Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.
I do not know if homeopathy works. I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.
I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.
 
Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.
I do not know if homeopathy works. I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.
I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.

1) science admits it does not have all the answers.
2) not one person in this thread made the assertion that medical science has all the cures.
3) if you reread this thread, the only people providing any empirical evidence are those not actually believing in homeopathy.

who is "us"? You say you don't know if homeopathy works, yet you refer to yourself as part of a group ("us") cryptically.


ETA:


By the way, if you think this thread was hostile or condescending, try being a skeptic on a homeopathic forum. We are kid gloves compared to the insults thrown there.
 
Last edited:
Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.
I do not know if homeopathy works. I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.
I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.
Thanks for that post.
Some of what you say is true and it needs to be said.
But, thankfully, there are some exceptions.

We can sometimes put people off by our extreme negativity.
More's the pity.

However, the problem is sometimes on the other foot as well.

regards,
BJ
 
1) science admits it does not have all the answers.
But some defenders of science don't.

2) not one person in this thread made the assertion that medical science has all the cures.
I think there was an initial assumption by some that cough mixtures had more going for them than they actually had (and by some that they had less going for them than they actually do :o).
Fortunately we all the wiser now. :)

3) if you reread this thread, the only people providing any empirical evidence are those not actually believing in homeopathy.
But some are just along for the ride. :(

By the way, if you think this thread was hostile or condescending, try being a skeptic on a homeopathic forum. We are kid gloves compared to the insults thrown there.
If we think of a poster as an individual rather than a member of a group, we won't tend to blame them for the faults of the group that we presume they belong to.
 
But some defenders of science don't.

True, and I don't think those types help anything.

I think there was an initial assumption by some that cough mixtures had more going for them than they actually had (and by some that they had less going for them than they actually do :o).
Fortunately we all the wiser now. :)

Indeed. I learned a great deal about cough medicines in this thread.

But some are just along for the ride. :(

I hope they strapped in. It gets rough around here. Well to be fair, it gets rough on most internet forums. Nice thing about here is the effort put in by mods to not ban people for disagreeing or for heated exchanges wholesale without recourse.

If we think of a poster as an individual rather than a member of a group, we won't tend to blame them for the faults of the group that we presume they belong to.

Indeed. But the general observation that we're big meanies is easily applicable to just about any internet forum that hosts topics that can cause heated debate. I couldn't count how many times I've been told my cancer was my fault by a believer, or that if I was more open minded I would be cured using some unproven or quack remedy.
 
I think Mini is speaking as a heretofore lurker on this thread.

Which clarifies the confusion of mine some. It appeared at first glance that mini was taking on a group position as an alt-med believer. Either way, perhaps I should have not come straight from the politics section to here. Let the blood pressure drop and such...
 
Indeed. But the general observation that we're big meanies is easily applicable to just about any internet forum that hosts topics that can cause heated debate.
Yes, it cuts both ways.

I couldn't count how many times I've been told my cancer was my fault by a believer, or that if I was more open minded I would be cured using some unproven or quack remedy.
Multiple myeloma if I remember correctly? It must be difficult not to be tempted to try a "remedy", that happens to come your way.

I suppose most people would try it, not realising that there are thousands more "remedies" waiting to be tried. If they made a list all of them, which one would they pick first? How many would they be able to try before times runs out? Maybe making a list of "remedies" would help them realise that they need evidence of efficacy before they should consider trying any of them.

And there are charlatans who know that what they offer is false.
It's a sad world sometimes.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
I have never in my life heard or read anyone say that science has all the answers.
If it did there would be no point in being a scientist.
 
Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.

Can you provide specific examples of what you consider to be "outrage"? I thought this was generally a bland thread.

Nobody here has suggested that conventional medicines provide universal cures. Nobody here has suggested that Science knows everything. Nobody here has suggested that there isn't much to be discovered.

Those statements are common strawman arguments used by people initiating an argument for psuedoscience and non-science. I hope that's not your intent.

If you think there is eye-rolling and sighing, I would suggest that it is not over the suggestion that maybe <insert any idea that seems to defy established laws of nature> works. It is over the continued waste of time, money, and effort long after the evidence is over-whelmingly negative. Or it is about whether or not the nature of the pursuit qualifies as scientific.

If you look at the discussions on the JREF forum, other unconventional (crazy?) ideas can be considered seriously, and be unaccompanied by "eye-rolling and sighing". The difference is in what an objective weighing of the evidence tells you so far, and whether those that are pursuing the idea are doing so in a scientific manner.

I also think that experience very quickly teaches the skeptic that there are people that are unreachable by evidence-based arguments. And with practice, it becomes very easy to spot these people early in the game. Sometimes, one doesn't want to bother with all the intermediate steps and prefers to jump ahead.

I do not know if homeopathy works.

We have discovered that a consistent application of the scientific method has served us well in determining that which is likely to be true. And some of us prefer to use that method. I don't think you should be surprised when you encounter this on a forum for skeptics.

Generally, if the evidence does not provide any support for a particular idea, the provisional assumption is that it does not work.

I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.

Exactly! We know that wishful thinking and ignoring the evidence does not serve us well. We discover when and how conventional medicine fails, just as we discover when and how conventional medicine helps. So we can know whether or not we are doing something useful, and whether or not we are doing something harmful. Vioxx and Thalidomide are arguments for the use of rigorous science when it comes to drugs, not against. If anyone wants to claim that the rigorous application of science shows that conventional medicine can be questionable, then by the same standards, homeopathy has completely failed. All I am asking for is some consistency.

I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.

I dunno. I'm unconvinced. Evidence?

Linda
 
Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.
I do not know if homeopathy works. I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.
I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.

Oh calm down! We are smug in our knowledge because we can point to real, testable evidence, and homeopaths can't. So there.

M.
 
I do not know if homeopathy works. I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.

Nobody said science is infallible. And we are not the ones who dragged conventional medicine into this thread to give it a spanking (which it didn't deserve in light of the subject being discussed). We were only trying to make it clear that the shortcomings of conventional medicine have no bearing on homeopathy one way or the other. If they're even failings at all, which Rodney has definitely failed to provide any evidence for. Hence no need to spank conventional medicine for apparent failings of cough medicines. They haven't failed at all.

As for Thalidomide, I hope you're not saying what you think I'm saying, or we may have to drag in the anti-anti-vaxxer people to set you straight on the whole autism-myth. Not that you deserve to get torn a new one on your very first post, but if you post mistakes, you'll get them pointed out to you every single one at a time, until you can't swallow any more. And that goes for everyone here, including those who you may perceive as obnoxious, mindless defenders of modern medicine.
Rodney made numerous incorrect claims, and got them all pointed out to him numerous times. And when he trots out the same discredited claim AGAIN, sure, we tend to lose our patience, roll our eyes and start sighing ...

You say you're not sure if homeopathy works, which to me suggests you haven't even read this thread from start to finish. And if you have and still think we're jumping to conclusions regarding its validity, then just know that we've had discussions like this countless times before on this message board and many others, and there's a lot more information out there that pretty much makes it clear that in order for homeopathy to work, you have to be willing to believe in some really crazy, illogical, silly ideas, all of which go against everything we know about the way the universe works.

As far as bets go, homeopathy being BS is one of the safest you can possibly make.
 
Last edited:
As for Thalidomide, I hope you're not saying what you think I'm saying, or we may have to drag in the anti-anti-vaxxer people to set you straight on the whole autism-myth.

Are you thinking of thimerosal?

Linda
 
I now deserve some public humiliation for getting the two mixed up :blush:

You may be safe. It looks like Mini was a drive-by.

Although......

You could try to pretend that you didn't get it mixed-up and defend your statements with increasing pomposity. That might be good for another 200 posts (I was hoping we'd break a thousand).

Linda
 
I think you're right.
Mini has been around for about 8 months and posted only 4 times.
The others were virtually one liners which were completely ignored.
Perhaps (s)he got stage fright?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom