Let me tell you how most of you come across: you seem as pig-headed as you claim the wicked, evil, useless homeopaths are in refusing to see The Truth.
There is a general eye-rolling and sighing, if not outright outrage at any suggestion that MAYBE homeopathy is not all balderdash, and that MAYBE conventional medicines do not provide universal cures either. That maybe you are making excuses to validate your beliefs because you think that they are backed by Science, quite forgetting that it just might be possible that you don't yet know everything there is to know -that there is still much to be discovered.
Can you provide specific examples of what you consider to be "outrage"? I thought this was generally a bland thread.
Nobody here has suggested that conventional medicines provide universal cures. Nobody here has suggested that Science knows everything. Nobody here has suggested that there isn't much to be discovered.
Those statements are common strawman arguments used by people initiating an argument for psuedoscience and non-science. I hope that's not your intent.
If you think there is eye-rolling and sighing, I would suggest that it is not over the suggestion that maybe <insert any idea that seems to defy established laws of nature> works. It is over the continued waste of time, money, and effort long after the evidence is over-whelmingly negative. Or it is about whether or not the nature of the pursuit qualifies as scientific.
If you look at the discussions on the JREF forum, other unconventional (crazy?) ideas can be considered seriously, and be unaccompanied by "eye-rolling and sighing". The difference is in what an objective weighing of the evidence tells you so far, and whether those that are pursuing the idea are doing so in a scientific manner.
I also think that experience very quickly teaches the skeptic that there are people that are unreachable by evidence-based arguments. And with practice, it becomes very easy to spot these people early in the game. Sometimes, one doesn't want to bother with all the intermediate steps and prefers to jump ahead.
I do not know if homeopathy works.
We have discovered that a consistent application of the scientific method has served us well in determining that which is likely to be true. And some of us prefer to use that method. I don't think you should be surprised when you encounter this on a forum for skeptics.
Generally, if the evidence does not provide any support for a particular idea, the provisional assumption is that it does not work.
I know that conventional medicine often fails. If the standard is "they have to work and be safe", then obviously the Thalidomides and Vioxxs fail the an important part of the test - after doing the damage they were set free to do.
Exactly! We know that wishful thinking and ignoring the evidence
does not serve us well. We discover when and how conventional medicine fails, just as we discover when and how conventional medicine helps. So we can know whether or not we are doing something useful, and whether or not we are doing something harmful. Vioxx and Thalidomide are arguments
for the use of rigorous science when it comes to drugs, not
against. If anyone wants to claim that the rigorous application of science shows that conventional medicine can be questionable, then by the same standards, homeopathy has completely failed. All I am asking for is some consistency.
I know this will invite equal outrage and abuse - of that rather entertaining variety you admittedly smart people provide. Nonetheless, I thought it might not be a bad idea to state how you appear to some of us.
I dunno. I'm unconvinced. Evidence?
Linda