthy of your courtesy or patience. SOLELY my OPINION. Feel free to ignore it, as I believe I am free to state it.
I am in no way an anti-vaxxer nor am I supporting substituting homeopathy in any serious problem except in case of ‘last resort’. I just don’t see that IF people are duly informed about the unlikelihood of homeopathy working, and if they choose to try it nonetheless, where is the harm? If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree? Maybe because a lot of homeopaths spend TIME with their clients and let them unburden or whatever – there’s probably great value in letting someone talk about themselves. What about ‘last resort’ – someone has some disease that conventional medicine says cannot be cured. What if ayurveda or homeopathy offer some hope? Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?
Oh dear – okay, since I said I would, if you would like me to, I shall go over the whole bally 20-odd pages again and offer bits I think indicate eye-rolling and sighing. Will take me time, so please don’t think I’ve vanished into dark night.
And thank you, BillyJoe.
 
.... I just don’t see that IF people are duly informed about the unlikelihood of homeopathy working, and if they choose to try it nonetheless, where is the harm? If it ‘works’ because of a placebo effect, should that not be preferable to suffering – of whatever degree? ...

Not everyone is aware that homeopathy is unlikely to work. My niece is presently paying good money to one for pain management... she has never been told by the homeopath what it is, nor did she believe me when I told her (so I sent her a copy of the Organon, Hahnemann's book on homeopathy, with a printout of the Nat Mur recipe up to 6C (which fit on one page) that I found on Usenet slipped in the pages on the chapter on how to make the medicines!).

Also, the harm comes when homeopathy substitutes for real medicine. For instance, there have been several people coming down with malaria because they did not take the recommended precautions recommended by real medicine, but instead relied on the advice of a homeopath. An investigation was done in the UK by Sense About Science and the homeopaths apparently did not even advise people to avoid getting mosquito bites:
http://www.senseaboutscience.org.uk/index.php/site/project/75http://www.senseaboutscience.org.uk/index.php/site/project/71/
 
Mini,
Rude, abrasive people know that they're rude and abrasive. I think they even tend to take a bit of pride in it, as well.
And you, yourself are coming across a little hostile here, to be honest.

Regarding homeopathy:

Maybe because a lot of homeopaths spend TIME with their clients and let them unburden or whatever – there’s probably great value in letting someone talk about themselves. What about ‘last resort’ – someone has some disease that conventional medicine says cannot be cured. What if ayurveda or homeopathy offer some hope? Okay, EVEN if it’s false hope – and I’m sorry to tell you I’m not sure of that – will you deny that so you can uphold your stance against what you see as propagating falsehood?

What I don't get is...why not advocate that these practitioners become nutritionalists or something similar that's a little more promising?
Homeopathy is just a dead end.
It's not just that we find the theory of water having memory a little far fetched. It's that combined with the fact that when it's compared with a placebo it doesn't work.
It's the double whammy. That's why we are so insistent that it's silly.

But there are valid, more scientifically sound things these people could be doing that would at least hold some promise or potential of having a real effect, plus the placebo stuff on top of that.
I don't hate homeopaths, by the way. I just think they're deluded. And I don't think being overly gentle with the very real truth that homeopathy doesn't work, at all, period, ever helps anyone.

As for you, what would it take to convince you?
More placebo controlled trials demonstrating the same thing over and over again? How many more?
What more do you need?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom