I do not care about "earnestness". I care about effectiveness. When my son was very ill I cared about the effectiveness of the medical work, not the earnestness of the doctors and nurses.
"Effectiveness" and "earnestness" are not mutually exclusive, they are mutually reinforcing in
this case.
If someone, anyone, is earnest about getting into diagnosing, prescribing and advising on health then they should be prepared to put the work into studying the basics of it and be able to apply it.
The typical homeopathy course is 3 or 4 years. Some homoeopaths earnestly do not believe they will benefit from doing a medical course. They earnestly believe that homoeopathy is the answer to treating illness. Others believe that homoeopathy is complimentary to medicine and work in with medicos (some of whom are very willing and eager to do so). The medico does his bit and the homoeopathy does his bit.
Let me put it another way - would you allow someone to pilot a jetliner with your children on board merely because they were "earnest" about it?
That is not my point. What I am saying is that it is unfair to heap complete and utter scorn on someone who earnestly believes he is helping people in their suffering.
No I do not. Up to this point Homeopathy has not done the research and obtained the proven results. Until they do they are quacks, pure and simple.
The have done the research and they have got the results which, they believe, prove homoeopathy is useful.
Based on what? Being polite about it does not seem to have made much headway at all - in fact quite the opposite. Where is the evidence for "counter productive"?
First of all, I don't think there has ever been a time when everyone was
politely arguing against homoeopathy. Do you listen to anyone who abuses and scorns you? Do you think a person who attends a concerned, empathetic homoeopath is likely to be influence by you heaping scorn on him?
In other words, attack homoeopathy, not the homoeopath.
You have a point. However I do not believe they need to be shown the flaws in their "tests" - what needs to be done is to show the world at large how valid tests should be done so they can judge the "worth" themselves.
That as well. But unless you show up the methodological flaws in their tests, you will have your results and they will have theirs. For every negative result, homoeopaths will have a positive result to show their attending public
There is a point where ignorance becomes wilful neglect
Homoeopaths will reply that you are ignorant of the very real beneficial effects of homoeopathy which they demonstrate every day in helping their patients. They will say that it is only ignorance of homoeopathy that prevents it from being much more widely used by medical practitioners and the public alike. Isn't it time you educated yourself and stopped wilfully neglecting the benefits of homoeopathy in relieving suffering?
...total twaddle. You are attempting to gauge the reaction of people who, by definition, you have no idea who they are....I am not writing for the "lurkers" or some wider and mythical audience - I am expressing my views in a forum for sceptics....If, by expressing my views about the dangers of homeopathy and other quack nostrums I piss off one person enough so that they go "hold it, there must be something in this crap because this guys hates it so much" and they go off and try it? So what? That isn't losing a "war"...
Okay, I will concede your point...if you will concede that you have never, and will never speak this way about homoeopaths
in the broader public sphere.
[BJ:Then you will lose the argument with people like mini.] Nice prediction based on - what?
Have you seen mini around lately?
Damage? You arrogant poser. What damage? Do you seriously think there are legions of lurkers who come to this site and who are suddenly going to convert to Wiccan merely because someone says it's twaddle? What sort of assumption is that?
I'm saying that someone who has not decided about homoeopathy, but is thinking about it, is unlikely to be persuaded by
someone (I wasn't meaning to personalise it, sorry) abusing and ridiculing homoeopaths, especially if they have attended one who has left them with a positive impression.
I'm saying that it is understandable to let your frustration give way to anger, but that it doesn't help to vent it publicly (and, if their are no lurkers here, and you don't do that publicly, fine).
Hey, if you want to be polite about homeopathy or whatever - then go argue on their sites and be nice and polite
I think you are saying that I will get a heap of abuse for my trouble? Have you been there yourself and had this experience perhaps? If you have, maybe you can see how unproductive it is.
See how far that wins the "war
There are people who believe in homoeopathy and believe in it absolutely. I gather people on homoeopathy boards are like this. We can't hope to influence them much. There are lots of people who are undecided. It's a question of how best to influence them, if that's what you are aimimg to do, rather than just let off a bit of steam

).
Just to be clear, I am not immune from that temptation
regards,
BillyJoe