Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Although......

You could try to pretend that you didn't get it mixed-up and defend your statements with increasing pomposity. That might be good for another 200 posts (I was hoping we'd break a thousand).
Nononono! It'll just give the anti-vaxxers more ideas (that's assuming that anti-vaxxers somewhere are not already claiming that thalidomide and thimerosal are the same thing). Might have been kind of fun though...

We could always argue about whether it's "thimerosal" or "thiomersal". :)
 
I'll let the thimoresal go, since I don't know what the heck it is. Lucky you.
If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible.
I have been doing a fair bit of reading – nowhere have I read on a homeopathic forum (admittedly, I skimmed) the kind of venom I have come across here (I’m sorry if I can’t provide the exact ref, but I assure you, there was one post which wished the bally homeopaths would get cancer or some such… it’s just that that sort of contempt-bordering-on hatred is VERY off-putting). Of course homeopaths are hardly going to welcome you lot with open arms if you make rude noises – because NO MATTER what you are convinced of, they are equally convinced of their whatchacallit – system?
When I say “us” I meant a few people with whom I discuss randi-topics. I came here because friends of mine told me of the great variety of discussions – and I come by now and then, just to read. I really would like to keep an open mind on the homeopathy issue, which I’m sure makes most of you want to kill me - or yourselves. J
“We can sometimes put people off by our extreme negativity. … However, the problem is sometimes on the other foot as well. ”
YES.

“Indeed. But the general observation that we're big meanies is easily applicable to just about any internet forum that hosts topics that can cause heated debate.”

Nah, not ‘big meanies”, awwww! Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something. And somehow the argument that this manner of bullheadedness occurs anywhere else doesn’t help.

“It appeared at first glance that mini was taking on a group position as an alt-med believer.”
Actually, I believe in minimum intervention. I have had - and witnessed - bad experiences with conventional medicine, but no doubt it has its uses. Of course, we take the not-bad experiences for granted.
“Can you provide specific examples of what you consider to be "outrage"? I thought this was generally a bland thread.”
Not this thread alone – there are loads of threads where a sort of mob mentality manifests. Besides, I think I said “if not outright outrage”. Please read some responses to Rodney – if you like, I’ll go over the thread and cull them for you. Of course it’s a subjective viewpoint. Maybe all viewpoints are, in the final analysis, subjective. (And that’s not as inane as it might sound.)

”If you think there is eye-rolling and sighing, I would suggest that it is not over the suggestion that maybe <insert any idea that seems to defy established laws of nature> works. It is over the continued waste of time, money, and effort long after the evidence is over-whelmingly negative. Or it is about whether or not the nature of the pursuit qualifies as scientific.”
You mean there are NO homeopathic cures? That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable? If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it? Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever. I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.

“Oh calm down! We are smug in our knowledge because we can point to real, testable evidence, and homeopaths can't. So there.”
Thought I was pretty calm. Maybe you know better.

” Nobody said science is infallible. And we are not the ones who dragged conventional medicine into this thread to give it a spanking (which it didn't deserve in light of the subject being discussed). We were only trying to make it clear that the shortcomings of conventional medicine have no bearing on homeopathy one way or the other. If they're even failings at all, which Rodney has definitely failed to provide any evidence for. Hence no need to spank conventional medicine for apparent failings of cough medicines. They haven't failed at all.”

I beg to differ. Again, subjective view. I think what you are failing to take into account is that sometimes it’s a choice between the devil and the deep blue. If you can ‘spank’ and spit at homeopathy, and if someone else spits at orthodox medicine, then to THAT individual homeopathy becomes a viable alternative if only because it’s seen as the lesser of two evils. Okay, chances are it won’t work – chances are it might and you’ll say it’s just not possible, so it must be placebo-effect, imagination, natural conclusion (which’s have occurred with or without intervention) or something –ANYTHING –else. At least, if its so useless, it won’t cause further problems because of incompetence or drug-related idiopathies.

” You say you're not sure if homeopathy works, which to me suggests you haven't even read this thread from start to finish.”

I have read most of this thread, but over several days. Its not this thread alone that prompted me to come out of my corner (I have to tell you – you seem like really intellegent people, by and large, and it’s kind of intimidating.) What you’re implying is IF I had read this thread or sundry discussions on homeopathy, I would be a brainless twit not to be convinced that’s it’s BS. But I’m not – so what then?
What I wanted to say, and shall therefore reiterate, is that a lot of you come across as simply rabid; you trash everything connected to homeopathy with a vengeance that makes one almost turn to them in sympathy. Stupid? Yes, maybe. Just thought someone should tell you.
 
Mini said:
I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.
All kinds of otherwise intelligent people believe all kinds of weird things. And when coincidences strike, it can really seem like it "means something".
The human body is amazingly good at healing itself almost all of the time, so this would really make homeopathy look very effective.
And a lot of people start "believing in" homeopathy before even learning how diluted it actually is or exactly how biologically implausible the theory really is.
But once a belief is started, it's almost impossible to change. And this is a universal fact of human nature which no one is exempt from, critical thinker or otherwise.
 
...If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible.
....

Simple question then: A 12C remedy has a ratio of 1 part of the active ingredient to 1000000000000000000000000 parts of the solvent. That is 10-24. Could this tiny concentration of ingredient have any effect on a human body?

Another question related to that: Is there anyway to create a solvent so pure that it would not have anything but the 1 part of active ingredient to 1024 parts of the solvent? (like no dissolved gas molecules like nitrogen, oxygen or carbon dioxide... which could enter the fluid just by shaking it)

And yet another question related to the above: Would this number have any significance to these simple questions?
 
If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible....I really would like to keep an open mind on the homeopathy issue....Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something
Science will never have all the answers.
Someone once said that science merely reduces the amount of stuff that we don't know. Which, is not a bad thing. Do you agree?
And no thing is ever totally 100% proven by science. Although sometimes it gets pretty close. For example, the Heliocentric Theory states that the Sun, not the Earth, is the centre of our planetary system. And, despite all the evidence to the contrary, there are some, otherwise very intelligent, people who still believe the Earth is the centre of the whole universe.

So, the only solution is that we have to go with the evidence.
People can make all sorts of claims but, unless they can back them up with evidence, there is no basis for believing that they are true. That's how science developed in the first place. Before there was science, there was only philosophy. The problem was that different people said different things that were contradictory and there didn't seem to be any way of telling who was right. Until someone hit upon the idea of testing things experimentally and finding what worked and what didn't. The most reliable method found was the double-blind, placebo-controlled, trial.

And it doesn't matter how many believe it. For instance, if Muslims are right, then Christians are wrong and vice versa. But both represent very large numbers of people.

You mean there are NO homeopathic cures? That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable? If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it.
As far as we can tell, there are no homoeopathic cures.
"Anecdotal evidence" is not really evidence. The term "anecdotal evidence" is really an oxymoron, if you like. A better term is simply "anecdotes". Scientists would say that anecdotes are merely testimonies, not evidence, and testimonies are notoriously unreliable. Anecdotes/testimonies might suggest a a possible theory (or, to be more scientifically accurate, hypothesis) and lead you on to find the evidence for it, but they are not evidence themselves. Does that make sense?

And, yes, the very basis of homoeopathy IS untenable.
What do you make of the The Law of Similarities ("like cures like") and The Law of Infinitesmals ("The more dilute, the more potent")? And what about the Water Memory theory? Do you have a view on those?

But, yes, if tomorrow, or in the future, there was evidence for homoeopathy, I would accept it. Remember, though, that the results of any one trial need to be replicated by another trial in order to ensure there were no errors in the original trial (remember Pons and Fleischmanm and their fusion experiment - nobody could replicate the experiment and the results were eventually, and rightly, discarded)

I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever. I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.
Think of the Muslims and the Christians. At least one of those groups of 100 million or more people have to be wrong. They can't both be right. I think it is fair to say that those people, as a group, ARE brainwashed, though only from the point of view of their religious belief. Same for homoeopaths. But that doesn't make them idiots or money grubbing creeps. There are medical practitioners who practice homoeopathy and you can't be an idiot and get into medical school.
Somewhere along the line people choose to believe things without evidence (and no basis in theory). Why? Who can guess. Maybe evidence is too time consuming and hard. Maybe they have a different world-view where scientific evidence is only one truth, and what they feel to be true is another. That's all it comes down to sometimes. It feels right to them and they go for it.
Science doesn't agree, so I guess you have to make a choice.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible.

The possibility rapidly vanishes after the 1000th time the ridiculous thing remains ridiculous.

Homeopathy is an idea that started with no merit and doesn't appear to apply to reality and hence retains no merit.

Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something.

And the assumption is that dumb people would stumble upon something by making up lots of mystical sounding stuff? No I don't think so. That hasn't worked for the last 8000 years of human civilization, I don't think it's going to start working now.

You mean there are NO homeopathic cures?

Things cannot exist in a homeopathic state - this puts cures or anything else in a bad position.

That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable?

Anecdotal evidence must always be dismissed because its quality is so very poor.

If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it?

To do otherwise would to be to deny reality. For it be scientifically validated would overturn much of our current understanding of physics - let alone medicine. I don't see any physicists remotely interested.

In short let us see this occur first.

Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever.

Thousands go to Lourdes. There's no justification for healing there either.

I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.

I find it hard to believe that there are billions of people who routinely practise the god beliefs of people living thousands of years ago and yet it happens.

What I wanted to say, and shall therefore reiterate, is that a lot of you come across as simply rabid; you trash everything connected to homeopathy with a vengeance that makes one almost turn to them in sympathy. Stupid? Yes, maybe. Just thought someone should tell you.

People feeling sympathetic for the charlatans being exposed? Most people feel angry when they know they're being tricked.
 
mini,

Simple question then: A 12C remedy has a ratio of 1 part of the active ingredient to 1000000000000000000000000 parts of the solvent. That is 10-24. Could this tiny concentration of ingredient have any effect on a human body?
This is The Law of Infinitesmals ("the more dilute, the more potent").
Homoeopaths say that the more dilute they make the mixture, the more powerful it is as a cure. Does this make sense to you? Can you think of a mechanism whereby this could work?

Another question related to that: Is there anyway to create a solvent so pure that it would not have anything but the 1 part of active ingredient to 1024 parts of the solvent? (like no dissolved gas molecules like nitrogen, oxygen or carbon dioxide... which could enter the fluid just by shaking it)
This is the theory of Water Memory.
Let's set aside a possible mechanism for "water memory"for the moment.
How do water molecules know which ingredient to remember? Any water you use will have something other than just water molecules in it, even if it's only molecules dissolved into it form the surrounding air. How do the water molecules distinguish between these molecules already in there and the molecules the homoeopath decides to put in it?
Also, it will have had other types of molecules in it at other times in the past. How do the water molecules know that they have to switch off the memory of these other molecules and switch on the memory of the molecules that the homoeopath puts in it? How do the water molecules know which of these molecules were the ones the homoeopath put in?
Doesn't this make you question the whole idea of homoeopathy?

And yet another question related to the above: Would this number have any significance to these simple questions?
This is Avagadro's number.
Beyond a certain dilution, there will no longer be any of the molecules of the "active ingredient" (the ingredient the homoeopath puts in it) in the mixture. This is the point at which Water Memory must come into play. But you have to come up with a mechanism for the memory of water. Remembering, though, that the water molecules have to be very selective about what they actually remember and have to somehow know what the homoeopath put in it as opposed to what has just drifted in. And it has to know to switch off old memories as soon as the homoeopath puts his ingredient into it.
Does this seem in any way reasonable to you?

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
You may be safe. It looks like Mini was a drive-by.

Although......

You could try to pretend that you didn't get it mixed-up and defend your statements with increasing pomposity. That might be good for another 200 posts (I was hoping we'd break a thousand).

Linda

I'm surprised it's reached 21 pages with not a recipe in sight. :)

(Who was that masked Mini?)

M.
 
Nononono! It'll just give the anti-vaxxers more ideas (that's assuming that anti-vaxxers somewhere are not already claiming that thalidomide and thimerosal are the same thing). Might have been kind of fun though...

We could always argue about whether it's "thimerosal" or "thiomersal". :)

To go completely away from the OT, any light you can shed on the anti-vaxxers and their screwball ideas is very much appreciated.

I have a cousin-in-law who has bought into both homeopathy and anti-vaccination big time, much to our disappointment. What's worse, she has refused to have her children inoculated against the common childhood illnesses.

Our counter arguments have been met with stony silence, and we've all but ceased communicating.

M.
 
If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible.

How many times in 200-odd years have people tried to validate homeopathy? How many times have they succeeded? (Rhetorical question, since it's been asked and answered innumerable times both here and elsewhere.)

I have been doing a fair bit of reading – nowhere have I read on a homeopathic forum (admittedly, I skimmed) the kind of venom I have come across here (I’m sorry if I can’t provide the exact ref, but I assure you, there was one post which wished the bally homeopaths would get cancer or some such… it’s just that that sort of contempt-bordering-on hatred is VERY off-putting).

Could it be that the "venom" you perceive resides in yourself? Posts here have ranged from the straightforward recitation of scientific fact to the downright humorous. Could it be you have no sense of humor?

Of course homeopaths are hardly going to welcome you lot with open arms if you make rude noises – because NO MATTER what you are convinced of, they are equally convinced of their whatchacallit – system?

What was it Groucho Marx said -- "I would not want to belong to a club that would have me as a member?" Well, I wouldn't want to be "welcomed" by people who practice a primitive form of witchcraft called "homeopathy."

When I say “us” I meant a few people with whom I discuss randi-topics. I came here because friends of mine told me of the great variety of discussions – and I come by now and then, just to read. I really would like to keep an open mind on the homeopathy issue, which I’m sure makes most of you want to kill me - or yourselves. J

Say, did you major in melodrama at university? And about "keeping an open mind," how many more centuries are you willing to do that before you will accept the fact that homeopathy is worthless bunkum? How long is a piece of string?

<snip>

Nah, not ‘big meanies”, awwww! Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something. And somehow the argument that this manner of bullheadedness occurs anywhere else doesn’t help.

You don't have to be terribly smart to read the scientific literature and figure out that homeopathy doesn't have a credible leg to stand on.

Actually, I believe in minimum intervention. I have had - and witnessed - bad experiences with conventional medicine, but no doubt it has its uses. Of course, we take the not-bad experiences for granted.

That explains a lot about your soured attitude toward us, and critics of scientific (read evidence-based) principles in general.

<snip>

You mean there are NO homeopathic cures? That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable?

If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it? Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever. I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.

There haven't been any scientifically proven homeopathic cures to date. It's been 200-odd years. Again, how long are you prepared to wait? And, really, do you actually equate anecdotal testimonies with evidence?

<snip>

...I think what you are failing to take into account is that sometimes it’s a choice between the devil and the deep blue. If you can ‘spank’ and spit at homeopathy, and if someone else spits at orthodox medicine, then to THAT individual homeopathy becomes a viable alternative if only because it’s seen as the lesser of two evils. Okay, chances are it won’t work – chances are it might and you’ll say it’s just not possible...

"Viable alternative?" Homeopathy the "lesser of two evils?" Just what herb are you smoking?

"Chances are it won't work"? It's been proven again and again that there's nothing there beyond placebo. Like Rodney (you're not Mini-Rodney, are you?), you seem to persist in this wishful thinking that, someday, homeopathy will work.

Please get this into your skull: "We" do not say that homeopathy "is not possible". We do say that in 200 years or so it remains unproven. It's those 200 years that allow us to think that homeopathy most likely will never be more than quackery. However, we stand to be corrected, but we won't hold our collective breath.

...so it must be placebo-effect, imagination, natural conclusion (which’s have occurred with or without intervention) or something –ANYTHING –else. At least, if its so useless, it won’t cause further problems because of incompetence or drug-related idiopathies.

Wish all you want, but to convince a skeptic there needs to be clear, unambiguous, testable and reproducible evidence. Belief isn't evidence. Some people keep a rabbit's foot and attribute all kinds of magical properties to it.

Do you think that this is a rational position to take?

...What you’re implying is IF I had read this thread or sundry discussions on homeopathy, I would be a brainless twit not to be convinced that’s it’s BS. But I’m not – so what then?

Well, aren't you? (Rhetorical question :D )

What I wanted to say, and shall therefore reiterate, is that a lot of you come across as simply rabid; you trash everything connected to homeopathy with a vengeance that makes one almost turn to them in sympathy.

Your opinion, and you're entitled to it. But citing the evidence about the inefficacy of homeopathy isn't "trashing" it.

Stupid? Yes, maybe. Just thought someone should tell you.

Stupid? No. Misguided, perhaps.

Conduct your own study. Check all of the real (non-anecdotal) evidence, and perhaps come up with a scientifically valid protocol that will finally put all our arguments to rest by demonstrating clear, unambiguous, testable and reproducible evidence that homeopathy really does work.

Half your luck.

M.
 
Last edited:
I have been doing a fair bit of reading – nowhere have I read on a homeopathic forum (admittedly, I skimmed) the kind of venom I have come across here
It's not on a homoeopathic forum, but you might like to read this mature, friendly and factually accurate e-mail from a director of the Faculty of Homeopaths to someone he disagrees with (see also post #19 in the comments). Nice chap.
You mean there are NO homeopathic cures? That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable?
No, it should be dismissed because when properly conducted trials are carried out so as to eliminate factors like the placebo effect, spontaneous recovery and reporting bias, which are not eliminated by anecdotal accounts, the effects tend to disappear. Meta analysis of the data from trials has shown that the better controlled the trial, the less likely it is to show positive results for homoeopathy:
Studies of high methodological quality were more likely to be negative than the lower quality studies.
The fact that the entire basis of homoeopathy appears to be complete nonsense is just the icing on the cake. What it should stand or fall on is reliable and reproducable results under controlled conditions, and that is what it has failed to produce over the last couple of centuries.
If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it.
Certainly, but no progress seems to be being made in this direction. Well conducted research such as that conducted by Edzard Ernst and his team seems to be consistently coming up with negative results. At the moment the homoeopathic establishment seems to be shying away from the idea of properly controlled trials for some reason, and either making statements like "It has been established beyond doubt and accepted by many researchers, that the placebo-controlled randomised controlled trial is not a fitting research tool with which to test homeopathy." (a statement made by a spokeswoman for the Society of Homoeopaths in this story about a recent meta analysis which had found no convincing evidence that homoeopathy is anything other than a placebo) or conducting customer satisfaction surveys like this one, which conspicuously failed to eliminate the placebo effect, regression to the mean, spontaneous recovery, and wishful thinking, but was nevertheless touted as evidence that homoeopathy works. If they are so confident that the effects are real, why the evasion? Why are we still waiting for good quality research showing that homoeopathy works?
Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever.
Me too, but it appears that they do.

To go back to an earlier point from your post:
I really would like to keep an open mind on the homeopathy issue ... Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something.
Science doesn't claim to have all the answers; on the other hand homoeopaths seem absolutely certain that their remedies work. They make anecdotal claims of all sorts of spectacular results for homoeopathy, but when it is examined under controlled conditions the effects seem to become so slight as to be pretty much undetectable.

Perhaps it is you who is "missing something" as a result of not being open-minded enough to consider all the evidence?
 
Last edited:
What you’re implying is IF I had read this thread or sundry discussions on homeopathy, I would be a brainless twit not to be convinced that’s it’s BS. But I’m not – so what then?
Maybe you're using a false dilemma to fish for insults. Then you can go and tell the people you "discuss randi-topics" with what nasty people skeptics are.
 
If science does not have all the answers, then MAYBE there are things that appear ridiculous because we do not know what might validate them? -Just asking if that’s possible.

Exactly. There are many things that I believe to be valid that are profoundly ridiculous - for example, on the surface, does it make any sense that all of the great variety of objects around us are composed of a few combinations of only three different particles? Or that there is something that can appear to be moving towards me at the same speed regardless of whether I am moving closer to it or further away from it?

When it comes down to it, most of what we now know is ridiculous. Many people accept ideas that are ridiculous. Skeptics, on the other hand, only accept ideas when it would be more ridiculous if they weren't valid.

At the moment, based on centuries of gathering evidence, it is far more ridiculous for homeopathy to be valid, than it is for homeopathy to be not valid.

When I say “us” I meant a few people with whom I discuss randi-topics. I came here because friends of mine told me of the great variety of discussions – and I come by now and then, just to read. I really would like to keep an open mind on the homeopathy issue, which I’m sure makes most of you want to kill me - or yourselves. J

You put that "J" there to indicate you are joking, right?

I use the term "open-minded" to refer to whether or not someone makes assumptions "a priori" - i.e. do they come to conclusions about the validity of a particular idea before assessing the information. However, I notice that you seem to be using it to refer to someone is uninformed and credulous. When I say I am open-minded about homeopathy, it means that I didn't come to the conclusion that it was ridiculous until after my review of the evidence led to that conclusion. But in order to think that it is possible homeopathy is not ridiculous (in light of all the available evidence), one must start with an assumption that homeopathy is a credible idea (which shifts the type of evidence that would be needed), and one must be ignorant of the available evidence and what it means. And this is a very common and very easy position to take. It requires expertise to adequately evaluate the evidence for yourself, and most people do not have that expertise. And most people allow their biases to determine what they want to find credible.

It is hard work to overcome cognitive biases. It has been incredibly rewarding, as that forms the basis of the scientific method that has led to a vast increase in our understanding of the universe. But it does not come naturally to most.

Nah, not ‘big meanies”, awwww! Just that for smart people you seem awfully unable to consider that you might be missing something. And somehow the argument that this manner of bullheadedness occurs anywhere else doesn’t help.

I think you are mischaracterizing our mindset in order to make it appear that your position is less ridiculous.

“Can you provide specific examples of what you consider to be "outrage"? I thought this was generally a bland thread.”
Not this thread alone – there are loads of threads where a sort of mob mentality manifests. Besides, I think I said “if not outright outrage”. Please read some responses to Rodney – if you like, I’ll go over the thread and cull them for you. Of course it’s a subjective viewpoint. Maybe all viewpoints are, in the final analysis, subjective. (And that’s not as inane as it might sound.)

Yes, it would be helpful if you pointed to specific examples.

”If you think there is eye-rolling and sighing, I would suggest that it is not over the suggestion that maybe <insert any idea that seems to defy established laws of nature> works. It is over the continued waste of time, money, and effort long after the evidence is over-whelmingly negative. Or it is about whether or not the nature of the pursuit qualifies as scientific.”
You mean there are NO homeopathic cures?

Yes, that is what I mean. Or to be more specific...."homeopathic cures" have not been demonstrated to be due to anything but already well-established known mechanisms independent of the idea of homeopathy.

That all “anecdotal evidence” must be dismissed because to you the very basis of homeopathy is untenable?

No. That the anecdotes do not demonstrate anything other than non-homeopathic mechanisms.

If, tomorrow it happens to be scientifically validated, will you then change your stance and accept it?

Of course. Scientists have demonstrated over and over and over again that they are willing to follow the evidence.

Again, I don’t know if it works because I have witnessed probable cures, but then again, I am aware of the lurking variable factor, so who knows. I find it hard to believe that there is a population out there who runs to these “quacks” without any justification whatsoever. I find it hard to believe that thousands of practicing homeopaths are either brainwashed idiots or money-grubbing little creeps.

You don't have to think that anyone is any different from you. It is in our nature to fool ourselves.

” Nobody said science is infallible. And we are not the ones who dragged conventional medicine into this thread to give it a spanking (which it didn't deserve in light of the subject being discussed). We were only trying to make it clear that the shortcomings of conventional medicine have no bearing on homeopathy one way or the other. If they're even failings at all, which Rodney has definitely failed to provide any evidence for. Hence no need to spank conventional medicine for apparent failings of cough medicines. They haven't failed at all.”

I beg to differ. Again, subjective view. I think what you are failing to take into account is that sometimes it’s a choice between the devil and the deep blue. If you can ‘spank’ and spit at homeopathy, and if someone else spits at orthodox medicine, then to THAT individual homeopathy becomes a viable alternative if only because it’s seen as the lesser of two evils. Okay, chances are it won’t work – chances are it might and you’ll say it’s just not possible, so it must be placebo-effect, imagination, natural conclusion (which’s have occurred with or without intervention) or something –ANYTHING –else. At least, if its so useless, it won’t cause further problems because of incompetence or drug-related idiopathies.

You have identified the heart of the issue. For a long time, pseudoscience and non-science have been ignored because they were assumed to be mostly harmless. We may bemoan the waste of time, money and effort, but after all, it is individual patients and practitioners that are wasting their resources, right? I think that we are coming to the realization that that may be an erroneous assumption. The waste of resources is spreading to me because my money is being used to support it - through government support of CAM research or health insurance payments to CAM practitioners. Large numbers of people die (I'm thinking of treatment for AIDS in Africa) because officials in charge of public policy base their decisions on pseudoscience. Municipalities put their residents at risk of losing money and health by buying various unproven water treatments for their municipal water supply. The list goes on and on. And there may be a greater intellectual danger to allowing the growth of a population of people that are unwilling or unable to critically examine their beliefs - making them prone to manipulation and worse.

” You say you're not sure if homeopathy works, which to me suggests you haven't even read this thread from start to finish.”

I have read most of this thread, but over several days. Its not this thread alone that prompted me to come out of my corner (I have to tell you – you seem like really intellegent people, by and large, and it’s kind of intimidating.) What you’re implying is IF I had read this thread or sundry discussions on homeopathy, I would be a brainless twit not to be convinced that’s it’s BS. But I’m not – so what then?

It simply tells us that you are a non-skeptic. Not really a big deal; most people are. I guess it makes me wonder what you wanted to accomplish here, though.

What I wanted to say, and shall therefore reiterate, is that a lot of you come across as simply rabid; you trash everything connected to homeopathy with a vengeance that makes one almost turn to them in sympathy. Stupid? Yes, maybe. Just thought someone should tell you.

Why should we be interested in your opinion? (serious question)

Linda
 
What I wanted to say, and shall therefore reiterate, is that a lot of you come across as simply rabid; you trash everything connected to homeopathy with a vengeance that makes one almost turn to them in sympathy. Stupid? Yes, maybe. Just thought someone should tell you.

Why should these people be treated with anything other than complete and utter scorn?

If someone wishes to sell water (which is what a homeopathic 'medicine' is) as a cure for a medical condition should they not, at least, be challenged for proof of their assertion? And should they not have to provide it before being allowed to advertize? Is there anything at all unreasonable in that?

Homeopathy has never done it.

The BBC earlier this year ran an article about the increase in Malaria cases from people vacationing in Africa.

Why was there an increase? Because tourists had opted for the "homeopathic remedy" and found themselves with malaria.

When quacks advertize "cures" they don't have and persuade people to take them instead of real, tested, medicine, it may not matter very much when it's the common cold. But such behavior can endanger lives when it comes to disease like malaria.

I do not see what virtue there can possibly be in being polite about this, They have made their claims and they have refused to even test them. It seems the only way they wish to test is on people and damn the consequences.

That may be something you consider worthy of politeness. I don't.

And I don't care if people like you get put off by it.
 
Why should these people be treated with anything other than complete and utter scorn?
I had an exchange with "fls" (Linda) about this. She pointed out that the public can be more receptive if they don't feel insulted.
That may be something you consider worthy of politeness. I don't.
I believe this is a challenge to us- to politely set matters straight; normally, I am not considered polite. On the other hand, we don't seem to be making much headway.

I must say that "Deus," and many other posts just prior to this, are quite on target.
 
Object Lesson

I have a cousin-in-law who has bought into both homeopathy and anti-vaccination big time, much to our disappointment. What's worse, she has refused to have her children inoculated against the common childhood illnesses.

Our counter arguments have been met with stony silence, and we've all but ceased communicating.
Well, I wonder why. :confused:

How many times in 200-odd years have people tried to validate homeopathy? How many times have they succeeded? (Rhetorical question, since it's been asked and answered innumerable times both here and elsewhere.)

Could it be that the "venom" you perceive resides in yourself? Posts here have ranged from the straightforward recitation of scientific fact to the downright humorous. Could it be you have no sense of humor?

What was it Groucho Marx said -- "I would not want to belong to a club that would have me as a member?" Well, I wouldn't want to be "welcomed" by people who practice a primitive form of witchcraft called "homeopathy."

Say, did you major in melodrama at university? And about "keeping an open mind," how many more centuries are you willing to do that before you will accept the fact that homeopathy is worthless bunkum? How long is a piece of string?

You don't have to be terribly smart to read the scientific literature and figure out that homeopathy doesn't have a credible leg to stand on.

That explains a lot about your soured attitude toward us, and critics of scientific (read evidence-based) principles in general.

There haven't been any scientifically proven homeopathic cures to date. It's been 200-odd years. Again, how long are you prepared to wait? And, really, do you actually equate anecdotal testimonies with evidence?

"Viable alternative?" Homeopathy the "lesser of two evils?" Just what herb are you smoking?

"Chances are it won't work"? It's been proven again and again that there's nothing there beyond placebo. Like Rodney (you're not Mini-Rodney, are you?), you seem to persist in this wishful thinking that, someday, homeopathy will work.

Please get this into your skull: "We" do not say that homeopathy "is not possible". We do say that in 200 years or so it remains unproven. It's those 200 years that allow us to think that homeopathy most likely will never be more than quackery. However, we stand to be corrected, but we won't hold our collective breath.

Wish all you want, but to convince a skeptic there needs to be clear, unambiguous, testable and reproducible evidence. Belief isn't evidence. Some people keep a rabbit's foot and attribute all kinds of magical properties to it.

Do you think that this is a rational position to take?

Well, aren't you? (Rhetorical question :D )

Your opinion, and you're entitled to it. But citing the evidence about the inefficacy of homeopathy isn't "trashing" it.

Stupid? No. Misguided, perhaps.

Conduct your own study. Check all of the real (non-anecdotal) evidence, and perhaps come up with a scientifically valid protocol that will finally put all our arguments to rest by demonstrating clear, unambiguous, testable and reproducible evidence that homeopathy really does work.

Half your luck.
Enough said. ;)
 
Why should these people be treated with anything other than complete and utter scorn?

I do not see what virtue there can possibly be in being polite about this, They have made their claims and they have refused to even test them. It seems the only way they wish to test is on people and damn the consequences.

That may be something you consider worthy of politeness. I don't.

And I don't care if people like you get put off by it.
The power of your argument is absolutely compelling.
I'm certain mini can't help but be completely convinced.

:nope:
 
A note for Moochie, Mojo, and Deus...

I had an exchange with "fls" (Linda) about this. She pointed out that the public can be more receptive if they don't feel insulted.I believe this is a challenge to us- to politely set matters straight; normally, I am not considered polite. On the other hand, we don't seem to be making much headway.
:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom